Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor

- 434 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553

For residents across the Hudson Valley and the greater New York region, finding that perfect local pizzeria that feels like home is a serious quest. Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor is widely recognized as a cornerstone of the New Windsor, NY, dining scene, offering a menu that extends far beyond your standard pie. This establishment has successfully carved out a reputation as a full-service, family-friendly destination where Italian-American comfort food meets variety and convenience.

While their reputation is built on excellent pizza, the menu at Tosco's is a true culinary melting pot. Diners can explore everything from classic Italian hot heroes and generous pasta portions to surprising, perfectly executed Mexican-inspired dishes. This variety makes it an ideal spot for any meal, whether you are planning a casual Lunch break or a full Dinner with the family. The restaurant proudly serves a diverse crowd, consistently attracting Locals, College students, Families, and Groups, all seeking quality food in a welcoming, Casual atmosphere.

The core offerings are spectacular, featuring a wide array of Specialty Pizza options that elevate the classic Italian dish. You can indulge in unique creations like the tangy Bruschetta pizza, the house signature Tosco's Pizza, the intriguing Sweet Chili Calamari pie, and the fiery Bee Sting pizza. For traditionalists, the Grandma Pie offers that deep, rustic flavor so beloved in the New York area. Beyond pizza, the menu is packed with satisfying comfort meals, including full Pasta dishes like Meat Lasagna and Cheese Ravioli, alongside chicken specialty entrees such as Chicken Sorrentino and Chicken Fiorentino. It’s truly a one-stop-shop for satisfying almost any craving.

Conveniently located at 434 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553, Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor is situated to provide easy access for all of Orange County and surrounding areas. As a local business deeply rooted in the New York community, accessibility and ease of visit are prioritized for all patrons.

The restaurant offers multiple, stress-free parking solutions, including a dedicated Free parking lot and general On-site parking, supplemented by nearby Free street parking. For patrons requiring assistance, the entire facility is highly accessible. This includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance, designated Wheelchair accessible parking lot spaces, and comfortable Wheelchair accessible seating within the dining area. A fully accessible Restroom is also available, ensuring a comfortable and worry-free experience for every member of the New York community who chooses to dine at Tosco’s.

Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor understands the need for flexible dining options in the fast-paced New York lifestyle, offering a comprehensive suite of services to ensure customers can enjoy their food any way they prefer.

• Dine-in: The cozy, casual dining room offers comfortable Seating and full Table service for guests who wish to relax and enjoy their meal on-site.
• Delivery and Takeout: As a recognized Delivery Restaurant, Tosco's offers both traditional Delivery and standard Takeout services.
• No-Contact Options: Demonstrating a commitment to customer convenience and safety, the restaurant provides Curbside pickup and No-contact delivery options for a seamless transaction.
• Outdoor Seating: When the New York weather is pleasant, guests can take advantage of the delightful Outdoor seating area.
• Catering: Tosco's offers full Catering services, making it the perfect choice for office lunches, private parties, or large family gatherings in the area.
• Payment Options: Paying for your meal is simple with acceptance of major Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments.

Tosco's Pizzeria is celebrated for several key features that contribute to its standing as a must-visit local eatery in the New Windsor area.

• Expansive Menu Diversity: The offerings span beyond pizza to include Comfort food, Small plates, and an entire Mexican Menu featuring popular dishes like Tacos and Fajitas. They even offer a variety of fully-loaded Quesadillas and delicious Paninos.
• Speed and Efficiency: A notable highlight is the Fast service, ensuring that whether you dine in or order out, your food is delivered promptly.
• All-Day Dining: The restaurant is Popular for Lunch and Dinner, serving satisfying meals throughout the day, and even offers Late-night food options for those late-evening cravings.
• Family and Group Focus: The establishment is explicitly Family-friendly, provides High chairs for the youngest guests, and features a dedicated Kids' menu, making it a stress-free option for families. It is also excellent for accommodating Groups.
• Diverse Appetizers: The Appetizers menu is perfect for sharing, with favorites like Mozzarella Sticks, Fried Calamari, and the specially crafted Tosco's Taster.
• Specialty Heroes and Wraps: The menu features a vast selection of full-size sandwiches, including named Specially Heroes like the Rosendale's Special and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Hero, plus varied Wraps like the Mexican Burrito.

Getting in touch with Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor for orders, reservations, or general inquiries is quick and easy for customers across the New York region.

Address: 434 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 561-8484
Mobile Phone: +1 845-561-8484

What truly makes Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor a compelling choice for New York-area locals is the sheer depth of their menu combined with their commitment to accessible, friendly service. Many long-time customers express their loyalty, with some even stating the food is absolutely delicious and their pizza has a phenomenal texture and great taste—truly ranking as the Best Pizza in town for Delivery and Takeout for many in the community. Their specialty pies, like the Mac & Cheese pizza (a noted favorite), and the classic plain cheese are lauded for their flavor and quality.

While the business has experienced some isolated issues with food consistency—as reflected in a few customer comments about undercooked dough—it’s important to note the overwhelmingly positive sentiment from the local community, especially regarding their specialty pizzas and huge portions. The kitchen also offers a number of full Our Specialty Dishes - Chicken like the popular Tosco's Special Dinner, which provides an exceptional, generously-sized, and very reasonably priced meal. The availability of Lunch specials, an excellent homemade house salad dressing, and a very wide variety of specialty items, from Calzones & Stromboli to a full Mexican Menu, make Tosco’s an undisputed champion of variety and value in the Hudson Valley. For a local place that has satisfied generations with great food and is always trying to offer a quick, filling, and diverse meal, Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor is the place to call.

Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor

434 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA