Plaza Pizza

- 50 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306

For New Yorkers seeking that nostalgic, quintessential "class reward" slice of pizza, Plaza Pizza, centrally located in Staten Island's New Dorp Plaza, is a local institution. This establishment proudly identifies as a veteran-owned business, offering a straightforward, classic, and comprehensive menu that caters to every craving for traditional Italian-American comfort food. It’s more than just a pizza shop; it’s a full-service Italian restaurant that excels at fast, quick-bite service while providing ample seating for a casual, family-friendly dine-in experience.

Plaza Pizza’s reputation is built on its classic Cheese Pizza, which customers praise for its perfect crust, satisfying sauce, and high-quality cheese. However, the menu extends far beyond the traditional slice, offering a wide array of specialty gourmet pizzas, enormous heroes, baked pasta dishes, and hearty dinners. From their massive Family Sized Calzone and impressive Rib Steak Hero to unique specialty pies like the Lasagna Pizza and Chicken Marsala Pizza, Plaza Pizza ensures that every patron, whether stopping for a quick lunch or ordering a full family dinner, finds something delicious and satisfying.

As a local favorite, Plaza Pizza is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it an excellent spot for solo diners, groups, and families with children. The atmosphere is definitively casual and welcoming, a hallmark of a long-standing neighborhood pizza spot. While the business is dedicated to its veteran-owned status and high food quality, prospective customers should note that the operation is primarily focused on the speed and volume of a classic slice shop, with customer service experiences varying as mentioned in public feedback. Nevertheless, the food itself remains a local standard for classic comfort.

Plaza Pizza is conveniently situated in the commercial heart of the New Dorp neighborhood on Staten Island, making it an easily accessible location for residents and visitors throughout New York City.

Contact Information (Address and Phone):

Address: 50 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306

Phone: (718) 667-7170

Mobile Phone: +1 718-667-7170

The restaurant’s location in a plaza environment, off a major thoroughfare, aids in accessibility. For those driving, Paid street parking is available nearby. The business is also family-friendly, offering High chairs for children, and uniquely, permits Dogs allowed outside for customers utilizing outdoor seating or waiting for pickup.

Plaza Pizza has adapted its service model to meet the diverse needs of modern New York diners, prioritizing convenience alongside traditional sit-down dining.

• Dine-in and Seating: Casual seating is available for both lunch and dinner, offering a relaxed spot for a quick slice or a full meal.
• Takeout Service: The traditional pickup option remains a fast and easy way to get your order.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Comprehensive delivery service is offered, including a no-contact option for maximum safety and convenience.
• Curbside Pickup: Patrons can quickly retrieve their orders without leaving their vehicles.
• Quick Bite Service: Designed for speed, perfect for a fast lunch break or a quick dinner.
• Extensive Catering Options: The menu features large-format and party specials, such as the Party Special 3 Pies 2L Soda, and seasonal packages like the SUPERBOWL SPECIALS, making it ideal for events and gatherings.
• Payments Accepted: Convenience is key, with acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

The unique selling points of Plaza Pizza are its broad menu variety, its commitment to classic favorites, and its dedication to the community.

• Veteran-Owned Business: The establishment proudly identifies its ownership as veteran-led, providing a connection to the local community.
• Classic NYC Cheese Slice: Widely recognized for producing a high-quality, old-school cheese pizza with a popular sauce, perfect for those craving a traditional New York slice.
• Gourmet and Specialty Pizza Selection: A vast selection of unique and creative pies, including the fully loaded Plaza Special Pizza (Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Olives and Extra Cheese), the rich Vodka & Fresh Mozz Pizza, and the family-favorite Lasagna Pizza.
• Extensive Hero and Roll Menu: Offering one of the most comprehensive selections of heroes and rolls in the area, from classic Chicken Parmigiana to specialty items like the Rib Steak Hero and the local favorite Broccoli RABE & Sausage Roll.
• Full Italian Dinner Menu: Serves a complete range of traditional Italian-American dinners (served with pasta or salad), including various chicken, veal, and shrimp dishes such as Chicken Marsala, Veal Parmigiana, and Shrimp Scampi Dinner.
• Diverse Appetizer and Side Offerings: Features all the essential Italian-American sides, including Fried Calamari, Mozzarella Sticks, and unique vegetable sides like Sautéed (RABE) Broccoli RABE.
• Vegetarian and Gluten-Free Options: Caters to dietary needs with clearly marked Vegetarian options and a Gluten Free Cheese Pizza.
• Seasonal and Holiday Specials: Known for creating special menus around holidays and major events, such as the ST. PATRICK'S DAY SPECIALS (featuring Corned Beef) and the SUPERBOWL SPECIALS, adding value for event planning.

Plaza Pizza represents the quintessential Staten Island pizza experience: high-volume, reliable, and deeply rooted in the Italian-American culinary tradition. For New Yorkers, especially those in the borough, it is worth choosing for several compelling reasons centered on value and variety.

Firstly, the sheer variety on the menu ensures that Plaza Pizza can be your one-stop shop for everything from a quick lunch slice to a major dinner or party order. Where else can you grab a classic Cheese Pizza SLICE, a Philly Cheese Steak Supreme Hero, and a full Veal Francese Dinner all in one stop? The ability to order Pizza by the Slice, including specialties like Sicilian and Lasagna slices, is a major advantage for quick, affordable dining.

Secondly, the dedication to classic comfort food is unmatched. Whether you crave a perfectly baked Lasagna, a generous portion of Baked Ziti, or a hearty Chicken Parmigiana Hero, the kitchen consistently delivers the robust, familiar flavors that define New York's neighborhood Italian spots. The Plaza Special Pizza is a must-try for those who want a fully loaded pie that captures the spirit of their entire menu.

Finally, the combination of convenient services—including Delivery, Curbside pickup, and Takeout—with options like Gluten Free Pizza and Vegetarian offerings, makes Plaza Pizza a highly practical choice for busy families, office workers, and diverse dietary needs across Staten Island. While some customer experiences suggest that service can be brisk and extra condiments may incur a charge, the long-standing local popularity and the consistent quality of the classic New York pizza and Italian specialties make Plaza Pizza a reliable and essential part of the New Dorp dining landscape. For a taste of classic Staten Island pizza and Italian comfort food, Plaza Pizza delivers on its promise of an extensive, satisfying menu.

Plaza Pizza

50 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA