Tony + Benny's Introduce
For New York residents and visitors venturing near the Hudson Valley, especially those enjoying a day of shopping, finding a satisfying meal is a priority. Look no further than **Tony + Benny's**, a premier **pizza restaurant** that also excels as an authentic **Italian restaurant**, **pasta shop**, and **salad shop**. Conveniently situated in **Central Valley, NY**, Tony + Benny's offers a delicious escape with a menu that goes far beyond a simple slice of cheese.
Emphasizing **comfort food** and **quick bites**, this establishment has become a popular destination for **lunch** and **dinner**. It's known for its friendly, **casual atmosphere** and its ability to serve up satisfying meals with **fast service**, making it a fantastic choice whether you're dining solo, with family, or with a group of friends. They are especially popular with **tourists** visiting the area, thanks to their location and quality offerings.
The core of the menu is undoubtedly the pizza, available by the **slice or pie**. Customers can choose from several styles, including the classic **NEO - CHEESE**, the elevated **NEO DELUXE**, or the heartier **PAN PIZZA**. For those seeking something truly filling, the **STUFFED PIZZA** is a must-try. Beyond the pies, the menu is a celebration of Italian-American staples, ensuring there's something to please every palate, from savory pasta dishes to fresh, crisp salads.
---Tony + Benny's boasts a highly advantageous and **conveniently located** spot at **498 Red Apple Ct Ste FC10, Central Valley, NY 10917, USA**. This specific address places the restaurant right inside the bustling **Woodbury Common outlet mall** food court. This makes it a perfect pit stop for shoppers who've worked up an appetite browsing the many surrounding shops.
Accessibility is a key priority here, ensuring that all guests can enjoy a meal with ease. The establishment offers excellent provisions for guests with mobility needs, including a **wheelchair accessible entrance**, **wheelchair accessible parking lot**, a **wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **wheelchair accessible seating**. This commitment to accessibility means everyone can feel welcome and comfortable.
For parking, patrons will find both **free street parking** options nearby, as well as **on-site parking** provided by the mall, which greatly simplifies a visit.
---Tony + Benny's provides a variety of service options to fit any schedule, whether you want to linger and enjoy the atmosphere or grab a meal on the move:
- **Dine-in:** Guests can enjoy their meal at the restaurant's seating area, which includes the food court's extensive table space.
- **Takeout:** Quick and easy pickup service is available for those who want to enjoy their food elsewhere.
- **Delivery:** For ultimate convenience, the restaurant offers delivery service directly to customers.
- **Outdoor seating:** Patrons have the option to dine in the fresh air, perfect during pleasant weather.
- **Counter service:** The service model is built around efficiency, with counter service being the primary way to place and receive orders.
- **Catering (Implied):** While not explicitly stated, the variety of whole pies and meals suggests options for larger groups or events.
- **Lunch and Dinner Service:** The full menu is available to satisfy cravings throughout the day.
Tony + Benny's stands out for several reasons, blending quality food with excellent service and a comfortable setting:
- **Fast Service:** A major highlight is the commitment to **fast service**, which is especially important in a high-traffic location like a food court, ensuring minimal waiting time.
- **Casual Atmosphere:** The vibe is relaxed and **casual**, making it a perfect spot to unwind after shopping.
- **Popularity:** It is a highly **popular** choice for both **lunch** and **dinner**, as well as for **solo dining**.
- **Family-Friendly Amenities:** The restaurant is **good for kids** and provides **high chairs**, along with a specialized **Kids' menu**, making it ideal for families.
- **Diverse Offerings:** Beyond the pizza, they offer a diverse range of items including **Coffee**, satisfying **Comfort food**, **Quick bites**, and a fresh **Salad bar**.
- **Payment Flexibility:** They accept various modern payment methods, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.
- **Dedicated Restroom:** Guests have access to a clean **Restroom** facility.
To reach out or place an order, here is the essential contact information for Tony + Benny's:
- **Address:** 498 Red Apple Ct Ste FC10, Central Valley, NY 10917, USA
- **Phone:** (845) 928-3162
Choosing Tony + Benny's means opting for variety, speed, and genuine Italian-American taste in a highly convenient location. The menu’s breadth is one of its most appealing features. While the pizza is a star—with options like the **Flatbread** and the **Twice As Nice** deals—the Italian specialties offer equally compelling choices. You can dive into a generous portion of **MEAT LASAGNA** or customize your plate with **Spaghetti** or **Baked Ziti/Mac & Cheese**, with or without protein additions like meatballs or other meats.
The **STROMBOLI'S/Calzones** are a fantastic choice for a portable, satisfying meal, and the menu even features a selection of **HOT SANDWICHES**. For lighter fare, the **SALADS**—available in both side and dinner sizes, with or without protein—are a fresh option. The presence of a dedicated **Salad bar** further underscores their commitment to offering healthy choices alongside their more indulgent comfort food options.
Don't overlook the popular **Value meals**, which are excellent for budget-conscious diners or those wanting a pre-packaged deal. Options like the **#2 NEO SLICE** or the **Whole Pie Deal** are perfect for a quick, fulfilling lunch or dinner. The dessert section, featuring **COOKIES** and other options, provides the perfect sweet ending to any meal.
Beyond the food, the combination of **quick and smiling service**, a family-friendly environment with a **casual atmosphere**, and highly accessible facilities makes Tony + Benny's a standout choice. It delivers a quality dining experience, proving you don't have to sacrifice taste or convenience when dining near a major New York-area shopping destination.
Tony + Benny's Menu
PIZZA
Slice or pie
- NEO - CHEESE
- NEO - ONE TOPPING PLUS
- NEO DELUXE
- PAN PIZZA - CHEESE
- PAN PIZZA - TWO TOPPING PLUS (one topping plus as well)
- STUFFED PIZZA
- Xtra Cheese
- Flatbread
- Twice As Nice
STROMBOLI'S/Calzones
- All Flavors
- HOT SANDWICHES
PASTA & ITALIAN SPECIALTIES
- Spaghetti
- Spaghetti and protein (meat)
- Pasta - Baked Ziti/Mac & Cheese
- Baked Ziti/Mac & cheese and Protien
- MEAT LASAGNA
SIDE ORDERS
- MEATBALLS
- GARLIC STICK
- SIDE ORDERS -Pasta/No Protein
- SIDE ORDERS -Meat
- CHICKEN WINGS Each at least 3
- Side Chicken Strips 3 on side salad
SALADS
- SIDE SALADS (NON PROTEIN)
- SIDE SALADS (PROTEIN/MEAT)
- DINNER SALADS --( NO PROTEIN)
- DINNER SALADS --(PROTEIN/MEAT)
DESSERTS
- COOKIES
- Chips
BEVERAGES
- MED.
- LG.
- COFFEE
- BOTTLED WATER
- JUICE'S
- BOTTLED TEAS / PUNCH/Soda
- ICED TEA MED.
- ICED TEA LG.
- Monin Beverages Reg
- Monin Beverages Large
- Upcharge Large FTn on Value Meal
- Upcharge to Monin Reg on Value Meal
- Upcharge to monin LG on Value Meal
- upcharge to Bottled Soda
- upcharge to bottled tea
- upcharge to water
- upcharge to coffee
- upcharge to juice
- charge to milk
Value meals
- #1 Stromboli
- #2 NEO SLICE
- #3 Pan
- Create your own meal
- Whole Pie Deal
Tony + Benny's Details
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Salad bar
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
Crowd
- Tourists
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free street parking
- On-site parking
Tony + Benny's Photos










Tony + Benny's Location
Tony + Benny's
498 Red Apple Ct Ste FC10, Central Valley, NY 10917, USA
Tony + Benny's Reviews
pricedmozzarella stickscashierpiefood courttoddlerchicken parm sandwichshopping centercupgarlic knots
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Conveniently located within Woodbury common outlet mall.. right inside the food court . So many other shops and restaurants around .. kids decided to eat pizza and garlic bread and we bought it here . Service was good 👍 quick and smiling . Lots of tables to sit and eat but it gets really crowded . We had to wait 10 mins to get a table !The garlic bread was soft and tasted good . It went well with marinara sauce . The flavor on it was really good . Pizza was good too. Brooklyn style . 6$ for a slice ! Not bad . Pizza and garlic bread price was ok but all others were expensive . About 18$ for a wrap etc. Mall pricing ! Good experience overall. 4 stars !
June 19 · Raj SThe garlic knot was dry and didn’t have a good taste. The pepperoni pizza was better than the plain. The plain wasn’t that good. It reminded me of HS lunch pizza. It was SUPER EXPENSIVE and not worth it.
July 04 · Emma RogersWorst customer service in the entire world! We spent a lot of money for food for our small children. We asked for a cup of water. The young lady at the restaurant refused to give a cup of sink water to my young toddler. When we walked away, she laughed with her coworker. Very sad!
October 20 · Tonya RogersPlain slices were $5.45 each. They were reheated in a specialized oven. Not terrible, not great, but not bad, for pizza from a mall food court.Cashier seemed to have some issues with English, service was prompt, but not perfect.We haven't been to this outlet mall in many years, and the updated food court is very attractive with lots of food options.Plenty of shared seating areas. We were here on Wednesday in Sept after 6 PM, and it was very quiet.
September 11 · Agile DodgerStopped by to have lunch with my family today. The food was ok, it was served quickly and the staff was friendly. It was quite easy to find a seat in the food court. The pricing is normal
December 27 · Dimitris Karyamis
More restaurants near me
Flours Pasta & Bakeshop4.0 (49 reviews)11 New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Chai Hing4.0 (76 reviews)5B New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
LC Craft Beer Brittle5.0 (1 reviews)8 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Lucas Candies4.0 (72 reviews)6 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Asi y Asado4.0 (79 reviews)75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Mari's Cafe3.0 (3 reviews)75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Treats by Esther0.0 (0 reviews)4402 Admirals Cove Blvd, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Riverside Scoops5.0 (37 reviews)1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Harbors Cafe4.0 (85 reviews)1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA
Lin's Family Chinese Restaurant4.0 (86 reviews)368 New Hempstead Rd, New City, NY 10956, USA
Dannyu2019s Pizza & Deli4.0 (56 reviews)368 New Hempstead Rd #1, New City, NY 10956, USA
Hilltop Deli & Pizza3.0 (122 reviews)368 New Hempstead Rd #1, New City, NY 10956, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Subway3.0 (76 reviews)
Xcellent Soul Food4.0 (804 reviews)
Malibu Farm4.0 (1119 reviews)
Best Sicily Bottega4.0 (270 reviews)
JJ Restaurant & Cuchifritos4.0 (656 reviews)
Yummy Dips4.0 (71 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
How Brunch Restaurants Use Seasonal Produce for Innovative Dishes
How Food Courts Are Evolving in Modern Malls: Trends, Technology & Dining
What Is Meadoscaping? A Low-Maintenance Trend for 2025
Exploring Bagel Shops That Combine Classic and Gourmet Flavors
Discovering French Restaurants That Emphasize Seasonal and Local Ingredients: A Culinary Journey
How Fast Casual Restaurants Are Integrating Technology to Personalize Customer Experience
