Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn: Authentic Italian Dining in Staten Island, NY

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Introduce

For New Yorkers craving a taste of authentic Italian-American cuisine with a touch of Brooklyn flair, look no further than **Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn**. This beloved establishment brings its rich, flavorful cooking traditions to Staten Island, offering a warm and inviting setting for families, groups, and solo diners alike. Known for serving up generous portions of classic comfort food, exceptional service, and a vibrant atmosphere, Aunt Butchie's has cemented its status as a must-visit Italian restaurant in the New York metropolitan area.

The menu is a celebration of Italian favorites, ranging from hearty **pasta dishes** and traditional **Artisan Pies** to expertly prepared **meat, veal, and seafood entrées**. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, a lively dinner, or need **catering** for a special event, Aunt Butchie's provides a truly memorable dining experience that resonates with the rich culinary heritage of New York's Italian communities. It’s a place where every dish feels like a homecoming, made with care and served with genuine hospitality.

Location and Accessibility for New York Residents

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn is conveniently situated in the heart of **Staten Island**, making it easily accessible for residents across the New York region. Located at **4864 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA**, the restaurant is positioned to serve the local community and is worth the trip for anyone in the greater NYC area seeking high-quality Italian food.

Accessibility is a key priority, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment features a **wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating**, eliminating barriers for guests with mobility needs. For those driving in from other boroughs, the availability of a **free, on-site parking lot** is a significant convenience, a true rarity in the bustling New York dining scene. This focus on easy access and ample parking makes planning a visit straightforward and stress-free, whether you're meeting friends or bringing the entire family.

Comprehensive Services Offered

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn is a full-service restaurant that goes beyond simple dine-in service, offering a variety of convenient options to meet the needs of today's busy New Yorker. Their dedication to flexibility and service ensures you can enjoy their exceptional food wherever you are.

**Dine-in:** Enjoy the full, cozy, and trendy atmosphere with table service. **Dinner reservations are recommended** and accepted to guarantee your seating.
**Takeout and Curbside Pickup:** Easily place an order and pick up your meal to enjoy at home or the office.
**Delivery and No-Contact Delivery:** Have your favorite Italian dishes brought right to your door with flexible delivery options.
**Catering:** The restaurant offers full catering services, perfect for local New York events, parties, or office gatherings, bringing the taste of Aunt Butchie's to your occasion.
**Dining Options:** Available for **Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert**, ensuring they cover all your mealtime needs.
**Table Service:** Dedicated staff provides traditional table service during your dine-in experience.
**Bar Service:** A **bar onsite** offers a full range of alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks.

Key Features and Highlights

What truly sets Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn apart are the unique features and commitment to quality that enhance the overall dining experience. From the moment you walk in, you’ll notice the blend of exceptional service and high-quality offerings.

**Exceptional Beverage Program:** The restaurant boasts a **Great Wine List**, features excellent **Cocktails** and hard liquor, and serves a quality selection of **Beer**. They also serve **Great Coffee** for a perfect ending to your meal.
**Great Dessert Selection:** The dessert menu is a highlight, featuring specialties like the famous **Caramel Cone, dubbed "Oprah's Favorite Dessert,"** and fun choices like the **Nutella Pizza (For Two)** and **Deep Fried Cheesecake**.
**Fast Service:** Customers often praise the **Fast Service**, a great plus for a busy New York crowd during lunch or dinner rush.
**Live Music:** Enjoy an elevated dining experience with the addition of **Live Music**, contributing to the cozy and trendy atmosphere.
**Atmosphere and Crowd:** The ambiance is described as **Casual, Cozy, and Trendy**, attracting a diverse crowd including **Families, Groups, and Loyal Locals**. It's known for being **Family-friendly** and is **Good for Kids**, offering **High Chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' Menu** with classics like Chicken Fingers and Grilled Cheese.
**Serves Local Specialty:** The menu features local and regional specialty items, showcasing an authentic taste of Italian-American cuisine.
**Flexible Payments:** Accepts all major **Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments** for a quick checkout process.
**Dog-Friendly Patio:** **Dogs are allowed outside**, a bonus for pet owners looking to enjoy a meal on the patio.

Contact and Location Information

Planning your visit or placing an order is easy with the provided contact information. For the fastest service regarding reservations or immediate questions, a phone call is always recommended.

Address: 4864 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA

Phone: (718) 227-0002

Why Choose Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn?

For New Yorkers who appreciate quality, tradition, and value, Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn stands out as a top-tier choice for Italian dining. The menu is robust, featuring an impressive variety of authentic dishes, from comforting **Sunday Sauce** and rich **Rigatoni Bolognese** to sophisticated seafood options like **Linguini Seafood Fra Diavolo** and a delicate **Filet of Sole Limoncello**.

The culinary strength is evident in the details. The restaurant offers generous portions of **Comfort Food** and delicious options for a **Quick Bite** or **Small Plates**. Vegetarians will appreciate options like **Eggplant Parmigiana** and a variety of meat-free pasta dishes. For those looking for a lighter meal, the diverse **Salads** menu, including the **Strawberry Arugula Salad** and the **Honey Bleu Cheese Chopped Salad**, offers fresh alternatives.

The dedication to making guests feel at home is a consistent highlight. Customer reviews frequently praise the **amazing food, wonderful servers,** and dishes like the "perfect" **Fried Calamari** and the famously "crispy and light" **Fried Zucchini**. This reputation for both quality cuisine and attentive service is what keeps local New Yorkers returning again and again. Whether you are celebrating a special occasion, looking for a great spot for **Solo Dining**, or simply seeking the best Italian comfort food in the region, Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn delivers an authentic, satisfying, and consistently excellent dining experience right here in Staten Island, NY.

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Food & drink

Vegetarian Entrées
Eggplant Parmigiana $29.00
Layers of fried eggplant, fresh Mozzarella and marinara sauce.

Artisan Pies - White Pie
Sausage & Rabe Pizza $22.00
Sautéed sausage and broccoli rabe with garlic, red pepper, Gorgonzola and Ricotta cheese.
Ricotta Pizza $19.50
Fresh Ricotta, fresh Mozzarella, Romano and Parmigiano cheese topped with olive oil and basil.
Pesto Pizza $22.00
Creamy pesto, fresh Mozzarella, sliced fresh tomato, grilled chicken topped with olive oil.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $22.00
Chicken, buffalo sauce, butter, fresh buffalo Mozzarella and Gorgonzola cheese.

Meat Entrées
Filet Mignon $49.00
Portabella mushrooms in a port wine sauce and served with mashed potatoes.

Veal Entrées
Veal Parmigiana $34.00
With fresh Mozzarella, marinara sauce.
Veal Marsala $34.00
Onion, prosciutto, marsala wine and mushrooms.
Veal Milanese $34.00
Fried veal cutlet over a bed of arugula topped with bruschetta and Mozzarella.

Children's Menu
Chicken Fingers $18.00
With French fries.
Grilled Cheese $16.50
With French fries.

Specialty Desserts
Caramel Cone "Oprah's Favorite Dessert" $10.50
Almond Caramel Cone with a cheesecake Mascarpone Filling
Brownie Sundae $13.00
Served warm and topped with Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup
Deep Fried Cheesecake $16.00
NY Cheesecake served in a pastry & deep fried with cinnamon & sugar topped with whipped cream & caramel syrup
Chip & Dip (For Two) $16.00
Crushed Cannoli Shells topped with powdered sugar, served with cannoli cream
Nutella Pizza (For Two) $15.00
Topped with Nutella, Strawberries, Bananas and Whipped Cream
Chipwich Sandwich $13.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich filled with Vanilla ice cream topped with whipped cream and chocolate syrup
Crumb Cake Sundae $13.00
served warm topped with Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & caramel syrup

Risotto
Carciofo Risotto $30.00
Artichoke risotto with peas, onions and Parmigano Reggiano cheese.

Pasta
Linguini Seafood Fra Diavolo $40.00
Spicy marinara with shrimp, calamari, clams and mussels. Not available in half portion size.
Farfalle Zucchini $28.00
Sliced Zucchini, Butter, Vegetable Stock, White Wine, Romano Cheese, Touch of Cream, and Topped with Parmigiana Reggiano Cheese.
Rigatoni Eggplant $26.00
Italian eggplant, fresh Mozzarella, marinara sauce.
Orecchiette With Sausage & Broccoli Rabe $30.00
Chopped sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic, olive oil and red pepper.
Lobster Ravioli $29.00
Topped with shrimp in a pink sauce.
Linguini & Mussels $29.00
Mussels in choice of white or red sauce.
Gnocchi Sorrentina $28.00
Homemade potato gnocchi in marinara sauce with Mozzarella.
Cappellini Arrabiata With Shrimp $25.00
Angel hair pasta in a spicy marinara sauce with shrimp.
Spaghetti Al Forno $31.00
Baked spaghetti with shrimp and prosciutto in a cream cognac sauce. Not available in half portion size.
Rigatoni Aunt Butchies $29.00
Chop meat, prosciutto, onion, peas, heavy cream, and tomato sauce.
Linguini Carbonara $29.00
Spaghetti with fresh garlic, onions, Parmigiano Reggiano, pancetta
Sunday Sauce $30.00
Rigatoni pasta with sausage and meatballs.
Penne Alla Vodka $24.00
Smoked pancetta, onion, vodka, cream and tomato sauce.
Peas & Macaroni $26.00
Ditalini pasta with prosciutto, onions, peas, vegetable stock and grated Romano cheese.
Rigatoni Bolognese $31.00
Meat Sauce with a blend of Finochio, Carrots, Celery, Tomato, Romano Cheese and topped with Bashemel
Penne Escarole $28.00
Sautéed escarole and toasted seasoned breadcrumbs.
Cappellini Arugula $25.00
Marinara sauce, fresh Mozzarella and arugula.
Homemade Cheese Ravioli $19.00
Ravioli with marinara sauce.
Farfalle Pesto Grilled Chicken $30.00
Basil, heavy cream, garlic, Reggiano cheese and grilled chicken.
Linguini & Clam $29.00
North east little neck clams in choice of white or red sauce.

Chicken Entrées
Chicken Marsala $29.00
Onion, prosciutto, marsala wine and mushrooms.
Grilled Chicken With Broccoli Rabe $31.00
Grilled chicken with sautéed broccoli rabe.
Chicken Sorrentina $30.00
Chicken, prosciutto, fried eggplant, Mozzarella in a white wince, tomato sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana $29.00
With fresh Mozzarella, marinara sauce.
Chicken Limoncello $29.00
In a lemon, butter, white wine sauce.
Chicken Rollatini $31.00
Boneless chicken breast stuffed with Ricotta, prosciutto and Mozzarella cheese in a Marsala sauce.

Seafood Entrées
Filet Of Sole Limoncello $35.00
In a lemon, butter white wine sauce, touch of limoncello.
Shrimp Parmigiana $35.00
With fresh Mozzarella, marinara sauce.
Shrimp Oreganata $35.00
Garlic, white wine, vegetable stock, topped with breadcrumbs.
Salmon $35.00
Over a bed of baby arugula, shitake mushrooms and balsamic reduction.

Soups
Pasta Fagioli $15.50
Italian beans soup with celery, garlic, onion and a touch of tomato.
Chicken Tortellini $15.50
All white meat chicken with celery, carrots and cheese tortellini.

Appetizers
Zuppa Di Clams $19.00
Gluten-free. Choice of white wine sauce or spicy tomato sauce.
Fried Calamari $22.00
Lightly flowered zucchini.
Frutti Di Mare $23.00
Gluten-free. Calamari, pulpo, scungilli, shrimp, celery, sweet cherry peppers and onions with a fresh lemon dressing.
Mozzarella Spiedini Rosso $17.50
Signature dishes. Fried Mozzarella and bread in a lemon, white wine, touch of marinara.
Eggplant Caponata $12.00
Our famous eggplant caponata, served with crustini bread.
Hot Antipasto $18.00
Baked clam, shrimp, eggplant rollatini, carozza.
Italian Eggrolls $16.50
Signature dishes. Fried egg-rolls with sausage and broccoli rabe served with a side of garlic demy sauce.
Fried Zucchini $16.50
Lightly floured zucchini.
Stuffed Meat Ball $16.50
Beef, breadcrumb, Romano cheese, stuffed with Ricotta and Mozzarella and baked with tomato sauce.
Cold Antipasto $20.00
Gluten-free. Hot and sweet soppressata, olives, roasted peppers, Reggiano, Provolone cheese, Mozzarella and tomato.
Baked Clams $19.00
Littlenecks stuffed with breadcrumbs, Romano cheese, lemon, olive oil, and white wine.
Old World Tripe $21.00
Beef tripe served in a spicy tomato sauce with peas and potatoes.
Eggplant Rollatini $16.50
Lightly fried eggplant filled with ricotta & mozzarella, topped with marinara sauce
Our Famous Fritto Misto $22.00
Signature dishes. Golden fried calamari, zucchini, shrimp and hot cherry peppers.
Mozzarella Di Buffalo $19.00
Served over arugula. Topped with bruschetta and olive oil.
Zuppa Di Mussels $19.00
Gluten-free. Choice of white wine sauce or spicy tomato sauce.
Mozzarella Spiedini Bianca $17.50
Signature dishes. Fried Mozzarella and bread with lemon, capers, white wine.

Salads
Escarole Salad $16.50
Escarole, olive oil, garlic, lemon, Romano and Reggiano cheese with a hint of truffle oil.
Buffalo Calamari Salad $23.00
Iceberg wedge, shaved carrots, red cabbage, and homemade Bleu cheese dressing.
Pear Salad $17.00
Gluten-free. Romaine, mesculine, pears, Reggiano cheese, onions, almonds and finnocchio with honey lemon garlic dressing.
Italian House Salad $15.00
Gluten-free. Romaine, arugula, escarole, mesculine, red onion, grated Romano cheese, tomato, and Italian dressing.
Honey Bleu Cheese Chopped Salad $18.00
Gluten-free. Iceberg and romaine lettuce, heirloom tomato, bacon, red cabbage, craisins, walnuts, crumbled Bleu cheese, homemade Bleu cheese dressing with a touch of honey.
Strawberry Arugula Salad $20.00
Gluten-free. Baby arugula, fresh strawberries, crumbled goat cheese, topped with oney balsamic dressing.
Pete's Salad $17.00
Gluten-free. Romaine, mixed greens, almonds, craisins, Gorgonzola cheese, finocchio and sliced apples with honey lemon garlic dressing.
Caesar Salad $15.00
Romaine lettuce, croutons, Romano cheese and homemade Caesar dressing (Contains anchovies).

Artisan Pies - Red Pie
Meatball Pizza $19.50
Our famous meat balls with tomato sauce, Romano and Parmigiano cheese topped with olive oil and basil.
Sausage Parm Pizza $19.50
Tomato sauce, Romano and Parmigiano cheese topped with sausage, olive oil and basil.
Margherita Pizza $19.00
Tomato sauce, fresh Mozzarella, Romano and Parmigano cheese, topped with olive oil and basil.
Eggplant Pizza $19.50
Sautéed eggplant, tomato sauce, Romano and Parmigiano cheese and basil.
Vodka Pizza $19.50
Smoked pancetta, onion, vodka, tomato sauce, heavy cream and Romano cheese.
Pepperoni Pizza $19.50
Tomato sauce, Romano and Parmigiano cheese topped with pepperoni, olive oil and basil.

Pork Entrées
Pork Chop Scarpariello $34.00
With hot and sweet vinegar peppers, mushrooms, garlic, white wine and butter.

Sandwiches
12. Panella Special Sandwich $18.00
Chickpea Fritters with Ricotta, Parmigiana and Fresh Mozzarella.
3. Grilled Veggie Sandwich $18.00
Assorted grilled vegetables, crumbled goat cheese, and topped with olive oil.
10. Fried Chicken Sandwich With Roasted Peppers $17.50
Served with fresh Mozzarella and Herb Mayo.
2. Buffalo Mozzarella Sandwich $18.00
Sliced tomato, fresh basil, and olive oil. Topped with Honey Balsamic.
7. Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $17.50
With fresh Mozzarella.
10. Grilled Chicken Sandwich With Roasted Peppers $17.50
Served with fresh Mozzarella and Herb Mayo.
16. Grilled Chicken With Prosciutto Sandwich $19.00
With Arugula, fresh Mozzarella, and Pesto.
13. Soppressata Sandwich $20.00
Sweet Soppressata with arugula, shaved reggiano, truffle oil and lemon garlic dressing.
1. Italian Tuna Sandwich $17.50
Olive oil based tuna, mixed with chopped olives, sweet peppers, tomato, onions, celery, lemon, touch of balsamic. Topped with lettuce and sliced tomato.
9. Fried Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich $19.00
Served with Fresh Garlic and topped with Gorgonzola Cheese.
4. Eggpplant Parmigiana Sandwich $17.00
With fresh Mozzarella.
16. Fried Chicken With Prosciutto Sandwich $19.00
With Arugula, fresh Mozzarella, and Pesto.
9. Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich $19.00
Served with Fresh Garlic and topped with Gorgonzola Cheese.
15. Grilled Chicken With Bruschetta Sandwich $19.00
With fresh Mozzarella and Honey Balsamic.
11. Italian Combo Sandwich $20.00
Italian Cold Cuts, Provolone Cheese, and Bruschetta.
6. Veal Parmigiana Sandwich $22.00
With fresh Mozzarella.
15. Fried Chicken With Bruschetta Sandwich $19.00
With fresh Mozzarella and Honey Balsamic.
14. Shrimp Parmigiana Sandwich $20.00
With fresh Mozzarella.
8. Grilled Chicken Finocchio Sandwich $18.00
Sliced Finocchio, shaved Parmigiana Reggiano, Touch of Truffle Oil, and Lemon Garlic Dressing.
5. Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich $17.50
With fresh Mozzarella.
18. Prosciutto, Arugula, And Fig Sandwich $19.00
Prosciutto, figs, Goat cheese and Honey Balsamic.
8. Fried Chicken Finocchio Sandwich $18.00
Sliced Finocchio, shaved Parmigiana Reggiano, Touch of Truffle Oil, and Lemon Garlic Dressing.
17. Prosciutto And Arugula Sandwich $19.00
With Shaved Reggiano, Truffle Oil, and Lemon Garlic Dressing.

Sides
Sautéed Broccoli $9.00
Sautéed broccoli bursting with healthy nutrients and vibrant flavors.

Drinks
Coke $4.00
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Diet Coke $4.00
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Sprite $4.00
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Locals

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Photos

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Location

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn

New York Richmond County Charleston Arthur Kill Road

4864 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA

Aunt Butchie's of Brooklyn Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 610 user reviews.

food and servicepartyappetizermeatballparkingchicken parmroomcalamaribakeryafternoon

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We were there last week for a repast luncheon and the food and service was excellent. Salad, appetizers and pasta course was served family style and they took orders for the choice of entree. I had filet of sole oreganota and it was delicious. The meatball appetizer was also great. My favorite was the fried zucchini because they cut it so thin, probably using a "vegettie" type of tool, and then fry it so it is perfectly crispy and light. I'm looking forward to going back on a happier occasion.
October 19 · Andrea Connors
The experience was so amazing I didn't even take the time to take more pictures. We had to wait for our table despite having reservations because it was so busy but we sat at the bar and had a drink while we waited. Once we were seated our servers were wonderful, food was amazing, fried calamari was perfect , bread hot and fresh. Great experience overall, will definitely return!
September 28 · Shirley M
We went to Aunt Butchies for lunch today after a long absence and can't understand why we forgot about it. The food is always awesome, even the bread and olive oil is as good if not better than you will get anywhere. I got a chicken cutlet sandwich that could've fed 2 and it was delicious. The atmosphere is beautiful, excellent service and ample parking. We will definitely be back soon!
September 02 · JAMES MURPHY
We had a surprise party for 55 people on Sat 8/9 in the Staten Island location. It was FANTASTIC!The food was delicious, the service great and the overall experience couldn't have been better. Peter, Angelo and the team provided excellent suggestions and delivered from booking the party to ensuring that every guest was happy.Would highly recommend!!!!Plan to go back soon.
August 12 · Monica Tarantino
Great experience dining there this evening. Food, atmosphere, service on point. We will definitely be back!
February 15 · Ann Sportiello