Arthur Avenue

- 210 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570

Welcome to a slice of authentic Italian-American culinary tradition right here in Westchester County. Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza & Catering in Pleasantville, NY, is a local favorite that brings the rich, rustic flavors of a classic Italian kitchen to its community. Known for its commitment to high-quality ingredients and speedy, friendly service, this establishment has carved out a niche as a must-visit destination for pizza lovers and those craving genuine Italian comfort food.

The restaurant's core identity revolves around its specialty: spectacular wood-fired pizzas. These personal-sized pies are cooked in an 800-degree Fahrenheit oven, ensuring a perfectly crispy crust and allowing for a flavorful meal to be served in minutes. But Arthur Avenue is more than just pizza; it's a full-service Italian-American experience, offering everything from hearty appetizers and classic sandwiches to decadent desserts and comprehensive catering services. The atmosphere is consistently described as warm, family-oriented, and casual, complemented by a rustic decor that pays homage to its deep-rooted Italian heritage. Whether you are a local or just passing through the greater New York area, Arthur Avenue offers a delightful and authentic dining experience that resonates with a love for great food and tradition. The sounds of classic Italian-American music, such as Sinatra, often fill the air, creating a cozy and nostalgic backdrop for your meal.

Location and Accessibility

Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza & Catering is conveniently situated in the heart of Pleasantville, making it easily accessible for residents and visitors throughout Westchester County and the New York metropolitan area. Its precise location is:

210 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA

The restaurant is committed to ensuring a welcoming environment for all patrons. It offers a variety of accessibility features, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating, making it a comfortable and convenient choice for everyone. For those arriving by car, the establishment provides a free parking lot as well as free street parking, eliminating one of the usual hassles of dining out. This accessibility, combined with the casual, local-friendly atmosphere, makes Arthur Avenue an ideal spot for a quick lunch, a relaxed dinner, or even a solo meal.

Services Offered

Arthur Avenue provides a comprehensive suite of dining and catering services to meet various customer needs.

The core services include:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy, Italian-American ambience with seating available for lunch and dinner.
• Takeout: Convenient pickup service for those on the go.
• Delivery: Offering home delivery, including a no-contact option for a safe experience.
• Catering: Extensive catering options are available for events and parties, with customizable trays of main dishes, salads, and more. They even offer a Wood Fire Pizza Oven Trailer available for booking private events.
• Online Ordering: Accepts various forms of payment, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, for easy and quick transactions.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making planning for dinner an easy process.

A key highlight of their offering is the menu variety, covering a full Italian-American experience:

• Specialty Wood Fired Personal Pizza: The main attraction, featuring pies like the classic Cheese Pizza, Basil Pizza, Buffalo Pizza, and the highly-praised specialty, The Bee Sting Pizza. Pies are typically 10" personal size (4 slices).
• Starters, Sides & Salads: Featuring classic appetizers such as 2 Rice Balls ($15.95), Our Homemade Mozzarella Sticks ($12.00), Burrata - Appetizer ($15.95), and the Side Of Mama's Meatballs ($17.95). Salad options include House Salad and Caesar Salad.
• Sandwiches & Archived Entrees: A selection of substantial heroes and sandwiches, like the Chicken Parm ($15.00) and Meatball Parm ($15.00), along with rotating weekly specials. Archived entrees have included classic dishes like Borgatti's Cheese Raviolis.
• Desserts & Drinks: Authentic Italian desserts, including N.Y. Cannoli ($6.00) and Tiramisu Single Serving ($8.00), alongside a variety of Italian and American sodas, coffee, and water.
• Alcohol Service: Offers beer and wine, complementing the authentic Italian dining experience.
• Take Home Frozen Pies: Convenient options like the Take Home Frozen Cheese Pizza ($11.99) and Take Home, Frozen Tomato Pizza ($10.99) are available for customers to enjoy at home later.

Features / Highlights

Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza distinguishes itself with several key features that draw a loyal local crowd:

• Authentic Wood-Fired Pizza: The primary specialty. Pizzas are cooked in an ultra-hot, 800-degree wood-fired oven, resulting in a thin, crispy, fire-crisped crust—a style often compared to Roman-style pizza. The quick cooking time, typically under 10 minutes, contributes to its "Fast service" highlight.
• The Bee Sting Pizza: A signature and highly-recommended menu item, featuring Hot Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano Cheese, San Marzano Pizza Sauce, and topped with Mike's Hot Honey. This combination of sweet and spicy flavors is a major customer favorite.
• High-Quality Ingredients: The establishment prides itself on using premium components, including dough sourced directly from Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, San Marzano tomatoes for the in-house sauce, and the freshest local mozzarella.
• Cozy and Authentic Ambiance: Customers frequently praise the "Great Italian-American ambience with Sinatra playing in the background," describing the spot as a "cozy little spot with a warm vibe." The rustic decor enhances the experience, reflecting a deep-rooted Italian heritage.
• Comfort Food Focus: In addition to pizza, the menu excels at classic Italian-American comfort food, including "Mama's Meatballs" and eggplant dishes, which have received excellent reviews.
• Local and Family-Oriented: The atmosphere is casual, welcoming, and good for kids, appealing strongly to a local crowd seeking a family-friendly dining option.

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout, catering inquiries, or general information, you can reach Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza & Catering using the following details:

• Address: 210 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA
• Phone: (914) 741-2828

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone new to Arthur Avenue or a seasoned local looking for a recommendation, there are a few items that consistently stand out and encapsulate the restaurant’s best offerings.

The clear champion is the Specialty Wood Fired Personal Pizza selection. If you are adventurous, the Bee Sting Pizza ($18.00) is a mandatory choice. Its unique flavor profile—the spicy Soppressata balanced by the sweet 'Mike's Hot Honey'—is what customers hail as superb and distinct. It provides a crisp, thin-crust experience that some reviewers have compared favorably to authentic Roman-style pizza. For a more classic yet equally authentic experience, the simple Basil Pizza ($15.00) showcases the quality of their San Marzano sauce and fresh mozzarella.

Beyond the pies, don't miss out on the side of Mama's Meatballs ($17.95). Italian-American restaurants are often judged by their meatballs, and these have received rave reviews, demonstrating the quality of the non-pizza entrees. For starters, the 2 Rice Balls ($15.95) are a popular comfort food selection. For those seeking something indulgent and easy to take home, the Take Home Frozen Cheese Pizza ($11.99) is a perfect solution for a quick, quality meal on another day.

The entire experience at Arthur Avenue is worth choosing—from the moment you step in and catch the amazing aroma of the wood-fired oven to the moment you take the last bite of a New York cannoli. It is an honest, warm, and high-quality Italian-American establishment that lives up to its name and reputation in Westchester County.

Arthur Avenue

210 Marble Ave, Pleasantville, NY 10570, USA