Pizza Heaven

- 357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553

Welcome to **Pizza Heaven**, a true local gem in the New Windsor area of New York. Known as much for its warm, cozy atmosphere as its authentic Italian cuisine, this establishment has quickly become a cornerstone for great food, excellent value, and dependable service. Far more than just a place for a quick bite, Pizza Heaven delivers a genuine New York-style pizza experience, crafted with care and a commitment to quality that shines through in every slice. For anyone in the Hudson Valley or New York region looking for that quintessential, perfectly cooked thin-crust pizza, your search ends here.

As a combination **Pizza restaurant** and classic **Italian restaurant**, the menu caters to every craving, focusing on comforting, satisfying fare. Locals consistently point to the quality of the dough, the fresh ingredients, and the dedication to traditional cooking methods. It's the kind of reliable, neighborhood spot that appeals to everyone from busy college students and large groups to families and solo diners looking for a casual, enjoyable meal. The vibe is always friendly, making it an ideal place to unwind after a long day or grab a delicious lunch. Whether you're planning a full dinner with seating and table service or just need the fastest **takeout** or **delivery** option, Pizza Heaven is structured to meet your needs with speed and quality. This focus on customer satisfaction and high-quality food is precisely why this establishment garners such favorable local reviews. The overall experience is designed to be hassle-free and delicious, cementing its status as a must-try dining destination in the area.

---

Conveniently situated at **357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553**, Pizza Heaven boasts an easily accessible location for residents and visitors throughout the New Windsor and greater Orange County area. Being right off a major local thoroughfare makes it simple to stop in for lunch or dinner, whether you’re passing through or making a dedicated trip. The fact that the location is considered one of a dozen favorable restaurants within a small radius speaks volumes about its standing in the local dining scene, ensuring its prominence among the many options available.

In today's dining landscape, ease of access is paramount, and Pizza Heaven goes above and beyond to ensure a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment features truly comprehensive **wheelchair accessibility**. This isn't just limited to a ramp; the entire experience is considered. They provide a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, a dedicated **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** for maximum convenience, a fully **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating** within the dining area. This dedication ensures that everyone in your group can enjoy a meal with absolute comfort and dignity.

Furthermore, parking is completely stress-free. Patrons benefit from multiple convenient options, including a **Free parking lot** directly on-site, ample **On-site parking**, and even the availability of **Free street parking** nearby. This commitment to easy, free parking adds another layer of convenience, especially for families or large groups planning a dine-in experience. Finding a spot will never be an issue, allowing you to focus on enjoying your meal rather than worrying about the logistics of your visit.

---

Pizza Heaven offers a comprehensive suite of dining and service options designed to fit any schedule or preference. Whether you're planning an extended meal or require a quick solution, the restaurant has a system in place to serve you efficiently.

• **Dining Service:** Full **Dine-in** service is available, featuring comfortable **Seating** and dedicated **Table service**. The atmosphere is always described as **Casual** and **Cozy**, creating a perfect setting for both intimate meals and larger gatherings.
• **Convenience Options:** For those on the move, both **Takeout** and reliable **Delivery** service are core offerings. This flexibility means you can enjoy the restaurant's authentic NY-style pizza and comfort food whether you're at home or simply passing by.
• **Meal Periods:** The restaurant is popular for serving delicious meals across various times of the day, making it an excellent choice for **Lunch**, a perfect spot for **Dinner**, and even a place to grab a satisfying **Dessert**.
• **Amenities:** Customers can take advantage of essential amenities, including a clean **Restroom** and complimentary **Wi-Fi**, ensuring a comfortable and connected experience whether you’re dining in or waiting for your takeout order.
• **Family & Group Focus:** Catering to all age groups, the restaurant is known to be **Good for kids**, offering **High chairs** for the little ones, and a dedicated **Kids' menu**. It's frequently busy with local **Groups** and **College students**, underscoring its broad appeal.
• **Payment Flexibility:** For maximum convenience, the restaurant accepts a wide range of payment types, including major **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and modern **NFC mobile payments**.

---

The true stars of Pizza Heaven are the food and the atmosphere, which together create a memorable experience. The dining environment is universally praised as **Casual** and **Cozy**, drawing a crowd of **Locals** who appreciate the genuine warmth.

• **Authentic NY-Style Pizza:** The foundation of their success is the pizza itself. Patrons repeatedly confirm it is exactly "what you would expect for **NY style pizza**." The dough is lauded for being **thin** and cooked to absolute **perfection**. You can choose to order a **whole pizza** for the table or, as one reviewer strongly suggested, dive into the incredible variety of **Pizza by the slice**, noting that there are often at least six different options available at any given time.
• **The Giant Slice:** This particular feature has achieved legendary status. The **Giant slice with pepperoni** is highlighted by customers as "one of the best if not the best in NY state." This bold claim indicates a level of quality and portion size that truly sets Pizza Heaven apart from the competition, making it a must-try item on the menu for any serious pizza enthusiast.
• **Irresistible Garlic Knots:** The aroma alone is a major feature. Customer reviews rave about the **garlic knots**, noting that the moment they start prepping them, the whole restaurant fills with the irresistible smell of garlic. They are described as being made with an abundance of garlic, making them a perfect accompaniment to the pizza and a popular item to add to any order, providing excellent value as an extra side.
• **Value and Menu Focus:** The restaurant is known for offering great value, with a large pizza and bottled drinks costing under $30. The menu itself is centered on satisfying staples, focusing on delicious **Comfort food** and ensuring that everything is a **Quick bite** option, catering to busy New Yorkers who still demand high quality.
• **Ideal for All Crowds:** The setting is ideal for various social dynamics, making it excellent for large **Groups**, convenient for **Solo dining**, and perfectly welcoming to **Families** with its kid-friendly options and amenities.

---

For directions, placing an order for takeout, or inquiring about their delivery radius, please use the contact details provided below. We look forward to seeing you at our New Windsor location.

**Address:** 357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553

**Phone:** (845) 569-8888

---

Choosing Pizza Heaven means opting for a guaranteed high-quality, authentic New York dining experience right here in New Windsor. The key factors that make this restaurant stand out are its unwavering commitment to authentic pizza, unparalleled value, and dedication to customer convenience and comfort. The ability to get a perfectly cooked, thin-crust **NY-style pizza**—either a full pie or one of the fantastic **by-the-slice** options—is the primary draw. The legendary **Giant slice with pepperoni** is a regional highlight that alone warrants a visit, living up to its reputation as arguably one of the best in all of New York State.

Beyond the pizza, the menu’s focus on delightful **Comfort food**, including the famously aromatic **garlic knots**, ensures there’s a satisfying option for every craving. The restaurant's fantastic value proposition is also a major plus, allowing patrons to enjoy a full meal without breaking the bank. Furthermore, the extensive service options—from cozy **Dine-in** with **Table service** to efficient **Takeout** and reliable **Delivery**—mean Pizza Heaven fits seamlessly into any New Yorker's busy schedule. Add to this the fact that the entire establishment is fully **Wheelchair accessible** (entrance, parking, seating, and restroom) and offers completely **free on-site parking**, and you have a local business that truly prioritizes its community. Whether you're a local group, a busy college student, or a family looking for a friendly, dependable spot, Pizza Heaven is the easy and delicious choice. Stop by, check the box, and decide for yourself—you'll quickly see why the reviews are so favorable.

Pizza Heaven

357 Old Forge Hill Rd #600, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA