Annabelle's Pastaria

- 717 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11228

Annabelle's Pastaria has cemented its place as a beloved, authentic local spot for Italian fare right in the heart of Dyker Heights, Brooklyn. In a borough renowned for its rich Italian-American heritage and abundance of incredible restaurants, Annabelle’s manages to stand out by focusing on quality, freshness, and a genuinely warm atmosphere that feels like a trip to a family member's home. It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s a true New York neighborhood institution where the aroma of slow-cooked sauce and fresh dough welcomes you the moment you step inside.

The core of Annabelle’s culinary philosophy is centered around two simple yet powerful ideas: fresh pasta and quality pizza. They proudly make all of their pasta on the premises daily, from scratch, using only the finest ingredients. This commitment to 'from scratch' preparation is evident in every dish, providing a noticeable difference in texture and flavor that sets it apart from many other places in the competitive NYC dining scene. The environment is described by locals as cozy, authentic, and welcoming, offering an immersive Italian experience where the focus remains squarely on enjoying great food and company.

Annabelle's Pastaria caters to a broad New York audience, seamlessly fitting the descriptions of an Italian restaurant, a family restaurant, a lunch restaurant, a dedicated pasta shop, a pizza restaurant, a classic neighborhood restaurant, a sandwich shop, and even a wine bar. Whether you are seeking a quick bite of comfort food, a hearty lunch, or a full-course dinner with a great glass of wine, this Dyker Heights gem has crafted a diverse menu to satisfy every craving. It is popular for lunch, dinner, and even for solo dining, making it a flexible and convenient option for Brooklynites throughout the week.

### Location and Accessibility

Annabelle's Pastaria is conveniently situated at 717 86th St in the quintessential Brooklyn neighborhood of Dyker Heights, NY 11228, USA. This location makes it a central hub for residents of Dyker Heights and neighboring areas like Bay Ridge. The restaurant maintains a strong local feel, perfectly reflecting the community it serves.

For New Yorkers who rely on public transportation or those driving, accessibility is straightforward. The restaurant is easily reachable and welcomes diners with inclusive features. For those planning a visit, the establishment is attentive to the needs of all guests, offering several accessibility amenities. Finding parking can often be a challenge in this part of Brooklyn, but visitors to Annabelle's benefit from the availability of free street parking nearby, a definite plus in the city.

### Services Offered

Annabelle's Pastaria is dedicated to providing a comfortable and convenient dining experience, offering a full range of services to suit any occasion, from an intimate dinner to a large celebration:

• Dine-in service with seating and table service available for all meals.
• Takeout options for those preferring to enjoy their meal at home or on the go.
• Delivery service, ensuring fresh and delicious food arrives right at your door.
• Reservations are accepted, making it easier to plan for groups or popular dining times.
• Catering services are provided, perfect for bringing authentic Brooklyn Italian flavor to your next party or event.
• Full meal options for Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner are available.
• Alcohol, Beer, and an extensive Wine selection are offered, complemented by a great coffee and dessert menu.

### Features / Highlights

The appeal of Annabelle's Pastaria goes beyond its menu, built on a foundation of quality service and a welcoming ambiance. Several features make this restaurant a standout in the local Dyker Heights food scene:

• Fresh, Homemade Pasta: The signature highlight—all pasta is made daily on the premises, from scratch, guaranteeing the freshest possible dish.
• Grandma Style Pizza: A specialty item, this pizza is made with house-made fresh mozzarella and hand-crushed Italian tomatoes, a local favorite.
• Extensive Gluten-Free Menu: Annabelle’s offers an impressive selection of gluten-free options, including small pizzas, various pasta dishes like Rigatoni Bella GF*, Chicken Parmigiana GF*, and even desserts like Flourless Chocolate Cake GF*, accommodating a wide range of dietary needs.
• Authentic & Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant is consistently praised for its warm, inviting, and intimate vibe, described as the perfect setting for relaxing and enjoying a genuine Italian experience.
• Dietary-Friendly Options: In addition to the gluten-free menu, the restaurant offers plenty of healthy options, comfort food, small plates, and vegetarian choices.
• Accessibility: The establishment includes wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, prioritizing comfort for all patrons.
• Great Dessert and Wine List: Reviewers frequently highlight the excellent desserts (like Mini Cannolis, Cheesecake, and Tiramisu) and a carefully curated wine list.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: With high chairs available and a crowd that is welcome to families and groups, Annabelle's is a great choice for dining out with kids.

### Contact Information

To plan your next authentic Italian meal or inquire about catering, you can reach Annabelle's Pastaria using the following contact details:

Address: 717 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA

Phone: (718) 836-9444

### What is Worth Choosing

With a menu as extensive and diverse as the one offered at Annabelle's Pastaria, picking just one dish can be a challenge. However, a few items consistently receive high praise from local diners and are considered essential choices:

• The Homemade Pasta: Any pasta dish is a must-try, given the restaurant's commitment to daily, scratch-made quality. For example, the

  Rigatoni Bolognese

  ($23.05) with its slow-cooked beef, veal, and pork sauce, or the classic

  Spaghetti With Meatballs

  ($22.00).
• Grandma Pizza: A signature item, the

  Grandma Pizza

  ($15.70+) showcases their fresh mozzarella and quality tomatoes. For a flavorful twist, consider a specialty option like the

  Toscana Pizza

  ($19.90+) with Prosciutto di Parma, arugula, and shaved reggiano.
• Recommended Pasta Specialties: The

  Penne Vodka

  ($17.80), with its light cream sauce, is a popular classic. Diners also rave about the

  Ravioli

  ($19.95), which is house-made with four cheeses.
• Appetizer Favorites: Don't miss the best-selling

  Meatballs With Ricotta

  ($14.65) or the

  Fried Zucchini

  ($14.65).
• Heartier Entrees: For a more substantial meal, the

  Center Cut Grilled Pork Chop

  ($31.45) is highly recommended by those who visit. Another classic New York favorite is the

  Sunday Gravy

  ($34.65), featuring sausage, meatballs, and bracolia with your choice of pasta.
• Dessert Finale: Complete your Brooklyn Italian experience with the smoothest

  Cheesecake

  ($7.88),

  Tiramisu

  ($7.88), or an order of

  Mini Cannolis

  ($7.88).
• Gluten-Free Menu: Celiac diners should feel confident exploring the vast dedicated gluten-free options, from GF pizzas to a variety of GF pasta and entree preparations like

  Chicken Parmigiana GF*

  ($33.00).

Annabelle's Pastaria provides New York locals and visitors alike with an unforgettable taste of authentic, fresh Italian dining. Its dedication to quality ingredients, homemade preparations, and a genuinely friendly service culture truly embodies the spirit of a classic Brooklyn neighborhood restaurant. Whether you're in Dyker Heights for lunch or looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner, Annabelle's Pastaria is a must-visit destination for those seeking the best of New York’s Italian cuisine.

Annabelle's Pastaria

717 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA