Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
ConnecticutNew JerseyNew York

Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew JerseyEssex CountyMaplewoodrestaurants in Boyden AvenueCorner Slice
Corner Slice ico

Corner Slice
- 419 Boyden Ave, Maplewood, NJ 07040

Pizza restaurant ★4.0 (98)·$10–20

419 Boyden Ave, Maplewood, NJ 07040, USA

4.0
This is a great neighborhood spot. The pizza is fresh even by the slice. It stays fairly busy to where fresh pizza continues to sling out of the oven. The crust is crispy, light and airy, sauce has good flavor, and high quality ingredients are used. I had the Margherita, pepperoni, white, and upside down slices. That is also the order of what I like from best to least. On a 10 point scale in the same order I give 8.3, 8.2, 7.9, 7.7 on a one bite scale. - Robert Fagan
Corner Slice Overview Intro Menu Detail Photos Location Reviews
$10–20 per person Reported by 98 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Corner Slice Introduce

For residents and visitors in the **New Jersey** area who appreciate a truly authentic pizza experience, **Corner Slice** in Maplewood stands out as a must-visit destination. More than just a local pizzeria, Corner Slice has quickly become known for mastering the art of the **New York Square Pie**, a local specialty that requires precision in technique and a commitment to quality ingredients. This establishment delivers a pizza experience that is often described as fresh, crunchy, light, and airy—a perfect blend of texture and flavor that satisfies even the most discerning pizza lovers in the region.

The core philosophy at Corner Slice seems to be centered around simplicity and execution. They focus on a limited, yet incredibly high-quality, selection of pies and sides, ensuring that every item that comes out of the oven is top-notch. Their commitment to using **high quality ingredients** is evident in every bite, from the flavorful sauce to the perfectly charred crust. This dedication makes it a staple for those seeking genuine **comfort food** and a reliable spot for a **quick bite** throughout the day.

Operating as a great **neighborhood spot**, the atmosphere at Corner Slice is decidedly **casual** and welcoming. It's the kind of place where fresh pizza is continually being prepared and served, ensuring that even ordering "by the slice" guarantees a warm, delicious experience. This high-volume, high-quality approach keeps the energy lively and the food consistently excellent. Whether you’re stopping in for a solo lunch or grabbing a pie for a family dinner, Corner Slice embodies the best of local, specialty dining in **Maplewood, New Jersey**.

The reputation of Corner Slice extends beyond just the standard cheese pie. Their menu features creative and classic options alike, appealing to a wide range of tastes. For many in New Jersey, this specific style of pizza is a culinary treasure. The square pie offers a textural masterpiece, achieving a thicker profile while maintaining a surprising lightness and a crust that is lauded for being **crispy, light and airy**. This unique characteristic, paired with a sauce that **has good flavor**, cements Corner Slice's status as a premier pizza destination. Their dedication ensures the full process, from dough preparation to the final bake, is handled with care, reflecting the **passion put into the shop and the pizza**.

In a region where pizza is taken seriously, the consistent operation of Corner Slice—where **fresh pizza continues to sling out of the oven**—is a testament to their success. This constant rotation guarantees that patrons, whether they are local regulars or visiting **Tourists**, always receive a product at its peak freshness. It’s this combination of traditional technique, high-quality ingredients, and efficient service that makes Corner Slice a worthy choice for any meal, reinforcing its position as a central figure in Maplewood's casual dining scene. From the moment you approach the counter to your final bite, the experience is designed to be satisfying and memorable.

The quality of the square pie is consistently highly rated. One enthusiastic customer gave specific scores, noting the **Margherita** at 8.3 and the **Pepperoni** at 8.2 on a ten-point scale, demonstrating the superior quality of their foundational offerings. Even slices considered "least favorite" in that assessment, such as the White (7.9) and Upside Down (7.7), still score exceptionally well, underscoring the high baseline quality that Corner Slice maintains for all its menu items. This level of consistency is a key factor for New Jersey residents when choosing a reliable, high-quality pizza spot. The commitment to crafting such a specialized and beloved product makes Corner Slice a truly unique and valued establishment within the competitive Essex County food landscape.


Location and Accessibility

Corner Slice is ideally situated in the vibrant community of **Maplewood, New Jersey**. Its location makes it highly accessible for residents of surrounding towns like South Orange, Irvington, Union, and Millburn in the greater **Essex County** area. The exact address is:

419 Boyden Ave, Maplewood, NJ 07040, USA

Accessibility is made easy for patrons, as the restaurant offers **free street parking** nearby. This convenience is a significant benefit in a busy suburban area, ensuring that a stop for a quick slice or a full pie is hassle-free. The location is strategically placed to serve the local community while also attracting visitors drawn by its reputation for serving a local specialty pie. This ease of access, combined with its popularity, contributes to its status as a bustling and beloved spot. Finding parking should be a simple affair, allowing you to quickly get in and enjoy your **comfort food** without unnecessary delay. The proximity to main local routes ensures that whether you're commuting or running errands, Corner Slice is an easy addition to your daily routine, providing a convenient and high-quality meal option.


Services Offered

Corner Slice focuses on providing straightforward and convenient service options to meet the needs of the Maplewood community. Their services ensure that patrons can enjoy their highly-rated pizza in a way that suits their schedule:

  • **Dine-in:** Patrons can enjoy their food on-site in the **Casual** atmosphere, perfect for **Lunch** or **Dinner**. Seating arrangements are comfortable and conducive to a relaxed meal.
  • **Takeout:** A popular service option, allowing customers to easily grab their order and enjoy it at home or elsewhere. This is ideal for quick, scheduled pickups, especially for the popular **PIZZA NIGHT SPECIAL**.
  • **Onsite Services:** The restaurant is primarily focused on serving customers directly at their location, ensuring quality and freshness, whether you are eating a single slice or a whole pie.
  • **Payment Options:** For customer convenience, they accept both **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**, making transactions smooth and fast. This also includes the acceptance of major digital payment methods, reflecting a commitment to modern consumer convenience.
  • **Family-Friendly:** Considered **Good for kids**, making it an easy choice for a family meal, with options and an atmosphere suitable for all ages.
  • **Dining Times:** They are popular for all main dining times, including **Lunch** and **Dinner**, making it suitable for both a midday break and an evening meal. It is also noted as a great place for **Solo dining**, offering a quick, comfortable, and satisfying experience for one.
  • **Ordering by the Slice:** A major convenience, allowing customers to sample different varieties, such as the **Margherita, pepperoni, white, and upside down slices** all in one visit. This flexibility is a huge advantage for a quick lunch or a testing of the waters for newcomers.

Features and Highlights

The features and highlights of Corner Slice are centered around their high-quality products and customer-focused convenience:

  • **Signature New York Square Pies:** This is their core offering, celebrated for its unique texture—a **crispy, light, and airy crust**. Menu items like the **UPSIDE DOWN**, **VODKA**, and the hearty **GARBAGE PIE** are key draws. The pricing is competitive for a specialty product of this caliber, with pies ranging from $25.00 to $36.00.
  • **Serves Local Specialty:** The restaurant prides itself on delivering an authentic version of a regional pizza style, establishing it as a local culinary authority on the square pie.
  • **The 'Dangerously Delicious' Garlic Knots:** The **GARLIC NOT** special ($8.91) is a non-negotiable side order for many patrons. The high praise it receives reflects the quality and care put into all menu items, not just the pizza, confirming the intense **passion put into the shop**.
  • **Great Value Combo Meals:** The **PIZZA NIGHT SPECIAL** ($35.00) offers an excellent value proposition, providing a complete meal solution that is perfect for hassle-free weeknight dinners or small gatherings, making dinner planning easy for busy New Jersey families.
  • **Specialty Pies and Sides:** Beyond the basics, they offer exciting options like the **CHICKEN SAUSAGE & BROCCOLI RABE PIE** ($36.00) and delicious, simple desserts like **THE BROWNIE** and **SHIRLEY TEMPLE CAKE**. The **BROWNIE BAG** ($13.99) is an ideal dessert option for sharing after a big meal.
  • **Consistent Freshness:** The continuous flow of business ensures that all pizza is perpetually **fresh**, a quality highlight appreciated by customers who order by the slice or the whole pie. This ensures high quality regardless of the time of day.
  • **Simple, Flavorful Salad Option:** For those looking for a lighter accompaniment, the **PIZZERIA SALAD** ($14.54) provides a fresh contrast to the rich comfort food, offering a complete and balanced meal option.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about the menu, or confirm hours of operation, you can reach Corner Slice using the following location and contact details:

Address: 419 Boyden Ave, Maplewood, NJ 07040, USA

While a public phone number was not provided in the primary data, the best way to contact the restaurant is often by visiting their website or checking local business listings for updated contact information and online ordering options. The physical address is central to their operations, inviting direct visits for dine-in or takeout. Patrons are advised to utilize online search tools to find the most current phone number or digital ordering portals to facilitate quick and easy ordering, especially for takeout during peak hours.


What is Worth Choosing at Corner Slice

For any pizza aficionado in New Jersey, choosing Corner Slice is a decision to prioritize quality, technique, and authentic flavor. The reputation of the restaurant is built on several key factors that make it a standout choice in the competitive local dining scene:

  • **The Masterful Crust:** The absolute most compelling reason to visit is the quality of their square pie crust. It is a technical feat in pizza making, providing a texture that is simultaneously **CRUNCHY FRESH**, **crispy, light, and airy**. As one reviewer noted, this sets the benchmark for the entire meal, making it distinct from many other pizza styles available in the state.
  • **Flavor and Ingredient Quality:** The consistency in using **high quality ingredients** is evident across the menu. Whether it's the rich, flavorful sauce or the perfect balance of toppings, the dedication to taste ensures a highly satisfying meal. This commitment results in the high customer satisfaction ratings seen for popular items like the **Margherita** and **Pepperoni** pies.
  • **The Value of the Combo:** The affordability and convenience of the **PIZZA NIGHT SPECIAL** make Corner Slice a practical and delicious solution for feeding a family or hosting a casual get-together in New Jersey. It's a testament to their commitment to offering value alongside quality, making a premium meal accessible.
  • **The Essential Side Order:** The legendary **GARLIC NOT** is a compelling reason to stop in, even for a quick snack. The "dangerously delicious" nature of this side dish demonstrates the high level of care applied to the entire menu, proving that every item, from the main event to the small plates, is treated as a specialty.
  • **Reliability and Atmosphere:** As a busy **neighborhood spot** popular with both **Locals** and **Tourists**, the high volume of business ensures constant freshness and a lively, **Casual** atmosphere. It’s a reliable destination that guarantees a quick, satisfying, and high-quality meal every time, suitable for a solo quick bite or a relaxed family dinner.
  • **Menu Exploration Opportunities:** The availability of both classic favorites and unique specialty pies like the **UPSIDE DOWN** and **VODKA** allows patrons to continually explore new flavors, ensuring that Corner Slice remains an exciting and rewarding place to visit repeatedly. Furthermore, the option to buy the delightful **BROWNIE BAG** ensures dessert is always covered.

Corner Slice is the kind of local business that truly elevates the casual dining experience in New Jersey. It's a place that understands its specialty—the New York Square Pie—and executes it flawlessly, making it a highly recommended stop for anyone in the Maplewood area or beyond seeking authentic, top-tier comfort food.

Corner Slice Menu

  • COMBO MEALS

  • PIZZA NIGHT SPECIAL $35.00

    Cheese Pie & Pizzeria Salad Combo 1 Whole Cheese Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, tomato sauce, pecorino. & 1 Pizzeria Salad–Local salad greens, roasted red pepper, cucumber, roasted cherry tomato, red onion, castelvetrano olives, and pepperoncini, Served with red wine vinaigrette on the side. No Substitutions Please! (Big Enough To Share)

  • NEW YORK SQUARE PIES

  • CHEESE $26.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, tomato sauce, pecorino.

  • PEPPERONI $30.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with Ezzo pepperoni, mozz blend, tomato sauce, pecorino.

  • UPSIDE DOWN $30.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with fresh mozz, tomato sauce on top, garlic oil, pecorino.

  • MARGHERITA $30.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, crushed plum tomato, pecorino, basil oil.

  • WHITE $30.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, ricotta, black pepper, pecorino, parsley.

  • TOMATO $25.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with tomato sauce, garlic confit, wild oregano, fresh basil, olive oil (VEGAN).

  • VODKA $30.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with fresh mozz, vodka sauce, calabrian chili, pecorino.

  • BUFFALO $36.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce, buttermilk ranch, green onion, aleppo pepper.

  • GARBAGE PIE $36.00

    Whole Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, tomato sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, red onion, jalapeno, wild oregano, garlic crema.

