Brooklyn Hero Shop: Your Neighborhood Sandwich Spot in Brooklyn, NY

Brooklyn Hero Shop Introduce

In a city like New York, where every neighborhood boasts its own culinary identity, Brooklyn stands out as a hub for authentic, high-quality food. And when it comes to sandwiches, no ordinary deli will do. Enter Brooklyn Hero Shop, a local institution on Vanderbilt Avenue that has earned its reputation for crafting exceptional sandwiches that are anything but basic. This beloved spot is a testament to the art of the hero, a sandwich style that is a hallmark of New York food culture. With a menu that is both expansive and expertly curated, Brooklyn Hero Shop offers something for everyone, from the classic hero lover to the adventurous eater looking for a unique pressed panini. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot to grab a quick lunch or relax for a moment at an outdoor table. This article will take you on a tour of Brooklyn Hero Shop, exploring its convenient location, the wide range of services it provides, and the standout features that make it a true hero in the borough's food scene.

Brooklyn Hero Shop has built a loyal following on the strength of its menu and the quality of its ingredients. The term "hero" is a classic New York term for a large sandwich, often with Italian ingredients on a long roll, and Brooklyn Hero Shop lives up to the name with every creation. The menu is a feast for the eyes, offering a variety of pressed paninis, chicken heros, vegetarian options, and even breakfast sandwiches served all day. Customer reviews paint a picture of a spot that consistently delivers. One happy patron raved about the "scrumptious" Cold Italian sandwich, and another proclaimed their chicken mole and al pastor tacos to be "incredible." The shop's commitment to quality is evident in its preparation, with one reviewer noting that the roast beef is a "high quality" Wagyu and the sausage "tastes like it was home made." While one review mentioned a less than perfect experience with a fried shrimp sandwich, others passionately defended the value, stating the sandwiches are "worth every penny" despite the prices. The diverse menu also includes a variety of fresh salads, satisfying snacks, and a full coffee and tea menu, making it a comprehensive destination for any meal.

Brooklyn Hero Shop is located at 270 Vanderbilt Ave in Brooklyn, NY 11205, a prime location in the Fort Greene neighborhood. This area is known for its beautiful brownstones and vibrant, local-centric vibe, making the hero shop a natural fit. Its position on Vanderbilt Avenue, a bustling street with local businesses and cafes, makes it a convenient and well-known spot for locals and a great find for tourists. For those traveling by car, there is free street parking available, which is a significant bonus in a busy urban area. While not explicitly mentioned in the provided data, accessibility in a neighborhood like Fort Greene is often well-supported by public transportation, including several nearby bus routes. The shop's easily identifiable address makes it a simple destination to find, whether you're meeting friends or just stopping by for a solo meal. The availability of outdoor seating also adds to its appeal, offering a pleasant spot to enjoy your meal while soaking in the neighborhood's lively atmosphere.

Brooklyn Hero Shop provides a range of service options designed to fit the fast-paced life of a New Yorker, ensuring that getting a great sandwich is always easy and convenient.

Outdoor Seating: The shop offers sidewalk tables, perfect for enjoying your meal outside and engaging in some quintessential New York people-watching.
No-contact Delivery and Delivery: For those who prefer to dine at home or at the office, the shop provides both standard and no-contact delivery services, bringing their delicious heroes right to your door.
Onsite Services: The shop’s ability to cater to dine-in customers with a casual and cozy setting makes it a great place to stay and enjoy your food.
Takeout: A classic option for a reason, takeout is a quick and efficient way to get your food when you're on the go.
Catering: With its diverse menu of sandwiches and salads, Brooklyn Hero Shop is a great option for catering larger events, from office lunches to special gatherings.

Brooklyn Hero Shop has a number of features and highlights that set it apart from other sandwich spots in the city. These unique elements make it a special place to visit.

