Maria's Italian Bakery: Your Bergen County Destination for Authentic Italian Pastries and Sweets

Maria's Italian Bakery Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Maria's Italian Bakery - A Taste of Italy in Saddle Brook, NJ

For New Jersey residents with a craving for authentic, old-world Italian sweets and fresh-baked goods, Maria's Italian Bakery stands out as a true Bergen County gem. Located in Saddle Brook, this establishment is more than just a local Bakery; it’s a dedicated purveyor of classic Italian-American baking traditions, offering everything from daily bread to intricate holiday pastries and custom celebration cakes. The inviting aroma of baking and fresh coffee is a hallmark of the experience, instantly transporting visitors to a classic Italian "pasticceria."

Maria's Italian Bakery has cultivated a reputation based on the quality and variety of its offerings. While many bakeries specialize in one area, Maria's provides a comprehensive selection that caters to everyday needs and special events. Customers flock here for the signature Italian treats—including a fantastic selection of classic Butter Cookies, delicate Biscotti, and the crowd-pleasing Cannolis that are often filled fresh upon request. Beyond the daily assortment, the bakery is highly valued for its specialized, harder-to-find Sicilian pastries, often available on weekends, which draw appreciative crowds from across North Jersey.

The atmosphere at Maria's is geared towards a focused and friendly service model. It is designed for a Quick visit, making it an efficient stop for commuters, local families, and anyone looking for a fresh, high-quality treat. As a staple in the Saddle Brook community, Maria’s commitment to providing delicious Italian staples has solidified its status as a go-to spot for an authentic taste of Italy right here in New Jersey.

Location and Accessibility in Saddle Brook, NJ

Maria's Italian Bakery is ideally situated at 386 Market St, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663, USA. Market Street is a convenient artery in the heart of Saddle Brook, positioning the bakery for easy access from various points within Bergen County and beyond. The strategic location makes it an effortless stop for locals picking up a morning treat or for those traveling specifically for its renowned Italian specialties.

Understanding the importance of convenience for all New Jersey patrons, Maria's has prioritized accessibility and parking:

Free Parking Lot: Customers benefit from a dedicated Free parking lot, eliminating the stress of searching for street parking and ensuring a quick, hassle-free stop for Takeout orders.
Wheelchair Accessibility: The bakery is committed to accommodating all guests, featuring both a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot. This ensures that every member of the community can easily access the baked goods and service.

The combination of a central location and thoughtful accessibility features makes Maria's Italian Bakery a straightforward and pleasant visit for all customers in the North Jersey area.

Services Offered

Maria's Italian Bakery focuses on providing high-quality baked goods and a streamlined purchasing experience for its customers:

Specialty Baked Goods: Offering an extensive selection of classic Italian baked goods, including various Butter Cookies, Biscotti, Cupcakes, and its highly acclaimed Cannolis.
Custom Cake Orders: The bakery provides the service of ordering Custom Cakes for birthdays, holidays, and other significant events, baked to customer specifications for flavor and size.
In-Store Purchase: The primary service model is efficient and focused Takeout, designed for a Quick visit to pick up fresh items.
Morning Dining: The availability of Coffee alongside their fresh treats provides a simple Breakfast or morning snack option for early visitors.
Payment Versatility: Customers can easily complete their transactions using a variety of modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
Catering Consultations: While the specific menu items are pastries, the bakery's expertise in large-volume sweets and special occasion orders often positions it as a key resource for Catering dessert and baked goods tables for local events.

Features / Highlights

Maria's Italian Bakery distinguishes itself within the competitive New Jersey bakery scene through several unique highlights:

Authentic Italian & Sicilian Specialties: The bakery is locally famous for its mastery of traditional Italian baking, particularly its challenging Sicilian pastries. Specialties like Sfogliatelle, Lobster Tails, and, especially on weekends, the deep-fried, cream-filled Cartocci (or Maccalei) and Iris/Inis with ricotta and chocolate chips, are significant draws for discerning patrons.
Freshness and Quality of Classics: The commitment to quality is evident in their most popular items. Many patrons highlight the freshness and deliciousness of their staples, from Cannolis filled to order to a visually appealing array of baked Cookies and delicate Cupcakes.
A Reliable Morning Stop: Offering fresh pastries and Coffee, Maria's is positioned as an excellent choice for a quick, delicious Breakfast or mid-morning break, making it a regular stop for many local New Jersey commuters.
Customer-Centric Convenience: The dual commitment to Free parking lot access and full Wheelchair accessibility underscores a focus on making the visit seamless and effortless for every customer, which is a significant value-add in a busy suburban area.
A Staple for Celebrations: While customers should be mindful of customization details when ordering, the availability of Custom Cakes and large orders of pastries for events positions Maria's as a reliable local partner for celebrating life's milestones.

Contact Information

For New Jersey customers in the Saddle Brook area and beyond who wish to place a custom order, inquire about specific Sicilian pastries, or simply check operating hours for a quick visit, please use the following contact details:

Address: 386 Market St, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663, USA
Phone: (201) 843-7990

What is Worth Choosing Maria's Italian Bakery

For residents of New Jersey, choosing Maria's Italian Bakery is worthwhile when your priority is authenticity, speed, and access to a wide variety of time-honored Italian-American treats, especially pastries and cookies.

