Bagel Shack

- 395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430

New Jersey's bagel scene is legendary, and for good reason—we know how to make a bagel. In Mahwah, NJ, and the greater Bergen County area, the Bagel Shack is upholding that tradition, quickly becoming the go-to destination for locals seeking that perfect, authentic bite. This is more than just a quick breakfast spot; it’s a dedicated bagel shop that offers a comprehensive menu to satisfy cravings from morning until lunch and beyond. They are a local small business committed to delivering high-quality, freshly made products with outstanding service.

The true mark of a great New Jersey bagel is its texture: a slightly crispy outside that yields to a soft, pillowy, and chewy inside. According to local reviews, Bagel Shack consistently delivers on this promise. Their bagels are described as hearty and substantial, clearly made with care and freshness you can taste. From the classic Plain and Everything bagels to unique options like French Toast and the popular Flagel, they offer a wide variety to suit every preference.

Beyond the exceptional bagels, the Bagel Shack has established itself as a full-service deli, offering a wide array of breakfast, sandwich, and deli items. Whether you're looking for a quick Bagel + Cream Cheese on the run, a hearty Taylor Ham, egg, and cheese sandwich, or a full Deli Hero for lunch, this Mahwah gem has you covered. Their commitment to efficiency is also evident, with customers noting a smooth and efficient ordering process and super friendly staff that greets you as you walk in. For anyone living or working in the 07430 area, Bagel Shack is an essential addition to your list of local favorites.

Location and Accessibility

Location is everything when you need a quick start to your day, and Bagel Shack is strategically positioned for maximum convenience. You can find this popular spot at 395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA. Its address places it directly on Route 17, one of the main arteries for travel through Northern New Jersey. This high-visibility, high-traffic location makes it incredibly easy for commuters traveling through Mahwah, particularly those heading to or from neighboring towns like Ramsey, Upper Saddle River, or even New York.

Accessibility is a core strength of the business. Recognising the demands of the modern customer, Bagel Shack offers multiple ways to access their delicious offerings without the hassle. They feature a highly sought-after drive-through service, allowing you to grab your coffee and bagel without even leaving your car—a major time-saver on busy weekday mornings. Furthermore, for those who prefer to pick up their order, there are curbside pickup and in-store pickup options available. For customers who choose to dine in or shop, the facility provides a free parking lot with ample on-site parking, including a wheelchair accessible parking lot. They are truly designed for the convenience of the busy Bergen County resident.

Services Offered

The Bagel Shack menu and services are extensive, catering far beyond a simple bread-and-spread concept. They focus on delivering a full-service, high-quality deli experience centered around their fresh bagels.

• Wide Variety of Fresh Bagels: They offer a vast selection of bagel flavors, including Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, Multigrain, Garlic, Onion, Pumpernickel, and Rye, alongside specialty varieties like Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, and the popular Rainbow. They also feature the unique Bialy and the flattened Flagel.
• Gourmet Cream Cheese & Spreads: In addition to standard Cream Cheese and Butter, they feature savory and sweet specialty spreads such as Nova Lox, Scallion, Vegetable, Green Olive, Jalapeno, Walnut Raisin, Strawberry, Peanut Butter, and Nutella (on mini bagels).
• Comprehensive Breakfast Menu: Their Bagel Shack Omelettes section offers Egg Sandwiches, Wraps, and Platters, with choices of popular meats like Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Taylor Ham, and Turkey Bacon. They also prepare Western, Mexican, Carnivore, and Florentine Omelettes, along with classics like Pancakes and French Toast Platter.
• Full-Service Deli and Salads: They serve up fresh, high-quality deli meats and cheeses like Ovengold Turkey, Maple Honey Turkey, Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey, Roast Beef, Ham, Genoa Salami, and Pepperoni, available as sandwiches on a Roll, Bagel, Hero, or Wrap. They also sell meats and house-made salads (like Tuna, Chicken, Egg, and White Fish) Per lb., alongside sides like Coleslaw, Macaroni, and Potato Salad.
• Hot Food and Burgers: The menu extends to include filling options like Cheeseburger Deluxe, Philly Cheesesteak, Chicken Wings, Chicken Tenders, and a specialty Bagel Shack Burger, proving they are a top choice for both breakfast and lunch.
• Coffee and Beverages: A full range of beverages is available, including Hot Coffee in small, medium, and large sizes, as well as Iced Coffee, Iced Flavored Coffee, and Iced Tea.
• Multiple Service Options: Customers can choose from Dine-in, Takeout, Drive-through, Curbside pickup, and Delivery, ensuring maximum convenience for any situation.

Features / Highlights

Bagel Shack stands out among its competitors in the Mahwah area thanks to a combination of product quality and exceptional customer-focused features.

• Authentic, High-Quality Bagels: Customer reviews consistently highlight the huge, fresh bagels that are crispy outside and soft inside—the quintessential New Jersey bagel texture. The popular Flagel is a local favorite that sets them apart.
• Exceptional Convenience: The availability of a Drive-through and Curbside Pickup on a major highway (NJ-17) is a game-changer for commuters and busy parents, making it one of the easiest breakfast stops in the area.
• Wide-Ranging Menu: From breakfast Omelettes and Pancakes to a full selection of deli Heros and Burgers, the menu provides options for any time of the day, making it a reliable spot for both morning and lunch rushes.
• Superb Customer Service: The staff is repeatedly praised for being super friendly, welcoming customers as they enter, and maintaining an outstanding level of service and ordering accuracy.
• Great Value for Catering: They cater to larger orders, as noted by a local business owner who used them for a catering event and praised their ease of work and the quality of the bagels for large groups. A Baker's Dozen of fresh bagels is a fantastic option for the office or a family gathering.
• Accessibility and Amenities: The shop is equipped with a wheelchair accessible parking lot and restroom, along with customer amenities like Free Wi-Fi and acceptance of all modern NFC mobile payments in addition to credit and debit cards.

Contact Information

To plan your visit, place an order, or make an inquiry, please use the following contact details for Bagel Shack in Mahwah:

Address: 395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA

Phone: (201) 331-3237

Mobile Phone: +1 201-331-3237

What Is Worth Choosing

When you're searching for your next go-to spot in Bergen County, Bagel Shack on Route 17 is worth choosing for three compelling reasons: authentic quality, unparalleled convenience, and full-service variety.

First, the quality is truly New Jersey authentic. Locals know that a great bagel must have that perfect contrast—a crisp, chewy crust with a soft, warm interior. Bagel Shack delivers this consistently, offering a substantial, freshly made product that satisfies the highest standard. They're not offering small, mass-produced rolls; they're serving huge bagels and local specialties like the Flagel that earn them five-star reviews.

Second, the convenience for the busy Mahwah resident is unmatched. Being located right on NJ-17 and offering a dedicated Drive-through means you can grab a hot coffee and a Taylor Ham, egg, and cheese without derailing your commute or having to fight for a parking spot. Whether you opt for curbside pickup, the drive-through, or a quick in-store purchase, the process is guaranteed to be smooth and efficient.

Finally, the sheer variety means you never have to go anywhere else for breakfast or lunch. From the vast array of bagel flavors and specialty spreads like Nova Lox and Walnut Raisin to the extensive Deli menu featuring Ovengold Turkey heroes and Philly Cheesesteak, the Bagel Shack is more than just a bagel shop—it’s a full-scale deli and eatery. This combination of top-tier bagels and comprehensive, high-quality menu items makes Bagel Shack a true gem and the smart choice for any New Jerseyan in need of a reliable, delicious meal.

Bagel Shack

395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA