Made In New York Pizza

- 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

When you think of New York City, one of the first things that comes to mind is a classic slice of pizza. For a truly authentic experience that lives up to the hype, look no further than Made In New York Pizza. Located on the Upper West Side, this casual and trendy spot is dedicated to serving the quintessential New York-style pizza, with a commitment to quality ingredients, a perfect crust, and the quick, efficient service the city is famous for.

More than just a pizza place, Made In New York Pizza is a local institution, a place where college students, tourists, and neighborhood regulars alike can grab a satisfying meal. The atmosphere is no-frills and classic, focusing on what matters most: the food. Whether you're looking for a quick bite on the go or a place to sit down and enjoy a pie with friends, this pizzeria delivers. It’s a testament to the belief that the best pizza is often the simplest, made with care and a touch of that legendary NYC water.

Made In New York Pizza is conveniently situated at 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024. This address places it firmly in the heart of the Upper West Side, a bustling and vibrant area known for its iconic brownstones, local businesses, and easy access to Central Park. The restaurant is located on Amsterdam Avenue, making it a visible and easy-to-find destination.

Getting to the pizzeria is straightforward for anyone in the New York City region. The area is well-served by public transportation, with the 1 train stopping at nearby 79th Street, just a short walk away. For those who prefer to drive, the neighborhood offers various parking options, including free and paid street parking, as well as paid parking garages.

The restaurant is also committed to accessibility, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance that ensures all customers can easily enter and enjoy their meal. The outdoor seating provides a great view of the city streets, a classic New York experience for any visitor.

Made In New York Pizza understands the fast-paced nature of the city and offers a wide range of services to cater to every need.

• Dine-in: The pizzeria provides a small but comfortable seating area, allowing you to enjoy your pizza fresh and hot right out of the oven.
• Takeout: For those on the move, you can grab a slice or a full pie to go. The fast and efficient service ensures you won't be held up for long.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery, including no-contact delivery, so you can enjoy their delicious pizzas from the comfort of your home, office, or hotel.
• Catering: For events, parties, or large gatherings, Made In New York Pizza offers catering services, making it easy to share a taste of New York with a crowd.
• Onsite Services: As both a pizza restaurant and an Italian grocery store, they offer a unique combination of dining and retail, with various items for sale.

What makes Made In New York Pizza a local favorite is its dedication to simple, delicious food and a no-fuss experience.

• Fast Service: Customers consistently praise the restaurant for its quick and efficient service, making it an excellent choice for a fast lunch break or a late-night craving.
• Authentic New York Pizza: The name says it all. The pizza has the classic New York "flop" with a perfect balance of crispy, thin crust, flavorful sauce, and quality cheese.
• Wide Variety of Pies: The menu offers a fantastic selection of round and square pies, from the classic Cheese and Pepperoni to more unique options like the Vodka Pie and Buffalo Chicken Pie.
• Great for Slices: The display case of freshly made slices makes it easy to choose your favorite. This is the perfect way to experience different flavors and truly get that quintessential NYC slice experience.
• Comfort Food and More: In addition to pizza, the menu features other comfort food items like garlic knots, calzones, and a variety of desserts, including Tiramisu and NY Cheesecake.
• Good for Kids and Late-Night Eats: With a casual atmosphere and a kid-friendly menu, it's a great spot for families. The restaurant also offers late-night food, making it a reliable option for a late-night craving.

With so many delicious options, deciding what to order at Made In New York Pizza can be a challenge. If you're looking for the best of the best, here are a few things that come highly recommended.

For a classic experience, you can't go wrong with the Cheese Pie or a slice of it. It’s the perfect representation of an authentic New York slice. If you're a fan of a little spice, the Spicy Pepperoni Pie is a standout, praised for its crispy cupping pepperoni and crunchy crust. The Vodka Pie is another fan favorite, celebrated for its rich and flavorful sauce.

For those who prefer a thicker crust, the square pies are a must-try. The Classic Sicilian Pie and the Grandma Pie offer a different but equally delicious experience, with a focus on fresh ingredients and a satisfyingly thick crust. The Upside Down Pie is also a popular choice, where the sauce is placed on top of the cheese for a unique flavor profile.

Beyond the pizza, don't miss the sides. The 5 Garlic Knots W/ Sauce are a perfect companion to your meal, known for their flavorful garlic and soft texture. And for dessert, a slice of the NY Cheesecake is the perfect way to finish off a truly New York meal.

For questions, to place a takeout order, or to check on delivery, you can contact Made In New York Pizza directly.

• Address: 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
• Phone: (646) 484-6200

Made In New York Pizza

421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA