Bagel Supreme | Wallington Introduce
Bagels are more than just a breakfast item in New Jersey; they are a vital part of our local culture and a staple in any good morning routine. When you're searching for an authentic, high-quality bagel experience in Bergen County, you’ll inevitably hear the name Bagel Supreme. Specifically, the Bagel Supreme location in Wallington, NJ, has established itself as a go-to spot for locals who crave that perfect combination of a chewy, fresh-baked bagel and a savory or sweet spread.
This article provides a friendly, professional overview of what makes Bagel Supreme in Wallington a favorite among neighborhood residents, detailing their offerings, convenient services, and why it should be your next stop for a supreme bagel fix.
Location and Accessibility
Bagel Supreme is conveniently situated at the heart of the community, making it an easy stop for your daily commute or a planned weekend breakfast run. The Wallington shop’s address places it directly on a key thoroughfare, ensuring excellent accessibility for everyone in the area and surrounding towns.
P: The exact location is:
P: 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
P: The convenience of the location is enhanced by the service options available. For those rushing out the door or planning a quick meal at the office, Bagel Supreme is set up for efficiency. They understand the need for speed without sacrificing quality, which is essential for a high-traffic New Jersey bagel shop.
Services Offered
Bagel Supreme is a full-service bagel shop that focuses on providing maximum convenience and a comprehensive menu for its customers. Whether you prefer to grab your order and go, or have it brought right to your door, they have an option that fits your busy schedule.
UL
Features / Highlights: More Than Just Bagels
While the name is Bagel Supreme, the menu extends well beyond just the bread. The shop offers a wide variety of items for a complete breakfast or lunch, catering to every craving from classic comfort food to lighter, healthier options. Here are some of the standout features and menu highlights that draw locals in:
UL
Contact Information
Connecting with Bagel Supreme in Wallington is straightforward, whether you're calling ahead to place an order or looking up the exact address for your GPS.
P: Address: 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
P: Phone: (201) 587-5101
P: Mobile Phone: +1 201-587-5101
What is Worth Choosing at Bagel Supreme | Wallington
The consistent positive feedback and loyalty from local patrons are clear indicators that Bagel Supreme is a trustworthy choice for your bagel and breakfast needs. Customers consistently highlight the quality of the bagels themselves—often described as truly "supreme"—and the willingness of the staff to ensure a great experience, especially with the owner’s presence being noted for delivering exceptional quality.
Beyond the core product, the sheer variety is a major draw. Where else can you grab a Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese on a perfectly toasted bagel, a hearty Big Buffalo Wrap, and a Lox Cream Cheese bagel all in one place? The deep menu selection ensures that whether you're feeding a family, catering an office event, or just grabbing a quick bite for yourself, there's always something new and delicious to try.
The specialty cream cheeses, such as the Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese and Jalapeño Cream Cheese, are particularly worth seeking out to elevate a plain or toasted bagel into a gourmet experience. For a quick and traditional start to the day, the efficiency of their in-store pickup and takeout options makes them a perfect pit stop for anyone on a tight schedule.
In summary, Bagel Supreme in Wallington, NJ, offers a winning combination of authentic, quality bagels, a massive menu of breakfast and lunch options, and convenient service methods, making it a truly supreme choice for the North Jersey community. Next time you're in the area and craving a proper Jersey bagel, make the stop on Paterson Avenue.
Bagel Supreme | Wallington Food & drink
BAGEL'S
- Mini Bagel $0.85
- Flagel $1.50
- 1/2 Dozen Mini Bagels $5.10
ON A BAGELS
- Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese $4.50
- Peanut Butter $3.25
- Olive Cream Cheese $4.50
- Mini W/Butter $1.75
- Lox Cream Cheese $4.75
- Jalapeño Cream Cheese $4.50
- F T CC $3.99
- Ext Lettuce $0.50
- Ext Cheese $0.50
- Ext C C $4.25
- Cream Cheese Bagel $3.25
- Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese $4.50
- CC And Jelly $3.45
- Buttered Bagel $2.25
- Butter And Cc $3.45
- Butter & Jelly $2.50
BREAKFAST SANDWICHES
- Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese $5.95
- Taylor Ham , Egg & Cheese $6.50
- Taylor Ham & Cheese $6.95
- Sausage , Egg & Cheese $6.50
- Sausage &Egg $5.50
- On A French Toast $1.00
- On A Croissant $1.25
- Grilled Chicken, Egg & Cheese $7.50
- Grilled Cheese & Meat $6.50
- Ext Lettuce $0.50
- Ext Cheese $0.50
- Ext Meat $1.75
- Bacon , Egg & Cheese $6.50
- Bacon & Egg $5.95
- B.L.T $6.95
- 2 Egg & Cheese $4.50
BREAkFAST WRAPS
- Ext Cheese $0.50
- Ext Meat $1.75
- BW 5 BROOKLYN BURRITO $7.95
CITY SIZE OMELETS
- Supreme Protein $8.95
- Pancake W/Meat $8.50
- Pancake $6.50
- Ext Meat $1.75
- Chicharron $8.95
- Cheese Omelette $7.99
LUNCH WRAPS
- W3 MANHATTAN $8.95
- W 2 CALIFORNIA $8.95
- European Wrap $8.95
- Big Buffalo Wrap $8.95
SANDWICH SELECTIONS
- Tuna Salad $7.95
- Ext Lettuce $0.50
- Ext Cheese $0.50
- Egg Salad $6.95
- Baked Salmon Salad $8.95
BEVERAGE
- Vitamin Water $3.50
- Up Time $3.99
- Star Bucks Cold Brew $5.95
- Sanpellecrino $2.00
- Pure Leaf $3.00
- Nesquick Protein $3.99
- Joes $3.25
- Cold Brew $3.75
- Coconut Water $3.75
- C4 $3.75
- 32oz Snapple $4.00
COFFEE & TEA
- Small Hot Chocolate $2.50
- Lg Cappuccino $3.95
- Box Coffee $21.99
WATER
- Smart Med $2.25
- Small Poland Spring $1.50
- Medium Fiji $3.50
- Med Essentia $3.25
- Small Core $2.50
- Med Core $2.95
COLD DRINK'S
- Watermelon $5.50
- Frappuccino $4.95
BOAR'S HEAD SANDWICH'S
- Salami $8.50
- Pepper Turkey $8.50
- Pastrami $8.50
- Honey Ham $8.50
- Ext Lettuce $0.50
- Ext Cheese $0.50
- Ext Meat $1.75
SUB'S
- The Vegetarian $9.95
- Pepper Jack Pastrami $9.95
- Italian $9.95
- Gyro $8.99
CREAM CHEESE
- Blue Cup Butter $5.95
FRESH BAKED PASTRY
- Rugula $2.25
- Pound Cake $2.50
- Chocolate Crossaint $2.95
- Apple Turnover $2.75
MILK
- Gallon $6.25
- 1\2 Gallon Milk $3.75
CHOCOLATE MILK
- Yoohoo $2.95
- Froot Loops $3.75
- Fair Life Yup $3.50
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch $3.75
HOT SPECiAL
- Buffalo Wings $9.95
- Box3 Vegetable Quesadilla $9.95
- Box2 Italian Quesadilla $9.95
- Box1sizzling Quesadilla $9.95
Salad
- House Salad $8.95
- Green Salad W/Tuna $8.95
- Add Avocado $1.25
CHIPS
- Lg Joe $4.50
- LAYS $2.25
Pancake & Waffles
- Add Whipped Cream $1.00
- Add Fruit $3.00
- Add 2 Eggs $1.00
Bagel Supreme | Wallington Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Bagel Supreme | Wallington Photos










Bagel Supreme | Wallington Location
Bagel Supreme | Wallington
457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA
Bagel Supreme | Wallington Reviews
eggbaconpork roll sandwichmind
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I go to this place often. I keep giving them a chance. Depending on who is working definitely has an effect on how your bagel will be. If it’s the man that I believe to be the owner your food will be amazing. If it’s not him sometimes I don’t stop in. Today I made the mistake of stopping in when he wasn’t working. Anyhow I order an egg bagel with EXTRA butter. I got a hard bagel with minimal butter. I feel bad but it’s just been to many times. I’ll drive to the bagel place in heights.
September 13 · ChrisThey are supreme bagels for real.We have a bagel spot closer to us but love making the drive to pick up breakfast here. Also they have fresh squeezed orange juice!
September 16 · Gicell ReyesThought I'd give these guys another shot. Received stale croissants a few times and a muffin with mold growing on it. They lost my business after today. Asked if the croissants are fresh and the guy behind the counter told me they are "soft". Oh and another muffin with mold on it that my two year old was going to nibble on. Stay away. Quality check isn't great and the bagels are decent at best. Photos of the muffin attached.
May 13 · Mathias ZabaFood was great. 5 stars for food. Ordered pick up thru their website around 2:30pm on a Monday. I get a call at 2:57 saying they close in 3 minutes and to hurry and pick up my food because they're gonna close at 3pm. I told them online it says they're open till 5pm on Mondays. I don't mind if it's a mistake but the man on the phone sounded upset about it. Idk just fix your hours on Google.
April 21 · Amanda MartinezWow! Fantastic, fresh, oversized bagels traveling back with us to North Carolina! Great customer service and location, definitely recommend!
October 16 · Maple Roads
More restaurants near me

443 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA

437 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA

413 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057, USA

675 Paterson Ave STE 4, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA

443 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

356 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

334 Main St, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

267 Paterson Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

310 Union Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

300 Union Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

332 Union Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

317 Union Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