  • SALADS

  • PIZZERIA SALAD $14.54

    Local salad greens, roasted red pepper, cucumber, roasted cherry tomato, red onion, castelvetrano olives, and pepperoncini, Served with red wine vinaigrette on the side. No Substitutions Please! (Big Enough To Share)

  • SPECIALS

  • CHICKEN SAUSAGE & BROCCOLI RABE PIE $36.00

    This Week’s Special Pie— THE CHICKEN SAUSAGE & BROCCOLI RABE PIE! For this one we doubled down on flavor with Pete’s house-made chicken sausage that’s packed with broccoli rabe and provolone right inside the sausage. Topped with our mozz blend, smoked scamorza, cherry pepper & garlic marinated broccoli rabe, Pete’s famous chicken/broccoli/provolone sausage, and pecorino. Baked and finished with Sicilian oregano and plenty of that good parm! Available WEDNESDAY 10/15 — WEDNESDAY 10/22!

  • GARLIC NOT $8.91

    Our GARLIC NOT is braided pizza dough swirled with garlic butter and pecorino, baked, then topped with more garlic, garlic oil, parsley and pecorino. Served with warm tomato sauce for dipping.

  • SHIRLEY TEMPLE CAKE $5.63

    SHIRLEY TEMPLE CAKE 🍒 IT WOULDN’T BE A PEE-WEE PARTY WITHOUT A LITTLE SOMETHING SWEET! Lemon Lime Chiffon Cake + Cherry Ginger Cream Cheese Frosting + Cherry On Top = SHIRLEY TEMPLE CAKE THIS WEEKEND ONLY! • FRI 10/17–SUN 10/19 ALL BAKING DONE ON PREMISES 😎

  • PIZZA NIGHT SPECIAL $35.00

    Cheese Pie & Pizzeria Salad Combo 1 Whole Cheese Pie (8 Slices - 10"x17") with mozz blend, tomato sauce, pecorino. & 1 Pizzeria Salad–Local salad greens, roasted red pepper, cucumber, roasted cherry tomato, red onion, castelvetrano olives, and pepperoncini, Served with red wine vinaigrette on the side. No Substitutions Please! (Big Enough To Share)

  • DESSERTS

  • THE BROWNIE $3.99

    THE BEST! Housemade Valrhona Chocolate Brownie.

  • BROWNIE BAG $13.99

    THE BEST! 4 piece bag of Housemade Valrhona Chocolate Brownies.

Corner Slice Details

  • Service options

  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Delivery
  • Highlights

  • Serves local specialty
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Offerings

  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite
  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Crowd

  • Tourists
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • Parking

  • Free street parking
  • Parking

Corner Slice Photos

Corner Slice Picture 1Corner Slice Picture 2Corner Slice Picture 3Corner Slice Picture 4Corner Slice Picture 5Corner Slice Picture 6Corner Slice Picture 7Corner Slice Picture 8Corner Slice Picture 9Corner Slice Picture 10

Corner Slice Location

Corner Slice

419 Boyden Ave, Maplewood, NJ 07040, USA

Corner Slice Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 205 user reviews.

pieslightgarlic knotsvodkabuffalo chickenpriceslicessicilian pizzasoft openinginstagram

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • Bibiu2019s Authentic FlavorsBibiu2019s Authentic Flavors4.0 (6 reviews)

    S 17th St, East Orange, NJ 07018, USA

  • Aduke Nigerian restaurantAduke Nigerian restaurant3.0 (2 reviews)

    88 11th Ave W, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Magic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream ParlorMagic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream Parlor4.0 (13 reviews)

    550-552 Central Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Green GeniusGreen Genius0.0 (0 reviews)

    551 Central Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • The Zucchini Bar Herbal Teau2019s & TreatsThe Zucchini Bar Herbal Teau2019s & Treats4.0 (158 reviews)

    547 Central Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Blueberry Cafe Juice Bar And Vegan GrilleBlueberry Cafe Juice Bar And Vegan Grille4.0 (604 reviews)

    547 Central Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Tropical RestaurantTropical Restaurant4.0 (34 reviews)

    543 Central Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Reggi's JerkReggi's Jerk4.0 (16 reviews)

    98 9th Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • S&S DeliS&S Deli4.0 (12 reviews)

    98 9th Ave, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • AMAT AFRICAN FOOD & CATERING LLCAMAT AFRICAN FOOD & CATERING LLC3.0 (20 reviews)

    91 S 9th St, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Sazon Del PatioSazon Del Patio4.0 (41 reviews)

    485 W Market St, Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Domino'sDomino's5.0 (1 reviews)

    Newark, NJ 07107, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Top restaurants Searches

    Trending Dining Insights Posts