First and foremost, the bakery is a powerhouse of classic Italian baking. While all bakeries sell sweets, Maria's excels in specialties that are difficult to find, such as Sicilian pastries and consistently fresh Cannolis. Many long-time patrons consider their everyday cookies and pastries to be among the best in the area, offering a genuine taste of tradition that elevates a simple treat into a memorable indulgence. If you are preparing for a holiday or family gathering in New Jersey, stocking up on their traditional Italian cookies or a tray of classics like Sfogliatelle will impress your guests.

Secondly, Maria's is perfectly suited for the busy New Jersey lifestyle. The combination of a convenient Market St location, ample Free parking lot space, and a business model geared towards a Quick visit and Takeout makes it an incredibly efficient stop. Whether you are grabbing a quick coffee and pastry for Breakfast before work or picking up a box of treats for Dessert, the in-and-out experience is designed to be smooth and straightforward, a crucial advantage in North Jersey.

While customer feedback suggests custom cakes may require extra vigilance regarding design details, the consistent praise for their staple pastries, cookies, and unique Sicilian offerings is a strong indicator of their core strength. If your focus is on a diverse and authentic selection of everyday Italian baked goods, fresh bread, and classic Italian-American holiday sweets, Maria's Italian Bakery in Saddle Brook is a trusted, convenient, and delicious choice for the New Jersey community.

Maria's Italian Bakery Details

Service options
Takeout
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Maria's Italian Bakery Photos

Maria's Italian Bakery Location

Maria's Italian Bakery

New Jersey Bergen County Saddle Brook Market Street

386 Market St, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663, USA

Maria's Italian Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 605 user reviews.

cannolispricescookieslobsterselectionqualitypartyholidayfillingtiramisu

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This bakery was highly recommended by friends’ and family for their service and treats. So, I decided to order a custom birthday cake from them for my daughter’s birthday. I submitted my order a week prior and sent an image via email that they would printout and layer it on top of the cake. My wife picked up the cake the day prior to the occasion. The bakery packaged the cake without showing my wife the end product for customer satisfaction, and sent her on her way. As they were packing it up, at a glance, my wife got a glimpse and the image on top of the cake appeared wrinkled. But thought to herself, staff would have said something if there were any issues with the cake. My wife got home and placed it in a cool dry place until the next day. As we were preparing for the birthday, on the next day, I opened up the box and noticed that the top image was not placed completely flat, causing the wrinkles. I also noticed that they only bordered the cake with one color, not 2 as ordered. The image would have been placed first prior to adding the border decorations (piping), it appears that it was rushed and not taken seriously. The border decoration (piping) should have been 2 colors, yellow & blue, but they only used yellow. I called to inform them of the issues and lack thereof, but all I got was excuse after excuse. When I finally advised the woman over the phone that I wasn’t asking for a refund ($55.11) or another cake, because I needed the cake, since the birthday party was in a couple of hours. She then stopped with the reasoning/excuses and stated she would talk to the person who prepared the cake. After we served the cake, I notice that the chocolate sponge they used was very, very thin. Although this bakery does prepare very good pastries, making custom cakes isn’t their forte. They should just stick to making pastries, or hire someone who knows how to make cakes. I will not be ordering custom cakes from them again. I had a better experience ordering from BJ’s with the same request a couple years back.
April 08 · Chino 2406
I bought a strawberry shortcake there for my sisters birthday. It wasn’t a good cake and it wasn’t tasteful. It was full of whipped cream and wasn’t fresh and it was mediocre. It was dry and they didn’t decorate it the way I wanted. So, disappointed and I won’t return. This was my first experience here. There’s way better places for strawberry shortcake.
August 30 · Monarch Butterfly
Maria’s bakery has an abundance of delicious treats to choose from. Their employee Natalie was very kind and patient and went above and beyond to assist us with our order and is such a sweetheart! We will definitely be back for more delicious desserts! :)
June 06 · Nadia Gani
My first time stopping by and was impressed by the variety and service. I ordered rainbow cookies, chocolate covered strawberries and a classic cheesecake. The cookie had too much moisture, almost cakey. The cheesecake was okay but the strawberries were not sweet or ready. The chocolate they used was the same for the rainbow cookie so I wont be ordering fruit based goods from them. Otherwise the service was amazing! I would go back for the traditional Italian cookies and maybe some Italian or French Products they sell.
February 16 · Elizabeth La Salle
No care for the customers at all. If you’re planning a party don’t bother calling ahead to pre order. A week before the surprise party I was planning I went in to ask if I had to preorder if I was getting large amounts of cookies and pastries. The girl at the counter told me no. The next week I called just to confirm and they told me I did have to pre order. Already confusion but I thought it’s a good thing I called to double check. So I preordered the pastries and cookies and told them my pick up time for 11am. I get a phone call at exactly 11am while I’m on my way over to pick them up and was told they ran out of the cookies I had pre ordered. No apology or anything. Then they proceeded to ask when I was picking up my order because it wasn’t written down…..??? Then they asked if I could come in later on when the cookies were done baking. What??? I was throwing a surprise party that afternoon there was no way. Then I thought maybe I’ll just get more of the pastries I had ordered to make up for the loss but when I went to look at the spots in the display cases they were empty. They didn’t prepare at all. I don’t understand why you would tell your customers to preorder ahead so you have enough cookies for other customers while also making the customer put down a deposit yet then run out. Then to ask if I could come back when I’m throwing the party? That’s just ridiculous. The girl was totally unapologetic both over the phone and when I came to pick up the cookies. Also, make sure to check your boxes before you leave the bakery. Anytime I ask for powdered sugar on the pastries they barely put it on or forget to put any at all. Cannolis were hardly filled as well. You definitely don’t get what you paid for here.
July 18 · Brittany