Brother’s Pizza

- 233 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928

For New York residents in the Highland Falls area, Brother’s Pizza is a cherished local institution recognized for delivering authentic and delicious New York-style pizza at highly affordable prices. Functioning as both a classic Pizza Restaurant and a straightforward Italian Restaurant, it provides a cozy, casual spot for locals, groups, tourists, and military personnel from nearby West Point to grab a satisfying meal.

The core of the menu is the beloved pizza, available by the regular slice or as a whole pie. Customers consistently praise the pizza for being "authentic and delicious," making it a favorite stop for a quick bite. Beyond pizza, the menu offers a concise selection of Italian-American staples, including calzones stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, hot sandwiches like Meatballs and Sausages, and fresh salads, ensuring a complete and satisfying meal experience.

While the quality of the food and the pricing are significant draws, the dining experience has been noted for its inconsistency in customer interaction. One customer reported a piece of plastic wrap on their pizza (attributed to dough resting) and, more notably, described uncomfortable interactions with an older male staff member during their dine-in visit. As such, while the food is highly recommended, patrons who prefer to avoid potentially awkward interpersonal situations may find the takeout service a safer bet, a pragmatic recommendation for local users.

Overall, Brother's Pizza is defined by its great food and excellent value, securing its reputation as the "best place for pizza around" for many in Highland Falls, a testament to its product quality and affordability.

Brother’s Pizza is centrally located on Main Street in Highland Falls, placing it directly within the town’s main hub of activity and ensuring it is easily accessible to both pedestrians and drivers.

• Address: 233 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928

The location offers good options for parking, a key consideration for dining in the area. Patrons can utilize the free parking lot, which is available on-site, as well as free street parking in the vicinity. For those with mobility needs, the restaurant provides essential accessibility features, including a wheelchair-accessible parking lot and wheelchair-accessible seating, creating a welcoming environment for all members of the community.

The atmosphere inside is described as casual and cozy, making it suitable for quick lunch visits or a relaxed dinner. The availability of a bar on-site also adds a potential feature for adult patrons looking to pair their Italian meal with an alcoholic beverage.

Brother’s Pizza maintains a focused service model that prioritizes the core dining and quick-meal experience, with an emphasis on speed and convenience:

• Takeout: The most direct way to enjoy their highly-rated pizza and Italian food at home or on the go.
• Dine-in: Provides seating for a casual, cozy lunch or dinner experience.
• Bar Onsite: Offers alcohol for patrons who wish to enjoy beer or other beverages with their meal.
• Counter Service: Facilitates quick purchases, especially for the popular Plain Slice or 1 Item Slice.
• Quick Bite Focus: The entire operation is geared toward fast service and quick turnaround, perfect for solo diners or groups on a schedule.
• Payment Versatility: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for streamlined transactions.
• Catering to Groups: The atmosphere and offerings are well-suited for family-friendly gatherings and groups of tourists or locals.

Brother’s Pizza has several distinctive features that establish it as a local favorite for New York residents and visitors in the Highland Falls area:

• Authentic NY Style Pizza: The primary highlight is the genuinely delicious and authentic New York-style pizza, available whole or by the affordable slice ($1.62 for a Plain Slice).
• Exceptional Affordability: The pricing across the menu is noted as very affordable, offering great value, especially when compared to similar options in the broader New York region.
• Fast Service: Recognized as a "Highlights" feature, ensuring minimal waiting time for orders, which is ideal for a quick lunch or dinner.
• Cozy and Casual Atmosphere: The dining environment is described as casual and cozy, making it a comfortable and unpretentious place to eat.
• Traditional Italian Staples: Features classic, comforting Italian food beyond pizza, including stuffed calzones, hot Meatball and Sausage sandwiches, and a full Antipasto Salad.
• Convenient Accessibility: The availability of on-site free parking and full accessibility (wheelchair accessible seating and parking) makes it easy for the entire community to visit.
• Family and Group Friendly: The large pizza portions and casual setting, coupled with being "Good for kids," make it a reliable choice for families and large groups.

For placing a takeout order, inquiring about the daily specials, or confirming current operating hours, please use the contact information provided below. Given the emphasis on takeout, calling ahead for whole pies or larger orders is recommended.

• Phone: (845) 446-4988
• Mobile Phone: +1 845-446-4988
• Address: 233 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928

Brother’s Pizza is absolutely worth choosing for any New York user in or near Highland Falls who prioritizes authentic New York-style pizza and Italian comfort food at an unbeatable price point. It’s the quintessential local pizzeria experience—quick, cozy, and high-quality in terms of the food itself.

The primary reason to choose Brother’s is the **Authentic NY Style Pizza and Slices**. At $1.62 for a plain slice, it is an extremely budget-friendly and delicious option for a quick, classic New York lunch or snack. The menu is perfectly balanced for simplicity and satisfaction, focusing on what they do best: traditional pizza, calzones, and hearty hot sandwiches.

While the highly-rated food and affordability make it a top recommendation, patrons planning to dine in should be mindful of the customer reviews regarding atmosphere and personal interaction. If a user is highly sensitive to potentially awkward service or unfriendliness, opting for a quick takeout order remains the best way to secure the delicious, highly affordable pizza while minimizing any potential discomfort, allowing the superior quality of the food to speak for itself.

Brother’s Pizza

233 Main St, Highland Falls, NY 10928, USA