Amore Pizza

- 371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110

Welcome to Amore Pizza, a beloved local institution and essential stop for New Jersey residents seeking a truly exceptional slice of pizza and authentic Italian comfort food. Located right in the heart of Nutley, Amore Pizza has solidified its reputation not just as a pizza parlor, but as a full-service Italian restaurant dedicated to quality, flavor, and a uniquely satisfying crispness in their signature pies. For locals in the Essex County region and beyond, this establishment represents the best of casual, high-quality Jersey dining—a place where the sauce is robust, the dough is revered, and every visit feels like coming home.

Amore Pizza prides itself on providing a wide variety of options that cater to all tastes, from traditional New York-style slices to their famous, extra-crispy pan pizzas. They are popular for being a go-to spot for both a quick bite during lunch and a full, cozy dinner. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick slice or settling down with the family for a hearty Italian meal, Amore Pizza delivers a consistently excellent experience that focuses on fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes.

The overall atmosphere is casual and cozy, making it the perfect family-friendly environment. They have built a strong following among the Nutley locals, who appreciate the dedication to flavor, speed of service, and the genuinely nice, welcoming staff. In a state renowned for its pizza, Amore Pizza stands out by continually focusing on a quality product—particularly their commitment to a perfectly crispy crust and a rich, flavorful sauce that many customers liken to a traditional “Sunday gravy.”

Amore Pizza is conveniently situated at

371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA

Parking is a significant convenience for customers, which is a notable feature for any popular local spot. Amore Pizza offers both a

Free parking lot

Free street parking

Paid street parking

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

The location on Centre Street places it near other local points of interest, solidifying its status as a central gathering spot for the Nutley community. Its ease of access makes it ideal for a spontaneous weeknight dinner, a quick lunchtime pick-up, or even a catering order for a weekend event.

Amore Pizza is built around maximum convenience and a complete dining experience, offering a range of service options tailored to modern local demands:

• Onsite Services: Enjoy a meal in the casual, cozy atmosphere with

  Seating

  available for

  Lunch

  and

  Dinner

  .

• Outdoor Seating: Perfect for warmer weather, guests can enjoy their food in the spacious outdoor area.

• Takeout: A quick and easy option for picking up your favorite pizza or Italian dish.

• Delivery: Full delivery service, including a

  No-contact delivery

  option, bringing hot, fresh food right to your door.

• Catering: The perfect choice for feeding large groups, offering their full menu for events and parties.

• Accepts Reservations: Planning a group dinner? They gladly

  Accepts reservations

  for your convenience.

• Payment Flexibility: Accepting all major methods, including

  Credit cards

  ,

  Debit cards

  , and

  NFC mobile payments

  .

The menu at Amore Pizza goes well beyond the standard pizza parlor fare, offering an extensive selection of classic Italian dishes and innovative, house-created pies. The focus here is on high-quality

Comfort food

Quick bite

• Specialty Pan Pizzas: A true highlight, with options cooked

  well done and crispy

  . Favorites include the

  Giuseppe Pan Pizza

  (thin and crispy), the

  Nutley Tomato Pie

  , and new offerings like the

  Giuseppe Ala Vodka

  (thin crust, extra crispy with vodka sauce).

• Thin-Crust Excellence: Known for their thin crusts, options like the

  Barstool Margherita Pizza

  (thin and crispy) and the

  Amore's Lean Thinny Skinny Pizza

  exemplify the perfect New Jersey thin-pie style.

• Variety of Slices: Perfect for a lunch break or quick taste test, slices include

  Large Cheese

  ,

  Sicilian

  ,

  Grandma Slice

  ,

  Penne Vodka Slice

  , and

  The Sunday Gravy Slice

  .

• Substantial Appetizers: A great way to start, featuring items like

  Sicilian Rice Balls

  (available with Vodka Sauce),

  Fried Calamari

  , and the popular

  Cheesy Garlic Sticks

  .

• Hearty Italian Dinners: Traditional dinner platters such as

  Chicken Parmigiana Dinner Over Penne

  ,

  Veal Parmigiana Dinner Over Penne

  , and

  Homemade Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner

  .

• Classic Pasta Dishes: Staples including

  Penne Vodka

  ,

  Manicotti

  , and

  Stuffed Shells With Vodka Sauce

  .

• Hot and Cold Subs: A full sandwich menu, with favorites like

  Chicken Parmigiana Sub

  and specialty cold cuts such as

  The Calandra's Special

  and

  The Angelina

  .

• Vegan Options: Acknowledging diverse dietary needs, they offer a

  New Vegan Pan Pizza

  with eggplant, fresh basil, and garlic (no cheese).

• Delicious Desserts: Finish your meal with treats like

  NEW Tiramisu Cups

  or

  Funnel Cake Fries W/ Nutella

  .

For residents and visitors in the Nutley area looking to order a pie, make a reservation, or inquire about catering, here is the essential contact information for Amore Pizza:

• Address:

  371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA

• Phone:

  (973) 667-5000

• Mobile Phone (Alternate):

  +1 973-667-5000

The staff is known for being friendly and professional, ensuring that whether you call in a large delivery order or step up to the counter for a

Quick bite

In a state where excellent pizza is found on practically every corner, Amore Pizza distinguishes itself by excelling in the areas that matter most to a loyal, local clientele. The establishment is a triple threat: a dedicated

Pizza restaurant

Italian restaurant

Pizza Takeout

First and foremost, the pizza is consistently praised for its quality and unique characteristics. The robust, flavorful sauce—often described as being slightly sweet and rich—is a core component that sets it apart. This commitment to an amazing sauce, combined with a dough that achieves a delightful balance of crispness and chewiness (especially in the specialty pan pies), creates a truly memorable New Jersey pizza experience. The menu’s variety also ensures there is something for everyone, whether you’re a purist who orders a

Large Cheese Pizza

The Sunnyside Jersey Pie

Penne Vodka Slice

Beyond the food, Amore Pizza offers a dining environment that keeps locals coming back. It’s categorized as

Good for kids

Casual

Cozy

Atmosphere

Seating

Outdoor seating

The strong positive sentiment from the local

Crowd

Comfort food

Amore Pizza

371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA