Bagelry

- 507 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers, especially those of us on Long Island, the daily ritual of a fresh bagel is more than just breakfast—it's a tradition. Bagelry, nestled right in the heart of Cedarhurst, NY, stands as a prime example of this beloved local institution. This dedicated bagel shop offers a wide array of options, making it a reliable stop for both the morning rush and a midday meal. It operates with a focus on providing quality grab-and-go options, perfect for the fast-paced life in Nassau County. Bagelry is committed to serving up fresh, authentic bagel selections, creamy spreads, and deli-style sandwiches, establishing itself as a key spot for local residents and visitors looking for that quintessential Long Island bagel experience.

The menu is designed to cater to classic tastes while also offering specialty items. From the standard yet essential Plain bagel to the popular Everything Bagel, the foundation of their offerings is rooted in tradition. Beyond the baked goods, the shop is a functional and convenient location for a quick visit, whether you're starting your day or grabbing a quick lunch. The ease of takeout, combined with simple dining options like breakfast, solidifies Bagelry's role as a neighborhood staple in the Cedarhurst community.

Location and Accessibility

Bagelry is conveniently located at 507 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA, placing it directly on one of the main commercial thoroughfares of the Five Towns area. This central location ensures it's easily accessible for local residents and those passing through Cedarhurst. Central Avenue is known for its busy retail and dining scene, and Bagelry provides a necessary fueling station amidst this bustling environment.

Accessibility by car is straightforward, as the shop's location is well-integrated into the local road network. For those driving, it is important to note that the parking situation involves paid street parking. Customers should plan accordingly for a quick stop to pick up their order, especially during peak morning hours. For local patrons, the spot is highly walkable within the Cedarhurst shopping district. The establishment's clear focus on 'Quick visit' planning and efficient 'Takeout' service ensures that patrons can get in and out with minimal fuss, making it an excellent choice for a busy schedule. Furthermore, for those who prefer to bring their furry companions along, the policy of 'Dogs allowed inside' for pets is a friendly and welcoming feature for the community.

Services Offered

Bagelry provides a comprehensive list of products and services centered around the perfect New York-style bagel and deli favorites. Their offerings cover a full spectrum of breakfast and lunch needs. Key services include:

• Bagels, Flagels, and Minis: A broad selection including classic options such as Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Everything Bagel, Salt, Onion, Garlic, Cinnamon Raisin, and Egg. Specialty bagel doughs like Pumpernickel, Caraway, Sunflower, and Whole Wheat varieties (Plain, Everything, and Sesame) are also available.
• Cream Cheese Spreads: A wide variety of house-made cream cheese options to top off any bagel, including Plain Cream Cheese, Scallion Cream Cheese, Vegetable Cream Cheese, Lox Spread, Olive Cream Cheese, Walnut and Raisin Cream Cheese, and Cream Cheese with sliced Lox for an authentic Long Island taste.
• Sandwiches: Classic deli sandwiches featuring staples like Tuna Salad, Tuna Melt, Whitefish Salad, Egg Salad, and a Melted Cheese Sandwich. They also offer simple, comforting choices such as Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Butter and Jelly, and Butter and Cinnamon Sugar.
• Beverages: A robust coffee and tea menu featuring both iced and hot drinks. Coffee choices include Regular Coffee, Decaf Coffee, French Vanilla Coffee, Hazelnut Coffee, Toasted Almond Coffee, Cinnamon Hazelnut Coffee, Decaf French Vanilla Coffee, and Decaf Hazelnut Coffee.
• Muffins and Baked Goods: A selection of freshly baked muffins to complement your coffee, with flavors such as Corn, French Vanilla Chips, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Blueberry Crumb Cake, and Raisin Bran.
• Salads: Light and fresh choices are available, including Greek Salad, Tuna Salad, a Combo Tuna and Egg Salad, and a Garden Salad.
• Service and Dining Options: Primarily offering Takeout service, with dining options available for a quick Breakfast. Payment methods are convenient, accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

Bagelry's success in the Cedarhurst community is built upon several key features that appeal to the local New York clientele:

• Extensive Bagel and Spread Variety: The sheer number of bagel flavors—over a dozen, including specialized whole wheat options and the unique Bialy—ensures there is a fresh option for every preference. The selection of gourmet cream cheese spreads, especially the Lox Spread and Walnut and Raisin, provides a sophisticated touch to the classic bagel sandwich.
• Specialty Coffee Selection: Beyond basic coffee, the availability of flavored hot and iced coffees, such as French Vanilla, Hazelnut, and Toasted Almond, elevates the morning experience for coffee lovers.
• Complete Meal Options: The menu extends beyond breakfast with a selection of classic sandwiches and fresh salads, including specialty mixes like the Combo Tuna and Egg Salad and the Greek Salad, making it a viable option for lunch as well.
• Convenient and Modern Payment: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments ensures a fast and seamless transaction process, catering to customers who are constantly on the move.
• Dog-Friendly Policy: The accommodation of 'Dogs allowed inside' is a thoughtful feature that appeals to local pet owners, adding to the welcoming, neighborhood-friendly atmosphere of the shop.
• Focus on Quick Service: The 'Quick visit' and 'Takeout' focus highlights the shop's efficiency, a critical factor for busy Long Islanders seeking a delicious and fast option.

Contact Information

For local customers in and around Nassau County, here is the essential contact information for Bagelry:

• Address: 507 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA
• Phone: (516) 295-1222
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-295-1222

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Bagelry in Cedarhurst is a choice for authentic, local New York breakfast and lunch fare. What truly makes this local bagel shop stand out and worth a visit is the sheer dedication to a well-rounded menu that respects tradition while offering variety. The core of any great New York bagel shop is the bagel itself, and with over fifteen distinct choices, from the robust Pumpernickel to the healthful Whole Wheat Everything, Bagelry provides a strong foundation for your meal. Whether you prefer the classic chew of a fresh Sesame bagel or the satisfying fluff of a Bialy, the options are plentiful. Furthermore, the ability to order a 'Flagel' (a flattened bagel) offers a unique textural alternative that many New Yorkers enjoy.

For those looking for a savory experience, combining a fresh bagel with one of their house-made cream cheese spreads is highly recommended. The Lox Spread offers a gourmet, flavorful experience, while the Vegetable Cream Cheese is a fresh, lighter option. The menu's dedication to quality is also seen in their deli choices, such as the classic Tuna Melt, which makes for a hearty lunch. The fact that the shop functions efficiently for quick visits, supporting busy daily routines, is a major advantage for local patrons. A noted customer appreciation for the "fantastic" bagels further validates the quality of the product. While customer experiences regarding service and pricing may vary, the consistent quality and extensive selection of the core menu items—the bagels, cream cheeses, and coffee—make Bagelry a dependable and excellent stop on Central Avenue for your daily fix.

Bagelry

507 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA