16 Handles Introduce
For residents and visitors of the New York metropolitan area seeking a diverse and customizable sweet treat experience, **16 Handles** in Garden City stands as a premier destination for frozen desserts. Combining the popularity of a classic **Ice cream shop** with the healthier appeal of a **Frozen yogurt shop**, this Nassau Boulevard location offers an expansive menu that goes far beyond simple soft serve. It is a local haven for indulgence, featuring everything from traditional creamy flavors to innovative **Smoothies** and decadent **Fro-yo Milkshakes**.
The core philosophy of 16 Handles is centered around variety and the freedom to create a personalized treat. This commitment is evident in the constantly rotating and extensive selection of **Soft Serve** flavors, which includes both frozen yogurt and specialized ice cream options. Whether you are craving the tartness of a classic Eurotart, the richness of a Chocolate Shake, or a complex blend like the Tahitian Vanilla, 16 Handles has positioned itself as the go-to spot on Long Island for frozen dessert enthusiasts looking for quality and choice. Its wide product range ensures that every member of the family or friend group can find the perfect cool treat to satisfy their cravings.
16 Handles is conveniently located at **3 Nassau Blvd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA**. Situated in the heart of Garden City, its Nassau Boulevard address provides easy access for New York residents across Long Island looking for a refreshing stop.
The shop is designed to be welcoming and accessible to all members of the community, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**. This commitment ensures that everyone can easily enjoy the vast array of frozen yogurts, ice creams, and other treats available. This location on a major thoroughfare makes it a simple destination for quick trips or planned dessert runs in the Garden City area.
16 Handles understands the need for convenience in the fast-paced New York lifestyle, offering a variety of flexible service options to ensure you can enjoy their treats anytime, anywhere.
The available services designed for customer ease include:
- Delivery: Offering the ultimate convenience of having your chosen soft serve, smoothie, or milkshake brought directly to your home or office.
- Takeout: Ideal for customers who want to quickly select their treat in-store and enjoy it on the go.
- In-store pickup: A seamless service for online or phone orders, allowing you to bypass the queue for a swift collection of your customized dessert.
The store is structured to accommodate various modern payment methods, simplifying the checkout process for a quick and pleasant transaction. This focus on multiple, easy service methods ensures that whether you are planning a delivery or a quick stop, your experience at 16 Handles is hassle-free.
The true appeal of 16 Handles lies in the remarkable diversity and constant innovation within its menu, catering to nearly every flavor preference and dietary need.
- Extensive Soft Serve Selection: The foundation of the shop is its wide array of Soft Serve flavors, including classic frozen yogurts and a dynamic rotation of new products. Recent additions include **Cookie Dough Ice Cream (NEW!)**, **Cookies & Cream Ice Cream (NEW!)**, and the seasonal favorite **OH MY, PUMPKIN PIE**.
- Unique and Trendy Flavors: The menu features inventive options like **THE ALL NIGHTER COLD BREW GELATO(NEW!)** and **ARRIBA COFFEE**, alongside familiar favorites such as **Peanut Butter Perfection** and **Birthday Cake Gf**.
- Dietary Inclusivity: 16 Handles offers several options for customers with specific dietary requirements, including:
- Vegan (V) and Gluten-Free (Gf) options, such as **Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet V Gf** and **Oatly Mocha (NEW!)**.
- **NSA (No Sugar Added)** options, like the **NSA RIPE RASPBERRY**.
- Complete Dessert Categories: Beyond soft serve, the menu features:
- Rich Smoothies: Options like **Acai Elixir**, **Surf's Up**, and the vegetable-infused **Oh Kale Yeah!**
- Classic Fro-yo Milkshakes: Including **Strawberry Shake**, **Chocolate Shake**, and the popular **Cookies & Cream Shake (New!)**.
- Edible Cookie Dough: Offering the universally loved **Classic Chocolate Chip** in a safe, ready-to-eat format.
- Delivery Service Perks: Highlighting their dedication to off-site service, they offer **DashPass Exclusive Item!** deals, such as the **Tahitian Vanilla + 2 FREE Toppings**, enhancing the value for delivery customers.
To place an order or inquire about current flavor offerings at the Garden City 16 Handles location, please use the following contact details:
- Address: 3 Nassau Blvd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
- Phone: (516) 500-9440
- Mobile Phone: +1 516-500-9440
For customers in the New York area visiting 16 Handles, the best experience comes from sampling the innovative and specialized options that define the brand.
A must-try for any frozen dessert enthusiast is the shop's rotating array of new and unique **Soft Serve** flavors. We highly recommend exploring the new ice cream options, such as the decadent **Cookie Dough Ice Cream (NEW!)** or the seasonal blend of **AMERICAN APPLE PIE (NEW!)**. For coffee lovers, the **THE ALL NIGHTER COLD BREW GELATO(NEW!)** offers a sophisticated, caffeinated indulgence.
Beyond the soft serve, the **Edible Cookie Dough** is a signature treat, offering a safe way to enjoy the classic **Classic Chocolate Chip** flavor in a cup. This provides a rich, satisfying alternative to the frozen products.
For those seeking a nutritious and refreshing treat, the **Smoothies** section is exceptional. While the **Acai Elixir** is a popular choice, the unique inclusion of the **Oh Kale Yeah!** smoothie demonstrates a commitment to offering more than just sweet options.
Finally, for an authentic taste of the core product, sampling one of the **Vegan** or **Gluten-Free** soft serve options, such as the **Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet V Gf** or the newest **Oatly Vanilla (NEW!)**, confirms that 16 Handles maintains quality and deliciousness across all dietary categories. The unparalleled variety and dedication to flavor innovation truly make 16 Handles a stand-out dessert spot in the Garden City area.
16 Handles Ice cream
Edible Cookie Dough
- Classic Chocolate Chip $8.95
Like licking the spoon after whipping up your favorite chocolate chip cookie dough recipe. Egg-free and made with heat-treated flour.
DashPass Exclusive Item!
- Tahitian Vanilla + 2 FREE Toppings $7.95
Smoothies
- Acai Elixir $6.95
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and acai berries with guarana
- Surf's Up $6.95
Made with strawberries and pineapple
- Bff $6.95
Made with strawberries and bananas
- Brr Berry $6.95
Made with strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries
- Oh Kale Yeah! $6.95
Made with pineapple, bananas, kale and spinach
- Tropic Thunder $6.95
Made with pineapple and mango
Fro-yo Milkshakes
- Strawberry Shake $6.95
Made with fresh strawberries
- Vanilla Shake $6.95
Made with premium vanilla syrup
- Cookies & Cream Shake (New!) $6.95
Made with crushed Oreos
- Chocolate Shake $6.95
Made with Ghiradelli chocolate sauce
Soft Serve
- Peanut Butter Perfection $5.95
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Our smooth and creamy Peanut Butter Perfection is made with natural, roasted peanut butter
- Birthday Cake Gf $7.95
Our fro-yo take on a classic cake batter ice cream
- THE ALL NIGHTER COLD BREW GELATO(NEW!) $7.95
NEW from 16 Handles x HBO Max: "The All Nighter" Cold Brew Gelato is made with real cold brew, and it's the perfect treat to enjoy while watching The Sex Lives of College Girls, new series streaming 11/18 on HBO Max!
- Cookie Dough Ice Cream (NEW!) $7.95
NEW Cookie Dough Ice Cream is the perfect indulgence. We fold real cookies and chocolate chips into 16 Handles' all natural, soft serve ice cream. Treat yo'self!
- Oatly Mocha (NEW!) $7.95
NEW from 16 Handles x Oatly! Oatmilk soft serve with notes of chocolate and coffee—a flavor match made in heaven. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
- Cookies & Cream Ice Cream(NEW!) $5.95
NEW: Delicious, silky sweet cream folded full with real OREO® cookies make what might be our most delicious ice cream yet
- Graham Cracker $5.95
Enjoy our sweet, cinnamon packed graham cracker frozen yogurt. A fan-favorite with real graham cracker pieces swirled in
- Eurotart $7.95
The new classic. Our latest tart fro-yo recipe is our very own, made with all natural ingredients that perfectly balance tart and sweet.
- Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet V Gf $7.95
This classic superfruit sorbet has been on our menu since Day 1
- NSA RIPE RASPBERRY $7.95
Indulge in the taste of real raspberries by the spoonful, swirled to perfection in this no sugar added fro-yo flavor
- Oatly Vanilla(NEW!) $7.95
A fruity, springtime twist on 16 Handles x Oatly made notes of vanilla. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
- So Fresh Mango $7.95
Our signature mango sorbet flavored with fresh mangoes from India
- Chocolicious $7.95
Classic and creamy chocolate frozen yogurt made with real cocoa
- OH MY, PUMPKIN PIE $7.95
A seasonal classic made with real pumpkin, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, nutmeg, and fresh baked graham cookies. You're sure to fall in love!
- AMERICAN APPLE PIE (NEW!) $7.95
An American classic in fro-yo form
- ARRIBA COFFEE $7.95
Rich, dark roast coffee frozen yogurt made with 100% Arabica coffee beans
- Tahitian Vanilla $7.95
Our Artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real Tahitian vanilla
16 Handles Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Payments
- Credit cards
16 Handles Photos










16 Handles Location
16 Handles Reviews
flavorsdoorsmachinesownershipwateryprices
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1When my husband and I arrived around 4:30pm it was closed. We checked the hours online and it said it was open at 4pm so we called the store and they said they opened at 5pm. No problem!! However when we went back at 5pm the place was filthy!!! Like if it had not been clean in a few day or the night prior. The machines were a mess!! The garbage was overflowing and the floors look like they have not been swept or mop for days. We asked to speak with a manger but there was only one employee there who I’m assuming didn’t care cause when we told her she just stared at us and said it did nothing. This is really unacceptable at a work place that is serving something edible. I don’t think I’d ever go back there after that. And I don’t recommend anyone else to go there. 16 Handles you gotta do better, smh.
March 07 · Lashonda WheelerThis place as disgusting!Upon entry, the doors and windows were completely covered in dirt, they were foggy and gross. I would have turned right around, but my kids were already excited for ice cream, so I was stuck going in.First of all, for a place called 16 handles, about 4 of the handles worked. They had watery ice cream that had pans underneath covered in drippings.The toppings section was even worse. The gummy items were all stuck together, and the “wet” items like booba and chocolate were melted and stuck together.At checkout, the employee was sitting there on his phone the whole time, and only got up to ring us up.Overall, it wasn’t that great before the new ownership, but now it is somehow worse now.
July 31 · Emily MacalusoClean good service but not many flavors available
September 10 · Mizu ShUsed to love coming here, especially for the Graham Cracker flavored frozen yogurt. Hasn’t been the same as of late, however. The place is more messier than I remember it being and newer flavors haven’t really been impressive, especially with the Cookie Dough flavor managing to somehow taste bitter. I couldn’t even get through it and ended up throwing it out, which really pained me, since frozen yogurt from here used to be such a huge treat for me. I don’t think I’ll be returning much anymore.
August 16 · AnonymousAll the flavors were soupy. To be fair, it was hot out. But, also to be fair, that's when people want cool stuff like ice cream and frozen yogurt - not soup. Place was clean and plenty of toppings. Service was one person, but she was friendly.
June 08 · cavac@4ctech .com
More restaurants near me

616 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

512 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

580 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

504 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

506 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

691 Hempstead Turnpike, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA

Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

719 Hempstead Turnpike, Franklin Square, NY 11010, USA

456 Hempstead Turnpike Unite 6A, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

480 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

472 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA

420 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites


![[Takeout & Delivery ONLY] Xi'an Famous Foods 西安名吃@PICNIC | Times Square](https://img.restaurantedroop.com/d36/2509/2054033999613331_150x150.webp)



Top Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts





