City Island Lobster House

- 691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464

For New Yorkers seeking an authentic seafood experience away from the Manhattan bustle, the journey to the City Island Lobster House is a time-honored tradition. Located on the charming, historic City Island in the Bronx, this restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it's a destination that captures the maritime soul of the city. Operating as a quintessential Seafood restaurant, it offers a welcome escape with a Casual, Cozy, and Historic atmosphere that is perfect for both locals and tourists.

City Island Lobster House specializes in the freshest catches, particularly its namesake lobster, preparing it in a variety of classic and modern ways. The restaurant prides itself on being a family-owned establishment that places a high value on great service and even greater food, a sentiment echoed by long-time patrons. It successfully blends the allure of a traditional seafood house with the diverse offerings of a full-service New York restaurant, ensuring there’s something for everyone, even "Land Lubbers" who prefer turf over surf.

The menu is built around generous portions, fresh ingredients, and a commitment to classic American seafood cooking, all while maintaining the personalized touch of a family-run business. This spot stands as a beacon of great food and service on City Island, recommended highly by those who value quality, fresh dining in a unique Bronx setting. With its extensive bar selection and focus on serving local specialty seafood, the City Island Lobster House remains a beloved fixture in the New York dining landscape.

Location and Accessibility

City Island Lobster House is uniquely situated at the very end of the Bronx, on the quaint peninsula of City Island. This distinct location provides a lovely, relaxed atmosphere often associated with New England coastal towns, yet remains firmly within the borders of New York City.

The exact address is 691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464, USA.

Accessibility is a key focus, making the dining experience stress-free for all patrons. The establishment provides:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot.

Furthermore, parking logistics—often a concern in the city—are simplified with a Free parking lot, Free street parking, and convenient Valet parking service. Given its popularity and status as a destination for Lunch and Dinner, reservations are recommended to secure seating and ensure a timely experience, particularly during peak hours. The historic and slightly remote location on Bridge Street offers a peaceful waterfront feel that is truly worth the drive for a relaxing meal.

Services Offered

City Island Lobster House offers a comprehensive range of dining services designed for comfort, convenience, and a high-quality experience. Their services cater to various dining preferences, from casual lunches to large group dinners.

• Dine-in: Full Table service is provided in an atmosphere suitable for a Romantic, Historic, or Casual outing, complete with a full Bar onsite.
• Outdoor seating: A highly desirable option that allows guests to enjoy the unique City Island environment while dining.
• Takeout: Meals can be quickly prepared for those who prefer to enjoy their seafood at home or elsewhere.
• Reservations: The restaurant Accepts reservations, with Lunch reservations recommended and Dinner reservations recommended due to its popularity, especially among Groups and Locals.
• Private dining room: Available for special events, business functions, or large family gatherings.
• Catering: Services are available for offsite events, bringing their celebrated seafood and turf menu to any location.
• Full Bar & Beverage Service: Offering Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and a Great wine list, alongside Great beer selection and Great cocktails.
• Children’s Accommodations: The restaurant is Good for kids, providing High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu.

Features / Highlights

What makes the City Island Lobster House a standout is its combination of a classic menu with a commitment to a full, high-quality dining experience.

• Authentic Lobster and Seafood Focus: Specializing in fresh lobster and an extensive variety of seafood, including Baked Day Boat Sea Scallops, Jumbo Shrimp Scampi, and a Broiled Seafood Combination, the restaurant is a genuine haven for seafood lovers.
• Steak and Surf & Turf Excellence: Beyond seafood, the menu features high-quality prime cuts like the 22 oz. Porterhouse Steak and the extravagant Surf & Turf Porterhouse Steak, ensuring superb options for "Land Lubbers" and those seeking classic combination meals.
• Award-Worthy Beverages: Customers frequently praise the bar offerings, noting the Great cocktails—specifically a "best I ever had" margarita—and the extensive Great wine list.
• Historic and Romantic Setting: The Historic and Cozy atmosphere makes it ideal for a Romantic dinner or a memorable outing, offering a unique backdrop distinct from typical city dining.
• Menu Variety and Inclusivity: The menu covers a wide range of needs, featuring Healthy options, Small plates, Comfort food, Late-night food, and even a Braille menu for accessibility.
• Signature Combination Feasts: Unique menu highlights include the Lobster House Crab and Lobster Feast and various Extraordinary Combinations like the Steak & Lobster Tail and Whole Lobster & Fried Shrimp, perfect for sharing.

Contact Information

For patrons planning a visit to this City Island gem, the contact information is readily available for reservations and general inquiries.

Address: 691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 885-1459

The restaurant also provides its mobile contact, +1 718-885-1459, for streamlined communication. With its popularity among Locals and its reputation as a destination for Tourists, contacting the restaurant directly to secure a table, especially for Dinner, is strongly encouraged. The dedication of the team, from the owner Joe to the attentive waitstaff like Danielle and Moises, ensures that any pre-visit inquiry will be handled professionally and helpfully.

What is Worth Choosing

Navigating the extensive menu at City Island Lobster House can be a delight, but a few items stand out based on the restaurant's specialties and customer acclaim.

The Signature Lobster: Since the word "Lobster" is in the name, ordering a dish featuring this shellfish is essential. The Whole Lobster & Fried Shrimp ($54.95) combination offers the best of both worlds—a complete, classic seafood feast. Alternatively, the Lobster Mac ‘N Cheese ($38.95) is a decadent and popular Comfort food choice that showcases the quality of the fresh seafood in a richer preparation.

The Catch of the Day: For patrons who prefer simply prepared fresh fish, choosing from the Catch of the Day selection is highly recommended. You can select your fish—such as Norwegian Salmon ($34.95), Red Snapper Filet ($31.95), or Mahi-Mahi ($31.95)—and have it grilled, baked, fried, or sautéed to your exact preference. This section is where the freshness of their ingredients truly shines.

Exemplary Appetizers and Drinks: Start your meal with the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail ($21.95) for a cold, fresh bite, or the Crab Cakes ($22.95) for a hot starter. Crucially, don't miss the bar. Customers consistently rave about the cocktail quality; requesting their signature White Sangria or a perfectly mixed Margarita is highly advised to complement the rich flavors of your meal. The overall combination of Fresh and good portions with Great service guarantees a memorable dining experience, making it a primary choice for anyone on City Island.

City Island Lobster House

691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464, USA