Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria

- 34 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725

For discerning New Yorkers in the Commack area, Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria is a culinary landmark that successfully bridges the gap between a casual, excellent local pizza shop and a sophisticated, traditional Italian restaurant. Situated conveniently on Veterans Memorial Highway, Taormina is cherished for its commitment to high-quality, homemade-style Italian food and its exceptional, decades-long dedication to customer service that treats every guest "like family."

Under renewed family co-ownership, the restaurant maintains a phenomenal standard of cuisine, featuring an expansive menu that caters to every taste and dining occasion, from a quick Regular Round Pizza 18" ($24.50) slice to an extravagant main course. The dining experience is a unique pleasure; upon entry, one is greeted by the small, bustling Pizza station, but the rear dining room reveals a "hidden gem" of a space—a Cozy area styled with chandeliers, booths, and tables that evokes an old-school, fine-dining ambiance, yet remains inherently Casual and welcoming.

The culinary offerings span the full spectrum of Italian cuisine. Beyond the perfectly crisp-crusted pizzas, the kitchen excels in seafood, chicken, and veal dishes. Patrons rave about the Shrimp Oreganata ($33.50), with its plump, soft shrimp and delicious sauce, and the incredibly tender chicken and veal cuts. The menu also features robust steak options, such as the NY Strip Steak Pizzaiola ($45.00). This dedication to phenomenal, high-quality, fresh ingredients, coupled with staff members like Karen and Leo who have served the community for over 20 years, solidifies Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria as a must-visit dining destination in Suffolk County.

Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria is ideally located at 34 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA. This highly accessible location is situated within a large shopping center, maximizing convenience for residents across Commack and the surrounding Long Island towns. The ease of reaching the restaurant via a major road makes it a practical choice for both scheduled dinners and spur-of-the-moment takeout or delivery orders.

A key feature of the location is the ample provision for vehicle traffic. Patrons will find an abundance of parking options, including a generous Free parking lot, readily available Free street parking, and dedicated On-site parking. This eliminates the stress of finding a spot, which is a major advantage for busy New York diners.

Furthermore, Taormina is dedicated to ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests, offering comprehensive accessibility features. The facility provides a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. These details ensure that the superb food and welcoming atmosphere are available to every member of the community.

Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria provides an array of services that cater to the modern needs of its Long Island clientele, blending traditional table service with modern convenience:

• Full-Service Dining: Offering full Dine-in and Table service for both Lunch and Dinner, with comfortable Seating in its attractive, cozy back dining room.
• Convenient Off-Premise Options: Provides efficient Takeout, Delivery, and No-contact delivery options, making it easy to enjoy the food at home or work.
• Specialized Request Accommodations: The staff and ownership are known for their willingness to make off-menu requests, offering to "make anything you ask for even if it’s not on the menu" provided they have the necessary ingredients.
• Catering Services: Offers full Catering for events and large gatherings, extending their acclaimed menu—from pizza to full Italian specialties—to parties across the region.
• Family and Kids' Provisions: The restaurant is designated as Good for kids and provides High chairs and a specialized Children's Menu, featuring popular items like Kids Chicken Parmigiana ($18.00).

The experience at Taormina is elevated by several key features and offerings that distinguish it as a top-tier Commack restaurant:

• Dual Atmosphere and Ambiance: While offering the speed and convenience of a front-end pizzeria, the back dining area is a "hidden gem" with a beautiful, fine-dining-like aesthetic, offering an Atmosphere that is both Casual and Cozy.
• Exceptional Dessert and Beverages: Known for offering a Great dessert selection. The establishment provides a full bar selection, including Alcohol, Beer, and Wine, ensuring a perfect pairing for any dish.
• Unique Culinary Secrets: Customers rave about the house secret dressing—the "champagne" dressing—for the crisp, fresh salads, which is described as being "like an addiction."
• Dietary Considerations: The menu features numerous Vegetarian options and offers a wide range of proteins and pasta dishes, making it suitable for various diets and ideal for Groups and Solo dining.
• Modern Conveniences: Patrons benefit from Fast service, Wi-Fi, a clean Restroom, and the option for Late-night food, typical of a professional New York establishment.
• Staff Dedication: The commitment of long-term staff members and the hands-on involvement of family co-owner Angelo ensure service is friendly, personal, and highly attentive—a major highlight noted in customer feedback.

For those in the New York region looking to enjoy the fine Italian cuisine and pizza at Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria, please use the following contact details:

Address: 34 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA
Phone: (631) 499-6900
Mobile Phone: +1 631-499-6900

Choosing Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria is a decision to embrace old-school Italian quality and service in a modern, welcoming Commack setting. What sets this establishment apart and makes it truly worth choosing is the unparalleled quality and authenticity of its food, paired with a personal, family-centric approach to hospitality.

The food quality is described by customers as "phenomenal all around," with fresh ingredients making the difference. The pizza, exemplified by the white slice being lauded as "the best I ever had" with a "crust crisp to perfection," stands as a testament to their dedication to classic techniques. Their Pizza Specialties, such as the Crispino Pizza ($33.50), are widely considered excellent.

However, the value extends far beyond the pizza oven. The menu is loaded with impressive, well-executed main courses and pasta dishes. Specialties like Shrimp & Clams ($32.95), Veal Sorrentino ($35.50), and the unique Stuffed Zucchini Flowers (often available upon request) showcase the kitchen’s capability to handle complex, traditional Italian cuisine. Portions are "more than plentiful," often including a salad or pasta side, providing exceptional value for the price.

The customer service is perhaps the biggest differentiator. The staff's longevity and personal investment—like server Karen, who knows customers and takes care of them "like family," and co-owner Angelo's visible presence—creates a level of comfort that is often missed in modern restaurants. Small details, such as cutting pizza slices in half for small hands and keeping the pizza "not too hot" for children, highlight the genuine care. This attentive service, the high-quality food that tastes homemade, and the beautiful, yet approachable, dining environment ensure that a visit to Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria is always a delightful and memorable experience for any New Yorker in search of a great Italian meal.

Taormina Ristorante & Pizzeria

34 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725, USA