Fast Service: One of the standout features is its fast service, making it an excellent choice for a quick bite during a busy day. Customers appreciate the efficiency without a compromise on quality.
Popular for Lunch and Solo Dining: The shop is a popular lunch destination for many, and its casual atmosphere is also perfect for solo diners who want to enjoy a quality meal in a comfortable setting.
Diverse Offerings: The menu is far from limited to just sandwiches. Brooklyn Hero Shop also offers an assortment of coffee, beer, wine, and cocktails, as well as comforting snacks like fresh pastries and desserts. They also have a selection of pickles, olives, and other charcuterie staples for sale, which one customer found to be a delightful bonus.
Casual Atmosphere: The vibe is relaxed and unpretentious, creating a space where everyone feels welcome. It’s the kind of place you can pop into for a delicious meal without any fuss.
Payment Options: The shop accepts a variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.
Family-Friendly: The shop is good for kids, with a menu that has something for even the pickiest eaters and a casual environment that is comfortable for families.

For more information or to place an order, you can contact Brooklyn Hero Shop.

Address: 270 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Phone: (718) 576-3958

Choosing Brooklyn Hero Shop is a decision rooted in a desire for quality, authenticity, and a true taste of New York. The positive reviews, which praise everything from the "scrumptious" food to the "super friendly" staff, paint a clear picture of a business that cares about its customers and its craft. The high-quality ingredients, from the in-house roasted turkey to the soft yet crunchy bread, are what elevate a simple sandwich to an extraordinary meal. While some may find the prices on the higher side, a common sentiment is that the quality and portion size make it "worth every penny." This is not just a place for a sandwich; it’s a destination for a delicious and memorable meal. The added bonus of being able to grab some unique Italian grocery items makes it a unique find in the neighborhood. Whether you are a local looking for your new go-to lunch spot or a tourist wanting to experience an authentic slice of Brooklyn life, Brooklyn Hero Shop is a standout choice that delivers on its promise of great food and a welcoming atmosphere.

Brooklyn Hero Shop Menu

Pressed Panini
Turkey Avocado Panino $19.50
Roast turkey, avocado, bacon, w/ roasted pepper aioli
Vegan Panino $18.50
Broccoli rabe, Portobello mushroom, grilled eggplant & balsamic glaze
Chicken Cutlet Cheddar Panino $19.50
Chicken cutlet, cheddar, bacon, avocado, garlic aioli
Tuna Panino $19.50
Italian tuna fish, onion, arugula, lemon basil aioli
Buffalo Chicken Panino $19.50
Chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce, gorgonzola, arugula w a garlic aioli
Fried Shrimp Panino $20.50
Fried shrimp, avocado, bacon & spicy aioli
Spicy Chicken Panino $19.50
Chicken cutlet, cherry peppers, balsamic glaze, spicy aioli
Grilled Chicken Panino $18.50
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & pesto
Steak & Onion Panino $20.50
Grilled rib-eye, sautéed onion, smoked mozzarella w/ a chili aoli
Cuban Panino $19.50
Pulled pork, porchetta, swiss, pickles & mustard

Buffalo Wings
10pc Buffalo Wings $11.95
Crispy Buffalo Wings Served with Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese
20 Buffalo Wings $21.95
Crispy Buffalo Wings Served with Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese

Chicken Heros
Chicken Cutlet Italian Hero $18.50
Served on seeded hero. Chicken cutlet, spicy Calabrian chili aioli, tomato, basil, and arugula.
Buffalo Chicken On A Roll $18.50
Buttermilk fried chicken thighs, spicy Buffalo sauce, Gorgonzola cheese, Romaine, onions & touch of garlic aioli
Korean Fried Chicken Sandwich $18.50
Buttermilk Crispy Fried Chicken Basted in "Yangnyeom" Style Korean Sauce Topped/ Cold Slaw, Pickled Onions finished in a Kimchi Mayo Served on Seeded Roll (Sauce: Soy Sauce-Honey-Gochujang Paste-Ginger Rice Wine-Sesame Oil-Black Sesame Seeds)
Nashville Spicy Crispy Chicken Roll $17.50
Spicy. Served on bun. Crispy spicy fried chicken, hot sauce, coleslaw, and pickles.
Chicken Bruschetta $20.50
Breaded chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella topped w/ tomato, onions & vinaigrette served in a toasted seeded hero
Fried Chicken Club $18.50
Crispy fried chicken thigh, Cheddar , bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato & garlic aolii
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Hero $18.50
Served on seeded hero. Grilled chicken, garlic, broccoli rabe, and cheese.
Chicken Cutlet Rustico $20.50
Breaded chicken cutlet, smoked mozzarella crispy Speck (Smoked Prosciutto) finished in a pesto aioli on a toasted sesame seeded hero
Chicken Parmesan Hero $18.50
Served on seeded hero. Chicken cutlet, sauce, and fresh mozzarella.

Signature Salads
Quinoa Salad $19.50
Quinoa, dried cranberry, chickpeas, toasted pumpkin seed, olives, and raspberry vinaigrette.
Beet Goat Cheese Salad $18.50
Beets, goat cheese, pine nuts, and tomatoes over baby spinach in a raspberry vinaigrette.
Mixed Green Salad $19.50
Mixed greens topped with cucumber, olives, radish, carrots, tomato, and balsamic vinaigrette.
Caprese Salad $19.50
Burrata, sliced tomato, olives, and basil over arugula served with balsamic glaze.
Tuna Salad $18.50
Italian tunafish, olives, shallots, and tomatoes over arugula served with lemon.
Cobb Salad $20.50
Bacon, egg, avocado, gorgonzola, tomato, and onion over romaine with cilantro vinaigrette.
Kale Salad $17.50
Kale, toasted almonds , craisins, shallots, shaved parmesan seeds, and lemon vinaigrette.
Chef's Salad $20.50
Ham, Salami, Provolone, Eggs, Onions, Olives over Romaine served w/ Oil & Vinegar
Arugula & Shaved Parmesan $19.50
Baby arugula, tomatoes, and shaved parmesan in a lemon vinaigrette.
Mexican Salad $19.50
Avocado, roasted corn, tomatoes, bacon, radish, toasted pumpkin seeds, and cilantro vinaigrette.
Chicken Salad $20.50
Sliced chicken breast, mayo, craisins, shallots tomato over toasted Pita
Caesar Salad $17.50
Romain, crouton, and shaved parmesan in Caesar dressing.
Apple & Pecan Salad $19.50
Sugared pecans , apples , craisins, Feta cheese over baby spinach in raspberry vinaigrette

Snacks All Day (Croissants/Donuts/Cookies)
Sfioatelle $4.00
Bambolini Jelly $4.00
Blueberry Muffin $4.00
Coffee Crumb Cake $4.00
Bambolini Plain $4.00
Bambolini Nutella $4.00
Chocolate Croissant $5.00
Bambolini Cannoli $4.00
Plain Croissant $4.00
Apple Turn Over $4.00
Green apple gorgonzola cheese candy walnuts and fried onions over endive.
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.00
Brownie $4.00

Coffee, Tea, & Cold Brews
Regular Coffee $3.75
Single origin.
Nutella Hot Chocolate $6.00
Small Single Espresso $2.75
Iced Latte $5.00
Cappuccino $5.50
Cold Brew 16oz (4 Jacks) $6.00
Cold Chai Latte $5.50
Latte $5.50
Americano $4.50
Nitro Cold Brew 16oz (4 Jacks) $6.00
Cold Brew $4.00
Tea $4.00
Hot Chocolate $5.00
Cortado $6.00
Iced Espresso $5.00
Cold Dirty Chai Latte $5.00
Double Espresso $3.75
Macchiato $3.75

Hal’s Kettle Cooked Bag of Chips 2oz
Hal's NY Kettle Chips $0.00

Turkey Heros
Turkey Philly $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Roasted turkey, cheese, and onions served with roasted pepper aioli.
Hot Turkey & Cheese Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Roasted turkey, cheese, arugula, roast tom, and peppers served with roasted pepper aioli.
Turkey & Avocado On Roll $19.50
Roasted turkey, avocado, cheese, bacon, roasted tomato, served with roasted garlic aioli.

Breakfast Sandwiches All Day
Bacon, Egg Omlet & Cheese On Choice Of Bread (Picture Shown Is 1/2 Everything Panino) $9.00
Crispy bacon, egg omlet, Cheddar cheese, salt, pepper, Mutti Italian ketchup & touch of spicy Calabrian spread

Vegetarian
Roasted Portobello On Roll $18.50
Served on bun. Roasted portobello, roasted tomato, baby spinach, and balsamic glaze.
Spicy Eggplant On Roll $18.50
Spicy. Served on seeded roll. Breaded eggplant, burrata, cherry peppers, balsamic glaze, and chili oil.
Caprese Vegan On Roll $17.50
Served on seeded hero. Grilled eggplant, vine tomato, and basil.
Eggplant Parmesan Hero $18.50
Served on seeded hero. Fried eggplant, sauce, and fresh mozzarella.

Fresh Italian Bread
Brick Oven Baguette $3.50
Seeded Italian Hero Bread $1.75
Round Bread (Large) $5.00

Soft Drinks
Aranciata $3.50
Mexican Coke $4.50
The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water 16oz $3.50
Benedetto Peach Tea $3.50
Benedetto Tea $3.50
Acqua Panna Flat Water 16oz $3.50
Fever Ginger Beer $3.50
Limonata $3.50
Pomegranite Orange $3.50
Coke 16oz Plastic Bottle $3.50
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Manhattan Special Espresso Coffee Soda 12 OZ Glass $4.50
Sprite 16oz Plastic Bottle $3.50
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Ginger Ale 16oz Plastic Bottle $3.50
Blood Orange $3.50
Diet Coke 16oz Plastic Bottle $3.50
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

Cold Heros
Cold Italian Hero $20.50
Hot Cappicola , Genoa Salami, Provelone & Prosciutto Cotto topped w/ Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Banana Peppers served w/ an Italian Vinaigrette
Speck & Burrata Hero $21.50
Thinly sliced Burrata, Arugula, roasted tomato, balsamic glaze & chunks of Grana Padano
Cold Roast Beef Hero $20.50
Wagu roast beef, lettuce, tomato, onions, garlic aioli served on seeded hero
Smoked Salmon & Bel Paese On Roll $19.50
Norwegian smoked salmon, creamy Bel Paese cheese , romaine, pickled onion & fresh dill on a roll
Muffaletta $19.50
“New Orleans” style Muffaletta stuffed w/ Mortadella, Sopresatta, Provelone, Swiss cheese, minced Gardiniera topped w a spicy stuffed pepper served on a seeded roll
Cold Turkey & Cheese Hero $19.50
Oven roasted turkey, Cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion garlic aoli served on seeded hero
Mortadella & Bel Paese On Roll $18.50
Thinly sliced Mortadella, creamy Bel Paese cheese, Arugula, Sicilian pistachio paste on a roll

Shrimp & Fish
Fried Whiting On White $17.50
Triple white bread. Panko fried whiting, lettuce, tomato, and pickled onions, served with roasted garlic aioli.
Fried Shrimp Po Boy Roll $18.50
Served on seeded roll. Fried shrimp, lemon basil aioli, arugula, and tomato.
Tuna Melt On White $18.50
Italian tuna fish, avocado, tomato, and cheese.
Shrimp Parmesan Hero $20.50
Served on seeded hero. Chicken cutlet, sauce, and fresh mozzarella.

Meat
Brisket Philly $20.50
In house roasted beef brisket topped w/ caramelized onions, peppers, touch of gravy & finished w/ Calabrian chili aioli
Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich $20.50
Wagu roast beef, long hots, spicy giardiniera, extra gravy served on seeded hero
Fried Mozz & Bacon On Roll $17.50
Panko & egg battered fried mozzarella, topped w/ Arugula, tomato & crispy bacon finished w/ pesto & roasted pepper aioli
Meatball Parmesan Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Meatballs made of pork and beef, sausage, and fresh mozzarella.
BBQ Brisket On Roll $18.50
Served on bun. Slow roasted dry rubbed brisket with slaw, pickle onions, and BBQ sauce.
Wagyu Roast Beef Hero $20.50
Served on seeded hero. Slow cookied roast beef and caramelized onions, gravy, and cheese.
The Philly Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Chopped steak and caramelized onion and cheese.
Reuben On Rye $19.50
Served on triple rye bread, swiss, slow-cooked corn beef, Sauerkraut, and grainy mustard.

Sausage & Porchetta
Sausage & Peppers Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Sweet Italian sausage, sauteed peppers, onions, and garlic.
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Sweet Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, and cherry peppers served with spicy chili oil.
Pulled Pork BBQ On Roll $18.50
Pulled pork, slaw, pickled onions, pickles, and BBQ sauce. No cheese recommended.
Porchetta & Rabe Hero $20.50
Served on seeded hero. Sliced roasted herbed pork with rabe, pesto, cherry peppers, and your choice of cheese (Fontina recommended).
BLTA (Bacon-Lettuce-Tomato-Avocado) $18.50
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Avocado on Triple White Bread / Garlic Aioli
Sausage Parmesan Hero $19.50
Served on seeded hero. Sweet Italian sausage topped with sauce and fresh mozzarella.

Desserts All Day
Nutella Panna Cotta $7.00
Panna Cotta is a popular chilled Italian dessert made of cream (and often milk) that is sweetened with sugar, flavored with vanilla and uses gelatin to thicken
Chocolate Cheesecake $7.00
Mixed Berry Tart $7.00
Shortcrust pastry base filled with pastry cream, topped with a layer of sponge cake and lavishly garnished with an assortment of berries: blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, red currants and strawberries.
Italian Cannoli $7.00
Thin wafer crust stuffed sweetened ricotta cream and chocolate chips.
Tortina Della Nonna $7.00
A smaller version of our Grandmother Cake. Shortcrust pastry filled with pastry cream, topped with pine nuts, almonds and powdered sugar
Tiramisu $7.00
Coffee-soaked cake with chocolate and mascarpone cheese.
Pistachio Cheesecake $7.00
creamy pistachio cheesecake with pistachio pieces, topped w/ a light pistachio mousse and sprinkled with pistachios, on a graham cracker base
Chocolate Dipped Italian Cannoli $7.00
Thin wafer crust stuffed with sweetened Ricotta cream and chocolate chips.
Sour Cherry Panna Cotta $7.00
Panna Cotta is a popular chilled Italian dessert made of cream (and often milk) that is sweetened with sugar, flavored with vanilla and uses gelatin to thicken
Strawberry Cheese Cake $7.00
Vanilla Eclair $6.00
Salted Caramel Panna Cotta $7.00
Panna Cotta is a popular chilled Italian dessert made of cream (and often milk) that is sweetened with sugar, flavored with vanilla and uses gelatin to thicken
Chocolate Eclair $6.00

Brooklyn Hero Shop Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Lunch
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Locals
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free street parking

Brooklyn Hero Shop Photos

Brooklyn Hero Shop Location

Brooklyn Hero Shop

New York Kings County Clinton Hill Vanderbilt Avenue

270 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA

Brooklyn Hero Shop Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 327 user reviews.

porchettabroccoli rabegroceriesitalian sandwichcutletitalian heropastriesdonutsnashville hot chickenmuffaletta

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

What a lovely spot! I had the Cold Italian sandwich and it was scrumptious, and if I lived in the neighborhood I would absolutely be there all the time to stock up on pickles and olives and other charcuterie staples. And the sidewalk tables are perfect for people (and dog!) watching
June 14 · veena rangaswami
Honestly was expecting more because their prices are high. I got this fried shrimp sandwich. It was very mediocre, it lacked of flavor, the bread was so dry. It was very expensive for what it is. The service was good! The workers were nice at least.
July 24 · David Cabanzo
Steep prices but the sandwiches are extraordinary and the owner is a kind soul. The turkey is roasted in house and the softest juiciest I've ever had in a sandwich. By far the best gluten free roll I've had a sandwich on and no reaction to any cross contamination. We came here from across the country on our honeymoon and have found a place we'll be sure to come back to.
September 14 · AyrtonT
The vibe at Brooklyn Hero Shop is just as good as their sandwiches. I got a Reuben that was out of this world, and my wife raved about the Nashville hot chicken. The staff was so friendly and genuine, making the whole experience really enjoyable. It's clear they care about their customers and their food. If you're looking for a delicious lunch and a welcoming atmosphere, this is your spot.
March 11 · Eric Zeak
Actively chewing the porcetta sandwich as I write this because it’s easily one of the best, freshest sandwiches I’ve ever had
September 19 · Remy Feldman