Margaritas Cafe Wantagh: Authentic Mexican Cuisine & Vibrant Long Island Dining

Margaritas Cafe Introduce

For New York residents, particularly those in the Long Island area, Margaritas Cafe in Wantagh has firmly established itself as a vibrant culinary destination offering an authentic taste of Mexican cuisine and a lively social atmosphere. This is more than just a typical restaurant; it is a full-service Mexican restaurant that also functions as a highly rated Bar, a spirited Sports bar, and an experienced Catering food and drink supplier, making it a versatile and indispensable part of the Nassau County dining scene.

Stepping into Margaritas Cafe, patrons are immediately greeted by a colorful, festive, and inviting ambiance. The atmosphere is consistently described as being Casual, Cozy, and Trendy, with decor that often reflects a celebratory spirit, as noted in customer reviews that mention timely decorations, such as the Halloween theme. The culinary experience is rooted in tradition, with a focus on delivering high-quality, flavorful dishes—from the freshly prepared GUACAMOLE EN MOLCAJETE to savory steaks and expansive seafood options.

The name itself, Margaritas Cafe, hints at one of its major draws: a comprehensive and creative drink menu that features an array of signature margaritas and other classic favorites. Whether you are visiting for a quick Lunch, a lively Dinner, or planning a large event, this Wantagh location combines genuine hospitality with a broad and appealing selection of food and drink, creating a dynamic environment that is equally welcoming to Family-friendly groups, College students, and large Groups of friends.

Location and Accessibility

Margaritas Cafe is strategically located in Wantagh, ensuring easy access for customers throughout Long Island. Its position within Nassau County makes it a convenient and well-known spot for locals seeking delicious Mexican fare and a festive atmosphere. The precise address is:

753 Wantagh Ave #2133, Wantagh, NY 11793

Recognizing the needs of its diverse New York clientele, the cafe is highly accessible, featuring excellent provisions for all guests, which greatly enhances the overall convenience. Accessibility features include:

Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot, with additional Free parking lot and Free street parking options, and On-site parking generally available.
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Furthermore, the establishment understands the importance of flexible seating. They offer standard Seating, Outdoor seating, and even permit Dogs allowed outside, allowing patrons to enjoy the vibrant setting with their four-legged companions when dining al fresco. The availability of ample parking is a key benefit, especially in a busy Long Island hub like Wantagh.

Services Offered

The extensive menu and service options at Margaritas Cafe go far beyond standard restaurant offerings, reflecting its multifaceted identity as a bar, a caterer, and a dining hub. Services are designed to accommodate nearly any need, from a quick solo meal to a significant catered event.

Dining Availability: Open for Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, with dedicated Dessert service. Table service is provided for seated guests.
Off-Premise Services: Offers comprehensive Catering services, positioning itself as a reliable Catering food and drink supplier for both personal and professional events across the region.
Convenient To-Go Options: Supports modern convenience with Takeout, Delivery, Curbside pickup, and No-contact delivery.
Reservations and Planning: Accepts Reservations, which are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends, as there can Usually a wait.
Special Offerings: Includes Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food to appeal to the after-work crowd and those looking for great value.
Family Amenities: Is Good for kids, offering a dedicated Kids' menu (for children under 12, including one soda) with favorites like CHICKEN FINGERS and CHEESE QUESADILLA, along with High chairs.
Payment Methods: Accepts all major Credit cards and Debit cards, alongside modern NFC mobile payments.

The dual role as a bar and grill is enhanced by the Bar onsite amenity, ensuring every meal is perfectly paired with a choice beverage, whether a classic soda from the Kid's Lunch Menu or one of their famous margaritas.

Features / Highlights

Margaritas Cafe's appeal stems from a carefully curated set of features that prioritize quality and atmosphere. These highlights combine to create a compelling reason for New Yorkers to choose this location for their dining and entertainment needs.

Unrivaled Drink Selection: The cafe lives up to its name with an excellent array of offerings, including Great cocktails (such as the MARGARITAS DE LA CASA and specialty options like CANCUN MARGARITA), a wide variety of Great beer selection (including popular Mexican and domestic beers like CORONA and MODELO ESPECIAL), and a Great wine list. Patrons can also enjoy creative options like the full PITCHER MOJITO or PITCHER SANGRIA.
Menu Diversity and Quality: The extensive menu features traditional Mexican classics alongside healthy and modern options. Offerings include Comfort food, Small plates, a Salad bar, Healthy options, Organic dishes, and Vegetarian options. The selection ranges from light soups like SOPA AZTECA to hearty entrees such as the MAR Y TIERRA (Surf & Turf) and various steak selections like BISTEC ALA BRASA.
Authentic Entertainment: Live music is a major highlight, adding a festive and authentic layer to the dining experience that many customers love, contributing significantly to the cafe's lively atmosphere.
Dining Experience: Known for Fast service, ensuring timely delivery of food from the appetizers to the main course. The restaurant also caters to the late-night crowd with Late-night food options.
Sweet Endings: Features Great dessert options, providing a perfect conclusion to any meal.

The fusion of a Casual, Trendy atmosphere with such a diverse, high-quality menu ensures that Margaritas Cafe is a place for celebration, relaxation, and delicious, authentic cuisine.

Contact Information

For New York users looking to make a reservation, inquire about catering services, or confirm hours, the following direct contact details for the Wantagh location are provided:

Address: 753 Wantagh Ave #2133, Wantagh, NY 11793
Phone: (516) 595-7278
Mobile Phone: +1 516-595-7278

What is Worth Choosing Margaritas Cafe

Choosing Margaritas Cafe in Wantagh, NY, means selecting a dining experience that offers an exceptional balance of authentic flavors, a lively atmosphere, and comprehensive service—qualities that are highly valued by Long Island residents. The restaurant stands out for several compelling reasons that make it worth your visit.

Firstly, the menu is a celebration of authentic Mexican cuisine, going well beyond standard fare. From the sheer variety of Tacos de la Casa and Enchiladas (including ENCHILADAS DE MOLE POBLANO), to specialized, richly flavored Lunch Platos Tipicos like CHIMICHANGAS and FLAUTAS, and an impressive Mar Bueno / Seafood list featuring dishes like JAMBALAYA and PAELLA EN CASUELA, the options are extensive and cater to every palate. The quality of ingredients, from C.A.B. grilled steaks to fresh seafood, underpins the positive food reviews.

Secondly, the beverage program is a powerful draw. The variety of MARGARITAS (by the glass) and the option for PITCHERS of specialty drinks like the PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA and PITCHER MOJITO establish the bar as a premier spot for social gatherings and celebrations. This commitment to quality drinks is frequently mentioned in customer reviews, highlighting the skill of the bartenders and the quality of the house specials.

Finally, the restaurant's versatility is a key reason for its appeal. It effectively serves multiple roles: an engaging spot for Solo dining, a fun place for a family meal with a dedicated Kids' menu, and a vibrant venue for Groups to enjoy Live music. The additional offerings like Catering and a lively Sports bar atmosphere ensure that Margaritas Cafe is a solution for nearly any social or dining need in the Wantagh area. While some external reviews point to occasional inconsistencies in service regarding special promotions, the overwhelming sentiment emphasizes the delicious, high-quality food and the attractive, celebratory environment, making it a reliable and favorite local gem for authentic Mexican dining on Long Island.

Margaritas Cafe Menu

Lunch Appetizers
GUACAMOLE EN MOLCAJETE $9.95
Freshly made a la vista
CEVICHE DE CAMARONE $11.95
Shrimp / Celery / Cucumbers / Green Olives / Onions / Cocktail Sauce / Cilantro & served with plantain chips
TAQUITOS DE POLLO $9.95
Crispy rolled tortilla stuffed with chicken, topped with queso fresco, crema & guacamole sauce with tampiquena
NACHOS SUPREME $9.95
Fresh made Tortilla chips topped with refried beans, melted cheese, Veracruzana sauce, sour cream, guacamole & jalapeños
JALAPENO POPPERS $9.95
Jalapeños stuffed with cheddar cheese. Served with guacamole, sour cream, & pico de gallo
ALITAS DE POLLO $9.95
Buffalo Wings served with celery sticks & blue cheese
MEXICAN QUESADILLAS $10.95
Flour tortilla stuffed with shredded mozzarella cheese. Served with Veracruzana sauce, guacamole and sour cream
ADD CHICKEN $14.95
ADD STEAK $15.95
ADD SHRIMP $15.94
FRIED CALAMARI $11.95
Served with Salsa Verde, Salsa Blanca & Salsa Roja
QUESO FUNDIDO $10.95
Melted mozzarella cheese, chorizo, tampiquena sauce, baked in skillet topped with cilantro and onions. Served with side a flour tortilla
EMPANADAS $10.95
Homemade shredded beef Mexican sofrito, topped with shrimp and chicken sautéed in a Mayan sauce
TOSTONES RELLENOS $11.95
Fried plantains stuffed with shrimp, chicken, ground beef. topped with queso blanco and cilantro. Served with Chili guajillo sauce
SOL RANCHERO $11.95
Nachos & quesados topped with melted cheese, jalapeños, lettuce, sour cream, guacamole and Veracruzana sauce
LA FAMILIA $20.95
Buffalo chicken wings, nachos, taquitos, jalapeno poppers, chorizo and quesado served with guacamole, sour cream, with tampiquena sauce
AGUACATE RELLENO $11.95
Avocado stuffed with diced shrimp, a dash of lemon juice, topped with red onion, radish, cilantro, pinch of paprika

Lunch Sides
PLATANOS FRITOS CON CREMA $4.95
Fried Plantains with crema
ESPINACA DE AJO $4.95
Spinach with garlic and oil
TAMALE DE ELOTE $4.95
Fresh corn tamale with crema
GUACAMOLE $4.95
Side of guacamole
RAJAS DE AGUACATE $4.95
Sliced avocado
RAJAS DE JALAPENOS $4.95
Jalapenos sautéd with onions Mexican Style
MAIZ BLANCO $4.95
Sautéed Peruvian corn
MELTED CHEESE $4.95
Melted nacho cheese
TOSTONES $4.95
Fried plantain disks
SOUR CREAM $1.95
SHREDDED MOZZARELLA $1.95
TORTILLA CHIPS (EXTRA) $3.95
Limit 2 baskets per table

SALADS & SOUPS
MARGARITA SALAD $9.95
Mixed salad with romaine, iceberg, red cabbage, cucumber, tomato and grilled zucchini. Served in a crunchy taco shell bowl, topped with queso fresco and balsamic vinegar
ADD CHICKEN $3.95
ADD SHRIMP OR STEAK $4.95
TACO SALAD $10.95
Mixed salad with romaine, iceberg, red cabbage, cucumber, tomato with choice of ground beef or shredded chicken topped with mozzarella, black beans and balsamic vinegar
ADD CHICKEN $3.95
ADD SHRIMP OR STEAK $4.95
SALMON SALAD $14.95
Pan seared salmon over mixed romaine salad, iceberg, red cabbage, tomatoes, cucumber with lemon garlic sauce
MEXICAN AVOCADO SALAD $9.95
With mixed salad, romaine, iceberg, red cabbage, red onions, tomatoes, avocado, served with Margarita dressing
ADD CHICKEN $3.95
ADD SHRIMP OR STEAK $4.95
SOPA AZTECA $5.95
Blended tortilla soup with pasilla, chili, queso blanco, avocado, tomato and chicken. Topped with Mexican onions
SOPA NEGRA $5.95
Black bean soup
SOPA DE POLLO $5.95
Chicken Soup with mixed vegetables

Lunch Platos De La Casa
#1 TACOS DE LA CASA $11.95
Crispy corn tortilla shell with choice of shredded chicken or ground beef, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and Veracruzana sauce. Served with rice and refried beans
#2 TACOS AL CARBON $11.95
Soft corn tortilla with chopped grilled chicken breast, sautéed with Veracruzana sauce, onions, a dash of cilantro, served with rice and refried beans
#3 TACOS MEXICANOS $14.95
Soft corn tortilla shell with choice of grilled skirt steak or shrimp sautéed with butter, onions, and a dash of cilantro, Veracruzana sauce. Topped with pico de gallo, queso fresco. Served with rice and refried beans
#4 TACOS DE PESCADO $13.95
Soft corn tortilla shell with pan seared tilapia, topped with pico de gallo, queso fresco, cilantro, served with rice and refried beans
#5 TACOS DE PUERCO $12.95
Soft corn tortilla shell with marinated pork loin, sautéed with adobo, garlic, onion, cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.

Enchiladas
#6 ENCHILADAS SUIZAS
Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken. Topped with green tomatillo sauce and melted cheese and sour cream. Garnished with onion and cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.
WITH CHICKEN $11.95
WITH SHRIMP $13.95
#7 ENCHILADAS ROJAS MIXTAS $11.95
Three soft rolled corn tortillas, one with steak, second with chicken, third with cheese, topped with Guajillo sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.
JUST STEAK $12.95
#8 ENCHILADAS DE MOLE POBLANO $11.95
Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken, topped with mole sauce and melted cheese. Served with rice and refried beans
#9 ENCHILADAS DE CHORIZO $12.95
Soft rolled corn tortilla stuffed with Mexican chorizo. Topped with guajillo sauce, melted Oaxaca cheese. Served with rice and refried beans

Lunch Platos Tipicos
#10 BURRITO MOJADO $11.95
Soft tortilla stuffed with grilled steak, Willy's style with refried beans, Oaxaca cheese, lettuce, Tampiquena sauce. Topped with tomatillo sauce, sour cream, guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans
#11 EL REY BURRITO $11.95
Soft Tortilla stuffed with chicken, chorizo, beans, grilled mushrooms and topped with chipotle and mozzarella cheese. Served with rice and refried beans
#12 CHIMICHANGAS $11.95
Crispy rolled flour tortilla, choice of shredded beef or shredded chicken topped with tampiquena sauce, sour cream, guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans
#13 FLAUTAS $11.95
Crispy rolled corn tortilla stuffed with chicken & topped with tampiquena sauce, sour cream, guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans
#14 HOMEMADE TAMALES $11.95
Homemade tamales wrapped in corn husks, stuffed in corn meal dough, with choice of chicken or beef, then baked and topped with a non spicy homemade chipotle sauce
#15 FAJITA FRITA $12.95
Flour tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken, mozzarella cheese, sautéed onions and peppers. Topped with chilango sauce and queso fresco. Served with rice and refried beans
#16 CHEESE QUESADILLAS $11.95
Flour tortilla with melted Oaxaca cheese
ADD CHICKEN $2.95
ADD SHRIMP OR STEAK $3.95

Lunch Pollos de la Casa
#17 POLLO MARGARITAS $14.95
Chicken on the bone, marinated in our oldest secret recipe. Fried and baked with white wine, lemon, garlic and cilantro. Served with rice and black beans
#18 POLLO AGUACATE $13.95
Grilled chicken breast with melted Oaxaca cheese topped with a touch of Tampiquena sauce, garnished with avocado. Served with rice and refried beans
#19 ARROZ CON POLLO $13.95
Diced chicken breast sautéed in garlic butter, white wine. Served with rice and beans with a touch of Veracruzana sauce and lettuce
#20 MOLE POBLANO $13.95
National dish of Mexico, complex assortment of sauces with over 25 ingredients served with sautéed diced chicken stewed in mole sauce. Served with rice and refried beans
#21 POLLO JALISCO $13.95
Chicken breast sautéd with artichoke hearts, jalapenos, capers and white wine lemon butter sauce. Served with black beans
#22 PECHUGA ADOBADA $13.95
Adobo marinated grilled chicken breast with guajillo sauce and warm pico de gallo
#23 ALAMBRE DE POLLO $13.95
Two skewers of chicken, onions, peppers, open flame grilled. Served over rice and avocado salad

Lunch Vegetarian
#24 QUESADILLAS DE CALABASITA $12.95
Flour tortilla stuffed with grilled yellow and green squash melted cheese, topped with salsa ranchera, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans

Lunch Mar Bueno / Seafood
#27 CAMARONES EN SALSA VERDE $16.95
Jumbo shrimp in an emulsion of fine herbs, garlic, white wine and fumed green tomatillo. Served with rice and refried beans
#28 JAMBALAYA $18.95
Crawfish meat, shrimp, chicken and sausage sautéd with green peppers and onions over Cajun rice in maya sauce. Served with Avocado salad
#29 CAMARONES AL CHIPOTLE $16.95
Tequila flamed shrimp in chipotle sauce served in fried taco bowl. Served with rice and refried beans
#30 MARISCADA DE LA CASA VERACRUZANA $24.95
Lobster tail, shrimp, scallops, clams and mussels in tomato green tomatillo and garlic broth. Served with rice and beans
#31 QUESADILLA DE LANGOSTA $23.95
Flour tortilla filled with lobster meat, adobo sauce, guacamole, sour cream and tampiquena sauce. Served with refried beans and rice
#32 PAELLA EN CASUELA $25.95
Lobster tail, shrimp, chorizo, scallops, clam and mussels tossed with saffron rice
#33 MIXIOTE DE SALMON $18.95
Grilled salmon marinated in guajillo sauce with manchamanteles. Served with avocado salad and Mexican rice
#34 CAMARONES EMPANISADO $17.95
Breaded Shrimp with rice and Avocado Salad
#35 PESCADO BLANCO $16.95
Tilapia sautéed in garlic, olive oil, white whine, roasted lime sauce. Served with rice and seasonal vegetables.
#36 MAR Y TIERRA $26.95
Lobster tail, tender grilled C.A.B. shell steak, shrimp, guajillo sauce, queso blanco. Served with black beans and Mexican rice

Lunch Steaks
#37 BISTEC ALA BRASA $17.95
Grilled New York strip steak, with roasted seasonal vegetables moro rice and mariquitas
#38 TAMPIQUENAS $17.95
C.A.B. grilled shell steak and cheese enchilada topped with tampiquena sauce. Served with rice, beans and avacado
#39 CARNE RANCHERA $17.95
14 oz C.A.B. skirt steak topped w/ onion, peppers, jalapeños, Veracruzana sauce and adobo Mexicano. Served with rice and black beans
#40 ROPA VIEJA MEXICANA $18.95
Braised and shredded flank steak topped with classic salsa havana criollo. Served with sweet plantains, rice and black beans
#41 COSTILLA DE CORDERO AL CHIPOTLE $22.95
Grilled baby rack of lamb chops rubbed with a chipotle & garlic adobo, topped with guajillo sauce and served with rice and black beans
#42 CERDO EN ADOBO PICANTE $15.95
Grilled pork chop marinated in chipotle adobo topped with sautéed red and green peppers. Served with rice and black beans
#43 BISTEC CON CAMARONES $18.95
C.A.B. tender shell steak marinated in a Mexican style broth served with shrimp a la tampiquena sauce. Served with rice and black beans
#44 MEXICAN FALDITA $15.95
Grilled strips of skirt steak served with black beans topped with queso fresco rice and avocado
#45 PARILLA MEXICANA (FOR TWO) $38.95
Baby back ribs, BBQ chicken, steak, shrimp and grilled chorizo, salad, black beans and rice
#46 MARGARITA SKILLET $24.95
Grilled & seasoned C.A.B. shell steak, pork chop, skirt steak and chicken topped with cebollas served on a sizzling skillet with rice, black beans and flour tortilla
#47 BBQ SHRIMP & RIBS OR BBQ SHRIMP & CHICKEN $20.95
Shrimp & ribs served with french fries / Shrimp & chicken served with rice and beans

Lunch Fajitas
#48 VEGETARIAN FAJITA $13.95
Seasonal vegetables, squash, carrot, onion, peppers and cauliflower
#49 CHICKEN FAJITA $14.95
Sizzling marinated chicken strips on a bed of sautéd onions and green peppers
#50 STEAK FAJITA $15.95
Sizzling marinated steak strips on a bed of sautéd onions and green peppers
#51 SHRIMP FAJITA $16.95
Sizzling marinated shrimp on a bed of sautéd onions and green peppers
#52 FAJITA COMBO $18.95
Combination of shrimp, chicken and steak fajita
#53 SALMON FAJITA $23.95
Sizzling salmon filet on a bed of onions and peppers garnished with wedges of lemon

Kid's Lunch Menu - (Under 12 - Includes One Soda)
CHICKEN FINGERS $10.95
Chicken strips breaded and crispy fried. Served with rice and refried beans
ARROZ CON POLLO $10.95
Strips of lean chicken breast sautéed with garlic butter with refried beans
CHEESE QUESADILLA $10.95
Flour tortillas with cheese. Served with refried beans and rice
TACOS (HARD OR SOFT) $10.95
Choice of ground beef or chicken topped with lettuce and cheese with refried beans and rice
BEEF BURRITO $10.95
Soft flour tortilla stuffed with beef, lettuce, cheese and beans, choice of refried beans and rice or french fries

Lunch Non Alcohol Drinks
PINA COLADA $5.95
MANGO COLADA $5.95
STRAWBERRY COLADA $5.95
ASSORTED FLAVORS $5.95

Lunch Margaritas (by the glass)
MARGARITAS DE LA CASA $10.95
MARGARITA SPECIAL $12.95
CANCUN MARGARITA $12.95
MARGARITA MAYA $12.95
APPLE MARGARITA $12.95
MAR AZUL $12.95
MARGARITA DE CORAZÓN $12.95
FLAVORED MARGARITA $12.95

Lunch Pitchers
1/2 PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA $18.95
1/2 PITCHER SPECIALTY MARGARITA $24.95
1/2 PITCHER MARGARITA DE FRUTA $19.95
1/2 PITCHER DAIQUIRIS $19.95
1/2 PITCHER MOJITO $30.95
1/2 PITCHER SANGRIA $29.95
1/2 PITCHER PINA COLADA $19.95
PITCHER REGULAR MARGARITA $25.95
PITCHER SPECIALTY MARGARITA $37.95
PITCHER MARGARITA DE FRUTA $30.95
PITCHER DAIQUIRIS $30.95
PITCHER PINA COLADA $30.95
PITCHER SANGRIA $30.95
PITCHER MOJITO $46.95

Lunch Classic Favorites
DAIQUIRIS $10.95
Raspberry / Strawberry / Peach / Mango / Coconut / Banana / Pomegranate
PINA COLADA $10.95
Crema de coco / Pineapple Juice / Fine rum
SANGRIA $10.95
Blanca / Roja / Passion Fruit / Coconut / Guava (choice of blanca or roja)

Lunch Cervezas / Beers
CORONA $7.95
DOS EQUIS LAGER $7.95
MODELO ESPECIAL $7.95
PACIFICO $7.95
CORONA LIGHT $7.95
DOS EQUIS AMBER $7.95
NEGRA MODELO $7.95
TECATE $7.95
HEINEKEN $7.95
COORS LIGHT $7.95
BUDWEISER LIGHT $7.95
HEINEKEN LIGHT $7.95
MICHELOB ULTRA $7.95
AMSTEL LIGHT $7.95
BUDWEISER $7.95

Margaritas Cafe Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Salad bar
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations
Usually a wait

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Margaritas Cafe Photos

Margaritas Cafe Location

Margaritas Cafe

New York Nassau County Wantagh Wantagh Avenue

753 Wantagh Ave #2133, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

Margaritas Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 850 user reviews.

guacamolemariachimusicbirthdaysangriabartendercolormanagerhappy hourskirt steak

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My wife and I went here for the first time and have to say we weren’t disappointed the food was great and came out hot from the appetizers to our main course. We sat in the bar area at one of the tables the bartender who also served us was awesome my wife loved the margaritas she made. The atmosphere was cool and decorated for Halloween we will definitely be going back.
October 19 · Danny Cook
I usually don’t post but I was upset about my experience at Margaritas Cafe in Wantagh today. I come here often because I LOVE the food, but today I went for their taco deal advertised online for taco day and was incredibly disappointed by how the situation was handled.I been to Margarita’s Café many times and usually love it, but my experience at the Wantagh location on Taco Day was really disappointing. Online (see attached screenshot), they advertised Unlimited Tacos for $21.95 AND House Margaritas for $2.95, so that’s why we came. When we got there, we ordered the drinks but didn’t get the special menu. When we asked about the unlimited taco deal, the waitress told us we couldn’t combine the offers — something that was never mentioned online. (Quote: “Unlimited tacos for $21.95 AND house margaritas for $2.95,” which is misleading — it implies both deals are included with no restrictions or location limits.) I politely explained this was the reason we came, and she said she could instead charge us full price for the margaritas and give us the taco deal. We said we’d think about it, but she never came back. Also- had I been given the menu originally and saw that there was a restriction I may have changed my order. We waited over an hour before another person finally came by, and at that point, we just asked for the check because we had completely lost interest.To top it off,I waited by the desk in the front to inquire about the taco menu to take a picture to send to a friend who wanted to come. A waiter ran over and rudely asked what I was doing. I said I just wanted to look at the special menu again, and he said they didn’t have one — until I mentioned the waitress had shown it to us, and then suddenly he pulled it out. It all felt really unprofessional and misleading.Between the false advertising, poor communication, and inattentive service, this visit left a bad impression. It’s a shame because I’ve always enjoyed Margarita’s Café, but after this experience, I won’t be going back 😞
October 07 · Alyssa Marcolini
This place is a hidden gem. I don’t know if all their restaurants are as good as the one in Wantagh but probably so. Food is amazing and drinks are beyond good. This place does it right when so many restaurants are cutting corners. Try the burrito mojado. Their restaurant In port Washington closed which is a shame. Highly suggest margaritas!!
July 26 · MIKE NA
Fun & festive spot! The food was delicious and the music was fun and a bit loud! We all enjoyed our meal. The guacamole was made table side and was fresh
October 21 · #SmartHomeSecurityNY
Racist staff - coming from a white person. Horrible service, owner was rude and lacked any accountability for him or his staff. Took 30 minutes to get a drink as every other table was served before us, even though they were sat after us. When our bill was charged incorrectly- mind you I wasn't even trying to ask for a refund or credit, just simply have it fixed. The rude waitress who had no courtesy or skills immediately got defensive and sent the owner over. The owner proceeded to accuse me of having too much to drink ( I was the designated driver and only had water). While the owner was speaking with me the two waitresses on duty stood behind him and were giving me threatening looks. I informed the owner of this and he again refused to acknowledge this. I would highly suggest avoiding this place - extremely unprofessional and terrible management and even worse service. Food is questionable, lacks flavor.-update went back and was threatened by staff
September 02 · Gina Waterbury