Michelino's Pizzeria

- 79 E Milton Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065

Michelino's Pizzeria, located in the heart of Rahway, has long been a cornerstone of the New Jersey pizza scene, celebrated not only for its consistently top-notch, perfectly cooked pizza but also for its commitment to serving the entire community. More than a simple local pizzeria, Michelino’s operates as a full-service Italian restaurant that excels in offering an incredibly diverse and high-quality menu. From traditional pies and massive Italian subs to full dinner platters and oven-baked specialties like Lasagna and Stuffed Shells, this establishment caters to all aspects of Italian-American comfort dining.

What truly sets Michelino's Pizzeria apart, making it a unique gem in Union County, is its successful and dedicated inclusion of a comprehensive vegan menu. Recognized as both a traditional Pizza Restaurant and a Vegan Restaurant, it is an ideal choice for groups with mixed dietary needs, ensuring that everyone at the table—or ordering takeout—can find a satisfying and delicious meal. They utilize quality vegan alternatives, such as Violife cheese and Beyond Meat products, to create popular items like Vegan Pizza and the Vegan Beyond Burger, demonstrating a true dedication to catering to modern New Jersey palates.

Customers consistently praise the quality, flavor, and freshness of the food, noting the care and consistency in every dish. Beyond the exceptional food, Michelino’s fosters a friendly, family-like atmosphere, driven by an owner who is genuinely invested in customer satisfaction and dedicated to supporting the local Rahway community. This combination of superior product and heartfelt service has solidified its reputation as a neighborhood institution.

Location and Accessibility

Michelino's Pizzeria is conveniently located at 79 E Milton Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065, USA. This central location in Rahway makes it easily accessible for customers throughout Union County, whether they are stopping by for a quick slice, picking up a family dinner, or dining in for a full meal.

Accessibility is a key priority for the establishment. Patrons arriving by car will appreciate the availability of a free parking lot, alongside free street parking and general on-site parking options, streamlining the process for quick takeout pickups. For those with specific mobility requirements, the restaurant is fully prepared, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, and seating. This commitment ensures that all members of the New Jersey community can comfortably visit and enjoy what Michelino’s has to offer.

Services Offered

The range of services at Michelino's Pizzeria is designed to offer maximum convenience and flexibility, allowing customers to enjoy their high-quality Italian food wherever they choose.

• Dine-in: Provides a casual and welcoming setting with comfortable seating and table service for enjoying a full meal.
• Takeout (Pickup): Customers can call ahead or order online for fast and easy pickup of their entire order.
• Delivery: Offering prompt delivery services, which include a convenient No-contact delivery option for safety and preference.
• Catering: Available for special events, parties, and corporate functions, bringing their full Italian menu to larger groups.
• Full Dining Spectrum: Serving both Lunch and Dinner menus, ensuring a comprehensive selection is available throughout the day.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The location is good for kids and provides high chairs, making it a stress-free option for families.
• Restroom Facilities: Includes both standard and gender-neutral restroom facilities, catering to all guests.

Features and Highlights

Michelino's Pizzeria distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New Jersey pizza market with several key features that appeal to a broad customer base.

• Dual Menu (Pizza and Vegan): A rare and impressive feature is the comprehensive offering of both traditional Italian fare and an extensive, high-quality Vegan Options menu, including Vegan Beyond Burgers, Vegan Chick*N Nuggets, Vegan Veggie Roll, and pizzas made with vegan cheese.
• Signature Specialty Pizzas: The menu boasts an exciting variety of Specialty Pizza Combos like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, and the Rustica Pizza, catering to both classic and adventurous pizza lovers.
• Massive Sub and Sandwich Selection: Known for their generous portions, the Hot Subs, Cold Subs, and Michelino's Specialty Sandwiches, such as the impressive Surf And Turf Specialty Sandwich, are a highlight and a local specialty.
• Fast and Friendly Service: The staff is consistently recognized by customers for being friendly, welcoming, and providing fast service, ensuring a pleasant experience whether dining in or picking up.
• Community Focus: A unique highlight is the owner's highly-praised dedication to the local community, including supporting local schools and events, which fosters strong neighborhood loyalty.
• Authentic Italian Entrees: Beyond pizza, the restaurant offers satisfying Comfort Food with traditional Oven-Baked Specialties like Lasagna and Manicotti, and high-quality Chicken and Seafood Platters.
• Dessert Specialties: They offer unique and indulgent desserts like Dulce De Leche Zeppoli and Oreo Zeppoles, providing a memorable sweet ending to any meal.

Contact Information

For residents in Rahway and the surrounding Union County area, here is the essential contact information for Michelino's Pizzeria.

Address: 79 E Milton Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065, USA

Phone: (732) 396-9229

The standard operating hours for Michelino's Pizzeria are generally Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, with extended hours on Friday and Saturday until 9:30 PM, and a slightly later start on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM. These hours make it a reliable option for lunch and dinner throughout the week. Customers are encouraged to use the provided phone number for quick inquiries, to check on their delivery status, or to place an immediate takeout order, though online ordering is also available through various platforms for maximum convenience.

What is Worth Choosing Michelino's Pizzeria

For any New Jersey local seeking a reliable, high-quality Italian meal, Michelino's Pizzeria is an exceptional choice that truly represents the best of a neighborhood establishment. The core reason to choose Michelino’s is its unparalleled menu versatility: it excels as a classic Italian-American pizzeria while simultaneously operating as a dedicated, fully-featured vegan restaurant. This is a game-changer for families, friends, and groups with diverse dietary needs, ensuring the pizza traditionalists, vegetarians, and vegans can all enjoy a delicious meal from the same place.

Furthermore, the quality extends beyond the pizza itself. The generous portions, particularly the "game player" 16-inch Italian subs and the flavorful specialty sandwiches, offer incredible value and quality. The dedication to community and the consistently friendly service from the staff and owner, John, transforms a simple meal into a positive neighborhood experience, fostering a genuine sense of loyalty among Rahway residents. With fast service, multiple ordering options (dine-in, takeout, and delivery), and a menu that ranges from a simple slice to a complex Surf and Turf platter, Michelino's Pizzeria is clearly the top, all-in-one choice for satisfying Italian comfort food in the Union County area.

Michelino's Pizzeria

79 E Milton Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065, USA