BorderLine Bagel & Deli Introduce
## Introduction / Overview
In New Jersey, the bagel is more than just a breakfast item; it's a way of life, and finding the right local spot is essential for any resident. Located conveniently in **New Milford, NJ**, **BorderLine Bagel & Deli** stands as a local cornerstone, offering the quintessential New Jersey bagel experience alongside a full-service deli and coffee shop. This beloved small business provides a daily starting point for many Bergen County locals, delivering the fresh, chewy, and perfectly crafted bagels that the region is famous for. But BorderLine is much more than just a bagel shop; it’s a complete morning and lunch destination.
BorderLine Bagel & Deli excels at providing the speed and quality demanded by busy New Jersey commuters and families. Their extensive menu covers everything from a simple, perfect bagel with cream cheese to hearty, famous **Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese sandwiches**—a true Jersey staple. Beyond breakfast, they transition seamlessly into a full-service deli offering robust lunch options, including classic sandwiches, paninis, and a variety of freshly prepared salads by the pound. They also serve as a dedicated **Coffee shop**, ensuring you can grab a high-quality cup of joe, an iced coffee, or a specialty beverage to perfectly complement your meal.
Operating as a genuine **Small business** within the community, BorderLine Bagel & Deli understands the local palate and the need for prompt, friendly service. They are organized to facilitate a **Quick visit**, making them an ideal choice for a grab-and-go meal on the way to work or school. Whether you are craving the simplicity of a toasted bagel, the complexity of a **Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich**, or a full **Big Breakfast Platter**, this New Milford establishment is equipped to satisfy your hunger efficiently and deliciously.
## Location and Accessibility
The location of BorderLine Bagel & Deli is highly convenient for residents throughout the area, making it an easy stop for your daily bagel and coffee run. You can find them at:
440 Madison Ave., New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Situated on Madison Avenue, the shop is accessible from major local roads, serving communities like Oradell, River Edge, and Bergenfield. This central location in New Milford makes it a natural gathering point for the surrounding neighborhoods.
Accessibility is a key priority for BorderLine Bagel & Deli, ensuring that every customer can visit with ease. The premises offer both a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, providing comfort and convenience for all patrons. For drivers, the available parking options simplify the pickup process:
- **Free parking lot** right at the location.
- **Free street parking** as an additional option.
These features, combined with multiple service options designed for speed, confirm BorderLine’s commitment to being a hassle-free, accessible local favorite for a quick and essential stop.
## Services Offered
BorderLine Bagel & Deli offers a comprehensive range of services tailored for the local New Jersey clientele, focusing on speed, convenience, and variety across their Bagel shop, Coffee shop, and Deli operations. Their service model is highly flexible to meet all customer needs:
- **Service Options:** Exceptional convenience is provided through multiple fulfillment methods, including **Curbside pickup**, **Delivery**, **In-store pickup**, and traditional **Takeout**.
- **Core Offerings:** Specializing in fresh, high-quality **Bagels** and a full selection of **Breakfast Sandwiches** that are available throughout the morning.
- **Deli Service:** Serving a full **Deli** menu, which includes **Classic Sandwiches**, **Paninis**, and freshly made **Salads by the pound** (e.g., Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad).
- **Beverages:** A dedicated **Coffee shop** component offering hot **Coffee**, **Iced Coffee**, **Tea**, and a wide range of specialty drinks including **Smoothies** (like Mango and Strawberry), various **Ades**, and bottled beverages.
- **Breakfast for the Group:** Convenient party and catering options are available, such as the **Borderline Bagel Platter** and the **Baker's Dozen Value Pack**, perfect for office meetings or weekend family gatherings.
- **Payment Flexibility:** Accepting various payment methods for ease of transaction, including **Checks**, **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and modern **NFC mobile payments**.
## Features / Highlights
What truly makes BorderLine Bagel & Deli a standout choice in the crowded New Jersey bagel market is its comprehensive menu, dedication to local staples, and convenient setup. Key highlights include:
- **New Jersey Breakfast Staples:** The commitment to classic regional favorites is evident in their menu, most notably the popular **Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich**. They offer a variety of breakfast sandwiches, ensuring a perfect start to any local's day.
- **Extensive Bagel and Spread Variety:** Beyond the basics, they offer a wide array of spreads, including specialized choices like **Lox Cream Cheese** and the premium **Bagel With Fresh Nova And Cream Cheese**, catering to every bagel preference.
- **Full Deli and Salad Bar:** Functioning as a full deli, they offer more than just breakfast. The availability of items like the **Italiano Panini**, **Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich**, and various **Salads by the pound** makes it an excellent choice for a robust lunch.
- **All-Day Menu Appeal:** While they are a premier destination for **Breakfast**, the menu is versatile enough to cover lunch and quick snack needs, from **Burgers & Fries** to a selection of **Sweet Deserts** like crumb cake and black & white cookies.
- **Remedy and Healthy Options:** The inclusion of items under "Borderline Remedies," such as a **Fresh Fruit Cup** and **Parfait**, and the availability of specialty items like **Avocado Toast**, cater to customers looking for lighter or healthier choices.
- **Small Business Dedication:** As a proud small business, they are directly invested in the local community, striving to provide a personalized touch that larger chains cannot match.
## Contact Information
For placing orders, checking on menu availability, or any other inquiries, BorderLine Bagel & Deli ensures they are easily reachable:
Address: 440 Madison Ave., New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
Phone: (201) 599-1990
We encourage customers to call ahead, especially for larger orders like the **Borderline Bagel Platter** or during busy morning rushes, to take full advantage of their efficient in-store or curbside pickup services.
## What is Worth Choosing
Choosing **BorderLine Bagel & Deli** is a choice for authentic New Jersey flavor, ultimate convenience, and exceptional variety. For New Milford and Bergen County residents, it is the quintessential one-stop shop for breakfast and lunch. What makes this establishment truly worth choosing is its ability to nail the basics while still offering unexpected variety.
The **Bagels** themselves, the foundation of the business, are the primary draw—best enjoyed with one of their many fresh cream cheese varieties or the indulgent **Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich**. Furthermore, any New Jersey local knows the sacred nature of the **Taylor Ham, Egg And Cheese Sandwich**, and BorderLine delivers this classic flawlessly. It is a mandatory choice for any first-time visitor.
Beyond the core breakfast offerings, BorderLine's strength lies in its versatility. The **Lunch** menu is expansive, offering signature items like the **Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich** or one of the customizable **Paninis**. For those needing to feed a crowd, the catering options, especially the **Baker's Dozen Value Pack**, provide excellent value and make hosting a gathering or supplying an office breakfast a breeze.
In short, BorderLine Bagel & Deli is an essential local business that provides the necessary fuel for a busy New Jersey day. It’s the place to go for a reliably fresh bagel, a classic deli lunch, and a great cup of coffee, all served with the speed and flexibility demanded by the local community through their array of pickup and delivery options.
BorderLine Bagel & Deli Menu
Bagels with Spreads
- Mini Bagel With Butter $1.99
- Bagel With Butter $3.75
- Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $5.50
Flavor Cream cheese spreads Vegetable, Scallion, Cinn-Walnut Raisin, Funfetti, Lox spread, Olive, Strawberry, Cucumber & Dills
- Muffin With Butter $4.25
- Bagel With Lox Cream Cheese $5.59
- Bagel With Cream Cheese $4.10
- Bagel With Peanut Butter And Jelly $4.35
- Muffin $3.49
- Mini Bagel With Cream Cheese $2.50
- Bagel With Fresh Nova And Cream Cheese $11.99
Nova scotia freshly sliced with cream cheese.
Salads
- Chef Salad $9.99
Romaine lettuce mesculine, carrots, red cabbage, cucumbers, tomatoes, topped with turkey, ham, cheddar cheese and Swiss with choice of dressing,.
- Garden Salad $7.99
Mix greens, tomato, cumber, green pepper and onion.
- Traditional Greek Salad $13.59
Mixed field greens, diced cucumber, ripe tomato, Bermuda onions, Kalamata olives and crumbled feta cheese. Served with a fresh bagel.
- Asian Sesame Chicken Salad $10.99
Grilled chicken on romaine lettuce with sesame seed, red onions, green onions. asian sesame dressing
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $12.99
Romaine, lettuce, mesculine, Bermuda onions, croutons and Parmesan cheese topped with grilled chicken cutlet.
Burgers & Fries
- Original Pepper Chicken Wings $6.99
6 pieces of Organic chicken wings Choose your choice of style.
- French Fries $6.49
Crispy French Fries.
Salads by pound
- Tuna Salad $6.99
1/2 pound of tuna
- Egg Salad $7.00
Egg salad by 1/2 pound
- Chicken Salad $6.99
Fresh Chicken salad by 1/2 pound
Breakfast Specials
- Hungry Man $11.99
3 eggs, Ham + Sausage + Bacon and Triple American cheese on a hero.
- Breakfast Burrito $11.49
3 eggs, sauteed onions & green peppers, home fries and ham.
- Protein Wrap $11.49
4 egg whites, spinach, Boar's head oven gold turkey, onion and green peppers.
Bagels
- Cream Cheese By Half Pound $7.49
8oz Container of our Freshly made Cream Cheeses Plain , Scallion, Vegetable, Olive, Strawberry, Lox Spread, Cucumber & Dills
- Philladelphia Whipped Plain Cream Cheese $6.00
8oz packed Philladelphia Whipped Cream cheese.
- Bagel $2.50
Plain Poppy Sesame Cinn-Raisin Everything Whole Wheat Egg Pumper Nickel Marble Rye wholewheat everything
- Breakstone Butter $6.99
8oz whipped butter.
- Nova Lox By 1/4 Pound $14.00
1/4 lb Nova (smoked salmon from Brooklyn) Freshly sliced.
- Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich $11.59
Nova (smoked salmon from Brooklyn) Freshly sliced. ** picture shown is nova & cream cheese sandwich, please select it on bagels with spreads section **
Classic Sandwiches
- Tuna Sandwich $9.09
- Roast Beef Sandwich $9.99
Our oven baked Fresh Boar's Head Roast Beef.
- Cheese Sandwich $6.99
- Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.49
Our slowly oven cooked Chicken Breast.
- Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $10.49
- Bologna Sandwich $8.49
- Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.49
Albacore white tuna and tongol tuna salad
- Ham Sandwich $9.49
Boar's Head deluxe ham
- Tuna Melt Sandwich $8.99
melted with Cheddar cheese on Rye
- Turkey Sandwich $9.49
showing : Boar's Head Oven gold turkey with lettuce and tomatoes on our Rainbow Bagel.
- Egg Salad Sandwich $7.49
Paninis
- Parmigian Panini $9.99
Breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella & tomato sauce
- Fajita Panini $9.99
Grilled chicken, salsa, hot & sweet peppers, cheddar cheese & pepper Jack cheese
- Italiano Panini $9.99
Grilled chicken, basil pesto, sweet peppers & fresh mozarella
- Buffalo Panini $9.99
Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce & Blue cheese
Potato Chips
- Deep River Chips $2.50
2 oz bag kettle boiled chips.
- Popcorn Indiana Movie Theater Buttered $3.50
4.0 oz bag.
- Kinder Chocolate $2.85
kinder brand cholates.
- Dirty Chips $2.50
2 oz bags all natural ketlle cooked with peanut oil chips.
- Glico Pocky Chocolate $3.75
2.46 oz box.
- Popcorn Indiana Original Kettlecorn $3.50
4.0 oz bag.
- Frito Lay $1.75
1.5 - 1.75 oz bags.
- Wise Chips $1.50
1.25-1.5oz bags.
Borderline Remedies
- Fresh Fruit Cup $4.99
16 oz fresh fruits Seasonal Changes on Choices: watermelon, cantalope, honey dew, pineapples.
- Parfait $5.99
Low Fat Vanilla Yogurt . Mixed Fruits
- Rice Puddings $3.99
16 oz Rice Pudding.
Omelettes
- Side Order Home Fries $4.99
- Spinach Omelette $11.99
- Big Breakfast Platter $14.99
2 eggs any style with Bacon or Sausage or Ham & home fries and buttered toast.
- Western Omellettes $13.99
Grilled onions and pepper with sliced ham.
- Hash Brown $2.25
- Home Fries With Onions & Peppers $5.99
idaho potato home fries.
- Meat And Cheese Omelette $14.99
please choose among bacon or sausage or ham.
- French Fries $6.49
crispy fried french fries
Breakfast for the Group
- Borderline Bagel Platter $59.99
15 assorted bagels, 6 assorted pastries with 2 tubs of cream cheese and butter. serves up to 20.
- Baker's Dozen Value Pack $27.00
includes 2 tubs of 1/2 lb cream cheese. Any flavor cc Please specify in a note
- Baker's Dozen $18.00
Please choose 13 bagels from the following flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, pretzel salt, onion, cinnamon raisin.
Sweet Deserts
- Croissant Plain $3.25
- Plain Crumb Cake $3.75
- Marble Pound Cake $3.75
- Lemon Iced Pound Cake $3.75
- Black & White Cookies $3.50
- Ritter Chocolate $4.50
3.5 oz German Chocolate.
- Plain Pound Cake $3.75
- Cinnamon Roll $3.75
- Cheese Danishes $3.75
- Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.50
- Chocolate Marble Crumb Cake $3.75
- Belgian Waffle $2.75
Beverages
- Hot Chocolate $3.00
- Half & Half $5.25
cream o land quart size.
- Red Bull $3.99
8.4 oz can.
- Grape Fruit Ade $6.99
Ice cold fresh made grapefruit ade
- V8 $2.99
Original 100% vegetable Juice 12oz bottle.
- Iced Coffee $3.29
- Mango Ade $6.99
Ice Cold fresh made Mango-ade 20oz
- Yoohoo $2.89
16 oz bottle.
- Fentimans Ginger Beer $3.25
9.3 oz bottle Organic ginger beer.
- Poland Spring Water $2.75
- Tropicana Family Size $8.99
1/2 gallon Original 100% pure juice bottle.
- Coffee $2.74
- Naked Juice $5.25
100% natural 15.2 oz bottle.
- Passion Fruit-Ade $6.99
Fresh Made ice cold Passion Fruit ade 20oz
- Vitamin Water $2.85
16oz bottle.
- Tropicana Juice $3.50
12 oz bottle
- Snapple $2.65
16oz bottle all natural.
- Strawberry And Banana Smoothie $8.99
Fresh made Strawberry and banana Smoothie 16oz
- Mango Smoothie $8.99
- Coco Well Coconut Water Original $3.25
11.2 oz paper pack.
- Lorina Natural Sparkling Premium Lemonade $2.99
11.1 oz bottle.
- Bai $3.25
18 oz bottle 1g sugar no Artificial sweeteners.
- Blueberry Ade $6.99
Ice cold fresh made blueberry ade 20 oz
- Lorina Natural Sparkling Premium Pink Lemonade $2.99
11.1 oz glass bottle.
- Core Ph Balanced Water $3.75
30 oz bottle.
- Orangina $2.75
Sparkling Citrus Beverage 16oz Bottle.
- Sodas $2.89
20 oz bottle coke, diet coke, sprite, seltzer, welch grape.
- Strawberry-Ade $6.99
Ice cold fresh made strawberry ade 20 oz
- Milk $2.89
Pint Valley Farm Regular milk.
- Nesquik Chocolate $3.50
14oz bottle.
- Strawberry Smoothie $8.99
Fresh made Strawberry Smoothie 16 oz
- French Vanilla Cappucino $3.00
- Tea $2.40
Lipton Decaf Green Tea, Earl Gray , Raspberry chimomile, lemon zinger.
- Martinellis Apple Juice $3.50
10 oz bottle.
- Fiji Water $4.24
Natural Artesian water.
- Gatorade $2.85
20 oz wide mouth bottle.
- Joe Tea $3.50
20 oz natural tea bottle.
- BelVoir Organic Ginger Beer $3.50
8.5 oz bottle.
Signature Sandwiches
- Chicken Supreme Sandwich $9.99
Breaded chicken, crispy bacon with melted cheddar cheese & Russian dressing.
- Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich $10.99
Thinly sliced sirloin steaks with melted american cheese with sauted onions and bell peppers on a long roll.
- Monte Cristo Sandwich $9.99
Grilled ham and turkey with Swiss.
- Chicken Parm Hero $12.99
Cutlets with mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce on a hero.
- Italian Bomber Sandwich $10.99
Boar's head Deluxe ham, pepperoni, salami and provolone with roasted peppers, red onion, lettuce, tomato with oil and vinegar on a hero bread.
- Club Deluxe Sandwich $9.99
Boar's Head Turkey, Deluxe Ham and Alpine Swiss cheese with Crispy Bacon , Lettuce, Tomatoes on 3 layered toasts.
- B.L.T Sandwich $7.99
6 strips of hotel grade bacons with iceberg lettuce and tomatoes.
- Manhattan Wrap $9.99
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella with honey mustard.
- Hot Pastrami Sandwich $9.99
On a Toasted Rye bread Brooklyn Style boar's head pastrami with Swiss cheese melted with mustard.
- Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich $9.49
With fresh mozzarella and roasted red pepper on toasted garlic roll.
- Atlantic Wrap $9.99
Breaded chicken, lettuce, bacon, onion, tomato, pepper Jack cheese with ranch dressing.
- Turkey Club Sandwich $9.99
Thinly Sliced oven gold turkey With bacon, lettuce, tomato on 3 layered white toast.
- Chicken Quesadilla $9.99
Grilled chicken, onion, pepper, pepper with melted Pepper-Jack cheese topped with ranch dressing.
- Turkey Delight Sandwich $8.99
Boar's Head Oven gold Turkey and home made coleslaw with Russian dressing.
- Mediterranean Wrap $9.99
Grilled chicken, black olives, roasted red pepper, feta cheese, tomato, and spinach with balsamic vinegar.
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Taylor Ham And Cheese Sandwich $8.59
extra meat and cheese on this sandwich
- Steak, Egg And Cheese Sandwich $9.59
- Bacon, Egg And Cheese Sandwich $8.99
3 strips of hotel grade bacons.
- Turkey Bacon , Egg & Cheese $9.99
- Sausage Egg & Cheese $8.59
Sausage pattie & Cheese with fried Egg.
- 2 Eggs Sandwich $6.09
double fried eggs.
- Taylor Ham, Egg And Cheese Sandwich $8.99
3 slices of trenton pork rolls.
- Ham, Egg And Cheese Sandwich $8.09
- Egg And Cheese Sandwich $6.35
double eggs and cheese.
- Avocado Toast $8.99
Fresh avocado on toasted bagel with everything season, red crushed peppers, tomatoes and fresh squeezed lemon Add onions, cucumbers or fresh slices of NOVA LOX
- Sausage & Cheese $9.59
Double Sausage & Double Cheese.
- Bacon And Cheese Sandwich $9.59
6 strips of hotel grade bacon with melted double american cheese.
BorderLine Bagel & Deli Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Checks
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
BorderLine Bagel & Deli Photos










BorderLine Bagel & Deli Location
BorderLine Bagel & Deli
440 Madison Ave., New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
BorderLine Bagel & Deli Reviews
pricesandwichmorningcream cheesemoneyhairtaylor hamtunanamespreads
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1First and last time going here paid $6 for a green bagel and hair in ABSOLUTELY NASTY I picked the green parts of the first half and let it go and ate it but the HAIR WAS THE LAST STRAW I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE TO ANYONE !!
September 23 · Vibeswithniyaareally disappointed and disgusted with Borderline Bagels, while eating my sesame bagel this morning the next bite I was about to take I noticed a black string coming out of the bagel. It ended up not being a string but piece of plastic that melted in the bagel. Future customers definitely beware, I’m not sure of the sanitary conditions of Borderline Bagels and we’ve repeat customers for years but they definitely lose our business.
March 09 · AnnMarieordered a bagel with scallion cream cheese and got some strange green paste with a hair in it, and it was $5. so disgusting couldn’t even eat it.
April 27 · a aHere's a Google review based on your feedback:---⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐I absolutely love Borderline Bagels in Dumont, NJ! The staff is always so nice and friendly, making every visit a pleasant experience. Even though the place gets busy, it's definitely worth the wait. My go-to meal is the Spinach Omelette paired with a refreshing strawberry smoothie—so delicious! If you're ever near Dumont, you have to check this place out. Highly recommended!
April 05 · Steven OsorioWe just picked up breakfast take out from Borderline Bagels. We sat down to eat, opened up the bagel and to our utter disgust and surprise, one of the bagels is COVERED in small black hairs. This is not an exaggeration - no less than a dozen strands of small hairs all over the outside of the bagel and stuck to the paper the bagel is wrapped in. I started taking photos after I pulled the 4th one off. It looks like the bagel was dropped on the floor and then packaged up to be sent home with us. Disgusting.I called this location to inform them that the bagel we just paid for is covered in hair. Their response, literally: “hair? From the floor?” As if they had no idea what I was trying to say. We asked for the manager and the person that picked up the phone either didn’t speak English or acted like they didn’t speak English. It’s hard to believe that neither the employee or the manager spoke English well enough to fix this problem of selling bagels that are covered in dozens of pubic-sized hairs.There are an abundance of bagel and breakfast options in our area. This is the first and very last time we will spend money at this establishment. I do NOT recommend Borderline Bagels. Absolutely disgusting.
August 09 · Ian Williams
More restaurants near me

193 Dixon Ave, Dumont, NJ 07628, USA

370 River Rd, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA

132 Veterans Plaza, Dumont, NJ 07628, USA

49 W Madison Ave, Dumont, NJ 07628, USA

22 Columbia Ave, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA

20 Columbia Ave, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA

84 Washington Ave, Dumont, NJ 07628, USA

181 N Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA

44 E Madison Ave, Dumont, NJ 07628, USA

108 N Washington Ave, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA

49 W Church St, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA

81 W Main St, Bergenfield, NJ 07621, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





