Eddie's Pizza

- 2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040

Introduction / Overview

For New York residents, finding a pizzeria that is not only famous but also rooted in deep history can be a rare treat. Eddie's Pizza, located in New Hyde Park on Long Island, is one such legendary establishment. Famed as one of the region's oldest pizzerias, its story began in the early 1930s when Eddie Fanelli first opened its doors as a bar. Over the decades, it grew into a full-service, sit-down restaurant, but its core identity—and its signature thin-crust creation—has remained faithfully preserved.

Eddie's Pizza is known far and wide as "The Home of The Bar Pie." This unique, thin-crust pizza is celebrated for its perfect size, making it ideal for a personal meal or to share while enjoying a drink at the full bar—hence the name "Bar Pie." Its crusts, or shells, are meticulously made in the restaurant's basement using an original recipe brought over from Italy and are prebaked to ensure a quick, crispy, and customized finish when you order. Beyond its legendary pizza, Eddie's offers a comprehensive menu of traditional Italian and American comfort foods, maintaining a casual, cozy, and distinctly historic atmosphere that attracts a diverse clientele, from locals and families to groups and tourists eager for a taste of authentic Long Island history.

Location and Accessibility

The original and iconic location of Eddie's Pizza is situated at 2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA. Positioned conveniently on Long Island, it is easily accessible for locals across Nassau County and the wider New York metropolitan area.

The restaurant ensures a welcoming environment for all patrons by offering several key accessibility features. These include a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, wheelchair accessible seating, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. For drivers, parking is made simple with both a free parking lot located behind the restaurant and free street parking options available. This ease of access contributes to the family-friendly and group-welcoming environment that Eddie's has fostered for generations.

Services Offered

As a historic institution and a full-service restaurant, Eddie's Pizza provides an array of dining options and convenience services:

• Dine-in Service: Full waiter service is provided within the casual, cozy, and historic atmosphere of the restaurant and bar.
• Takeout Service: Quick and easy option for guests to pick up their favorite pies and entrées to enjoy at home.
• Full Bar Service: A complete bar onsite offers a great selection of beer, wine, cocktails, and hard liquor, perfectly complementing the "Bar Pie" tradition.
• Catering: Eddie's Pizza is a premier choice for catering, utilizing their famous mobile food trucks and carts to serve their signature Bar Pies for corporate functions, family gatherings, after-wedding parties, and more across the NYC, Long Island, and Tri-State Area.
• Table Service: Comfortable seating is available for lunch and dinner with attentive table service.
• Kids' Amenities: The establishment is good for kids, offering a kids' menu and high chairs, making it an excellent spot for family dining.
• Payment Policy: It is important to note that Eddie's Pizza is a cash-only establishment for in-house dining.

Features / Highlights

Eddie's Pizza's enduring popularity across New York is built on several distinctive features and traditions:

• The Original Thin-Crust "Bar Pie": This is the defining feature. The personal-sized, thin, and crispy pizza is prebaked and finished in a brick oven, resulting in a unique texture often described as cracker-like, yet satisfyingly cheesy. The personal 10-inch pie is notably low in calories (only 270 calories for a cheese pie slice) and fat, utilizing part-skim mozzarella with a touch of ricotta, making it a "guilt-free" indulgence.
• Historic and Cozy Atmosphere: Established in the 1930s, the restaurant maintains a vintage, old-school bar feel with low lighting, classic paneling, and a distinct nostalgia that makes generations of customers feel at home. It’s a true New York institution.
• Diverse Menu of Italian Comfort Food: While famous for pizza, Eddie's offers a full slate of traditional Italian-American fare, including classic pasta entrées (Spaghetti, Baked Ziti, Lasagna), Chicken and Veal Cutlet dishes (Parmigiana, Marsala, Francese), and various Seafood options (Fried Shrimp, Calamari, Mussels). The menu also features popular appetizers like Antipasto and Baked Clams.
• Famous "Eddie's Special" Pie: A signature combination pie loaded with traditional toppings: sausage, meatball, pepperoni, pepper, mushroom, and onions.
• Commitment to Healthier Options: The famous cheese bar pie is consciously made with part-skim mozzarella to be low in calories and fat, and the menu offers a totally fat-free cheese option and whole-wheat crusts.
• Celebrity and Cultural Recognition: The restaurant has garnered attention from high-profile figures, including its inclusion in the HBO show Entourage, which cemented its status as a beloved New York/Queens institution.
• Fast Service: Despite its popularity and historic status, Eddie's is known for its efficient and quick table service.

Contact Information

To experience the iconic Bar Pie, inquire about catering, or place a takeout order, please use the following contact details:

Address: 2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA

Phone: (516) 354-9780

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the New York area, a visit to Eddie's Pizza is a must for both its culinary uniqueness and its deep Long Island history. What is truly worth choosing here is the opportunity to taste an original slice of New York's past.

The undisputed star is the Bar Pie. New Yorkers accustomed to foldable, doughy slices should know that Eddie's delivers a different, equally beloved experience: a light, crispy, almost cracker-like crust that is thin enough to allow the low-fat cheese and thin sauce to truly shine. Opt for the classic Cheese and Tomato Sauce Bar Pie for the authentic low-calorie experience, or try the fan-favorite Eddie's Special for a fully loaded, traditional taste.

Beyond the pizza, the menu offers high-quality comfort food. The Antipasto Salad is a popular choice, and their generous Italian entrées, particularly the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana or the Seafood Platter, are a fantastic way to experience the full range of Eddie's traditional Italian recipes. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere, complete with the vintage bar, makes it the perfect venue for any occasion—from a late-night bite to a celebratory group dinner. For a memorable piece of New York history with a crispy, delicious crust, Eddie's Pizza in New Hyde Park remains an essential choice.

Eddie's Pizza

2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA