Broadway Pizza

- 56 Broadway, Paterson, NJ 07505

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents, few dining establishments carry the weight of local history and family tradition quite like Broadway Pizza in Paterson. Situated prominently on Broadway, this establishment is far more than just a typical pizza place; it is an enduring Paterson staple that has been proudly serving the community for generations. Customer testimonials reflect this deep local connection, with one patron noting, "This place has been around for as long as I remember and has catered to 4 family generations!"

Broadway Pizza is renowned for specializing in two distinct culinary areas: classic, crowd-pleasing Pizza and hearty Italian Dishes, cementing its status as a premier Restaurant and Pizza delivery service. The pizza itself is a local legend, praised consistently for being "always on point: nice and crispy, sweet but not overpowering tomato base, great cheese." This consistent quality and authentic flavor have made it a true neighborhood favorite, where you can "tell as soon as you walk in that the customers just love it here."

While the pizza is the star, the menu provides a comprehensive selection of Italian-American comfort food. From baked classics like Lasagna and Stuffed Shells to various preparations of Spaghetti and Ziti with meatballs or sausage, the offerings cater to a need for satisfying, familiar flavors. The restaurant is particularly popular for both Lunch and Dinner service, appealing to everyone from College students to local Groups and those dining Solo who are looking for a quick and reliable bite of true local flavor. It is a genuine piece of Paterson's culinary history, characterized by an Historic and Casual atmosphere.

Location and Accessibility

Broadway Pizza is conveniently located at 56 Broadway, Paterson, NJ 07505, USA. This central Paterson address places it in a high-traffic, visible location—a testament to its long-standing presence and importance in the city's downtown commercial district. Its proximity to major thoroughfares makes it easily recognizable and accessible for New Jersey commuters and locals.

A significant highlight of this establishment is its commitment to accessibility. Broadway Pizza features a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring that it can comfortably accommodate all members of the New Jersey community. For patrons arriving by car, the amenity information confirms the availability of Paid street parking in the area, a standard consideration in this urban setting.

In terms of service accessibility, the restaurant offers full flexibility. Customers can choose to Dine-in and enjoy the historic, cozy atmosphere, or opt for convenience with Takeout and local Delivery services. The efficiency of the operation is underscored by its highlight of Fast service, which makes it ideal for a quick lunch break or a seamless weeknight dinner pickup. Payment options are streamlined, with the restaurant accepting Debit cards, though customers should be aware that some popular items, like the "Large plain pie," may be priced with CASH ONLY in mind, according to customer reviews.

Services Offered

• Full Service Model: Offers both comfortable Dine-in options and convenient services for customers on the go, including Takeout and local Delivery.
• Dining Availability: Open for both Lunch and Dinner service, catering to various daily schedules.
• Specialty Menu Items: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a strong focus on Italian-American Comfort food, such as various pasta bakes and classic heroes.
• Quick Meal Solutions: Perfect for those needing a Quick bite or Small plates (Appetizers), supported by its highlighted Fast service.
• Beverages: Offers Coffee and a selection of local favorites, including the unique "UPTOWN" drink (half lemonade/sweet tea), as mentioned in a customer review.
• Inclusivity: Features a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating to accommodate all diners.
• Family-Friendly: Categorized as Good for kids, making it a great option for New Jersey families.

Features / Highlights

• Generational Heritage: A true local institution that has served "4 family generations," underscoring its deep roots and reliability in Paterson's history. The atmosphere is described as Historic and Casual.
• Signature Pizza Quality: Famous for its New York-style pizza, praised for being "nice and crispy, sweet but not overpowering tomato base," making it a local standard for taste.
• The 'Broadway' Menu Staple: Serves a full range of Italian-American Comfort food, including classic baked pastas (Lasagna, Stuffed Shells) and an extensive list of Cold Heroes and hot sandwiches like the Chicken Cheese Steak.
• Local Specialty: Highly regarded for serving a Local specialty menu, which includes fan favorites like Beef Patties and the unique local beverage, UPTOWN (a mix of lemonade and sweet tea).
• Speed and Efficiency: A major highlight is its Fast service, which is crucial for the busy lunch and dinner crowds, especially those dining Solo.
• Patron Loyalty: The immediate sense of community is a highlight, where patrons "just love it here," demonstrating high customer loyalty and a friendly local crowd of Groups and College students.
• Accessibility Focus: Stands out for its commitment to Accessibility, featuring designated wheelchair accommodations.

Contact Information

Address: 56 Broadway, Paterson, NJ 07505, USA

Phone: (973) 279-3996

Mobile Phone: +1 973-279-3996

What is worth choosing

For New Jersey residents, choosing Broadway Pizza in Paterson is about choosing a proven, multi-generational winner for authentic, reliable, and deeply satisfying Italian-American and pizza comfort food. This is not a fleeting trend; it is a true institution—a place that has mastered the art of simple, high-quality, delicious food over decades.

The primary reason to choose Broadway Pizza is the pizza itself. Its reputation is built on a perfectly crispy crust and a uniquely balanced, sweet tomato sauce that has kept four generations of local families coming back. Beyond the signature pie, the menu is a haven of Comfort food, offering substantial options like the acclaimed Chicken Cheese Steak, traditional pasta dishes like Spaghetti With Meatballs, and a great variety of sub sandwiches, including the popular Italian Sub and the massive Broadway Super Sub.

Furthermore, Broadway Pizza offers a true taste of local Paterson specialties, which is why it is worth seeking out. Don't miss trying the customer-favorite Beef Patties and ordering a refreshing UPTOWN drink to complete the experience. The convenience of their operation, highlighted by Fast service and flexible options for Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery, ensures that you can enjoy this local gem whether you are on a quick lunch break or feeding the entire family for dinner. With a Casual yet Historic vibe, and a welcoming atmosphere for all, including Groups and Kids, Broadway Pizza remains the top choice for an authentic, time-tested slice of Paterson, NJ, culinary life. Just remember to be prepared for the possible CASH ONLY option for certain items, a classic nod to its neighborhood roots.

Broadway Pizza

56 Broadway, Paterson, NJ 07505, USA