Bagel Bazaar: Your Go-To Spot for Classic Brooklyn Bagels and More on 86th Street

Bagel Bazaar Introduce

Bagel Bazaar: A South Brooklyn Staple for Authentic New York Flavor

In a city where the bagel is a serious matter—a quintessential part of the New York diet—finding a truly authentic, high-quality bagel shop is paramount. For those in South Brooklyn, particularly in the Bensonhurst and surrounding neighborhoods, Bagel Bazaar stands out as a beloved, classic establishment that delivers on this promise. More than just a bagel shop, this location operates as a full-service restaurant, offering everything from fresh-baked daily bagels to hearty breakfast platters, hot-off-the-grill sandwiches, and a full-service deli counter. It embodies the authentic, old-school, mom-and-pop vibe that New Yorkers cherish, offering a combination of quick service and top-notch food that keeps the loyal community coming back morning after morning.

Bagel Bazaar is a cornerstone of its community, often lauded by locals as one of the best spots for bagels in South Brooklyn. Customers consistently rave about the quality and freshness of the bagels, as well as the generous portions and friendly service that define the New York experience. Whether you’re an early bird starting your commute or looking for a weekend feast, Bagel Bazaar promises a satisfying, delicious, and authentically Brooklyn experience.

Location and Accessibility in Brooklyn, NY

Bagel Bazaar is conveniently situated at 2208 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA. This prime location places it right in the heart of the bustling Bensonhurst area, an easily accessible spot for local residents and visitors alike. Being on 86th Street, the shop benefits from the high energy and foot traffic of a major Brooklyn thoroughfare, making it a natural gathering spot for the community seeking a quality meal.

Accessibility is a key convenience at Bagel Bazaar. The establishment features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that everyone can easily stop in for their morning coffee and fresh bagel. For those on a tight schedule, the shop is perfectly set up for a quick visit, with fast service often highlighted by patrons. Furthermore, modern convenience is covered with multiple payment options, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making your transaction as swift as possible.

Services Offered at Your Local Bagel & Deli

Bagel Bazaar goes far beyond the typical bagel and schmear, positioning itself as a comprehensive neighborhood eatery. Their service model is designed to cater to the fast-paced life of New Yorkers, offering flexibility and an extensive menu selection:

Services:

In-Person Ordering and Quick Visit Dining: Designed for efficiency, Bagel Bazaar is ideal for those needing a speedy, quality breakfast or lunch.
Takeout: Perfect for grabbing your order to go, whether it's a single bagel with cream cheese or a full family breakfast.
Delivery: For days when you can't make it to the shop, the full menu is available for delivery right to your door.
Breakfast All Day: Serving a wide range of menu items from the early morning and throughout the day, focusing on the most important meal of the day.
Full-Service Deli: Beyond bagels, the shop offers an impressive selection of Boar’s Head cold cuts by the pound and freshly prepared cold cut sandwiches.

Features and Menu Highlights

The menu at Bagel Bazaar is a showcase of classic New York breakfast and deli favorites, emphasizing fresh ingredients and homemade quality. Patrons can find both time-honored dishes and modern bagel variations:

Highlights:

The Classic Bagel and Schmear: Enjoy a variety of fresh-baked bagels, from plain to everything, paired with an extensive list of cream cheese options, including plain, scallion, vegetable, walnut raisin, and even the specialty lox cream cheese. The option to add fresh lox is also available for a premium New York breakfast.
The Legendary Flagel: A must-try for any bagel connoisseur. The 'Flagel' is a special, flattened bagel that is thin and crunchy on the outside while maintaining a satisfyingly soft interior. It's a fun New York variation that is perfect for those who crave a higher crust-to-fluff ratio. It is available by itself or with butter or cream cheese.
Hot-Off-The-Grill Breakfast Sandwiches: The shop is famous for its expertly prepared breakfast sandwiches, with the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a roll or bagel being a customer favorite and a top-selling item. The generous Big Breakfast Sandwich includes two eggs, hash brown, ham, sausage, bacon, and cheese—a true New York-sized meal.
Fresh, Hot Coffee: A vital complement to any bagel, Bagel Bazaar offers fresh Regular and Decaf Coffee, along with Iced Coffee, Cappuccino, and a variety of teas. Coffee is also available in a large format with the Box of Joe (96 Oz.) for catering or group orders.
Extensive Deli and Hot Sandwich Menu: For lunch or a bigger bite, choose from a wide array of Hot Sandwiches like the Hot Pastrami and Grilled Chicken Sandwich, or Cold Cut Sandwiches using premium Boar's Head meats, including Homemade Roast Beef, Ovengold Turkey, and Virginia Ham.
Homemade Salads and Baked Goods: Freshly prepared Tuna, Egg, Chicken, and Whitefish Salads are available by the pound for home use or as part of a sandwich. The shop also bakes an assortment of treats daily, such as Muffins, Crumbcake, and Croissants.

Contact Information

For your next order or to find out more about their daily specials, here is the direct contact information for Bagel Bazaar in Brooklyn:

Address: 2208 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA
Phone: (718) 996-7440

What Makes Bagel Bazaar Worth Choosing

Bagel Bazaar has secured its place as a cherished local favorite for a multitude of reasons, making it a standout choice for Brooklynites seeking the real deal. First and foremost is the unwavering commitment to quality and the "old-school" vibe. Customers frequently praise the shop for its authentic atmosphere and for serving up a classic bagel that instantly "transports you to your childhood"—a high compliment in New York food culture. The staff, described as "super friendly and funny," adds a personal, welcoming touch that enhances the entire experience, especially for early birds who rely on a quick, cheerful start to their day.

The shop is noted for its ability to manage high-volume orders without sacrificing quality, ensuring that the food is always fresh and served quickly. The menu is expansive, offering delicious variety without being overwhelming, from the simple perfection of a fresh bagel with cream cheese to complex, fully loaded sandwiches like the Big Breakfast Sandwich. Finally, the inclusion of local specialties like the Flagel—which provides a unique, crunchy texture and is available at a great value—demonstrates their commitment to catering to all New York bagel preferences. Bagel Bazaar is not just selling food; it's selling a consistent, high-quality, and reliable taste of authentic South Brooklyn life.

Bagel Bazaar Menu

What's A Flagel!
Flagel With Butter $2.95
Available Options: Plain, Sesame, Everything, Wheat, Cinnamon Raisin.
Flagel With Cream Cheese $3.25
Available Options: Plain, Sesame, Everything, Wheat, Cinnamon Raisin.
Flagel (Each) $1.75
Our Flagels are thin and crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

Cookies and Chips
UTZ Chips $2.50
UTZ Brand Chips (price includes a convenience fee)
Pepperidge Farm Cookies $5.49
Pepperidge Farm Brand (price includes a convenience fee)

Box of Joe
Box Of Joe (96 Oz.) $25.00
Serves 8-10 cups of our signature coffee. This option includes a choice of milk or cream, sugar and sugar substitutes, cups and stirrers.

Salads by the Pound
Chicken $6.75
Our Signature Homemade Chicken Salad by the pound. Due to pricing limitations we’re only able to serve by the quarter pound.
Egg $6.50
Our delicious homemade Egg Salad by the pound. Due to pricing limitations we’re only able to sell by the quarter pound.
Tuna $6.50
Our Signature homemade Tuna Salad by the pound. Due to pricing limitations we’re only able to serve by the quarter pound.
Whitefish $7.24
Our delicious whitefish salad by the pound. Due to pricing limitations we’re only able to serve by the quarter pound.

Cold Cut Sandwiches
Pepperoni $9.25
Boars Head Pepperoni served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Fresh Homemade Turkey $8.50
Our delicious Homemade Turkey breast served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Pastrami $10.50
Boars Head Lean Pastrami served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Cheese Sandwich $5.50
Thin slices of Boars Head American Cheese served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Muenster Cheese $5.00
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Provolone Cheese $5.00
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Ovengold Turkey $9.00
Boars Head Ovengold Turkey Breast served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Swiss Cheese $5.50
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Homemade Roast Beef $10.50
Our delicious homemade Roast Beef served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Mozzarella Cheese $5.50
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Bologna $6.50
Boars Head Bologna served on your choice of bread. This product contains pork. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Ham $9.00
Boars Head Ham served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Virginia Ham $8.75
Boars Head Quality Virginia Ham served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Cracked Pepper Turkey $7.50
Cheddar Cheese $5.50
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Capicola $9.50
Boars Head Spicy Capicola served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Honey Turkey $9.00
Boars Head Honey Turkey breast served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar
Genoa Salami $9.00
Boars Head Genoa Salami served on your choice of bread. **The Works: This option includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Salt, Pepper, Oil and Vinegar

Extras
Philly Cream Cheese (8oz) $7.50
Philadelphia Brand Cream Cheese Tub 8 Ounces
Jelly $0.25
Side Order Of Turkey Bacon $5.00
4 Strips of Turkey Bacon
Side Order Hash Browns $2.50
1 Hashbrown Patty
LaYogurt Probiotic Yogurts $1.95
Side Order Of Sausage $2.50
1 Sausage Patty
Temptee Cream Cheese Tub $7.49
Temptee Brand Cream Cheese Tub
Hero Bread $2.00
1 Loaf of Hero Bread
Chobani Greek Yogurts $2.50
Greek Yogurts
Fresh Fruit $2.50
Your choice of Apples or Bananas, Occasionally will offer fruit in season. When seasonal fruit is available additional options will appear.
Italian Bread $3.00
1 Loaf of Italian Bread
Side Order Of Homefries $4.50
Side order of our freshly made homefries,
Side Order Bacon $4.50
Side order of Pork Bacon
Lox Package (3oz) $9.00
Banner Brand Salmon Lox

Hot Sandwiches
Hot Turkey $10.75
Boars Head Turkey warmed to perfection and served on your choice of bread.
Grilled Cheese With Bacon $7.75
Grilled Cheese $7.25
Traditional Grilled American Cheese on Toast
Hot Ham & Cheese $11.99
Boars Head Ham and American cheese warmed to perfection served on your choice of bread.
B.L.T With Cheese $10.50
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato with Mayonnaise
Cheese Steak $12.50
Prepared with American Cheese, Onions and Peppers.
B.L.T With Turkey Bacon $10.00
Turkey Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $13.00
Prepared with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise
Chicken Cutlet $11.00
Prepared with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
B.L.T $9.50
Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and mayonnaise
Hot Roast Beef $11.50
Our Homemade Roast Beef thin sliced and warmed to perfection on your choice of bread.
Hot Pastrami $13.00
BoarsHead Pastrami thin sliced and warmed to perfection served on your choice of bread.

Boars Head Cold Cuts by the Pound
Homemade Roast Beef $7.10
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
American Cheese $4.10
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Bologna $6.99
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Spicy Capicola $6.50
Provolone Cheese $4.60
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Virginia Ham $6.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Genoa Salami $6.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Cheddar Cheese $5.30
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Swiss Cheese $5.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Ham $6.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Pepperoni $6.50
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Mozzarella Cheese $5.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Honey Turkey $6.50
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Fresh Homemade Turkey $5.30
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Muenster Cheese $4.60
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Oven Gold Turkey $6.20
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.
Pastrami $7.80
Your favorite cold cuts are cut to perfection.

Hot Off The Grill
Sausage Eggs And Cheese $6.75
2 Eggs, Sausage and American Cheese served on a roll.
Eggs On Roll $3.25
2 Fresh cracked eggs served in our freshly baked rolls, served any style.
Eggs On Bagel $3.25
2 Fresh cracked eggs served in our freshly baked bagels, served any style.
Ham Eggs And Cheese $6.75
2 Eggs, Ham and American Cheese served on a roll. For bagel, please use special instructions for bagel type otherwise plain will be sent.
2 Pancakes $6.00
Our delicious home made pancakes are served with butter and syrup on the side.
Bacon Eggs And Cheese $6.75
2 Scrambled Eggs, American Cheese, and Bacon served on a Roll. For bagel, please use special instructions for bagel type otherwise plain will be sent.
Egg Platter $3.75
Fresh cracked eggs served on a platter, served any style. Only includes toast, please add any other modifiers.
Fresh Oatmeal (Plain) (16 Oz.) $3.50
Slow cooked homemade oatmeal, served daily
Fresh Oatmeal With Topping ( (16 Oz.)) $4.50
Slow cooked homemade oatmeal, served daily.
Pancake Special $11.99
2 Pancakes, Hash Browns, choice of Bacon, Ham or Sausage.
French Toast Special $11.99
2 Pieces French Toast, Hash Browns, choice of Bacon, Ham or Sausage.
Big Breakfast Sandwich $9.75
2 Eggs (any style), Hash Brown, Ham, Sausage, Bacon, and Cheese.

Baked Fresh Daily
Muffins $3.25
Please use special instructions to make a selection. Available Options: Corn, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate, Raisin Bran
Chocolate Croissant $3.25
Black & White Cookies $3.25
Plain Croissants $2.25
Also available in Whole Wheat
Mini Muffins (Each) $0.85
Please use special instructions to make a selection. Available Options: Corn, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate, Raisin Bran
Linzer Tarts $3.25
Raspberry Flavored Linzer Tart
Cinnamon Buns $3.25
Strawberry Cheese Croissant $3.25
Blueberry Cheese Croissant $3.25
Apple Turnovers $3.25
Cookies (3 Pieces) $2.00
Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies
Crumbcake $3.25
Our Signature Crumbcake
Mini Muffins (6 Pieces) $3.75
Available Options: Corn, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate, Raisin Bran
Cookies (Each) $0.75
Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies

Beverages
Chocolate Milk $2.75
1 Pint of Lakeview Chocolate Milk, also available in Quart size
Gatorade $2.99
20oz or 32oz
2 Liter Soda $3.99
Please use special instructions to make a selection. Available Options: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Seltzer, Brisk Tea
Vitamin Water $2.50
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Simply Juices $3.00
11.5 Ounces
Decaf Coffee $2.75
Our Signature coffee served to your liking.
Iced Coffee $4.00
Our Signature Coffee served Chilled with ice.
Tetley Tea $2.75
Regular black tea served to your liking.
Bottled Soda $2.99
20 ounces
Regular Coffee $2.75
Our Signature coffee served to your liking.
Hot Chocolate $2.75
Presweetned Hot Chocolate
Snapple $2.99
16 Ounces
Herbal Teas $3.00
Please use special instructions for sugar and milk quantities
Nesquick $3.00
Nesquick flavored milk.
Canned Soda $1.50
12 ounces
Cappuccino $2.75
PreSweetned Cappuccino Mix

Bagels
Bagels With Fresh Lox & Flavored Cream Cheese $11.50
Our fresh baked bagels are served with a layer of cream cheese and your choice of salmon lox.
Bagels With Peanut Butter & Jelly $4.00
Bagels With Scallion Cream Cheese $5.00
Bagels With Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese $5.00
Bagels With Jelly $2.25
Bagels With Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese $5.00
Bagels With Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese $13.00
Our fresh baked bagels served with a layer of Cream Cheese and your choice of Salmon Lox.
Bagels With Nutella $4.00
Bogo offer: this offer only applies to bagels without additional additions. request for additions will only be honored for 1 bagel.
Bagels With Butter $2.75
Bogo offer: this offer only applies to bagels without additional additions. request for additions will only be honored for 1 bagel.
Bagels $3.00
Please use the special instructions section to indicate which bagel type you'd like and if applicable how many of each type. If no instructions are included the default option is Plain Bagel. If you are purchasing our Wednesday Special please use the Dozen Option and you will receive 18 bagels total.
Bagels With Lox Cream Cheese $6.00
Bagels With Cream Cheese $3.25
Bogo offer: this offer only applies to bagels without additional additions. request for additions will only be honored for 1 bagel.
Bagels With Vegetable Cream Cheese $5.00

Salads
Tuna Salad $9.25
Our delicious homemade Tuna salad served on your choice of bread.
Chicken Salad $9.25
Our delicious homemade Chicken Salad served on your choice of bread.
Egg Salad $8.75
Our delicious homemade Egg Salad served on your choice of bread.
White Fish $10.00
Our delicious White Fish salad served on your choice of bread.

Delicious Duos
Sandwich & Cookie $7.75
Sandwich & Salad $9.75

Bagel Bazaar Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Bagel Bazaar Photos

Bagel Bazaar Location

Bagel Bazaar

New York Kings County 86th Street

2208 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA

Bagel Bazaar Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 221 user reviews.

pricesbacon egg and cheesepastriescream cheesedeliveryschooljointplatterrudeluck

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

THE best breakfast sandwich I’ve had in years! I was totally transported to my childhood. It was so good! I don’t know what they put in those bagels but keep doing it!The guys are super friendly and funny. I will visit every time I’m on that side of Brooklyn.
September 11 · K. Wil
One of the very first to do it and still here standing strong. Amazing bagels 🥯🤤. Early birds come here and through the day. Fresh bagels. Staff are nice. Quick and easy bites. Highly recommend this location. Best in south Brooklyn.
September 14 · Eric Chan
Love this place—great food, great people, and every time I’m in town I go there. But during my last visit, I found a small nail in my breakfast sandwich. It was a pretty shocking surprise, though thankfully I wasn’t hurt.The staff was super apologetic and handled it well, which I appreciate. I’m still a fan, but wanted to share so others are aware and the kitchen can hopefully avoid this kind of thing in the future.
April 21 · Eric Maar
food is decent. service is slower than a snails pace. they would rather take big orders then a small order like mine which was simply a small hot coffee. I waited ten minutes just to not get acknowledged. If you guys know that the mornings are the busiest have at least a group of people working not just two older gentleman.
September 10 · hect0r perez
The small bagel store is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They have a variety of bagels. Bagels are available with different toppings. Breakfast specials include a choice of eggs, pancakes and French toast. Cold cuts, hot sandwiches and salads of tuna, egg, chicken and whitefish can be purchased. Customers can also order drinks and request catering. Store opens early at 5:00 AM and closes early at 6:00 PM(3:00 PM on Sunday). Friendly and helpful staff.
October 24 · Steven Nechamkin