Gencarelli's Restaurant

- 1 Hook Mountain Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058

For decades, residents of Morris County and surrounding New Jersey towns have known that finding an authentic, high-quality, and family-friendly Italian restaurant is key to a satisfying meal. Gencarelli's Restaurant in Pine Brook, a cherished local institution, perfectly fits this demand, offering a comprehensive array of Italian cuisine that ranges from classic comfort food to sophisticated seafood and veal entrees. This establishment is much more than just a typical restaurant; it operates as a full-service Italian dining room, a dedicated caterer, and a highly-rated pizzeria offering both takeout and speedy delivery.

Gencarelli's pride themselves on being a family-owned business, with the second-generation Coppola family ensuring that every customer feels like a welcomed guest. Their philosophy centers on providing a reasonably priced, comfortable, and satisfying dining experience, ensuring guests are comfortable enough to "feel like you're at your house." This commitment to traditional values is reflected in their expansive menu, which features generous portions of classic dishes, always made with fresh ingredients. From the homemade pastas and baked dishes like Lasagna and Eggplant Rollatini to an astonishing selection of chicken and veal preparations (such as Chicken Marsala, Francese, and the specialty Chicken Romano), there is an Italian staple to satisfy every craving.

The atmosphere is casual and cozy, making it an ideal choice for any occasion—whether it's a quick lunch, a family dinner, solo dining, or hosting a large group gathering. Furthermore, Gencarelli's is a BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle) establishment, allowing diners to pair their favorite wine or beverage with their meal, adding to the value and personal touch of the dining experience. Their dedication to community service and consistent quality has cemented Gencarelli's reputation as one of the best casual, authentic Italian options in the New Jersey area.

Gencarelli's Restaurant is conveniently situated in Pine Brook, a section of Montville Township in Morris County, making it easily accessible for local residents and those traveling from nearby towns like Parsippany, Montville, and Fairfield.

The official address is: 1 Hook Mountain Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058.

The location offers excellent accessibility features designed to accommodate all patrons comfortably, which includes parking and seating solutions:

• The venue provides a dedicated Free Parking Lot directly on site, which is noted for its ample space, alongside available Free Street Parking.
• Gencarelli’s ensures full accessibility with a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, a designated Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, and a Wheelchair Accessible Restroom.
• Dining areas include Wheelchair Accessible Seating, ensuring a smooth experience for all guests.
• The restaurant is easy to find, often described as having a cute storefront with both dedicated takeout and dine-in areas.

Gencarelli's provides a diverse range of services, establishing them as a one-stop-shop for Italian food needs—from a quiet dinner to a fully catered event.

• Full-Service Dine-In: Enjoy a comfortable, cozy dining experience with attentive table service for Lunch and Dinner. Reservations are accepted and recommended for dinner, especially on weekends or for groups.
• Takeout and Delivery: A robust system is in place for enjoying their food at home, including standard Takeout, Delivery, Curbside Pickup, and No-Contact Delivery options for ultimate convenience.
• Extensive Catering Services: Gencarelli's is a highly-rated caterer, specializing in tailored events for all occasions with a complete selection of hot and cold food, sold in half or full trays to suit different party sizes.
• Pizzeria Services: As a leading Pizza restaurant and Pizza Delivery service, they offer various pies, from the classic Large 18-inch Pizza to specialty options like the Square Grandma Pie and Drunken Grandma.
• Family and Kids' Amenities: The atmosphere is highly Family-Friendly, featuring a dedicated Kids' Menu and High Chairs for younger guests.
• Diverse Dining Options: Available for Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, offering quick bites, small plates, and substantial entrees.
• BYOB Dining: Note that the dine-in experience is BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle), which is a fantastic feature for customers to enjoy their preferred beverage with their meal.

Gencarelli's stands out in the competitive New Jersey dining scene due to several signature features and consistent quality marks.

• True Authentic Italian Cuisine: The food is known for its classical, traditional tastes, and critics praise Gencarelli's for offering genuinely authentic Italian food, unlike many places that only "claim" to be. Dishes like the Baked Clams Oreganata and Zuppa di Pesce are often singled out for their quality.
• Award-Winning Pizza and Specialty Pies: The restaurant is famous for its exceptional pizza, including the highly popular Grandma Pie and the unique Drunken Grandma, with customers raving about the quality mozzarella, thin dough, and use of real sausage.
• Signature Pasta Dishes: The menu features over twenty pasta dishes, with favorites including the Homemade Black & White Squid Ink Pasta Frutti di Mare, Lobster Ravioli, and the much-loved Linguini with Shrimp, Scallops & Arugula.
• Generous Portions and Value: Customers consistently highlight the great value and the "huge portion" sizes for their money, ensuring a satisfying meal that often leads to leftovers.
• Service and Comfort: The service is frequently noted as Fast Service, with friendly, attentive waiters who make the experience enjoyable and hassle-free. The entire staff strives to make every visitor feel at home.
• Health-Conscious Offerings: The menu thoughtfully includes a Healthy Options/Gluten-Free section with items like Whole-Wheat Penne, Grilled Chicken w/ Spinach, and Grilled Shrimp over Sautéed Broccoli Rabe, along with many Vegetarian Options.
• Excellent Catering Reputation: Known for knocking party orders "out of the park," their catering service is highly professional, reliable, and delivers fresh, delicious food for any event.
• Great Dessert: Patrons who save room are rewarded with desserts like Tiramisu and their famous Homemade Rice Pudding.

For making reservations, placing a takeout order, or inquiring about catering, New Jersey residents can reach Gencarelli's Restaurant using the following details:

• Address: 1 Hook Mountain Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058
• Phone: (973) 575-6745 (Also listed as +1 973-575-6745)

Gencarelli's Restaurant is an essential choice for anyone in the New Jersey area seeking quality Italian food, primarily due to its exceptional value, dual-threat menu, and genuine family atmosphere.

Firstly, choosing Gencarelli’s means opting for a place where Authenticity is Paramount. This is not a chain; it is a family-run business dedicated to the classical tastes of Italian cuisine, as attested by multiple long-time customers who appreciate the traditional preparation of dishes like Baked Clams Oreganata, Zuppa di Pesce, and the vast selection of Veal and Chicken entrees. The food is consistently rated as "off the charts" and "consistently amazing," a testament to their commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Secondly, the ability to serve as a Full-Spectrum Italian Provider—excelling at both a cozy dine-in experience and massive catering orders—sets them apart. Whether you need a quick, delicious Buffalo Chicken Pizza delivered, or trays of Chicken Parmigiana and Homemade Cheese Ravioli for a hundred guests, Gencarelli's handles it flawlessly. This versatility, combined with their BYOB policy, makes the dine-in option incredibly appealing and reasonably priced for a fine Italian meal in the area.

Finally, the Generous Portions and Attentive Service contribute significantly to the high praise. Diners receive ample servings for their money, a rare and welcome feature in today’s dining landscape. The friendly staff and cozy, comfortable atmosphere—where every effort is made to make you feel like family—ensures that every visit is a genuinely satisfying experience, making Gencarelli's a clear choice for lunch, dinner, or your next catered event in Morris County.

Gencarelli's Restaurant

1 Hook Mountain Rd, Pine Brook, NJ 07058, USA