L.I. McGrath’s

- 217 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Nestled on the vibrant Main Street of Farmingdale, New York, L.I. McGrath’s offers the Long Island community an authentic and welcoming Irish pub and grill experience. It is much more than just a bar; it is a full-service restaurant and a premier entertainment venue, seamlessly blending the cozy, genuine atmosphere of a traditional Irish pub with the trendy, casual vibe expected in a modern New York establishment. L.I. McGrath’s is a sister location to a popular pub in Galway, Ireland, bringing a true taste of the Emerald Isle—both in spirit and on the menu—right to the heart of Nassau County.

This popular spot serves up a diverse and satisfying menu that features classic Irish comfort food alongside American favorites, all prepared with a unique culinary twist. Whether you are looking for a hearty dinner, a satisfying lunch, or just a place to relax with a great cocktail, L.I. McGrath’s has established itself as a go-to destination. The atmosphere is notably casual and cozy, yet trendy, making it an excellent choice for groups looking to gather, friends catching up, or individuals simply seeking a welcoming environment for solo dining. It is a place that truly embodies the Irish concept of "good crac"—a convivial, fun, and engaging atmosphere—which makes it a unique and valued addition to the New York region's dining and nightlife scene.

The establishment successfully functions as a Bar, a Pub, a Bar & Grill, and a Restaurant, ensuring a dynamic environment that caters to different needs throughout the day and week. From delicious small plates and appetizers perfect for sharing to substantial entrées and sandwiches, L.I. McGrath’s is committed to delivering quality food and beverages with fast, friendly service.

L.I. McGrath’s is centrally located at 217 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, placing it in a prime position on one of Long Island’s most active thoroughfares. This Main Street location is highly convenient for local residents and those traveling from other parts of the New York metropolitan area, offering a hub for dining and entertainment.

Accessibility for all guests is prioritized at this Farmingdale pub. The premises include a wheelchair accessible parking lot and a wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring that the establishment can comfortably accommodate patrons with mobility needs.

Regarding parking, patrons have several choices, although it requires careful attention to local village regulations. The pub offers access to a free parking lot and free street parking, as well as a paid parking lot option. Visitors should note the common Long Island scenario of time-restricted and paid parking, particularly in the bustling Farmingdale Village area. While some municipal lots may have unrestricted parking during certain evening hours, Main Street parking often involves payment, which can continue until late at night. Customers are advised to check local signage or use the PayByPhone app to ensure compliance with the Village of Farmingdale's parking regulations to avoid inconvenience. Despite the typical Main Street parking challenges, the multiple parking options demonstrate an effort to accommodate the crowds L.I. McGrath's attracts.

L.I. McGrath’s is a full-service establishment, providing a comprehensive range of options designed to fit the dining preferences and schedules of the busy New York crowd. They aim for convenience and a quality experience, regardless of whether you choose to dine in or enjoy their offerings at home.

• Dine-In Experience: The pub offers comfortable seating and full table service within its cozy, inviting interior.
• Outdoor Seating: For guests who prefer to dine al fresco, L.I. McGrath’s provides a pleasant outdoor seating area.
• Takeout and Delivery: In line with modern dining demands, the pub facilitates both takeout and convenient delivery services, ensuring their menu is accessible whether you are at home or work.
• Full Bar Service: As a prominent bar and pub, they feature a full array of alcoholic beverages, including a recognized great beer selection, expertly crafted cocktails, hard liquor, and wine.
• Food at the Bar: Guests are welcome to enjoy the complete food menu, including their signature Irish dishes and American classics, while seated at the bar area.
• Private Gatherings and Events: The pub has a strong history of accommodating large groups and private gatherings, even demonstrating the ability to close the entire location for special events like funeral repasts, showcasing a level of community commitment and logistical capability to handle significant crowds with excellent service.

The appeal of L.I. McGrath’s extends significantly past its food and drink offerings, establishing it as a dynamic social and entertainment hotspot in Farmingdale.

• Authentic Irish Menu: The pub offers signature Irish dishes such as the rich Guinness Irish Stew, classic Shepherd's Pie (made with beef and topped with mashed potatoes), Bangers and Mash, and the unique MSM Private Corned Beef Kettle Dinner. American favorites are also featured, including the popular McGraths Smashburger and Galway Fish & Chips.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: The venue is recognized for its great beer selection, offering both local and imported drafts, and its commitment to quality mixed drinks is proven by its reputation for great cocktails. There are also indications of a Happy Hour, which, while specific details vary, provides excellent value on drinks and appetizers during specific windows.
• Lively Entertainment Venue: L.I. McGrath’s is a dedicated live music venue, frequently hosting live performances and acts, including both Irish traditional music and American music. They also host engaging activities such as bar games and Karaoke, ensuring there's always an interactive element to the pub experience.
• Sports Viewing: The pub is an ideal location for sports fans, with a focus on showcasing sports events in a communal, enthusiastic atmosphere.
• Warm and Cozy Atmosphere: The pub’s successful effort to borrow the logo, atmosphere, brickwork, and paint job from its Galway counterpart results in an ambiance that is authentically Irish, cozy, and inviting—a perfect place for "good crac" and relaxed sharing among groups.

For general inquiries, reservations, or placing an order, patrons in the New York region can use the following contact details for L.I. McGrath’s:

Address: 217 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 854-2040

Mobile Phone: +1 516-854-2040

L.I. McGrath’s is a destination worth choosing for any New Yorker seeking a genuine, multi-faceted pub experience on Long Island. It distinguishes itself by successfully merging high-quality Irish-American cuisine with a lively and welcoming entertainment atmosphere. For the food enthusiast, the menu is a strong draw, with perfectly executed comfort food like the savory Guinness Irish Stew and the comforting Shepherd's Pie. However, what elevates the experience beyond the plate is the energetic environment.

The pub's commitment to entertainment—highlighted by live music, bar games (like the fun late-starting bingo), and sports viewing—ensures a dynamic social setting that encourages patrons to stay and enjoy the "crac." Furthermore, the outstanding customer service demonstrated by the staff, who are noted for being quick, attentive, and able to manage large, demanding groups with smiles and efficiency, speaks volumes about the pub's dedication to its guests. The ability of the team to handle a large, unexpected gathering with such warmth and speed is a testament to the strong management and genuine hospitality, making L.I. McGrath’s a reliable choice for celebratory, memorial, or just casual gatherings.

For a Long Island night out that offers excellent Irish fare, a full selection of drinks, fantastic value (especially during reported Happy Hour times), and a fun, lively atmosphere, L.I. McGrath’s on Farmingdale’s Main Street is undoubtedly one of the top destinations.

L.I. McGrath’s

217 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA