Angelo's Pizzeria

- 986 McLean Ave, Yonkers, NY 10704

Welcome to the heart of Yonkers, where a true New York staple has been serving up classic Italian-American cuisine for years. Angelo's Pizzeria at 986 McLean Avenue stands out as a neighborhood favorite, offering everything from time-honored New York slices to hearty pasta dinners and heroes. If you are looking for a pizza shop that is a full-service Italian kitchen, Angelo's offers a massive menu designed to satisfy any craving for comfort food or a quick bite.

As a long-standing partner with platforms like Slice for over eight years, Angelo's has cemented its status as a reliable, local independent pizzeria. While every customer’s experience is unique, the community’s overall appreciation for the quality of the food is clearly reflected in its performance metrics: the restaurant holds an impressive average of 4.9 stars based on over 1,500 customer ratings on popular ordering platforms, underscoring its general popularity for food quality and efficiency.

The core of Angelo’s appeal is its comprehensive menu, which spans far beyond just pizza. Whether you're feeding a family, catering an event, or just seeking a solo dinner, you will find a wealth of options crafted from traditional recipes, making this a go-to spot for authentic Italian comfort food in the Yonkers area.

Location and Accessibility

Angelo's Pizzeria is conveniently situated at 986 McLean Ave in Yonkers, NY 10704. This location makes it easily accessible for residents across the New York region, nestled in a community where it operates as a dependable local hub for Italian cuisine.

For customers visiting the shop, the location is planned to be accommodating, featuring both a wheelchair accessible entrance and wheelchair accessible seating, helping to ensure a welcoming environment for all. Parking is available on the street, including both free and paid options in the surrounding area. The restaurant’s atmosphere is casual and designed to be good for kids, making it a simple, straightforward option for family meals, solo dining, and quick pickups.

Services Offered

Angelo's Pizzeria provides a comprehensive range of service options designed for maximum convenience:

• Dine-in: Enjoy a casual and quick meal directly at the restaurant.
• Takeout: Place your order for quick and easy pickup.
• Delivery: Fast and reliable service to the local area.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for quick order retrieval without needing to enter the shop.
• No-Contact Delivery: For a safe and socially distant delivery experience.
• Catering: A full range of menu items is available for catering large or small events.

Features / Highlights

The menu at Angelo's is one of its greatest strengths, providing a sheer variety of options that cover virtually every facet of Italian-American dining. This extensive selection makes it possible to return again and again to try something new, or simply enjoy a perfect version of your favorite classic.

• Specialty Pizza Selection: The menu features unique and customer-favorite pies like Chicken Francese Pizza, Lasagna Pizza, Buffalo Pizza, and the signature Angelo's Special Pizza (broccoli, chicken, & tomatoes).
• Generous Italian Dinners: Enjoy full dinners of classic dishes like Meatball with Parmesan Cheese, Shrimp with Parmesan Cheese, Eggplant Rollatini, Chicken Marsala, and Chicken Piccata, all served with your choice of pasta or salad.
• Signature Pasta Dishes: A wide variety of pasta plates, including classics like Penne Alla Vodka, Spaghetti Bolognese, and Baked Ziti Sorrentino.
• Heroes and Wraps: Choose from a robust selection of Heroes, including Veal Cutlet Parmesan, Deluxe Cheesesteak, and the Crispy or Grilled Chicken Caprese Hero.
• Appetizer & Side Variety: The menu offers numerous small plates perfect for sharing, such as Potato Croquettes, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, and their classic Garlic Knots.
• Vegetarian-Friendly Options: The menu clearly labels vegetarian options, from numerous pizza choices to Eggplant Heroes and side dishes.

Contact Information

To place an order or for general inquiries, you can reach Angelo's Pizzeria using the following information:

Address: 986 McLean Ave, Yonkers, NY 10704

Phone: (914) 237-2401

What is worth choosing

For a first-time visitor, a few items consistently stand out. The Sicilian Pizza is highly recommended by fans for its satisfying crust, as are the expertly prepared Chicken Rolls. The extensive variety of classic baked dishes, such as the Meat Lasagna, ensures that any choice will deliver on comforting, authentic flavor.

Ultimately, the choice of Angelo's Pizzeria comes down to the promise of a classic, dependable Yonkers dining experience. It is a local independent restaurant that has successfully become a “mainstay of the community” through years of serving up a menu focused on quality Italian staples. This reliability and wide appeal is validated by its high overall rating from a large volume of local customers.

However, as part of providing a complete and factual account, it is important for prospective patrons to be aware of the full range of customer experiences reported. While the vast majority of customer ratings are highly positive (4.9 stars from over 1,500 reviews), there have been explicit, serious complaints raised regarding an alleged pattern of disrespectful and discriminatory service at the location, with one customer detailing an uncomfortable interaction with a server regarding the bagging of an order and noting a perceived disparity in treatment based on race. Other reviews praise the staff, calling them "really nice staff" and "good service." Patrons who prioritize excellent food and convenience, as evidenced by the high ratings, typically find Angelo's to be a top choice. Those with concerns about service interactions should be aware of this specific customer-reported pattern to make an informed decision.

The restaurant remains a pillar for Italian food and pizza in Yonkers, well-known for its large portions, great prices, and the sheer breadth of its menu that offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of New York.

Angelo's Pizzeria

986 McLean Ave, Yonkers, NY 10704, USA