Sal & Paul's Pizzeria

- 1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212

For generations of New Yorkers, the pursuit of the perfect slice is a cultural touchstone—a delicious mission that often leads right to the doorstep of venerable neighborhood pizzerias. In Brooklyn, the tradition of authentic, quality, and generous Italian-American fare is alive and well, embodied perfectly by Sal & Paul's Pizzeria. This establishment is more than just a place for a quick bite; it's a neighborhood staple where the aroma of baking dough, rich marinara, and melted mozzarella is a comforting, daily constant. Located on Pitkin Avenue, Sal & Paul's stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of simple, well-executed comfort food, serving everything from classic New York-style slices to hearty Italian entrées and heroes.

The experience at Sal & Paul’s is consistently praised for its commitment to both quality and value. Many long-time customers express a deep loyalty to the restaurant, noting that the generous portions and use of quality ingredients—with some even mentioning imported Italian ingredients—have kept them coming back for years. Whether you're a local resident, a college student, a tourist, or simply someone looking for a great meal, Sal & Paul's delivers a friendly and professional service that makes everyone feel at home. It’s the kind of casual, welcoming spot that caters to all—from large groups to solo diners—making it an essential stop in the Brooklyn food landscape.

The menu is a comprehensive tour of Italian-American comfort food, anchored by their celebrated pizza. They offer a range of sizes, from the personal Baby Deep Dish Pizza to the X-Large 18-inch Cheese Pizza, perfect for sharing. Their slice selection, including the Regular Slice and the thick Sicilian Pizza Slice, ensures that every patron, whether on the move or settling in for a meal, can get a perfect taste of Brooklyn. Beyond pizza, the kitchen excels in crafting delicious, satisfying entrees and heros. From the popular Chicken Parmigiana Hero to the classic Baked Ziti, the focus is on hearty, flavorful food that satisfies.

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria is conveniently situated in the Brownsville neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it a key culinary landmark in the area. The full street address is 1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA. This central location on Pitkin Avenue is easy to access for local residents and visitors alike.

Accessibility is a key priority for Sal & Paul's, ensuring that the warm, casual dining atmosphere is available to everyone. They have a Wheelchair accessible entrance, allowing for smoother entry and exit for all patrons. This commitment to an inclusive environment reinforces its status as a true local hub for families, groups, and individuals. The surrounding area is vibrant, and the pizzeria itself serves as a reliable, quality destination for both lunch and dinner. Whether you are walking in from the neighborhood or planning a dinner with a group, the location is designed to be hassle-free.

For any inquiries, customers can reach the restaurant directly.

The main contact number is (718) 922-0550, a straightforward way to confirm hours, check on an order, or ask any questions about their extensive menu.

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria prides itself on offering flexible and convenient service options to meet the busy schedules of New Yorkers. Whether you prefer to dine-in, grab a quick slice on the go, or have a full meal delivered, they have you covered. Their operational model is built around making their delicious offerings as accessible as possible.

• Dine-in: A welcoming, casual atmosphere perfect for enjoying lunch or dinner. The space is great for groups and is considered an ideal spot for solo dining.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for those who want to grab their order and enjoy it at home or at work.
• Delivery: Convenient delivery service is a popular choice for customers, bringing hot, fresh pizza, pasta, and heroes right to your door.
• Payments: The restaurant accepts major forms of payment, including Credit cards and Debit cards, for an easy transaction process.
• Full Menu Availability: Offers a complete range of appetizers, salads, pizzas, calzones, heroes, and entrées throughout lunch and dinner service times.

The experience at Sal & Paul's Pizzeria is defined by its commitment to classic New York pizza tradition and a broad menu of high-quality comfort food. These highlights ensure that every visit, whether for a quick bite or a full meal, is satisfying and memorable.

• Authentic Pizza Slices and Pies: Featuring classic New York-style thin crust, as well as the thicker, square-cut Sicilian Pizza Slice and the deep-dish Baby Deep Dish Pizza, ensuring a style for every preference.
• Menu Variety: The extensive menu goes well beyond pizza, offering a wide selection of heroes, pasta dishes, and entrees like Chicken Parmigiana and Shrimp Scampi.
• Customer Favorites: Highly popular items include the generously sized EX Large Cheese Pizza, the flavorful Chicken Parmigiana Hero, and the rich, home-style Baked Ziti.
• Appetizers and Sides: Famous for their savory Garlic Knots and the sweet, powdered-sugar-dusted Zeppole, providing perfect starters or desserts.
• Full Hero Selection: A robust selection of hot and cold heroes, including the Philly Cheesesteak Hero, Sausage and Peppers Hero, and the fan-favorite Bacon Cheese Ranch Hero.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, making it a great place Good for kids and suitable for groups of all sizes, from college students to local crowds.
• Specialty Pizza Options: Creative and delicious specialty pizzas like the Buffalo Style Chicken Pizza, Margherita Pizza, and Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza are offered for those looking to try something unique.
• Value and Portions: Customers frequently highlight the excellent value, noting the generous portions of their dishes, ensuring you get a satisfying meal every time.

To place an order, inquire about the menu, or confirm hours of operation, you can reach Sal & Paul's Pizzeria using the following contact details:

Address: 1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA

Phone: (718) 922-0550

When visiting Sal & Paul's Pizzeria, the choice of what to order can be tough, given the array of delicious options. However, based on decades of operation and customer feedback, certain items consistently stand out as must-try options that capture the essence of what this Brooklyn pizzeria does best.

For the Pizza Purist: You must try a classic Regular Pizza Slice or the X-Large 18'' Cheese Pizza. These exemplify the traditional, thin-crust New York style that has made them a neighborhood institution. The balance of sauce and cheese is often highlighted by patrons as being 'just right,' offering that perfect, foldable slice. Alternatively, the Baby Deep Dish Pizza offers a personal-sized, thick-crust experience that is satisfyingly cheesy.

For the Hero Enthusiast: The Chicken Parmigiana Hero is a top-seller for a reason. Its combination of fried chicken cutlets, signature marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese, served on fresh Italian bread, makes for a legendary sandwich. For a different flavor profile, the Philly Cheesesteak Hero or the Shrimp Parmigiana Hero are excellent choices that showcase the quality of their ingredients and cooking techniques.

For a Comfort Meal: Look no further than the pasta dishes. The Baked Ziti is a comforting classic, often lauded for its creamy ricotta and savory meat sauce. Similarly, the Spaghetti With Meatballs is a traditional favorite, offering a hearty, home-style meal.

Must-Order Sides: No trip is complete without their legendary Garlic Knots, which many reviewers rave about as being among the best they've ever had—soft, buttery, and packed with flavor. For a refreshing complement to your meal, try a Slushie, a fan-favorite for its delicious, customizable mix of frozen flavors.

The staff at Sal & Paul's is often commended for their kindness and professional service, which contributes significantly to the overall positive dining experience. Whether you are a local who visits weekly or a newcomer, choosing Sal & Paul's Pizzeria guarantees a meal rooted in authentic Italian-American comfort, served with a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. It is a genuine piece of Brooklyn's culinary heart.

With a history of consistently good food and a commitment to using high-quality ingredients, this establishment is a must-visit for anyone in the New York area seeking an authentic, satisfying, and welcoming dining experience.

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria

1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212, USA