It's Greek To Me Syosset NY: Authentic Long Island Greek Restaurant & Pizzeria

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Introduce

For New Yorkers on Long Island seeking a genuine taste of the Mediterranean, It's Greek To Me Restaurant in Syosset stands out as an authentic, family-run destination. More than just a local eatery, this restaurant has been a Syosset staple since 1985, a testament to its enduring commitment to quality, tradition, and warm hospitality. Customers consistently praise the experience, often rating it highly for both the delicious food and the exceptionally friendly and welcoming service provided by the owners, John and Kathy, and their family.

The atmosphere within It's Greek To Me is described as casual and cozy, reflecting a quaint, beautiful place that proudly displays its Greek culture and heritage from the moment you step inside. It offers a comfortable and relaxed environment perfect for groups, couples, or solo diners, creating a local hub where patrons feel like a part of the family. The dedication to authentic, home-cooked flavors is evident across the extensive menu. Highlights often noted by locals include the incredibly juicy Chicken Gyro, the best they've tasted, and the fresh, homemade quality of their Tzatziki sauce and pita bread, which truly tastes like it was made in Greece. The generous lunch specials, available until 3:00 P.M., are noted as a great deal, making high-quality Greek cuisine accessible throughout the workday.

Beyond the beloved gyros and kebobs, the menu delves deep into traditional Greek specialties. Guests can explore dishes like Spanakopita (spinach pie), Tiropita (feta cheese pie), and the classic Greek comfort foods of Moussaka (Greek Lasagna with layers of potato, eggplant, and ground beef) and Pastitsio (Greek Baked Ziti). Seafood lovers will find a remarkable selection, including Grilled Octopus, Whole Branzini (a delicate, sweet-flavored fish native to Greece), and Stuffed Filet of Sole. For those with a sweet tooth, the dessert menu—which includes traditional Baklava, Galaktobouriko (custard in filo), and Rice Pudding—is highly recommended, often capped off with a complimentary dessert from the kind owners.

This establishment represents a cultural gem on Long Island, offering a blend of traditional recipes, a welcoming family atmosphere, and convenient dining services that make it a favorite among Syosset locals and those traveling from across the New York region.

Location and Accessibility

It's Greek To Me Restaurant is conveniently located on Jackson Avenue in the Syosset area of Long Island, New York. Its location in a shopping center ensures easy access and ample parking for all patrons.

127 Jackson Ave, Syosset, NY 11791

For New York residents driving to the location, the restaurant offers helpful parking amenities:

Free parking lot available on-site.
Free street parking is also an available option in the area.

The restaurant has taken measures to ensure a comfortable dining experience for all guests, offering complete accessibility:

Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Services Offered

The comprehensive service options at It's Greek To Me are designed to meet diverse customer needs, whether dining in, taking out, or hosting an event.

Dine-in: Enjoy table service in the casual, cozy restaurant atmosphere, with ample seating available.
Takeout: Convenient service for picking up orders to enjoy at home or the office.
Delivery: Available for ordering, bringing authentic Greek meals directly to your door.
Catering: Comprehensive catering services are offered for large groups and events, including traditional Greek casseroles (Moussaka, Pastitsio), skewers, salads, and desserts. Catering orders should be placed at least 48 hours in advance.
Accepts Reservations: Patrons are welcome to book tables, which is particularly helpful when dining with groups or during peak meal hours (Lunch and Dinner).
Table Service: Full service is provided for all dine-in guests.

Features / Highlights

It's Greek To Me stands out among Long Island's dining establishments due to its unique combination of quality food, service, and atmosphere.

Authentic Family-Run Business: Operating successfully since 1985, the restaurant is known for its incredible warmth, hospitality, and dedication from the owners, John and Kathy.
Homemade Quality: A major highlight is the use of fresh, home-made ingredients, including the much-praised Pita Bread and Tzatziki Sauce.
Fast Service: Noted as a key highlight, ensuring efficiency for both dine-in and takeout orders, which is popular for quick lunch breaks.
Great Dessert: The dessert selection, featuring traditional Greek sweets like Baklava and Galaktobouriko, is a celebrated feature.
Extensive Menu Variety: The menu balances traditional Greek staples (Souvlaki, Gyro, Moussaka, Pastitsio) with Specialty Entrees, fresh Seafood, Vegetarian Appetizers (Spanakopita, Dolmadakia, Grilled Falafel), and a selection of Kebobs.
Full Bar Offerings: Provides a selection of beverages including Alcohol, Beer (like Mythos Beer), Wine, and Cocktails, enhancing the dinner experience.
Dedicated Kids' Menu: The restaurant is 'Good for kids' and offers high chairs and a menu tailored for younger guests, making it a great option for family dining.
Dietary Options: The menu thoughtfully includes Healthy options, Small plates, Vegan options, and Vegetarian options, catering to a wide array of dietary needs.
Comfortable Amenities: Free Wi-Fi and a Restroom are available for all customers.

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout, catering inquiries, or general information, please use the following contact details:

Address: 127 Jackson Ave, Syosset, NY 11791
Phone: (516) 496-0771
Mobile Phone: +1 516-496-0771

What Is Worth Choosing

Choosing It's Greek To Me Restaurant is a choice for authenticity, longevity, and genuine customer care on Long Island. For New York locals, this is more than just a place to eat; it is a long-standing institution where the food reflects a deep pride in Greek heritage. The combination of its consistently delicious, authentic food—from the succulent Chicken Gyro to the rich, baked Moussaka—and the personal, family-level warmth of the service makes it stand head and shoulders above many competitors. The owners, Kathy and John, are celebrated for making every guest feel welcome, even sharing travel tips like recommending the Greek island of Lefkada, a personal touch that transforms a simple dinner into a memorable cultural exchange.

Furthermore, the practicalities are handled flawlessly: the convenient Syosset location, the ease of access with a free parking lot, the commitment to full accessibility, and the popular lunch specials all contribute to its strong appeal. Whether you're a local craving a comforting bowl of Avgolemono Soup, a tourist looking for a high-quality Moussaka, or a group planning a large celebration using their full catering service, It's Greek To Me is a trustworthy and highly recommended choice for experiencing the best of authentic Greek cuisine in the New York region.

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Services

Lunch Specials (Available only till 3:00 P.M.)
# 1 Salad With A Topper
Choose a Topper. Served over lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese with pita bread, tzatziki & dressing on the side.
# 2 Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich + Side Salad $13.95
Cubes of all white meat chicken on pita, topped with tomatoes and onions, Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 2 LAMB Souvlaki Sandwich + Side Salad $15.95
Marinated cubes of Lamb on pita, topped with tomatoes and onions, Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 3 Gyro Sandwich + Side Salad $13.95
Slices of beef/lamb mix on pita, topped with tomatoes and onions, Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
#4 Chicken Kebob Lunch Special $15.95
Grilled chicken cubes over rice and mixed vegetables. Served with pita bread, tzatziki sauce and salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese and vinaigrette dressing)
# 4 LAMB KEBOB $17.95
Grilled lamb cubes over rice and mixed vegetables. Served with pita bread, tzatziki sauce and salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese and vinaigrette dressing)
# 5 Spinach Pie With Rice And Salad $15.95
Spinach with a touch of feta cheese wrapped in a flaky phyllo dough, served with rice, pita bread, tzatziki sauce and a side salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing) and
# 6 Shrimp Kebob $15.95
Grilled shrimp over rice and mixed vegetables. Served with pita bread, tzatziki sauce and salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese and vinaigrette dressing)
# 10 Greek Keftedes $15.95
Greek style meatballs seasoned with minced onions and dill served over rice. Includes pita bread, tzatziki sauce and a side salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese and vinaigrette dressing.
# 11 FRIED-Falafel Sandwich $13.95
Fried falafel on pita topped with lettuce, tomato, cucumber and tzatziki sauce on the side. Served with a side salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 11 GRILLED-Falafel Sandwich + Side Salad $13.95
Grilled falafel on pita topped with lettuce, tomato, cucumber and tzatziki sauce on the side. Served with a side salad (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 12 CHX GYRO Sandwich + Side Salad $13.95
Slices of chicken on pita, topped with tomatoes and onions, Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 13 Loukaniko Sandwich + Side Salad $13.95
Grilled links of pork sausage seasoned with orange zest served on pita bread, topped with tomatoes and onions, Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 14 Hamburger Lunch Special $13.95
All beef burger grilled to your liking, served on a bun, topped with tomatoes and onions. Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing) Add American cheese for an additional charge.
# 15 Veggie Burger Lunch Special $13.95
Grilled veggie burger served on pita bread, topped with lettuce and tomato. Tzatziki sauce on the side and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
# 17 Philly Cheese Steak Lunch Special $15.95
Thin sliced grilled beef topped with grilled onions and american cheese and Served with a side salad (Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, feta cheese, vinaigrette dressing)
Extra Pita $1.25
Extra Tzatziki Sauce $1.25

Mediterranean Spreads
Tzatziki App $8.95
Mediterranean spread. Yogurt, cucumber and garlic spread. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.
Baba-Ganoush $8.95
Mediterranean spread. Smoked eggplant with garlic and herbs. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.
Hummus $8.95
Mediterranean spread. A blend of chick peas, garlic and herbs. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.
Taramosalata $9.95
Mediterranean spread. Carp fish roe spread. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.
Scordalia $8.95
Mediterranean spread. Creamy garlic potato spread. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.
Appeteazer $19.95
A taste of all 5 spread. Served with pita bread. Add carrots and cucumbers for an additional charge.

Seafood Appetizers
Soft Shell Crabs $17.95
Two soft shells, lightly battered and fried. (Seasonal)
Fried Calamari App $15.95
Links of fresh squid lightly flowered and fried, served with marinara sauce on the side.
Grilled Calamari App $15.95
Links of fresh squid prepared grilled with garlic and oil.
Grilled Octopus App $21.95
Fresh grilled spanish octopus, seasoned with fresh garlic, lemon, olive oil and oregano.
Crab Cakes App $15.95
Two house made crab cakes, lightly battered and fried. Served with tarter sauce on the side.
Scungilli Appetizer $18.95
Tender pieces of scungili (conch fish) in a lite lemon, buttery sauce.

Meat Appetizers
Keftedakia App $11.95
Greek style meatballs made with lean ground beef seasoned with minced onions, dill and lemon.
Meat Pie App $8.95
Lean ground beef seasoned with minced onions and herbs wrapped and baked in a flaky phyllo dough.
Chicken Fingers $9.95
All white meat chicken tenders, lightly battered and fried (4)
Loukaniko App $11.95
Links of pork sausage seasoned with orange zest, grilled and served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce.
Buffalo Wings $9.95
Mix of drums and wings, lightly battered and fried (6)
Greek Reunion $15.95
A combination of spanakopita, Tiropita, gyro and chicken souvlaki. Served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side

Vegetarian Appetizers
Spanakopita App $8.95
Spinach and a touch of feta cheese baked in a flaky phyllo.
Gigandes $9.95
The traditional Greek, giant white beans baked in a lite red sauce.
Sauteed Spinach $12.95
Fresh spinach sauteed with garlic and olive oil.
Grilled Falafel App $10.95
Made from fresh chick peas that are blended with herbs and prepared grilled (gluten free) Pita and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Fried Falafel Appetizer $10.95
Made from fresh chick peas that are blended with herbs and prepared fried. Pita and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Grilled Vegetables $10.95
A mix of broccoli, green peppers, onions, cauliflower and carrots. Lightly seasoned and grilled with olive oil.
Stuffed Mushrooms $11.95
Mushroom caps stuffed with a choice of crab-meat OR spinach & feta OR 1/2 and 1/2.
Onion Rings $9.95
Links of onions lightly battered and fried to a golden brown
Zucchini Sticks $9.95
Zucchini strips, lightly battered and fried to a golden brown, served with marinara sauce on the side
Dolmadakia $9.95
Vine leaves stuffed with rice and herbs (7)

Cheese Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks (5) $8.95
Saganaki Cheese $12.95
Kefalograviera cheese (blend of goat and sheep milk) simply grilled and seasoned with lemon, oregano and olive oil. Gluten free.
Feta Cheese Appetizer $12.95
Thick slice of feta cheese (cow's milk) seasoned with olive oil and oregano.
Halloumi Cheese $12.95
A blend of goat and sheep milk with a more spongier texture then saganaki cheese. It's simply grilled and seasoned with lemon, oregano and olive oil. Gluten free.
Tiropita Appetizer $8.95
Feta cheese baked in flaky phyllo.

Pita Pizzas
Chicken Pizza
Cubes of chicken breast with grilled onions and tomatoes topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
Gyro Pizza
Slices of gyro (beef/lamb meat) with grilled onions and tomatoes, topped with melted mozzarella.
Spinach And Feta Pizza
A mix of spinach and feta topped with melted mozzarella.
Veggie Pizza
A mix of grilled broccoli, onions, peppers and carrots, cauliflower, zucchini, topped with melted mozzarella.
Sauce & Mozzarella Pizza
Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on a pita

SIDES
Side Order Of Meat $11.95
Chose a Side order of meat.Served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Rice Pilaf $6.95
Baked Sweet Potato $6.95
Oven Roasted Potatoes $6.95
Sweet Potato Fries $7.95
Hand Cut-French Fries $6.95
Greek Fries $6.95
Round thin sliced potato chips fries.
Side Pita Bread $1.25
Extra Cup Tzatziki Sauce $1.25
Extra Cup Feta Cheese $2.00

Kids Menu
Kids Chicken Fingers $10.95
Kids Hamburger $13.95
Kids Cheese Burger $14.95
Kids Mozzarella Sticks $10.95
Kids Grilled American Cheese On A Pita $9.95
Kids Gyro $13.95
Gyro (beef & lamb meat) served with a choice of a side. Pita and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Kids Chicken Gyro $13.95
Chicken Gyro Slices served with a choice of a side. Pita and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Kids Chicken Souvlaki $13.95
Chicken Souvlaki Cubes (chx breast meat) served with a choice of a side. Pita and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Kids Sauce And Cheese Pizza $10.95
Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on a pita.

Soups
Avgolemono Soup $6.95
Chicken broth with orzo, minced onions and carrots. Pint Size. Served with pita bread.
Lentil Soup $6.95
Green lentils stewed with minced onions and carrots. Pint Size. Served with pita bread.
Yankee Bean Soup $6.95
(GF) White beans stewed with tomatoes, carrots and onions. Pint size. Served with pita bread.
Barley Soup $6.95
Barley pearls stewed with onions and carrots. Pint Size. Served with pita bread.
French Onion Soup $9.95
Stewed onions in beef broth, topped with melted mozzarella. Pint Size.

SALADS
Greek Salad With A Topping $20.95
Served with pita bread, house vinaigrette dressing and tzatziki sauce on the side.
COMBO-SALAD $25.95
A taste of two toppers! Chose two different toppers for your salad! (Chopped lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta cheese, olives and dolma (grape leaf). Served with pita bread, house vinaigrette and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Sm. Greek Salad $11.95
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta cheese, olives, grape leaf. Pita bread and vinaigrette dressing on the side
Sm. Horiatiki Salad $13.95
No lettuce. Just cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, green pepper, feta cheese, olives, grape leaf. Pita bread and vinaigrette dressing on the side
Lg. Greek Salad $15.95
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta cheese, olives, grape leaf. Pita bread and vinaigrette dressing on the side
Lg. Horiatiki Salad $17.95
No lettuce. Just cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, green pepper, feta cheese, olives, grape leaf. Pita bread and vinaigrette dressing on the side

Sandwiches
Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich $11.95
Cubes of all white meat chicken served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Lamb Souvlaki Cubes Sandwich $12.95
Cubes of lamb served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Loukaniko Sandwich $11.95
Links of pork sausage seasoned with orange zest served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Veggie Burger Sandwich $10.95
Grilled veggie burger served on pita bread and topped with lettuce and tomato, tzatziki sauce on the side
Gyro Slices Sandwich $10.95
Slices of lamb/beef mix, served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Chicken Gyro Slices Sandwich $11.95
Slices of chicken served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Pork Souvlaki Cubes Sandwich $11.95
Cubes of lean pork served on pita bread and topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Hamburger $10.95
All beef burger, grilled to your liking. Served on a bun, topped with tomato, onion
Cheeseburger $11.95
All beef burger, grilled to your liking. Served on a bun, topped with tomato, onion and american cheese
Grilled Falafel Sandwich $11.95
Chick-pea patties prepared grilled. Served on pita bread, topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side
Fried Falafel Sandwich $11.95
Fried chick-pea patties. Served on pita bread, topped with tomato and onion, tzatziki sauce on the side

House Platters
Combination Platter, Choice Of 2 Meats $25.95
Gyro-Platter $20.95
Slices of beef/lamb mix topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Chicken Gyro-Platter $20.95
Slices of lightly seasoned chicken topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Chicken-Souvlaki Platter $20.95
Cubes of all white meat chicken topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Pork Souvlaki-Platter $20.95
Cubes of lean pork topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Lamb-Souvlaki Platter $23.95
Cubes of lean lamb, topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Loukaniko-Platter $20.95
Links of pork sausage seasoned with orange zest topped with tomato and onion served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Fried-Falafel Platter $20.95
Fried chick-pea patties, topped with lettuce, tomato, cucumber and tzatziki sauce on the side
Grilled-Falafel Platter $20.95
Chick-pea patties prepared grilled, topped with lettuce, tomato, cucumber and tzatziki sauce on the side
Veggie Burger-Platter $19.95
Veggie burger patty grilled and topped with lettuce and tomato, served with pita bread and tzatziki sauce on the side.
Hamburger-Platter $19.95
All beef burger grilled to your liking, served on a bun, topped with tomatoes and onion
Cheeseburger-Platter $19.95
All beef burger grilled to your liking, served on a bun, topped with tomatoes, onion and american cheese

Specialty Entrees
Chicken Kebob Dinner $23.95
Cubes of grilled chicken breast served over grilled vegetables (broccoli, onions, peppers, carrots, cauliflower)
Spanakopita Dinner $20.95
Spinach and a touch of feta cheese baked in a flaky phyllo dough.
Tiropita Dinner $20.95
Feta cheese baked in a flaky phyllo dough.
Meat-Pie Dinner $20.95
Lean ground beef seasoned with minced onions and herbs wrapped and baked in a flaky phyllo dough.
Moussaka $23.95
"Greek Lasagna" Layers of potato, eggplant, lean ground beef, baked with a bechamel sauce and topped with a touch of marinara sauce.
Pastitsio $23.95
"Greek Baked Ziti" Layers of long ziti with lean ground beef, baked with a bechamel sauce and topped with a touch of marinara sauce.
Greek Keftedes Dinner $23.95
Greek style meatballs made from lean ground beef, seasoned with minced onions and dill. Also served with grilled vegetables.
Calves Liver Dinner $23.95
Steak cut, grilled to your liking and topped with grilled peppers and onions.
Chicken Santorini $25.95
Cubes of grilled chicken breast baked with feta cheese and home made marinara sauce, served with grilled vegetables.
Lamb Kebob Dinner $25.95
Cubes of lean tender lamb grilled and served over grilled vegetables.
1/2 Roasted Chicken $23.95
1/2 Roasted chicken braised in the oven till golden brown, served with grilled vegetables.
Whole Branzini $32.95
Native to greece, sweet flavor, lean, moist and delicate. Served with salad and grilled veggies.
Shrimp Kebob Dinner $24.95
Grilled shrimp, lightly seasoned and served with grilled vegetables.
Stuffed Filet Of Sole $25.95
Filet of sole, stuffed with crabmeat, or spinach with feta, or 1/2 and 1/2 (a taste of both). Also served with grilled vegetables.
Octopus Entree Special $32.95
Tender spanish octopus grilled and seasoned with garlic, olive oil and lemon, served with grilled vegetables.
Salmon Dinner $25.95
Grilled and lightly seasoned, served with grilled vegetables.
Shrimp Santorini $25.95
Grilled shrimp baked with feta cheese and home made tomato sauce served with grilled vegetables.
Stuffed Shrimp $25.95
Shrimp stuffed with crabmeat, or spinach with feta, or 1/2 and 1/2 (a taste of both). Also served with grilled vegetables.
White Sea Bass Filet $23.95
A thin-flaky white meat fish, grilled and lightly seasoned, served with grilled vegetables.
Filet Tilapia $23.95
Grilled and lightly seasoned, served with grilled vegetables.
Lamb Chops $32.95
5 piece baby lamb chops, lightly seasoned and grilled to your liking. Also served with grilled veggies
Skirt Steak $32.95
Long thin beef strip, lightly seasoned and grilled to your liking, served with grilled veggies
Braised Lamb Shanks $32.95
Braised (2) Lamb shanks in the oven till tender and butter soft, served with grilled vegetables.
Pork Chops $29.95
2 Center cut pork chops on the bone, grilled and lightly seasoned, served with grilled vegetables.
T-Bone Steak $39.95
20oz. Lightly seasoned and prepared to your liking, served with grilled vegetables.
Ribeye Steak $39.95
20oz. Lightly seasoned and prepared to your liking, served with grilled vegetables.
Chicken Linguine $23.95
Linguine tossed with a touch of sauteed spinach in garlic & oil Or marinara (whole wheat linguine is available).
Shrimp Linguine $25.95
Linguine tossed with a touch of sauteed spinach in garlic & oil Or marinara (whole wheat linguine is available).
Stuffed Chicken $25.95
Choice of Spinach with Feta, Or Crabmeat, Or 1/2 & 1/2 (taste of both)
Filet Baramundi $32.95
Wild Catch, white meaty texture, buttery flavor, high in omega3. Served also with grilled vegetables.
Stuffed Chicken $25.95
All white meat chicken stuffed with your choice of: Spinach with Feta or Crabmeat or Half and a Half (a taste of both). Served with grilled vegetables. greek salad and pita bread. Please Note: This dish will require extra prep time.

Extras
Extra Pita $1.25
Extra Tzatziki Sauce $1.25
Extra Cup Feta Cheese $2.00

Coffee/Desserts
Baklava $8.50
Jumbo slice of layered flaky filo dough with walnuts, cinnamon & syrup
Kourabiedes $6.00
Powder sugar cookies with chunks of almonds.
Rice Pudding $6.00
Simply made with milk, sugar, rice & cinnamon
Galaktobouriko $7.50
Layers of flaky filo with a creamy filling, seasoned with cinnamon and syrup
Tiramisu $7.50
Slice of your favorite "pick me up" dessert! Layers of lady finger cookies dipped in coffee with light mascarpone cream and cocoa.
Almond Cake $6.00
Yellow sponge cake layered with mascarpone cream and roasted almonds
Frappe Iced Coffee $4.50
Greek iced coffee with milk and sugar. "The Real Pick Me Up"
Cheese Cake $6.00
Have it plain or with blueberries! Please specify.

Greek Beer (Must be 21 to purchase)
Mythos Beer $5.50
Lager beer with a bright blonde colour and a pleasant, slightly sweet refreshing taste. Must be 21 to purchase.

Soda/Water
Seltzer (Can) $2.50
12oz Can Soda
Sm. Sparkling Water $2.75
Imported Greek sparkling "Souroti" water
Lg. Sparkling Water $6.50
Imported Greek sparkling "Souroti" water
Saratoga STILL Water $6.00
28oz.
Saratoga SPARKLING Water $6.00
28oz.
Coke $3.00
20oz Bottle
Poland Spring $3.00
20oz Bottle
Diet Coke $3.00
20oz Bottle
Ginger Ale $3.00
20oz Bottle
Lemon/Lime Diet Sprite (Can) $2.50
Sprite Zero (Can) $2.00
12oz Can Soda

Snapple Iced Tea
Lemon Snapple $3.00
16oz
Diet Lemon Snapple $3.00
16oz.
Peach Snapple $3.00
16oz.
Diet Peach Snapple $3.00
16oz.
Raspberry Snapple $3.00
16oz.

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great dessert

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Groups
Locals

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Photos

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Location

It's Greek To Me Restaurant

New York Nassau County Syosset Jackson Avenue

127 Jackson Ave, Syosset, NY 11791, USA

It's Greek To Me Restaurant Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 201 user reviews.

gyrogreek saladpricespitalambgrilledhomerice puddingdesertsouvlaki

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Loved this place! The family - yes it's truly a family business - was so friendly and welcoming. Food was delicious - and a bonus rice pudding to top it off at the end of the night! Delicious 😋! And we got some great travel tips - we're looking forward to seeing the island recommended - Lefkada. If I could give this place 6+ stars I would!
July 24 · Barbara Fitzgeorge
Amazing Authentic Greek Food In Syosset on Jackson Ave! I found this place while at an appointment in the area and it was phenomenal! The Chicken gyro was so juicy! I absolutely loved the best! The Tzatziki sauce is made fresh it is simply amazing and the pita bread is home made it tastes like it was made in Greece. This is small quaint beautiful place in a shopping center that takes pride in their culture and heritage, it shows as you step in. I love it! 💙 🇬🇷🏛️Family run..Kathy and John are great people extremely nice, funny and accommodating. The lunch specials are a great deal. I understand from John they are going strong since 1985 that’s incredible💪 I am so glad I found them..better late than never. I will be back again!
March 14 · Fish Fellas
We so enjoyed our dinner here! We got takeout once but this was the first time we ate in the restaurant. The staff was extremely welcoming and the food was hot and delicious. We enjoyed the spanakopita appetizer and I had Greek salad with falafel topper—my husband had the gyro with roasted potatoes. We will be back!
May 02 · Jillian
Order takeout Grilled Salmon, Roasted potatoes, grilled veggies, Greek salad and baklava for desert. The Food was hot and delicious!Thank you so much
May 17 · Cliff Russo
Nice place. Great food. Good variety. Great service. Can't help but love this place.
August 31 · Ira Pollak
Great food. This has become a regular spot for us. Family run, super friendly and authentic. Highly recommend it.
October 07 · Isidore Miller