Sammy's Fish Box

- 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Sammy's Fish Box is a world-famous seafood institution located on City Island in the Bronx, a true gem for New Yorkers seeking a memorable and generously portioned seafood experience. Since its humble beginnings as a small snack bar in 1966, it has grown into a massive, full-service restaurant capable of seating hundreds of guests and preparing well over a million meals annually. This longevity and scale are testaments to a simple, effective formula: serving the best quality, freshest food in generous portions.

For decades, Sammy's Fish Box has been a beacon for seafood lovers from all five boroughs and beyond. Locals know it as the go-to destination for a truly satisfying meal where quantity meets uncompromising quality. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a classic New York dining tradition on the scenic City Island, where the atmosphere is as cozy and historic as the dishes are legendary.

The restaurant's vast menu and commitment to large, satisfying servings have cemented its status as a must-visit dining spot. Whether you're planning a family celebration, a romantic dinner, or a casual lunch, Sammy's Fish Box offers a friendly, casual, and energetic environment perfect for any occasion.

Sammy's Fish Box is strategically located in the Bronx at the picturesque nautical haven of City Island. Its exact location is at 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA. This unique spot provides a delightful escape from the city hustle, offering a waterfront-adjacent dining experience without leaving New York City limits.

For ease of access, especially for New York drivers, the restaurant provides excellent amenities. Visitors can take advantage of the free parking lot, free street parking, and convenient valet parking services. For guests requiring accessibility, Sammy's is fully equipped with a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring a comfortable experience for all. The location is a favorite for locals, but also draws in tourists, making it a lively and well-known spot on the island.

Sammy's Fish Box prides itself on offering a wide range of services to accommodate every guest, from quick bites to large catered events.

• Dining Options: Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert are all available with full table service and comfortable seating.
• Order and Service Flexibility: Guests can choose from Dine-in, Takeout, No-contact delivery, and standard Delivery services. Outdoor seating is also available, perfect for enjoying the City Island air.
• Event Planning: The restaurant offers both a Private dining room and full Catering services for larger groups and special occasions.
• Atmosphere and Experience: The venue features a lively Bar onsite, making it a great spot for happy hour. The atmosphere is noted for being Casual, Cozy, and even Romantic, suitable for a Family-friendly crowd, Groups, Locals, and Tourists.
• Beverage Selection: They offer a full bar including Alcohol, Beer, a wide variety of Cocktails, Hard liquor, and a Great wine list.
• Family Amenities: The restaurant is Good for kids, offering a dedicated Kids' menu and High chairs.
• Reservations: While walk-ins are welcome, Brunch reservations are recommended and Dinner reservations are recommended, as there is often a wait, highlighting the restaurant’s popularity.

The commitment to quality, quantity, and service has earned Sammy's Fish Box multiple Best of the Bronx nominations, solidifying its place as an iconic New York establishment.

• World-Famous Feast Platters: Known for their gigantic, value-packed feasts such as the Italian Feast ($209.95), the Seafood & BBQ Feast ($209.95), and the luxurious The Crab & Lobster Feast For Two ($259.95). These platters exemplify the restaurant’s promise of generous portions.
• Legendary Crab & Lobster: Customers consistently rave about the perfectly cooked and seasoned crab, with the Jumbo Snow Crab Legs (2 Clusters) ($69.95) and Alaskan King Crab Legs ($240.00) being signature highlights.
• Extensive Surf & Turf Options: For those who crave both sea and land, the Surf & Turf at Sammy's menu offers exciting pairings like Snow Crab Legs & Filet Mignon ($112.95), Lobster Tail & N.Y. Shell Steak ($65.95), and Jumbo Fried Shrimp & Filet Mignon ($65.95).
• Signature Baked Fish: A classic highlight is the Sammy’s Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper (Head On) ($49.95), a beautifully prepared dish that showcases their dedication to fresh fish.
• Award-Nominated Dishes: The restaurant has been nominated for "Best Seafood Restaurant," "Best Clam Chowder," and "Best Lobster Roll" in Best of the Bronx awards, confirming the excellence of its menu staples.
• House-Made Bread and Sides: Patrons often mention the complimentary bread basket, which includes cornbread, toasted garlic bread, and a seeded round loaf, alongside sides of pickled veggies, and yellow rice included with many entrees.
• Atmosphere and Service: Renowned for its friendly and professional staff, which contributes to the restaurant receiving a "Best Wait Service / Staff" nomination. The atmosphere is perfect for both casual dining and special celebrations, including the added touch of celebratory ice cream and a song for birthdays.

For reservations, questions, or to place an order, you can contact Sammy's Fish Box directly.

Address: 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: (718) 885-0920

If you are visiting Sammy's Fish Box, the real value lies in the items that showcase their commitment to fresh seafood and their philosophy of abundant, comforting portions. New York diners looking for the most bang for their buck and the most famous dishes should consider the following:

The Feast Platters are arguably the most iconic offering, particularly for groups of two or more. Choosing the The Crab & Lobster Feast For Two ($259.95) offers an ultimate experience with a generous variety of high-end seafood.

Among the individual entrees, the Jumbo Stuffed Shrimp W/Crabmeat ($65.95) is a highly recommended signature dish, known for its rich flavor and size. The Jumbo Snow Crab Legs are another customer favorite, ensuring a deeply satisfying, classic seafood experience.

For a lighter, yet equally flavorful option, the Sammy’s Famous Baked Whole Red Snapper (Head On) ($49.95) is an exceptional choice, perfectly prepared to highlight the freshness of the fish. Additionally, you cannot go wrong with the highly-rated Traditional New England Split Open Lobster Roll ($42.95), a popular nominee for "Best Lobster Roll."

Finally, be sure to ask about the renowned Manhattan or **New England Clam Chowder ($9.95)**. Winning nominations for "Best Clam Chowder," these soups are an essential way to start your magnificent City Island seafood feast.

Sammy's Fish Box

41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464, USA