Picky Barista Introduce
In a city that runs on caffeine, finding the perfect coffee shop is a personal quest for many New Yorkers. The Upper West Side, with its charming streets and academic institutions, has no shortage of options, but Picky Barista offers a unique and welcoming space that sets it apart. Located on a vibrant stretch of West 72nd Street, this coffee shop is more than just a place to grab a quick drink; it’s a destination that blends a trendy, artistic vibe with a genuinely relaxed atmosphere.
As soon as you step inside, you’ll notice the bohemian touches that give the space its cool, vintage feel. Plants, art, and even a suspended bicycle create an environment that feels both curated and comfortable. This is a place where you can escape the city's relentless pace and simply enjoy a quiet moment. Despite its popularity and frequent crowds, the atmosphere remains surprisingly calm, making it a favorite spot for people looking to work, study, or just unwind. The combination of a cozy ambiance and a professionally run operation makes Picky Barista an appealing choice for a wide range of visitors, from local residents to tourists exploring the neighborhood. For a place that values both aesthetics and a satisfying experience, Picky Barista has hit the right notes, providing a much-needed haven for those who appreciate great coffee in a well-designed space. It has successfully created a unique identity in a crowded market, proving that thoughtful design and a focus on the customer experience can make all the difference.
---
Picky Barista is conveniently situated at 245 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023. This prime location places it in the heart of the Upper West Side, an area known for its accessibility and vibrant street life. The coffee shop is just a short walk from major landmarks and public transportation hubs, making it an ideal meeting point or a quick stop on your daily commute.
The most convenient way to reach the coffee shop is via the subway. The 72nd Street station, which is served by the 1, 2, and 3 lines, is located just around the corner. This proximity to a major transit line ensures that the cafe is easily accessible from various parts of Manhattan and beyond.
Picky Barista is committed to accessibility for all patrons. The establishment features a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that everyone can comfortably enjoy the space. The business's commitment to these features shows a dedication to creating an inclusive environment for the entire community. The location on a main street also means it’s easy to find and navigate, whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular customer.
---
Picky Barista offers a range of services designed to accommodate various customer needs.
- Dine-in: The coffee shop provides a full dine-in experience within its casual and cozy atmosphere. It is an excellent place to sit and enjoy your coffee, whether you are on your own or with a friend.
- Takeout: For customers on the go, Picky Barista offers efficient takeout service. You can quickly grab your order and continue with your busy day.
- Onsite Services: The cafe also offers onsite services, which likely include the ability to purchase coffee beans and other merchandise, as suggested by a customer review. This is a great feature for coffee lovers who want to enjoy the shop’s blends at home.
---
Picky Barista is a standout coffee shop for several key features and highlights.
- Great Coffee and Tea: As the name suggests, the coffee is a major draw. The shop is noted for its "great coffee" and "great tea selection." The menu includes a variety of coffee classics, from drip coffee and lattes to more specialized options like Balkan coffee and turmeric lattes, catering to a diverse range of preferences.
- Work-Friendly Environment: The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable, making it a popular spot for people working or studying. The availability of Wi-Fi is a key amenity that supports this use, providing a reliable and welcoming space for remote work or study sessions.
- Bohemian and Trendy Decor: The unique and artistic decor is a significant highlight. Features like plants, art, and a suspended bicycle give the space a cool, vintage feel that sets it apart from more generic coffee chains. This aesthetic adds to the overall experience and makes it a more enjoyable place to spend time.
- Perfect for Solo Dining: The cafe is highly popular for solo diners. Its atmosphere and layout are conducive to individual quiet time, whether you're simply enjoying a cup of coffee or getting lost in a book.
- Cleanliness: A standout point from a customer review is that the restroom was "very clean," which speaks to the overall level of care and professionalism of the establishment. This attention to detail contributes to a positive and comfortable experience for all guests.
---
To inquire about their menu, bean selection, or simply to get in touch, you can contact Picky Barista using the following information.
Address: 245 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023, USA
Phone: (212) 712-2227
---
Picky Barista is a compelling choice for New Yorkers seeking more than just a quick caffeine fix. While the coffee is a major draw—and, as one review notes, "satisfying"—the true value of the cafe lies in the overall experience it provides. The combination of its trendy, bohemian atmosphere, and its welcoming, work-friendly environment makes it a highly functional and aesthetically pleasing space. In a city where good coffee shops are plentiful, Picky Barista stands out by offering a place where you can truly relax and feel at ease, even when it’s busy.
The fact that it’s a great spot for working or studying, with Wi-Fi available, makes it a practical choice for students and professionals alike. This feature, combined with its popularity for solo dining, highlights its ability to cater to individual needs in a communal setting. The customer reviews, which praise the "efficient and professional" barista, the relaxed atmosphere despite the crowd, and the "cool, vintage feel" of the decor, all point to a consistent and positive experience. The option to buy coffee beans is another great feature, allowing customers to bring a piece of the cafe's quality home with them. Picky Barista has succeeded in creating a distinctive brand identity that goes beyond the product itself. For a New Yorker in search of a new go-to coffee spot that offers both quality and comfort, Picky Barista is a perfect choice for a quick stop or an extended stay. It’s a place that understands the importance of a great cup of coffee and a great atmosphere, a combination that is always in high demand.
Picky Barista Menu
Coffee Bar
- Drip Coffee $3.25
- Espresso $3.50
- Americano
- Cortado $4.50
- Latte $5.25
- Chai Latte $5.75
- Matcha Latte $5.25
- Turmeric Latte $5.25
- Mocha $5.50
- Cold Brew $5.75
- Iced Coffee $4.50
- Balkan Coffee $4.75
- Iced Tea $4.50
- Hot Chocolate $4.75
Others
- Массніато $3.75
- Flat White $5.25
- Τεα $3.75
Picky Barista Details
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Great coffee
- Great tea selection
Popular for
- Breakfast
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Dessert
- Table service
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Locals
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Picky Barista Photos










Picky Barista Location
Picky Barista Reviews
pastriesatmospherelattematchacappuccinomusiclaptopburekavocado toastwifi
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I recently visited Picky Barista and ordered a matcha latte. The drink was tasty, certainly not premium, but satisfying.The barista was efficient and professional,if a bit serious,which I appreciated.The Cafe was about 70% full, with many people working, but despite the crowd, the atmosphere felt relaxed and wasn't overwhelming.I really liked the bohemian touches in the decor - plants, art and a suspended bicycle gave the place a cool, vintage feel.The restroom was also very clean.Overall, it was a good experience for a quick stop, though nothing particularly made me want to rush back.
June 18 · Cari SanchezBought some coffee and some beans for my parents. I love the coffee and their space is nice. you can definitely use it for work or study
May 25 · GaluhExcellent, friendly service, but mediocre pastries and bad cold brew hold the place back. Horrible value for the money. (I don't care where I am in the world, if a cold brew costs $7, it has to be epic, or at least not overly bitter, like it was here.)Likely has such a high review score because they give you a free cookie for a 5 star review.I'd rather good cold brew than a free cookie, personally, particular given that based on the baklava and croissant, the cookie couldn't be any better than mid.
September 13 · Jeff ThibaultGood coffee. Quiet atmosphere. Wifi is great here. Pastries always look super yum.Addendum: I went here on a Sunday to get some work done after doing the same a few times during the week. There were signs for "no computer zone" / "let's talk to each other" and of course I didn't notice until I got my coffee and sat down to work. I went out alone with the intention of doing work on my computer. Let's face it, most people in New York City are not talking to strangers in 2025 in a meaningful way. If your goal is crowd control on weekends, just let it be known that you have a 1-2 hour stay policy during high-volume days. Not everyone is out to be social on the weekends unfortunately. It's off-putting to hide behind a facade of collectivism and community building when that's doesn't feel like the true intention of it. Maybe it's not that deep but TLDR it's not an ideal place for trying to get work done on the weekends. Great spot during the week though.
May 23 · Adrianna AlewineLovely environment. Coffee is good but the portions are tiiiiiny. A “large” is 12 oz. Baked goods (croissants, banana bread) are mediocre.
June 08 · Scott Pearson
More restaurants near me

445 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

411 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

655 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

441 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

461 W 34th St. Frnt 1, New York, NY 10001, USA

455 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

371 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

460 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

460 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

516W34St, New York, NY 10001, USA

30 Hudson Yards 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA

55 Hudson Yards, New York, NY 10001, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





