Tony's Pier

- 1 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Welcome to Tony's Pier, a beloved and quintessential New York seafood institution situated right on the water in the charming and nautical enclave of City Island in the Bronx. For locals across the five boroughs and visitors alike, Tony's Pier represents a classic New York casual dining experience, where the fresh sea air meets a vast, satisfying menu of both fried and broiled ocean delights. This is more than just a restaurant; it’s a destination for families, groups, and solo diners looking for a relaxed atmosphere, quick service, and genuinely good, no-frills seafood. Located at the end of the island, it offers some of the best waterfront views in the city, making every meal a scenic occasion.

Tony’s Pier is renowned for its generous portions, its commitment to serving food promptly, and its lively, casual vibe. Whether you are craving a basket of perfectly fried shrimp or a decadent broiled lobster tail, this establishment has been a staple for New Yorkers seeking that classic “seafood shack” feel without leaving the city limits. Its longevity and consistent popularity underscore its status as a true Bronx classic that has been satisfying appetites since before Hurricane Sandy and continues to thrive today.

The experience at Tony's Pier is one of simplicity and flavor. Food is often served cafeteria-style in paper baskets, emphasizing the casual, eat-and-enjoy nature of the restaurant. While there can be a line during peak hours, especially on warm summer weekends, the quick service means that the wait to place your order is usually fast-moving, and food delivery is speedy. For anyone traveling to City Island, Tony's Pier is consistently on the must-visit list for a memorable, authentically New York seafood experience.

Location and Accessibility

Tony's Pier is conveniently located at the very end of City Island Avenue, situated directly on the waterfront, providing guests with fantastic, picturesque views of the water and the surrounding area, including the Long Island Sound and the Throggs Neck Bridge. The location is an integral part of the restaurant’s appeal, transforming a casual meal into a scenic outing.

The address is 1 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA.

Accessibility is a notable feature of Tony's Pier, making it an excellent choice for a wide range of patrons.

Accessibility Features Include:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot (Free on-site parking is available)
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

Parking is made convenient with both a free parking lot and free street parking available. This is a significant advantage in a popular, high-traffic destination like City Island, though the lot can fill up quickly during busy weekend hours. For dining, guests have the choice of indoor, cafeteria-style seating or covered outdoor seating, both of which offer views of the water. The atmosphere is consistently casual, welcoming groups, families, college students, and tourists alike.

Services Offered

Tony's Pier prides itself on offering a straightforward, satisfying, and speedy dining experience. The primary services focus on ensuring a relaxed and accessible visit for all customers.

• Dine-in and Takeout Service
• Outdoor Seating: Enjoy your meal with beautiful waterfront views on the large pier.
• Onsite Bar: Offers a great selection of beer, wine, cocktails, and hard liquor, including their famously strong and well-regarded frozen drinks like the Henny Colada and Pina Colada.
• Fast Service: Known for quickly moving the ordering line and rapid food preparation, even during peak hours.
• Dining Options: Available for Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, and Dessert.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: Good for kids, with high chairs and a selection of items on the menu that appeal to younger palates (e.g., cheeseburgers, hot dogs, chicken tenders).
• Casual Atmosphere: The setting is cozy, casual, and historical, fitting the City Island vibe.
• Payment Options: Accepts debit cards for convenient payment.
• Late-Night Food: Offers food service well into the evening for late-night cravings.
• Cuisine: Specializes in fresh, no-frills seafood—primarily fried, broiled, and steamed dishes, along with American classics like BBQ, burgers, and wings.

Features / Highlights

Tony's Pier is characterized by several key features that solidify its status as a must-visit destination in the Bronx for seafood lovers.

• Iconic City Island Waterfront Location: Situated right on the water at Belden Point, offering spectacular views of the Long Island Sound and the Throggs Neck Bridge from its expansive outdoor seating area.
• Extensive Seafood Menu: A wide array of fresh seafood available, emphasizing both classic fried options—like Fried Shrimp, Calamari, and Flounder—and savory broiled dishes such as Snow Crab Legs, Lobster, Red Snapper, and Salmon.
• Famous Frozen Cocktails: Patrons frequently highlight the quality and strength of their frozen drinks, with the Pina Colada and Henny Colada being fan favorites.
• Broiled Combination Platters: Ideal for trying a variety of items, with options like Combo #3 featuring 1 Broiled Lobster Tail, 4 Broiled Shrimp, Scallops, and Calamari, or Seafood Pasta #4 which includes Snow Crab Legs, a Broiled Lobster Tail, Shrimp, and Scallops.
• Mini Doughnuts for Dessert: A unique and highly praised feature is the selection of hot, fresh, uniquely sugared mini doughnuts, available in a variety of creative flavors from sweet and nutty (e.g., "Coco Loco," "Pbj") to savory (e.g., "Rosemary Road"), along with traditional options and dipping sauces. This offers a memorable way to end the meal.
• Broad Menu Appeal: In addition to seafood, the menu includes comfort food options like BBQ Ribs, BBQ Chicken, Burgers, Hot Dogs, and classics like Chicken Parmesan, ensuring there is something for everyone in the group.
• Local Bronx Staple: With its history and consistent quality, Tony's Pier is considered a true “Bronx classic” and a local specialty, a testament to its place in New York City's casual dining culture.

Contact Information

For those planning a visit to Tony's Pier, here is the essential contact and location information:

Address: 1 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 885-1424

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Tony's Pier, the main draw is undeniably the seafood, which is served in a comforting, straightforward style. While the menu is extensive, a few items and categories stand out as "must-try" choices, reflecting the local sentiment and the restaurant's specialties.

The Fried Seafood is consistently praised, often hailed by reviewers as some of the best on City Island. For a satisfying, crispy, and flavorful meal, you can’t go wrong with the Fried Shrimp or the comprehensive Seafood Combo. This section of the menu fully embraces the spirit of a classic seaside fried platter. For those who enjoy a richer dish, the Fried Lobster Tails are a decadent, generously portioned favorite.

For patrons preferring a lighter, less fried option, the Broiled Dinners offer excellent choices. The Snow Crab Legs and the whole or Broiled Lobster Tails are excellent, tender options. To sample a bit of everything, the Broiled Combinations offer great value. Specifically, the Seafood Pasta #4, combining Snow Crab Legs, a Broiled Lobster Tail, Shrimp, and Scallops, is a substantial and highly recommended platter. All broiled dinners come served with a choice of French Fries or Baked Potato.

Beyond the main course, the Frozen Cocktails are an absolute highlight of the Tony's Pier experience. The Pina Colada and its various spiked renditions, like the Henny Colada, are famous for their taste and potency, making them the perfect accompaniment to a waterfront meal, especially on a warm day.

Finally, make sure to save room for dessert. The restaurant's hot, fresh Mini Doughnuts are a unique local specialty that transcends the typical seafood dessert offering. With a huge variety of unique sugar coatings—from the fruity Speckled Strawberry and exotic House of Cardamom to the indulgent Cacaoboy—and various dipping sauces like Beer Caramel and Nutella, these mini doughnuts provide a sweet and unexpected finale to your waterfront feast. The combination of classic New York seafood, stunning views, and inventive desserts solidifies Tony's Pier as a highly rewarding choice for New Yorkers seeking a fulfilling and authentic casual dining experience in the Bronx.

Tony's Pier

1 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA