Stellina Bakery & Cafe

- 34 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

For New York residents on Long Island and beyond, Stellina Bakery & Cafe in Oyster Bay has quickly established itself as a charming and essential local destination. More than just a bakery, Stellina is a multifaceted cafe and eatery, offering a delicious piece of Italian culture right in the heart of Nassau County. Founded by the Stellina Hospitality group, which includes world-renowned chef Fabrizio Facchini and Oyster Bay locals, the cafe’s mission is to blend authentic Italian culinary traditions with a warm, inviting, and community-focused Long Island experience.

The establishment is celebrated for its bright, clean, and cozy atmosphere, which patrons consistently find welcoming. The interior features attractive decoration and lighting, creating a perfect spot for casual meet-ups, a quick coffee break, or a relaxed lunch. Customers often describe the vibe as airy and filled with natural light, enhancing the enjoyment of their meal.

Stellina's menu is an expansive testament to Italian-American cafe fare, moving far beyond typical baked goods to offer a comprehensive selection for breakfast, lunch, and all-day dining. While their pastries are a major draw—with the croissant and petit cakes, especially the Tiramisu and Cappuccino creme cake, receiving high praise—the savory options are equally compelling. Guests can enjoy everything from classic American-style breakfast plates and creative Eggs & Savory dishes like the Stellina Omelette ($14.50) and Avocado Toast ($15.00), to gourmet Roman-Style Pizza and full Main courses.

The lunch and dinner offerings showcase a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. The Sandwiches and Paninis are particularly popular, featuring Italian-inspired combinations such as the Parma And Mozza ($16.00) with Prosciutto di Parma, and the Mortadella And Burrata ($18.00) with pistachio pesto. Other savory specialties include homemade Pasta dishes like the Spicy Rigatoni Alla Vodka ($17.50) and Trofie Pesto ($17.00), as well as Main dishes like Chicken Milanese ($24.00) and the Salmon Filet ($28.50). For a quick but satisfying bite, the Bagel ($3.50) and various Quick Bites are available, perfectly paired with one of their numerous coffee options, from a simple Medium Roast ($3.50) to a creamy Latte or Cappuccino (both $4.75).

Stellina Bakery & Cafe is ideally located in the charming downtown area of Oyster Bay, a picturesque town on the North Shore of Long Island, New York. Its convenient placement makes it an easily accessible spot for local residents and visitors driving from neighboring communities.

• Address: 34 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

The cafe is designed to be fully accessible for all members of the community, prioritizing comfort and ease of visit:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Free parking lot and Free street parking options available

This attention to location and accessibility ensures that whether you are stopping by for a morning coffee or planning a relaxed lunch with friends, your visit will be smooth and enjoyable.

Stellina Bakery & Cafe offers a flexible and comprehensive range of services to accommodate every customer’s preference, whether they are looking for a quick stop or a seated meal:

• Dine-in service with seating options for a relaxed cafe experience.
• Takeout and In-store pickup for convenient ordering and collection.
• Delivery services, allowing customers to enjoy their favorite pastries and savory items at home or the office.
• Catering and Custom Cakes services for special events, including wedding and birthday cakes, showcasing the talented pastry chefs.
• Dedicated Breakfast and Lunch dining options, with an all-day menu available.
• Quick visit friendly options for those needing fast service during a busy day.
• Accepts various methods of Payments, including Credit cards and Debit cards.

What truly makes Stellina Bakery & Cafe a standout spot in the New York area is the unique combination of authentic Italian recipes and a diverse menu that caters to contemporary tastes:

• Authentic Roman-Style Pizza: A unique offering featuring delicious, artisanal pizzas with high-quality toppings like the popular Prosciutto & Fig Pizza ($21.00) and the classic Margherita Pizza ($18.00).
• High-Quality Pastries: Renowned for their fresh baked goods, including flaky croissants (like the "delicious" one mentioned in a review), petite cakes, and Italian desserts like Tiramisu.
• Full Cafe Menu: A rare find in a bakery, the menu extends to full meals, including robust Mains, gourmet Burgers (such as the Classic Burger for $22.00), Salads, and a dedicated Kids' Menu (with items like Grilled Cheese for $7.00 and Pasta for $10.00).
• Premium Coffee Offerings: A full range of high-quality Coffee drinks, from Espresso ($3.50) and Americano ($3.75) to specialty lattes and cappuccinos.
• Healthy and Fresh Options: The menu includes a variety of fresh juices (Natalies Orange Juice, Urban Remedy options), healthy wraps (Chicken Caesar Wrap, $17.00), and custom-built salads, catering to health-conscious diners.

For New York residents wishing to place an order, inquire about custom cakes, or check current hours, the following contact details are provided:

• Address: 34 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
• Phone: (516) 402-7439 or +1 516-402-7439

Stellina Bakery & Cafe is unequivocally worth choosing for any New Yorker seeking an elevated cafe experience that seamlessly blends a top-tier bakery with a full-service Italian kitchen. It offers a unique value proposition: the warmth of a local, cozy cafe combined with a menu curated by world-class culinary talent. The quality of their baked goods, particularly their croissants and specialty cakes, is consistently praised, making it a reliable choice for sweet treats.

Beyond the sweets, the strength of their savory menu—highlighted by fresh, well-prepared sandwiches like the Caprese ($14.50) and the delicious Roman-style pizzas—means it serves equally well as a lunch or dinner spot. The ability to grab a quick, fresh baguette sandwich or sit down for a plate of Spicy Rigatoni Alla Vodka makes it versatile. While one review noted a minor initial service delay, the staff's kindness and the overall quality of the food and ambiance were enough to ensure the customer’s desire to return. For Long Island locals, Stellina is a culinary gem that delivers on its mission to bring authentic Italian flavors and warm hospitality to the community.

Stellina Bakery & Cafe

34 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA