The Black Whale

- 279 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Discovering a true New York gem often means venturing beyond the well-trodden Manhattan paths. For those in the know, City Island in the Bronx offers a unique, small-town coastal feel, and at its heart is a legendary dining spot: The Black Whale. Established in 1961, this is more than just an American restaurant and bar; it's a piece of local history, a gathering place, and a destination for exceptional food and a memorable atmosphere.

From its origins as a bohemian-focused dessert shop founded by self-proclaimed bohemian Richie DePierro, The Black Whale has evolved while retaining its unique, eclectic soul. It's a place where you can comfortably enjoy a hearty, New American meal, sip a handcrafted cocktail, and feel a million miles away from the city bustle—all without leaving the five boroughs. The Black Whale has historically been a foundational element for the unique bohemian population of City Island, having sponsored events like poetry readings and plays in the 1960s, creating a mood reminiscent of Greenwich Village happenings. Today, it continues to welcome both locals and tourists with a cozy, casual, and historic atmosphere that’s perfect for any occasion, from solo dining to a large family get-together.

The menu at The Black Whale is designed for the sophisticated New York palate, offering a diverse array of comfort food, seafood, and classic American dishes with a refined twist. Whether you're craving a robust entree, a light salad, or one of their famous desserts, there's a satisfying option to fit your mood. This establishment proudly represents the best of Bronx dining, offering high-quality food in an environment that is both welcoming and stylishly historic.

The commitment to quality is evident across the menu. For appetizers, you can begin with fresh Steamed New Zealand Mussels ($18.00), Pan Seared Maryland Crab Cakes ($19.00), or the Grilled Shrimp & Guacamole ($23.00). If you are in the mood for a lighter start, consider the Beet Salad with oranges, goat cheese, and pistachios ($15.00) or the fresh Burrata with tomatoes, roasted peppers, olives, and balsamic glaze ($12.00).

The main courses showcase a balanced mix of land and sea. Seafood lovers can indulge in the Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna with ginger orange sauce ($29.00), Grilled Salmon With Mango Salsa ($29.00), or the classic Broiled Shrimp Scampi ($28.00). From the land, patrons can enjoy a Rib Eye Steak ($38.00), Grilled NY Sirloin Steak ($32.00), or a comforting, homemade Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf ($24.00). Pasta selections are also a highlight, including the signature The Starving Artist with orecchiette pasta, spinach, white beans, tomatoes and fresh mozzarella ($19.00), and the rich Fettuccine with shrimp, mussels and crabmeat in a spicy marinara sauce ($34.00).

No visit to The Black Whale is complete without exploring their legendary dessert options. The restaurant first started as a dessert shop in 1961 and continues to live up to that heritage. Options range from the decadent Hot Fudge Fondue ($18.00) and Crème Brulée ($9.00) to towering Ice Cream Sundaes, such as the classic Whale Of Sundae ($10.00). Their selection of Unique Potions like the Root Beer Float ($8.50) and Traditional Milkshake ($9.00) are perfect for a nostalgic treat.

In addition to the main dining room, the restaurant also features a bar onsite with a great selection of beer, cocktails, hard liquor, and wine. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual, cozy, and historic, with maritime artifacts and unique decor adding to its personality. The staff is known for their fast, accommodating, and friendly service, making every diner feel like a valued guest.

Whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor exploring the unique charm of the Bronx, The Black Whale offers a dining experience that perfectly captures the eclectic spirit of City Island. Its enduring appeal lies in the combination of its rich history, diverse and delicious menu, and a genuinely welcoming environment. This iconic spot has rightly earned its reputation as a Bronx culinary destination.

For New Yorkers seeking a dining location that is off the beaten path but still boasts an incredible atmosphere and menu, The Black Whale should be at the top of your list. It’s a versatile spot perfect for a lunch meeting, a romantic dinner, or a celebration with a large group.

***

Location and Accessibility

The Black Whale is located on the main thoroughfare of the quaint and maritime City Island, an island neighborhood in the East Bronx that feels like a New England fishing village. This easily accessible location, just a short drive from the rest of the Bronx and Westchester County, makes it a convenient escape from the intensity of Manhattan.

Address:

279 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

The restaurant is committed to welcoming all guests, offering Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible seating. Parking is typically available via Free street parking. Its location also offers a great opportunity to explore the local shops and scenic streets of City Island before or after your meal.

***

Services Offered

The Black Whale provides a comprehensive range of services to accommodate all dining preferences:

• Dine-in and Table Service
• Outdoor Seating in a Unique Backyard Garden/Patio
• Delivery and Takeout options
• Catering services for private events
• Reservations Accepted (Brunch reservations recommended)
• Special Event hosting with facilities to accommodate up to 50 guests, and a perfect dining room for smaller private events of up to 20 people.
• Full Bar service with Cocktails, Hard liquor, Beer, and Wine

***

Features / Highlights

The Black Whale stands out from other dining options in the Bronx and New York area due to its exceptional features:

• Historic Establishment: Founded in 1961, the restaurant has a deep connection to City Island's bohemian and artistic past.
• Unique Outdoor Seating: A sprawling, tree-shaded patio in the back, described by customers as 'whimsically decorated' and 'unique,' offers a perfect, relaxed setting for sipping a craft cocktail away from the city noise. One customer noted, "The outside seating area is so unique."
• Great Dessert Selection: With its origins as a dessert shop, The Black Whale remains a top destination for sweets, including homemade Apple Crisp and towering Ice Cream Sundaes.
• Eclectic New American Menu: The menu offers a perfect blend of comfort food (like Homemade Meatloaf and the Black Whale Burger), fresh seafood (including Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna and Grilled Salmon), and healthy/vegetarian options (such as the Quinoa Salad and Veggie Burger).
• Cozy and Historic Atmosphere: The interior features rotating art exhibitions, stained glass, and maritime artifacts, creating a romantic, casual, and distinctly historic vibe that is beloved by families, groups, and tourists.
• Fast and Accommodating Service: Noted for its fast service and accommodating staff, even for large, last-minute requests.
• Award Recognition: The Black Whale has been nominated for 'Best of the Bronx' in categories such as Best All-American / Continental Restaurant.

***

Contact Information

To plan your visit or make a reservation, please use the contact information below:

Address: 279 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 885-3657

***

What is Worth Choosing

The Black Whale is the ideal choice for New Yorkers seeking a memorable dining experience that delivers on taste, atmosphere, and history. What is truly worth choosing here is the combination of their diverse, crowd-pleasing New American and seafood menu, and the escape offered by the historic, charming setting. From the moment you walk in, you’ll be treated to a warm, welcoming environment that stands in wonderful contrast to the typical New York dining scene.

Whether it’s a romantic date night in a cozy dining room, a relaxing lunch on the tree-shaded patio, or simply stopping by for one of their impressive, historic desserts, The Black Whale promises a delightful experience. Choose this City Island institution for its great cocktails and wine list, the high quality of its comfort food classics like the Homemade Meatloaf, the fresh seafood dishes, and the commitment to a genuinely hospitable, neighborhood atmosphere.

The Black Whale

279 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA