Brother's Pizzeria

- 750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302

For decades, New Yorkers in the know have made the pilgrimage to Brother's Pizzeria on Staten Island. More than just a local slice joint, this establishment is a celebrated institution in the competitive landscape of New York City pizza, recognized for serving some of the finest, most authentic Italian-American fare in the five boroughs. Operating as both a classic pizza parlor and a full-service Italian restaurant, Brother's Pizzeria has mastered the art of the perfect pie, particularly their renowned square slices, which many loyal patrons hail as the best on the planet.

The essence of Brother's Pizzeria lies in its commitment to traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients, upheld by dedicated owners and staff who put "love and skill" into every culinary masterpiece. The menu goes far beyond the standard Neapolitan slice, offering a range of specialty pizzas, including the coveted Sicilian, the savory Grandma's Pizza with fresh basil, and the rich Vodka Pie. Beyond the pizza, the kitchen prepares a comprehensive selection of Italian entrées, heroes, and appetizers, such as Chicken Francese, Coconut Shrimp, and massive portions of homemade Garlic Knots, ensuring a complete and satisfying dining experience for every visitor.

Location and Accessibility

Brother's Pizzeria is firmly rooted in the Port Richmond neighborhood of Staten Island, making it an essential destination for locals and a worthwhile "schlep" for pizza connoisseurs from the other boroughs and beyond. Its specific location is central to the area:

750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA

A key highlight for a New York City eatery is its convenient accessibility. Brother’s Pizzeria is notably accessible with dedicated features to accommodate all patrons, including:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot (with a free parking lot and free street parking available—a rarity in NYC).
• Wheelchair accessible restroom and seating.

The availability of a free, on-site parking lot and additional street parking is a significant advantage, removing the common urban stressor of finding a spot and encouraging groups and families to visit. Its corner location on Port Richmond Avenue contributes to its high visibility and ease of access for both drivers and local foot traffic.

Services Offered

Reflecting its status as a full-service neighborhood restaurant, Brother's Pizzeria offers a comprehensive suite of dining options tailored to the busy and varied lives of New Yorkers. Whether you're grabbing a slice on the go or settling in for a family dinner, the services ensure maximum convenience and flexibility:

• Dine-in / Table Service: Enjoy the full menu in a casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere, complete with seating for groups and table service.
• Takeout / Onsite services: Quick and efficient service for those picking up a pie or meal to enjoy at home.
• Delivery: Offering home or office delivery, ensuring that Staten Island residents can enjoy their favorite slices without leaving the house.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option allowing customers to stay in their vehicle while their order is brought out to them.
• Catering: Providing full catering services for large events, meetings, or family gatherings, extending their delicious Italian and pizza offerings to a broader audience.
• Late-Night Food: Available for those seeking a quick bite or comfort food later in the evening.
• Alcohol Service: The restaurant offers alcoholic beverages, including beer, to complement their Italian dishes.

Features / Highlights

Brother's Pizzeria distinguishes itself in the highly competitive NYC market with several features that underline its reputation for quality and community focus:

• World-Class Sicilian Pizza: The Sicilian slice is arguably the shop's crowning achievement, famous for its thick, crunchy crust, airy interior, and perfect balance of sweet sauce and generous cheese. Many consider it to be among the best square pies available in the entire region.
• Local Specialty Expertise: The restaurant is known for serving local specialties, which includes their unique take on the Grandma's Pizza, the Upside Down Square, and the diverse specialty pies like the Vodka Pizza.
• Fast and Friendly Service: Despite the frequent crowds—especially during lunch and dinner—the staff is consistently praised for providing quick service with a smile, contributing to a welcoming and professional atmosphere.
• Full Italian Menu: Beyond pizza, the extensive menu features classic Italian entrées, salads like the Antipasto Salad, and appetizers such as Rice Balls, Buffalo Calamari, and Buffalo Wings, providing a complete Italian-American dining experience.
• Family and Group Friendly: The establishment is explicitly noted as being good for kids and catering to groups, equipped with high chairs and a comfortable, casual dining space.
• Recognized Quality: Having been featured in media and recognized by dedicated food reviewers, the shop's quality has been affirmed beyond just local word-of-mouth.
• Ample Parking: The availability of a free parking lot is a crucial highlight for New York City diners, making visits stress-free.

Contact Information

To place an order, make a catering inquiry, or plan your next visit to this Staten Island favorite, please use the following contact details:

Address: 750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA

Phone: (718) 442-2332

What is Worth Choosing Brother's Pizzeria?

Choosing Brother's Pizzeria means opting for a piece of New York City culinary history and tradition. This is the place for the New Yorker who believes that a slice of pizza is not just food, but a foundational part of the city's identity. What makes Brother’s Pizzeria the superior choice is its exceptional, nationally recognized square pies—the Sicilian and the Grandma’s—which offer an elevated experience beyond the average New York slice. The famous Vodka Sauce, whether on pasta or one of their dedicated pizzas, is a must-try for its creamy, rich flavor. Furthermore, in an age where dining out can be a hassle, the ample, free parking, wheelchair accessibility, and commitment to fast, friendly service underscore a genuine respect for the customer.

The fact that a single pizza—or even a single slice, despite comments on its size—is described by loyal customers as "off the chart" and "possibly the best and finest Pizza on the planet" speaks volumes. For a genuine taste of Staten Island’s best, high-quality ingredients, and a truly authentic New York Italian restaurant experience that caters to both a quick bite and a full family dinner, Brother's Pizzeria on Port Richmond Avenue stands unrivaled. It remains a beloved local gem, providing comfort food and culinary perfection that is worth the trip.

Brother's Pizzeria

750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302, USA