Schmear Bagel & Cafe

- 83 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050

Schmear Bagel & Cafe, located in the heart of Port Washington, Long Island, has cemented its reputation as a must-visit local destination for New Yorkers seeking a high-quality bagel experience that goes far beyond the basics. While the name proudly spotlights the iconic New York bagel tradition, this cafe offers a truly expansive menu, blending classic deli staples with modern, health-conscious options, all served with a commitment to freshness and customer satisfaction. It’s more than just a morning stop—it’s a full-service cafe catering to all-day cravings, from breakfast to lunch and beyond.

For residents of Port Washington and visitors to the North Shore of Long Island, Schmear Bagel & Cafe is the go-to spot for that essential New York bagel fix. They offer a comprehensive variety of bagels, from the classic Plain and Everything to specialty options like the Pumpernickel, and even weekend-only treats like the French Toast and Blueberry Bagels. Their wide array of house-made cream cheeses, including savory flavors like Scallion, Vegetable, and Garlic & Herb, and sweet selections like Walnut Raisin and Strawberry, ensures every customer finds their perfect pairing. With options for every diet, including Tofu-based spreads and three varieties of Gluten Free Bagels (Plain, Sesame, and Everything), this establishment works hard to be inclusive of all community members.

Beyond the traditional bagel and schmear, the cafe has garnered a strong following for its signature sandwiches, hearty breakfast platters, and extensive healthy offerings. From complex, layered Staff Pick Sandwiches like the "Queen Queren" and "Kid Frankie" to freshly blended smoothies and chopped salads, Schmear Bagel & Cafe has redefined what a local bagel shop can be, evolving into a full-fledged culinary hub in Port Washington.

Location and Accessibility

Schmear Bagel & Cafe is conveniently situated at a prime location on Long Island’s North Shore, making it easily accessible for locals and those passing through the area.

The exact address is: 83 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA.

Located on Main Street, the cafe is a central point within the Port Washington community. For those driving, paid street parking is available nearby, which is a key convenience in a bustling town center.

The establishment is committed to serving all members of the community, evidenced by its array of accessibility features. The premises include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring a comfortable visit for every patron. Customers appreciate the option for a quick visit, whether they are grabbing a coffee and bagel to-go or settling in for a satisfying meal. Payment methods are flexible, accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

Schmear Bagel & Cafe offers a comprehensive range of dining and service options to suit every New Yorker’s busy schedule and preference:

• Curbside pickup for quick and convenient collection of orders.
• Delivery service, bringing fresh bagels, sandwiches, and coffee directly to the customer.
• In-store pickup for pre-ordered items.
• In-store shopping to browse the daily selections of baked goods and grab-and-go items.
• Onsite services, including the full cafe and dining experience.
• Takeout for meals on the go.
• Dine-in seating to enjoy breakfast or lunch in a comfortable setting.
• All-Day Breakfast options, including Pancakes, French Toast, and Belgian Waffles, ensuring you can enjoy classic morning fare anytime.
• Full-service Coffee and Tea bar, featuring Espresso, Cappuccino, and a curated selection of Hot Teas by Bushwick/Harney & Sons.

Features / Highlights

Schmear Bagel & Cafe stands out from other local eateries by offering an exceptional variety of menu items and prioritizing specific customer needs. Key highlights include:

• Extensive Bagel Selection: Beyond the 15 standard bagel flavors, they offer unique varieties like Rainbow Bagel, Flagel (a flatter bagel), and Bialy, along with two distinct weekend-only bagels (Blueberry and French Toast Bagel).
• Gluten-Free Bagels with Dedicated Prep: A major draw for health-conscious and sensitive patrons. Customer reviews highlight that the cafe maintains proper preparation procedures, including a separate toaster and prep area for their Gluten Free Plain, Sesame, and Everything Bagels, ensuring safe and delicious options.
• Gourmet Deli & Staff Sandwiches: The menu features over 20 unique, hearty sandwiches, including the popular Staff Picks like the "Queen Queren" (Chicken Cutlet, Pepper Jack, Bacon, Avocado Spread, Cajun Mayo on a Garlic Hero) and "Kid Frankie" (Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Smoked Gouda, Chipotle Mayo). These specialty sandwiches, which include a side of deli salad, truly elevate the New York deli experience.
• Focus on Healthy Options: The menu features a robust selection of nutritious items, including Fresh Chopped Salads (Cobb, Kale Caesar, Harvest, etc.), Avocado Toasts (Greek, Salmon, Caprese), and all-day Acai Bowls (Original and V.I.P., both made with gluten-free granola). Fresh-blended Smoothies like "Berry Blast" and "Iron Man" (Spinach, Avocado, Apple, Banana) further appeal to the wellness-minded clientele.
• Full Coffee & Beverage Program: They offer a range of brewed coffees, double-shot espressos, and a selection of Iced Teas from Bushwick, like the Fort Green Mint Tea and Hibiscus Elderberry, catering to all beverage preferences.
• Wide Deli Salad and Cream Cheese Variety by the Pound: Customers can purchase over 15 cream cheese varieties, including Plain, Scallion, Lox Spread, and various Tofu spreads, as well as classic deli salads like Tuna, Chicken, and White Fish Salad, making it an excellent stop for party platters or stocking up at home.

Contact Information

For a classic Port Washington bagel and a diverse menu of fresh options, reach out to Schmear Bagel & Cafe:

Address: 83 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA

Phone: (516) 439-4077

What is Worth Choosing

For a first-time visitor or a returning local, several categories at Schmear Bagel & Cafe stand out as especially worthwhile. The commitment to variety and quality is evident across the menu, making the decision difficult, but here are the essential picks.

If you are looking for an authentic New York bagel experience, the sheer range of bagel flavors, from Whole Wheat Everything to Pumpernickel, paired with any of their specialty cream cheeses (like the Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese or the Lox Spread), is the foundational choice.

For lunch, don’t miss out on the Staff Pick Sandwiches. These are often customer favorites for a reason, being packed with high-quality ingredients. For a savory and satisfying meal, try the "Scotty Licious" (Breaded Chicken, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Cajun Mayo on a Roll) or the "Davids Classic" (Roast Beef, Bacon, Melted Mozzarella, Mayo on a Garlic Hero). The Reuben Sandwich and The New Yorker Panini also offer a classic, comforting deli experience.

Finally, for those seeking lighter fare, the Acai Bowls and the Fresh Chopped Salads are highly recommended. The fact that the Acai Bowls feature gluten-free granola is a testament to the cafe's attention to detail. The "Harvest Salad," with its Fresh Mixed Greens, Grilled Chicken, Green Apple, Walnuts, and Dried Cranberries, is a perfect, protein-packed choice. Furthermore, patrons with dietary restrictions will be pleased to find delicious and safely prepared Gluten Free Bagels and the Vegan-friendly Tofu cream cheese options. The overwhelmingly positive customer feedback on the taste and friendly service further solidifies Schmear Bagel & Cafe as an essential local spot in Port Washington.

Schmear Bagel & Cafe

83 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050, USA