Brothers Barbecue

- 2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553

For New Yorkers seeking out authentic, pit-smoked barbecue and hearty Southern-style comfort food, Brothers Barbecue in New Windsor, NY, stands as a premier destination in the Hudson Valley. This establishment is much more than a typical restaurant; it is a place where the craft of low-and-slow smoking is taken seriously, resulting in meats that are tender, flavorful, and deeply smoky. As part of the "Smoken All Day" family, Brothers Barbecue lives up to its name by delivering a barbecue experience built on flavor, heart, and commitment to quality.

The menu at Brothers Barbecue is a testament to the diversity of American barbecue and Southern cuisine. Guests can indulge in standout offerings like pepper-crusted, hickory-smoked brisket and legendary ribs that practically fall off the bone. Beyond the pit, the kitchen offers up beloved classics such as Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken, Shrimp Po Boys, and indulgent sides like Fried Mac and Cheese Balls, Big Jay's Collard Greens, and French Toast Bread Pudding for dessert. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and trendy, making it an ideal gathering spot for locals, tourists, and groups looking for a vibrant dining experience. With a full bar, a great selection of beers and cocktails, and amenities like a fireplace and sports viewing, Brothers Barbecue provides a truly well-rounded experience in the heart of the New Windsor area.

Brothers Barbecue is conveniently located in the scenic New Windsor area, making it easily accessible for residents and visitors traveling through Orange County. The restaurant’s address is a key spot off a main thoroughfare: 2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553.

The restaurant prides itself on being fully accommodating to all guests, emphasizing excellent accessibility features:

• Parking Convenience: Patrons have the choice of a complimentary free parking lot, ensuring easy access right near the entrance, in addition to available free street parking.
• Full Accessibility: The location is equipped with a wheelchair accessible entrance, a designated wheelchair accessible parking lot, wheelchair accessible seating, and a wheelchair accessible restroom, providing comfort and ease of access for everyone.
• Location Highlights: Situated on NY-32, the location offers a perfect stop for those traveling or looking for a casual dining spot to meet up with friends and family.

Understanding the needs of the dynamic New York community, Brothers Barbecue offers a flexible and comprehensive range of services:

• Dining Options: Offering a full spectrum of dining opportunities, including Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert. The establishment provides comfortable indoor seating, complemented by friendly table service.
• Outdoor Seating: Guests can enjoy their smoked favorites and cocktails outside, taking advantage of the pleasant New York weather and the casual, cozy ambiance.
• Convenient Pick-Up and Delivery: For those on a tight schedule, services include both easy Takeout and Curbside Pickup. They also provide local Delivery service for the utmost convenience.
• Catering: Brothers Barbecue provides an extensive catering service, making their acclaimed smoked meats, sides, and specialties available for parties, corporate events, and large gatherings.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, an excellent amenity for groups or those planning a visit during peak dining hours.

Brothers Barbecue sets itself apart with several outstanding features, elevating the dining experience beyond the food itself:

• High-Quality Smoked Meats: Their core strength lies in their pit-smoked menu, featuring melt-in-your-mouth Brisket with a perfect bark, tender Pulled Pork, Smoked Yard Bird (half chicken), and the "Brothers Legendary" Ribs (available in Half and Full Racks).
• Southern Specialty Dishes: The menu features genuine Southern comfort offerings, including "Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken" and "Mama's Shrimp Grits," alongside unique appetizers like Beaufort Shrimp and Bacon Burnt Ends.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: The location boasts a Bar Onsite with a great selection of Beer, Cocktails, Hard Liquor, and Wine, making it a perfect spot to unwind. They also offer a dedicated selection of non-alcoholic beverages, coffee, and sweet tea.
• Unique Atmosphere and Amenities: The atmosphere is described as Casual, Cozy, and Trendy. A notable highlight is the Fireplace, which provides a warm and inviting ambiance, particularly on cooler New York evenings.
• Fast and Attentive Service: The staff is noted for providing fast service, ensuring happy and satisfied guests, a quality which is particularly appreciated by those on a time constraint during lunch or dinner.
• Sports Viewing: The "Sports" highlight indicates the venue is a great place to catch a game while enjoying delicious food and a cold drink.
• Family-Friendly Focus: The restaurant is "Good for kids," offering High Chairs and a dedicated Kids' Menu with popular items such as Kids Nuggets, Mac & Cheese, and Kids Ribs.

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services, you can contact the New Windsor location directly:

• Address: 2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States
• Phone: (845) 534-4227

For the New York regional barbecue enthusiast, choosing Brothers Barbecue is choosing quality, authenticity, and an enjoyable dining environment. The pitmaster's commitment to low-and-slow smoking is evident in every bite, from the tender Brisket to the fall-off-the-bone Ribs—the meats are truly the star of the show. Many customers opt for the 2 or 3 Meat Combos, which allow for a substantial and satisfying sample of the best the pit has to offer.

What makes Brothers Barbecue a standout choice is the combination of exceptional food with outstanding amenities. The casual, cozy, and trendy setting, complete with a full bar and a fireplace, transforms a simple meal into a memorable outing. It is a true local specialty, providing a taste of deep Southern flavors right here in the Hudson Valley. Moreover, the accommodating nature of the business—from its full wheelchair accessibility and free parking to its ability to serve breakfast, brunch, and catering—makes it a reliably excellent choice for any occasion, whether it’s a quick solo dinner or a large group gathering. The positive, attentive service, as noted by happy customers, ensures that your experience, from seating to the final dessert of French Toast Bread Pudding Ala Mode, will be nothing short of delightful.

Brothers Barbecue

2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA