Mr. Nick's Restaurant

- 19 N Broadway, Tarrytown, NY 10591

Welcome to Mr. Nick's Restaurant, a true culinary fixture nestled in the charming heart of Tarrytown, New York. For over 15 years, this family-run establishment at 19 N Broadway has been synonymous with exceptional, homemade, and old-school Italian cooking. It stands as a testament to warm hospitality, quality ingredients, and a dedication to traditional recipes that have made it a cherished gathering spot for families, friends, and discerning food enthusiasts across the Lower Hudson Valley.

More than just a local pizzeria, Mr. Nick's has cultivated a reputation as one of Tarrytown's premier Italian dining destinations. The core of its fame lies in its celebrated brick oven pizza, often hailed by locals as some of the best in the region—a perfect blend of artful craftsmanship and delectable flavor. However, the culinary journey at Mr. Nick’s extends far beyond pizza, encompassing a diverse and extensive menu that honors the rich tapestry of Italian cuisine, from hearty pasta dishes and fresh salads to robust entrees and satisfying heroes. Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its friendly, accommodating staff, the welcoming and comfortable atmosphere, and the generous portion sizes, ensuring a memorable and satisfying experience whether you are stopping by for a quick lunch or a full family dinner.

Mr. Nick's beautifully renovated interior offers a modern yet cozy and casual dining atmosphere, making it ideal for everything from a date night to a large family gathering. The ambiance is inviting, and the team is known for their outstanding service and genuine hospitality. The menu itself is a celebration of Italy’s diverse culinary regions, expertly blending Southern Italian classics, which often feature bold, tomato-based sauces, olive oil, and seafood, with richer Northern Italian influences like the inclusion of creamy sauces, specialty risottos, and veal dishes. This fusion ensures there is a perfect dish for every palate and preference.

For those in search of authentic Italian food in the Westchester County area, Mr. Nick's Restaurant is an essential stop. It represents the very essence of a beloved local eatery—a place where quality food, family values, and community spirit come together to create an outstanding dining experience.

Location and Accessibility

Mr. Nick’s Restaurant is conveniently situated at 19 N Broadway, placing it directly in a vibrant and accessible area of Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA. This prominent North Broadway location makes it an easy destination for both locals and visitors exploring the historic and lively village.

Accessibility is a key focus, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment is equipped with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible restroom. For guests arriving by car, both free and paid street parking options are available nearby. While parking can sometimes be tricky during peak hours, the central location in Tarrytown is worth the short stroll.

The casual and cozy atmosphere, combined with the comprehensive accessibility features, makes Mr. Nick's a welcoming spot for college students, tourists, family-friendly groups, and solo diners alike to enjoy genuine Italian flavors.

Services Offered

Mr. Nick's Restaurant provides a wide array of services designed to meet diverse dining needs, from a casual quick bite to full-scale event catering:

• Dine-in Seating: Enjoy a full-service experience in the comfortable, newly renovated, and inviting dining room, which includes bar seating.
• Takeout and Curbside Pickup: Conveniently place your order for pickup to enjoy fresh Italian meals at home.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Fast and reliable delivery service is available to bring your favorite dishes directly to your door.
• Catering Food and Drink Supplier: A full catering menu is offered, featuring large-format trays of pasta, entrees, salads, and appetizers perfect for any event or gathering.
• Full Bar Service: Enjoy a selection of alcoholic beverages, including beer, spirits, wine, cocktails, and happy hour drinks/food specials.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, which are especially recommended during peak dining hours to secure seating.
• Private Dining: A private dining room may be available for special occasions or larger group functions.

Features and Highlights

Mr. Nick's prides itself on several key features that set it apart as a premier Italian eatery in the Westchester area:

• Specialty Brick Oven Pizza: Renowned throughout the community for exceptional, artfully crafted pies, including unique varieties like the Mimosa Pizza, Lasagna Pizza, and Grandma Pizza.
• A Blend of Northern and Southern Italian Cuisine: The menu offers diverse options like creamy Risotto Funghi (Northern influence) and various seafood and Fra Diavolo pasta dishes (Southern influence), ensuring a comprehensive tour of Italian flavors.
• Extensive Menu Diversity: Beyond pizza, the menu is massive, covering classics like Veal Marsala, Chicken Scarpariello, Eggplant Parmigiana, an impressive list of Specialty Pastas (e.g., Rigatoni Alla Nick, Lobster Ravioli), a full range of Heroes, Paninis, and fresh Salads.
• Commitment to Dietary Needs: The restaurant provides options for those with various dietary preferences, including Halal food, Vegetarian options, Vegan options, and a dedicated Gluten-Free Pizza option prepared and cooked to prevent cross-contamination.
• Friendly, Family-Focused Atmosphere: Customers consistently highlight the warm hospitality, friendly owners, and attentive staff, making it a great choice for kids, with a specific kid-friendly menu and high chairs available.
• Comfort and Amenities: Patrons can enjoy amenities such as a bar onsite, outdoor seating, clean restrooms, and Wi-Fi access in a relaxed, casual, and cozy atmosphere.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or place an order at Mr. Nick's Restaurant, please use the following contact details:

Address: 19 N Broadway, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone Number: (914) 366-0666

Mobile Phone: +1 914-366-0666

What is Worth Choosing

When deciding what to try at Mr. Nick's, the overwhelming consensus points to the masterful blend of Italian tradition and local flavor. It is a place where every dish, from a simple slice of cheese pizza to a complex entree, is crafted with passion.

The Brick Oven Pizza is an absolute must-try—it’s the cornerstone of their reputation. Specialty options like the Vodka & Muzz Pizza or the hearty Lasagna Pizza are local legends. For those craving classic Italian comfort food, the extensive pasta menu is exceptional. The house favorite, Rigatoni Alla Nick, featuring sweet sausage, roasted red peppers, melted mozzarella, and marinara, is a delicious, savory choice that perfectly encapsulates the restaurant's approach to generous portions and robust flavor. Seafood lovers should explore the Linguini & Clams or the satisfying Zuppa Di Pesce.

The entree selection offers traditional favorites prepared with an attention to detail, such as the perfectly prepared Chicken Scarpariello with hot and sweet cherry peppers, a popular dish highly recommended by loyal diners, and the classic Veal Parmigiana. And don't forget to cap off your meal with one of their fresh, homemade desserts, like the Freshly Filled Cannoli or the rich Tiramisu, which customers consistently rave about.

In essence, Mr. Nick's Restaurant provides a reliable, high-quality, and friendly Italian dining experience that stands out in the New York region. It’s an essential local gem where you can expect excellent food, generous value, and the kind of warm, family-style service that keeps people coming back year after year. Whether you’re a Westchester local or just passing through Tarrytown, a meal here is a delightful, authentic taste of Italy.

Mr. Nick's Restaurant

19 N Broadway, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA