Stellina Pizza & Bar

- 302 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Nestled on the bustling Main Street in Farmingdale, Long Island, Stellina Pizza & Bar is a vibrant and beloved culinary destination that brings the warmth and authentic flavors of Italian cuisine to the heart of Nassau County. As a dedicated restaurant, Stellina is known for delivering more than just a meal; it offers an experience rooted in Italian hospitality and passion. Customers are quickly discovering that while the name highlights its exceptional pizza—with one reviewer noting the "very interesting choices!"—there is indeed "so much more to this highly recommended place to eat."

The establishment successfully marries the casual, comforting feel of a neighborhood eatery with a menu that speaks to a deeper, more traditional Italian heritage. The atmosphere is described as both Casual and Cozy, making it an inviting space for all occasions, whether it’s a romantic dinner, a solo meal, or a gathering for Groups and Family-friendly crowds. It has been commended for having a "New York City vibe" in its nice decor and lively environment, making it a sophisticated yet approachable spot in the Long Island suburbs. The culinary direction is helmed by a chef who moved from Italy, ensuring that the dishes, from the Neapolitan-style dry pasta to the house-made pasta and Roman-style pizza, retain a distinct authentic character. This commitment to traditional methods and high-quality ingredients, like 100% imported Italian flour and San Marzano tomatoes, is a core part of the Stellina brand's vision.

The comprehensive menu is structured around classic Italian courses: Antipasti (starters), Spuntini (small bites), Pizza, Primi (pasta), and Secondi (main courses). This extensive offering ensures a variety of authentic choices for every palate, ranging from comforting classics like Lasagna Tradizionale ($40.00) and Pollo Alla Parmigiana ($40.00) to more luxurious, decadent options such as Agnolotti Di Vitello E Tartufo ($45.00) and the rich Brasato Di Manzo Al Barolo ($65.00). The focus on authentic, scratch-made dishes truly sets Stellina Pizza & Bar apart as a premier Italian dining option in the New York metropolitan area.

Stellina Pizza & Bar is ideally situated in a prime location on Long Island, making it a focal point for dining and social activity in the Farmingdale area. The restaurant’s address is 302 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735. This Main Street location places it in the vibrant center of the community, easily accessible for local users across Nassau and Suffolk counties.

For patrons arriving by car, the restaurant offers crucial Wheelchair accessible parking lot accommodations. While specific details on other accessibility features are not provided, the availability of accessible parking is a key convenience for guests. The restaurant’s service options are designed to maximize customer convenience. Patrons can enjoy the full experience by opting to Dine-in and receive dedicated Table service. For those with busy schedules or preferring to eat at home, Takeout and Delivery services are efficiently offered. The restaurant also prides itself on Fast service, ensuring that whether you are dining in or taking out, your meal is delivered promptly. With "plenty of seating inside," as noted by a customer, it is well-equipped to handle high demand and accommodate groups of various sizes, making planning easier for families and friends.

The services offered at Stellina Pizza & Bar are designed to provide a complete and authentic Italian dining experience, from casual bites to full multi-course meals.

• Complete Dining Service: The restaurant is open for Dinner and offers Table service throughout the evening. They also provide delicious Dessert options to perfectly conclude any meal.
• Authentic Italian Menu Structure: The menu is thoughtfully divided into traditional Italian courses, including:
  • Antipasti (e.g., Tartare Di Tonno, Tartufo E Caviale for $36.00).
  • Primi (hand-made pasta dishes like Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina for $36.00).
  • Secondi (main courses such as Tagliata Di Manzo for $75.00 and Agnello Alla Griglia for $65.00).
  • Contorni (sides like Patate Fritte Al Tartufo for $17.00).
• Flexible Meal Options: In addition to full meals, the menu features Spuntini (small plates) and other items suitable for a Quick bite, ensuring suitability for various appetites and time constraints.
• Beverage Selection: A full bar service is provided, featuring Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, and a curated selection of Wine to complement the Italian fare. Coffee is also available.
• Convenience Options: Patrons can utilize Takeout and Delivery services, alongside the traditional Dine-in experience. The restaurant accepts major forms of payment, including Credit cards and Debit cards.

Stellina Pizza & Bar stands out in the competitive Long Island dining scene due to its commitment to quality, authenticity, and creating a memorable experience.

• Authentic Culinary Focus: The core strength is its truly authentic Italian food, often featuring fresh, homemade pasta and traditional recipes, a rarity in many suburban Italian establishments. Specialties like Lasagna Tradizionale and Paccheri Zafferano E Pistacchio showcase this commitment.
• Exceptional Pizza Program: The pizza menu is a major draw, offering both classic Neapolitan styles like the Pizza Margherita ($22.00) and more unique, specialty pizzas such as Ricotta Di Buffala E Tartufo ($36.00) and Calabrese Pizza ($26.00). The availability of "interesting choices" appeals greatly to modern New York diners.
• High-End Ingredients and Preparation: The focus on premium ingredients is evident in dishes like the veal chops (Cotoletta Di Vitello Alla Parmigiana at $76.00), the fine cuts of steak (Tagliata Di Manzo at $75.00), and luxurious items incorporating black truffle. Even the sides, such as Patate Fritte Al Tartufo, reflect this elevated approach.
• Welcoming & Versatile Atmosphere: The vibe is intentionally Casual and Cozy, successfully attracting a wide demographic, including Family-friendly groups and those seeking an intimate Solo dining experience. The "New York City vibe" provides a trendy yet comfortable backdrop for any occasion.
• Fast and Efficient Service: Despite offering high-quality, complex dishes, the restaurant is highlighted for its Fast service, indicating an efficient and well-managed operation that respects the time of its New York patrons.

For reservations, orders, or inquiries, please use the following contact details for Stellina Pizza & Bar:

Address: 302 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 943-9111 or Mobile: +1 516-943-9111

Stellina Pizza & Bar is unequivocally worth choosing for any Long Island user seeking an authentic, high-quality Italian meal without the need to travel into Manhattan. What makes it special is the palpable passion for Italian cuisine, evident in every menu category. The blend of comforting classics and elevated, contemporary dishes, often featuring luxurious ingredients like truffle, saffron, and premium cuts of meat, offers exceptional value and a memorable dining experience.

Diners who prioritize genuine Italian flavor, like that found in their homemade pasta selections such as Spaghetti Allo Scoglio ($45.00) or the unique Strozzapreti Al Fume ($32.00), will not be disappointed. Furthermore, the dedication to providing excellent customer service, including fast turnaround times for both dine-in and delivery, makes it a reliable choice for any occasion. With its warm, approachable atmosphere and a full bar offering everything from Cocktails to Wine, Stellina Pizza & Bar is a genuine culinary standout that has cemented its place as a must-visit Italian destination in Farmingdale.

Stellina Pizza & Bar

302 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA