Battaglia Brothers

- 138 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801

For anyone in New York searching for a truly authentic taste of Italy packed between fresh bread, or perhaps a hearty lunch that feels like a home-cooked meal, look no further than Battaglia Brothers in New Rochelle. Established in 1994, this staple of downtown New Rochelle is more than just a deli; it is a full-service Italian grocery store, a bustling takeout restaurant, and a beloved sandwich shop all rolled into one. Living by the motto 'La Famiglia e Tutto'—family is everything—Battaglia Brothers brings generations of Italian culinary tradition to the community, offering a delicious experience where every customer is treated like family.

The deli has earned a strong reputation for crafting some of the most satisfying and substantial sandwiches in the Westchester area. Whether you are craving a classic Italian hero loaded with top-quality cold cuts or a hot sandwich slathered in marinara and melted cheese, Battaglia Brothers delivers. Their commitment to using fresh ingredients and generous portions makes it a go-to spot for locals and a must-visit for anyone passing through the area. From quick weekday lunches to full-scale catering for your next event, the quality and flavor remain consistently high.

Location and Accessibility

Battaglia Brothers is conveniently situated in a central, accessible part of Westchester County. Its location in downtown New Rochelle ensures it is easy to find for daily commuters, students, and local residents.

Address:

138 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Accessibility is a key feature, making a quick visit hassle-free. The deli provides a welcoming environment for all patrons.

Accessibility Features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Parking and Payment:

The location offers both free street parking and paid street parking options, accommodating both a quick pop-in and a slightly longer lunch break. For a quick visit, the deli accepts a variety of convenient payment methods:

• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments

Services Offered

Battaglia Brothers operates as a multi-faceted food and market destination, providing a wide array of options beyond just cold-cut sandwiches. They expertly blend the function of an Italian grocery store with a casual dining and takeout experience.

Deli and Sandwich Shop Services:

• Full-service deli counter with fresh meats and cheeses
• Extensive menu of cold specialty sandwiches and heroes
• Hot sandwiches including classics like Chicken Parm and Meatball
• All-day breakfast options, featuring local favorites like the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese
• Freshly prepared side salads and steamed vegetables (priced per pound)
• Homemade sides like Potato Croquettes and Rice Balls
• Full lunch specials with rotating hot entrees like Penne A La Vodka and Chicken Marsala
• Variety of cold and hot beverages
• Italian Desserts, including Tiramisu and Limoncello Cake

Convenience and Market Services:

• Takeout service for all menu items
• In-store pickup for easy ordering and collection
• Delivery service for added convenience
• Authentic Italian grocery store items for home cooking
• Catering for parties, events, and family gatherings (available online)

Features / Highlights

The Battaglia Brothers menu is filled with iconic Italian-American deli creations that have become local legends. Here are some of the standout categories and specific items that customers rave about:

Signature Sandwich Highlights (Sandwiches Especiales/Specialties):

• The True Italian/Verdadero Italiano Sandwich: A quintessential Italian hero featuring Sopressata, ham, mortadella, provolone, and roasted peppers. It is often cited as a top-liked item.

• The Godfather/El Padrino: A rich, savory combination of Ham Cappy, genoa salami, provolone, roasted peppers, oil, and vinegar, embodying classic Italian flavor.

• The Big Joe/Gran Joe: A powerhouse chicken cutlet sandwich made with chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers.

• The Nonna Sandwich: A unique, gourmet option combining Fried Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and prosciutto.

• Hot Sandwich Favorites: The Chicken Parm/Pollo Parmesana and Meatball/Albondigas sandwiches are always popular, served generously on your choice of roll or wedge and smothered in savory sauce.

Menu Variety:

• Diverse Lunch Specials: Offering a rotating selection of prepared hot food like Grilled Steak, Chicken Scarpariello, and Lasagna, providing full-meal options that go beyond a simple sandwich.

• Homemade Sides: Customer-favorite sides include the crispy Potato Croquette and various Empanadas (Spinach & Cheese, Chicken, Beef), perfect for complementing any meal.

• Cold Cut Combos and Deli Salads: From the All American to specialty salads like Bocconcini Salad and Tuna Salad, there are options for every palate and preference, all available by the pound for easy meal prep.

Customer Experience:

• Generous Portions: Customers consistently mention the large, satisfying portions, offering great value for the price.

• Authentic Atmosphere: The deli prides itself on its authentic Italian feel, offering fresh meat, hot food, and a welcoming, family-focused environment.

Contact Information

Whether you need to place a takeout order, inquire about catering, or just want to confirm the day's specials, here is how you can reach the deli:

Address:

138 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Phone Number:

(914) 633-3382

What is Worth Choosing

Battaglia Brothers is a New Rochelle institution that is worth choosing for several compelling reasons, particularly for New Yorkers who appreciate quality and tradition in their local deli. The establishment successfully bridges the gap between a neighborhood market and a high-quality takeout restaurant.

The core value proposition lies in the authenticity and variety of its Italian offerings. Unlike many delis that only focus on sandwiches, Battaglia Brothers provides a complete Italian-American culinary experience. You can grab a Bacon, Egg, and Cheese for breakfast, a colossal specialty hero for lunch, pick up a ready-to-eat hot entree like Chicken Marsala for dinner, and even purchase a cannoli or a slice of Tiramisu for dessert. This range of options makes it an indispensable local resource.

For sandwich enthusiasts, the specialty menu is a masterpiece of deli artistry. The aforementioned True Italian sandwich is a must-try for any cold-cut aficionado, perfectly balancing a selection of high-quality Italian meats and provolone with the sweetness of roasted peppers. For those who prefer hot sandwiches, the simple but perfect Meatball or Chicken Parm are comforting classics that rival any restaurant dish. The portion sizes are notoriously large, ensuring you get your money's worth and often have leftovers for a second meal.

However, as with any high-volume spot, customer feedback suggests that certain items, such as the thinness or hardness of some fried chicken cutlets, may occasionally be inconsistent. The smart play is often to choose one of their popular, signature heroes like the Big Joe, the True Italian, or the Eggplant Parm, which consistently receive glowing reviews for flavor and portion size. Their focus on fresh ingredients, particularly in their deli salads and prepared hot foods, is a defining factor that keeps customers coming back.

For event planning, Battaglia Brothers' catering service is a reliable choice for bringing a taste of authentic Italian flavor to any gathering. Their full trays of hot food, cold appetizers, and sandwich platters simplify hosting, allowing you to serve restaurant-quality food with a local, personal touch. In a region known for its competitive deli scene, Battaglia Brothers stands out as a genuine, family-oriented spot where the quality of the food and the generosity of the portions consistently exceed expectations. It is a true taste of Italy right in downtown New Rochelle.

The fact that they are often rated highly for having some of the best sandwiches in Westchester is a testament to their enduring quality and commitment. For New York area residents, supporting a local, family-established business like Battaglia Brothers means getting authentic flavor, fresh ingredients, and a satisfying meal every time. Stop by for a quick, delicious experience—it is a place that feels like home.

Battaglia Brothers

138 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA