Mollys Pies

- 446 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11215

In the vibrant and community-focused neighborhood of Park Slope, Brooklyn, finding authentic, high-quality, homemade goods can often feel like a treasure hunt. Mollys Pies is one such cherished discovery—a specialized, women-owned artisanal bakery that has carved out a distinct niche by focusing on one thing: delivering truly exceptional, homemade pies to the demanding palate of New York City. This is not a conventional grab-and-go storefront; rather, Mollys Pies represents the modern evolution of the small, passionate, local food business, built on word-of-mouth and a dedication to old-world quality.

The story of Mollys Pies is rooted in family heritage, inspired by a grandmother’s simple philosophy: "Keep the pie simple. Source the freshest ingredients and don't make it fancy." This ethos translates directly into a product that New Yorkers often struggle to find—a homemade pie that is genuinely preservative-free and bursting with fresh, authentic flavor. Originating from successful "stoop sales" that quickly garnered a loyal local following, the business has successfully transitioned to a more formal, yet still highly personal, direct-to-consumer model. This unique approach ensures that every pie is made with intention and care, reflecting a commitment to quality over mass production. The result is a highly sought-after product, which, as customer reviews attest, is often sold out due to immense local demand.

Mollys Pies is a proudly women-owned establishment that actively fosters a welcoming and inclusive community. In the heart of Brooklyn, the bakery is distinguished as both LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, making it an establishment that is not only dedicated to delicious baking but also to supporting a diverse and respectful neighborhood atmosphere. This deep connection to the community, coupled with its focus on fresh, flavorful pies, makes Mollys Pies a standout culinary feature in the 11215 zip code, offering a specialized product that beautifully contrasts with the area's many large commercial bakeries.

Location and Accessibility

Mollys Pies is located in a residential corner of the popular Park Slope neighborhood at 446 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA. The non-traditional nature of the address reflects its unique operational model. Instead of a large, high-foot-traffic storefront, the location functions primarily as the central hub for baking operations and customer fulfillment. This arrangement allows the bakery to maintain a focus on production quality and manage the artisanal process effectively.

Accessibility is optimized for a Quick visit model. Since the business primarily uses pre-orders and scheduled pickups, the flow of customers is manageable, ensuring a smooth process. Patrons can utilize the service options of In-store pickup and Takeout, retrieving their freshly baked goods directly from the source. Given the focus on efficiency and pre-arranged orders, the accessibility is about ease of scheduled transaction rather than walk-in browsing. For payment, the bakery is set up to accept Debit cards, ensuring a simple and digital checkout process for pre-arranged orders. The address itself is easily reachable from major Park Slope avenues, making it a convenient stop for locals fulfilling their special occasion orders.

Services Offered

The services at Mollys Pies are tailored to deliver a specialized, high-quality product, focusing on advanced ordering and specialized fulfillment.

• Specialized Pie Production: The core service is the creation of a diverse array of fresh, full-sized pies, including favorites such as Apple Crumb, Bourbon Pecan, Cherry, Chocolate Cream Pie, Key Lime, and the nostalgic Grandma's Blueberry Pie.
• Advanced Order Fulfillment: The business model centers around pre-orders, particularly for events, where bulk 9-inch or mini pies can be provided. Orders for events are requested to be placed a week in advance, a requirement stemming from the focus on made-to-order freshness.
• In-store Pickup: Customers utilize the 8th Street location primarily for In-store pickup, a scheduled, personalized service that guarantees the pie is fresh and ready upon arrival.
• Takeout Service: The availability of Takeout further defines the business as a non-sit-down, high-quality product provider, emphasizing the consumption of the product at home or at events.
• Gluten-Free Options: To ensure inclusivity and cater to modern dietary needs, the menu features dedicated Gluten Free options, including Bourbon Pecan, Key Lime, and Apple Pie.

Features / Highlights

Mollys Pies has several defining features that cement its status as a unique and treasured local business in Brooklyn.

• Artisanal, Homemade Quality: The fundamental highlight is the strict adherence to the simple, fresh-ingredient philosophy, ensuring there are no preservatives in the pies, providing a superior, authentic taste rarely found in mass-produced baked goods in NYC.
• Women-Owned Business: The bakery proudly identifies as women-owned, contributing to the diversity and entrepreneurship within the Park Slope local business community.
• Commitment to Inclusion: Beyond its product, the bakery serves as an actively welcoming space, highlighted as both LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, fostering an environment of respect and safety for all customers.
• Acclaimed Chocolate Cream Pie: Customer feedback specifically calls out the "excellent chocolate cream pie at a reasonable price," indicating a high standard of flavor execution and value that earns enthusiastic repeat business.
• Unique Menu Variety: The focused menu offers both traditional fruit pies and popular cream/nut varieties, ensuring a choice for every palate, from the classic Apple Pie to the rich Salted Honey Carmel.
• Modern Convenience: The use of the Debit cards payment system facilitates quick, modern transactions, streamlining the pickup process for busy New Yorkers.

Contact Information

For general inquiries or to place an advanced order for Mollys Pies, the contact details are as follows. Customers should note the operational model typically requires communication in advance of desired pickup.

Address: 446 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (513) 256-0440

Mobile Phone: +1 513-256-0440

What is Worth Choosing

For any New Yorker seeking an authentic, high-quality baked good, choosing Mollys Pies is a decision to prioritize flavor, freshness, and local entrepreneurship. What makes this establishment worth choosing is its unwavering commitment to its grandmother’s simple recipe and its artisanal approach. In a city where baked goods are often loaded with preservatives for shelf life, Mollys Pies offers a rare product that genuinely tastes homemade, earning high praise from customers who appreciate the superior quality of the Chocolate Cream Pie and the reasonable pricing. The high demand, as reflected in the occasional critique that pies are "always sold out," should be viewed not as a deterrent, but as a strong endorsement of the product's excellence. This reality simply advises the savvy NYC shopper: plan ahead.

Furthermore, supporting Mollys Pies means supporting a women-owned business that actively contributes to the inclusive and diverse cultural fabric of Park Slope. The designation as an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace ensures that every transaction is supportive of a positive community ethos. By embracing the business's unique, order-in-advance model, patrons guarantee themselves a superior dessert—whether it’s for a special event or simply to brighten a weekend—without the disappointment of settling for a lesser, store-bought alternative. Mollys Pies offers a piece of nostalgic, high-quality Americana, baked right here in Brooklyn.

Mollys Pies

446 8th St, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA