Benjy's Kosher Pizza

- 12-46 River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410

Welcome to Fair Lawn, New Jersey, home to one of Bergen County’s most cherished local pizza institutions: Benjy's Kosher Pizza. This dairy establishment is not just a standard pizzeria; it's a neighborhood staple renowned for its commitment to high-quality, authentic kosher cuisine served in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. For local New Jersey residents seeking a delicious, casual, and reliably kosher dining experience, Benjy's is a go-to destination.

Benjy's Kosher Pizza has earned a reputation for mastering the art of the perfect pie, offering everything from the classic cheese pizza beloved by all ages to unique specialty creations that showcase a blend of traditional pizza-making with Mediterranean flavors. More than just a pizza shop, the restaurant also serves up a full menu of Italian-American comfort food and quick bites, making it an ideal spot for lunch, dinner, or a quick snack.

Locals frequently praise the dough, which is often described as soft, puffy, and an excellent base for the generous toppings and flavorful sauces. The owner, sometimes affectionately referred to as "the pizza rabbi," is noted for his warm demeanor, which contributes to the welcoming and familiar feeling that patrons often associate with this local gem. Whether you are a dedicated pizza enthusiast or simply looking for a reliable, enjoyable meal that adheres to strict kosher standards, Benjy's Kosher Pizza in Fair Lawn stands out as a must-visit location.

For families, students, and professionals in the North Jersey area, Benjy's provides a perfect backdrop for casual gatherings, a quick solo meal, or a convenient takeout option after a busy day. Their commitment to tradition and community is evident in every hand-crafted item on their extensive menu, promising a satisfying experience every time you step through the door or place an order.

The atmosphere at Benjy’s is distinctly casual, designed to be a comfortable setting for everyone. This relaxed environment is coupled with a strong emphasis on service options, ensuring that whether you want to dine in, grab a quick bite to go, or have a hot meal delivered right to your home, the experience is seamless and convenient. Benjy's truly embodies the spirit of a supportive, community-focused local business that New Jersey residents appreciate.

The enduring popularity of Benjy’s within the Fair Lawn community speaks volumes. It's a place that has created loyal customers over the years, with one customer noting that they "must buy pizza here at least once a week," calling it "by far the most delicious Kosher pizza in Fair Lawn." Supporting a local, small business that delivers such consistent quality and community warmth is a key reason why so many New Jersey residents make Benjy’s their preferred pizza spot.

For anyone planning a small gathering or even just a fun Friday night meal, the diverse menu, which includes substantial mains and delightful sides, ensures that all appetites are catered to, solidifying its place as a reliable and high-quality local dining choice.

Location and Accessibility

Benjy's Kosher Pizza is perfectly situated in the heart of Bergen County, making it easily accessible for local New Jersey patrons. The physical address is 12-46 River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA. This location benefits from being central to the Fair Lawn neighborhood, facilitating easy pick-up and dining for those in the immediate area and surrounding towns.

Accessibility is a key priority for the establishment. They offer a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring all members of the community can comfortably access the dining area. Additionally, for drivers, there is free street parking available, which removes the hassle of finding a spot, adding to the overall convenience for customers making a quick trip for takeout or planning to dine in.

The restaurant's location on River Road is a well-known area, which simplifies the process of finding the shop for both newcomers and long-time residents. Its integration into the Fair Lawn locale makes it a practical and visible choice for lunch or dinner.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: Enjoy a meal in the casual, family-friendly setting.
• Takeout: Conveniently place an order and pick it up to enjoy at home.
• Delivery: Options available, including no-contact delivery for maximum convenience.
• Curbside Pickup: A hassle-free option for grabbing your order quickly.
• Catering: Available for larger events and gatherings.
• Payment Options: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Dining Times: Popular for both lunch and dinner services.

Features / Highlights

• Kosher Certified: The establishment maintains strict adherence to kosher dietary laws, with the pizza specifically noted to be Cholov Yisroel, Pas Yisroel, and Yoshon, appealing directly to the needs of the local kosher community.
• Specialty Pizza Variety: Offers an exciting range of unique pies, including the highly recommended Zatar Pie, Baked Ziti Pie, French Fry Pie, Eggplant Pie, Garlic Pie, and White Pizza.
• Hand-Crafted Quality: Known for its commitment to hand-crafting each pizza, resulting in a thin-crust product that customers consistently rate as fresh and delicious.
• Mediterranean Influences: The menu is diversified with items like the Zatar Pie, Falafel options, Hummus Plate, and Burekhas, offering flavors beyond typical pizzeria fare.
• Comfort Food Menu: In addition to pizza, the restaurant serves a full line of classic comfort foods, including various calzones (such as Plain, Baked Ziti, and Zatar) and baked dishes like Baked Ziti and Eggplant Parm.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The restaurant is welcoming to all ages, described as casual and a popular spot for families, even providing amenities like highchairs for children.
• Community Favorite: Highly recommended by locals as the "most delicious Kosher pizza in Fair Lawn," with a reputation for consistent quality and friendly service.
• Options for Quick Bites: Ideal for customers looking for a fast, delicious meal, with popular sides like Garlic Knots, Spicy Fries, and Onion Rings.

Contact Information

For placing an order, confirming hours, or inquiring about catering, New Jersey residents can reach Benjy's Kosher Pizza directly.

Address: 12-46 River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA

Phone: (201) 773-6195

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Benjy’s Kosher Pizza in Fair Lawn, the menu offers several standout items that are consistently highlighted by local patrons as must-try dishes. The core of their reputation lies in their pizza, particularly the specialty pies that set them apart from other pizzerias in the North Jersey area.

The most celebrated pie is the Zatar Pie. This popular best-seller is a classic local favorite and is often cited as the signature dish of Benjy's Kosher Pizza. For those who enjoy a heartier, more unique pizza experience, the Baked Ziti Pie is an excellent choice, combining a generous serving of penne pasta, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce right on a pizza crust. It is a satisfying fusion of two Italian comfort classics.

Beyond the inventive specialties, the Plain Pie remains a top menu item, a testament to the quality of their foundation—the dough and classic cheese blend. Customers seeking a reliable, classic slice of kosher pizza will find their traditional pie to be expertly prepared.

The calzone selection is also worth exploring, providing a full, satisfying meal option. The Plain Calzone with ricotta and mozzarella is a comforting, cheesy favorite, while the specialty options like the Baked Ziti Calzone and Zatar Calzone mirror the popular pizza flavors in a baked pastry format. For a truly novel experience, the French Fry Pie or French Fry Calzone offers a fun and indulgent twist on traditional toppings.

For side dishes, the Garlic Knots are a traditional classic, strips of dough baked to perfection and coated in garlic, butter, and parsley. The Spicy Fries also come highly recommended as a “best seller,” offering a flavorful kick to any meal.

Benjy's Kosher Pizza delivers on its promise of delicious, authentic kosher food with a wide variety of options for every palate. The combination of classic favorites and unique specialties, all prepared with an emphasis on quality and community, is why New Jersey residents continue to choose Benjy’s for their pizza needs.

Benjy's Kosher Pizza

12-46 River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA