Craft Taqueria New City NY: Gourmet Tacos, Craft Beer, and Family Dining

Craft Taqueria Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For New York residents in Rockland County, the search for a truly exceptional Mexican dining experience often leads to Craft Taqueria in New City. More than just a local taco spot, this establishment has quickly become a premier destination for those seeking a fresh, elevated, and "craft" take on classic Mexican and Southwestern cuisine. Located conveniently on South Main Street, Craft Taqueria blends a trendy, cozy atmosphere with a serious dedication to quality ingredients, making it a favorite among locals, groups, and families.

The restaurant's core identity revolves around its namesake: innovative, gourmet tacos. While you can find traditional favorites, the menu shines with unique offerings like Birria Tacos, Grilled Spanish Octopus Tacos, and creative vegetarian selections, ensuring that all diners—including those with dietary preferences—find something truly exciting. Beyond the tacos, the commitment to "craft" extends to the beverage menu, which features a well-curated selection of local Craft Beer, House-Made Sangrias, and refreshing Agua Frescas. This dual focus on quality food and drink, all served with genuinely friendly and attentive service, is what defines Craft Taqueria’s unique place in the New City dining scene. It is a place where every meal, whether a quick bite or a full dinner, feels like a special occasion.

Location and Accessibility

Craft Taqueria is ideally situated at 170 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA. This central location in New City places it right in the middle of a vibrant Rockland County corridor, making it a convenient stop for a mid-day lunch or an evening out. The restaurant’s presence on South Main Street ensures easy driving access for patrons coming from neighboring towns throughout the region.

The establishment takes accessibility seriously, a major benefit for all guests in the busy New York metro area. It provides a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance, a Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, a Wheelchair Accessible Restroom, and Wheelchair Accessible Seating, ensuring a welcoming experience for everyone. Furthermore, for the convenience of its driving customers, Craft Taqueria offers both a Free Parking Lot and Free Street Parking. Inside, the layout supports its comfortable and trendy atmosphere while maintaining easy flow, featuring a Gender-neutral restroom and standard Restroom facilities for all patrons.

Services Offered

Craft Taqueria is built around flexible service to accommodate a modern, on-the-go New York lifestyle. From casual dining to large-scale events, they offer a comprehensive range of ways to enjoy their acclaimed Mexican cuisine:

Dining Flexibility: Offers Lunch and Dinner service, including options for Seating inside and a beautiful, coveted Outdoor seating area.
Service Types: Provides Delivery (including DoorDash and Grubhub), Takeout, and traditional Dine-in service, along with convenient Counter service for quick ordering.
Event and Group Services: Specializes in Catering for parties and events, offering large format items like Party Traditional Guacamole 32oz and Party Salsa Roja 32oz.
Beverage Program: Features a full bar with Alcohol, Beer, Wine, and Happy hour drinks.
Payment Options: Accepts a wide array of payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments.
Family Focus: A dedicated Kids' menu (CRAFT KIDS) is available, featuring options like Kid's Organic Grilled Chicken Tacos and Kid's Quesadillas, supported by the availability of High chairs and the restaurant being Good for kids.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Craft Taqueria apart for the discerning New York diner is its commitment to both culinary excellence and a superior guest experience:

Gourmet Taco Focus: The menu is a highlight, featuring high-quality ingredients in creative combinations such as Black Angus Skirt Steak Tacos, Marinated Shrimp Tacos, and the popular Birria Tacos.
Commitment to Quality: Strong emphasis is placed on healthy and fresh options, including Healthy options, Organic dishes, and a welcoming variety of Vegetarian options like the highly-rated Crispy Cauliflower tacos.
Atmosphere and Vibe: The restaurant has a distinct personality, described as Casual, Cozy, and Trendy. The open kitchen concept has been praised by patrons for contributing to an engaging, welcoming environment.
Speed and Service: Known for Fast service and an exceptionally Friendly and Attentive staff, ensuring a smooth and pleasant dining experience even during peak hours.
Beverage & Snack Variety: An impressive selection of non-alcoholic drinks, including four varieties of Agua Fresca (like the refreshing Pineapple Agua Fresca and Hibiscus Agua Fresca), complements the robust Booze list featuring craft beers and house sangria.
Group and Planning Amenities: Caters well to Groups and Family-friendly crowds, and notably Accepts reservations, a key feature for planning meals out in the busy New York area.

Contact Information

For reservations, catering inquiries, or to place an order for delivery or pickup, local New York patrons in Rockland County can reach Craft Taqueria using the details below:

Address: 170 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

Phone: (845) 499-2211

Mobile Phone: +1 845-499-2211

What is Worth Choosing

For those new to Craft Taqueria in New City, the best way to experience the restaurant’s dedication to elevated Mexican cuisine is by sampling a combination of their fresh, house-made items and standout tacos. The obvious first choice should be the Craft Tacos—specifically, the Black Angus Skirt Steak Tacos or the acclaimed Birria Tacos for meat-eaters, which are often cited as incredibly satisfying. For vegetarians, the Crispy Cauliflower tacos are a must-try, noted by customers as creative, beautifully presented, and flavorful—a far cry from an 'afterthought' dish.

No visit is complete without one of their shareable appetizers. The Traditional Guacamole & Chips is done right, featuring bright flavors and great chunks of fresh avocado. Alternatively, for a unique twist, the Mango Wasabi Guacamole & Chips offers a creative flavor profile that perfectly exemplifies the "craft" in their name. To drink, opt for a refreshing, house-made beverage such as the Pineapple Agua Fresca or enjoy the half-price Sangria special on Wednesdays. For those looking to share a larger meal, one of the Larger Plates like the Adobo Chicken or the premium SKIRT STEAK 12oz provides a generous, high-quality entrée experience, ensuring every guest leaves feeling "amazingly satisfied." The combination of fresh ingredients, gourmet execution, and a genuinely warm atmosphere makes Craft Taqueria a top choice for authentic, elevated Mexican dining in the New York region.

Craft Taqueria Menu

Drinks
Pineapple Agua Fresca $5.40
House Made
Mango Agua Fresca $5.40
House made
Unsweetened Ice Tea $2.40
Hibiscus Agua Fresca $5.40
House made
Mexican Sprite $4.80
A lemon-lime soda made with real cane sugar and bottled in Mexico.
Mineragua $3.60
Sparkling mineral water
Coffee $3.60
Bottled Water $2.40
Mexican Coke $4.80
The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
Jarritos $4.20
We have a variety of flavors available!
Diet Coke $4.50
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

Larger Plates
Adobo Chicken $31.20
Half chicken marinated in house-made adobo, cooked under a brick. Served with Mexican rice and coleslaw
SKIRT STEAK 12oz $45.90
Black garlic marinade, grilled to order. Served with Mexican rice and coleslaw
SAUTEED SHRIMP & CHORIZO $31.20
6 shrimp marinated in roasted garlic-chipotle mojo, house made chorizo. Served with Mexican rice and coleslaw

SHAREABLE
Traditional Guacamole & Chips $17.40
Mango Wasabi Guacamole & Chips $18.00
Tortilla Chips & Roasted Tomatillo Salsa $9.90
Craft Nachos $18.00
Oaxaca cheese, house made chorizo, lime crema, cilantro, and pickled jalapenos.
Party Traditional Guacamole 32oz $44.70
Includes 4 bags of house made tortilla chips
Party Salsa Roja 32oz $30.00
Includes 4 bags of house made tortilla chips
Party Mango Wasabi Guacamole 32oz $45.60
Includes 4 bags of house made tortilla chips
Crispy Vidalia Onion Rings $15.90
Crispy Vidalia Onion Rings- buttermilk battered to order, roasted garlic-chipotle aioli.
Tortilla Chips And Salsa Roja $9.90
House made salsa roja
Crab Empanadas $22.80
Hand pressed empanadas made with premium blue lump crabmeat & heirloom corn masa, served with epazote crema & roasted garlic-chipotle aioli

Booze
Juntos $10.80
Round Table Brewery German Style Pilsner 5.3% ABV PHOTO ID REQUIRED AT PICK UP
White Sangria $10.80
Passion fruit, mango, green apple (Photo ID required at pick-up)
Cerveza Pacifico $7.20
(ID required at pick-up)
Red Sangria $10.80
Hibiscus, strawberry, orange (Photo ID required at pick-up)
Aurora Fresh To Death IPA $10.80
ID required on pickup. 6.6% Northewst IPA
Art Of Storytelling IPA $10.80
ID required at pickup. 6.1% Northeast IPA
Farm & Fare Cabernet Sauvignon $24.00
Round Table Brewing Alto Lindo $8.40
ID Required at pickup. Rustic ale, refreshing lemon undertones. 7.2% Abv
Wild East Standard Deviation Stout $10.80
ID required at Pickup. Award winning Oatmeal stout. 6% Abv.
Amicone Pinot Grigio Bottle $24.00
District 96 Amerikanisch $10.80
ID required at pickup. 4.8% German Kolsch style beer with notes of lemon, citrus and malt.
Jose Cuervo Caleta Classic Margarita $10.80
Wine based cocktail with real lime and blue agave. 8.4oz 13.9%ABV (ID required at pick-up)
Modelo Especial $7.20
(ID required at pick-up)
Corona $7.20
(ID required at pick-up)
Cava $13.20

CRAFT KIDS
Kid's Quesadillas $13.20
Cheese quesadillas - served 3 per order with queso fresco and lime crema
Kid's Organic Grilled Chicken Tacos $15.60
Grilled chicken tacos - served 3 per order with queso fresco and lime crema
Kid's Ground Black Angus Steak Tacos $15.60
Ground black angus skirt steak tacos - served 3 per order with queso fresco and lime crema

Specials
Blood Orange Agua Fresca $6.00
Seasonal Vegetable Of The Day: Crispy Brussels Sprouts $12.00
Warm chorizo vinaigrette, Maldon sea salt, fresh herbs
Meyer Lemon Olive Oil Cake $10.80
House made served with strawberry blackberry compote & whipped cream
North American Bison Chili (GF) $14.40
Free roaming, all-natural North American bison from Fossil Farms, toasted Mexican chilies, fire roasted poblano peppers, cerveza, plum tomatoes, black & red beans. Served with lime crema, queso fresco, & pickled red onions. Available by the bowl or as a large plate served over rice.
Crispy Vidalia Onion Rings $14.40
Crispy Vidalia Onion Rings- buttermilk battered to order, roasted garlic-chipotle aioli.

Prepared Foods
16oz Black Bean Soup $14.40
Chili Arbol Hot Sauce $6.00
5.5oz container of fresh house made hot sauce
Bacon Marmalade 4oz Jar $12.00
Habanero Hot Sauce $6.00
5.5oz container of fresh house made hot sauce
Craft Granola $10.80
Gluten-free Mexican-inspired wholesome granola. Made with gluten-free whole grain oats, organic whole grain amaranth, whole cashews, pepitas, organic unsweetened coconut, pure honey, olive oil, dried cherries, brown sugar, pure vanilla extract, cinnamon, salt.
Tomato Jam 4oz Jar $9.60
House Made Chorizo 1lb $12.00
Uncooked, house made chorizo.

Craft Tacos
Birria Tacos $25.80
Local Black Angus short ribs and oxtail stewed with Mexican chilies herbs and spices, melted Oaxaca cheese, pickled red onions, served with the beef broth for dipping.
Organic Chicken Tacos $21.90
Goffle Road Farm chicken, roasted tomatillo salsa, grilled pineapple pico de gallo
Marinated Shrimp Tacos $23.40
Roasted garlic-chipotle mojo, pickled vegetables, bacon marmalade
Grilled Spanish Octopus Tacos $26.40
House made chorizo, epazote crema, crispy sweet potato
Black Angus Skirt Steak Tacos $25.80
Black garlic marinade, roasted poblano and avocado salsa, queso fresco
Baja Style Wild Alaskan Cod Tacos $23.40
Tempura battered fish fillet, Mexican coleslaw, chipotle crema
Crispy Cauliflower $21.90
Yogurt and Meyer lemon marinated cauliflower, roasted piquillo pepper romesco, toasted almonds, golden raisins, and fresh herbs.
Harvest Tacos $21.90
Roasted cheyote squash, charred eggplant, tomato jam, house made requesón cheese and toasted pepitas
Yellowfin Tuna Tartare $23.40
Soy-ginger dressing, daikon radish, mango-wasabi guacamole in a crispy wonton shell
Carnitas Tacos $22.20
Crispy pork confit, peach & mango salsa, fresh picked cilantro

Salads
Beet Salad Organic $15.60
Orange supremes, requesón cheese, candied pepitas, shaved red onion, aged sherry vinaigrette
Organic Baby Kale $15.60
Crispy quinoa, avocado, requesón cheese, red onion, citrus-herb vinaigrette

Sides
Roasted Tomatillo Salsa $3.60
Side Roasted Poblano Avocado Salsa $5.40
Side Salsa Roja $3.60
Bag Of Tortilla Chips $3.60
Fresh tortilla chips
Roasted Garlic Chipotle Aioli $0.90
Side Mango Wasabi Guacamole $5.40
Side Of Bacon Marmalade $4.20
Mexican Cole Slaw $7.20
Red and nappa cabbages, pico de gallo, lime, chipotle mayo
Rice & Pinto Beans $7.80
Cotija cheese and herbs
Hand Pressed Tortillas (3) $2.40
Side Traditional Guacamole $5.40
Side Lime Crema $1.20

Dessert
Craft Churros $12.00
Served with your choice of house made espresso-chocolate or dulce de leche dipping sauce
Craft Flan $9.60
Whipped cream, candied pepitas

Soup
Black Bean Soup $9.60
Lime crema, applewood smoked bacon

Merch
Craft Hoodies $48.00
This cotton/poly hooded sweatshirt is cozy, soft and warm. It has a drawstring hood and a kangeroo front pocket.
Craft Taqueria Logo T-Shirt $30.00
Now in vintage stonewash denim! This high quality regular fit tee is made with a super soft tri-blend fabric (50% polyester, 25% combed ringspun cotton, 25% rayon) making it extremely comfy - once you put it on, you won't want to take it off. Machine wash cold; tumble dry. Do not iron printed areas. Unisex. Image 1: Back, Image 2: Front, Image 3: Sizing Chart.

TORTAS/SANDWICHES
Spicy Chicken Milanesa Torta $23.40
Breaded chicken breast, black beans, melted Oaxaca cheese, avocado, locally grown pickled hot peppers, roasted garlic-chipotle aioli, garlic toasted ciabatta
Torta Chorizo $21.60
House made chorizo, black beans, Mexican coleslaw, Oaxaca cheese, pickled jalapenos, served on a garlic toasted ciabatta
Torta Black Angus Skirt Steak $28.80
Black garlic, melted Oaxaca cheese, crispy shallots, pickled jalapenos, roasted garlic-chipotle aioli.

Craft Taqueria Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Healthy options
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Locals
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Craft Taqueria Photos

Craft Taqueria Location

Craft Taqueria

New York Rockland County New City South Main Street

170 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

Craft Taqueria Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 442 user reviews.

chefmangochurrossteak tacossangriacauliflower tacoscarnitas tacoscarrot caketuna tacoswasabi

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Food, Service, and Atmosphere were all 5 stars!First off, the staff were very friendly, attentive and I appreciated the open and welcoming atmosphere that they gave off! They made sure we had everything we needed and more, checking on us and often giving us a glance in case we needed anything else.The food was very filling but even after ordering Nachos, Birria Tacos, Tacos with Black Angus Skirt Steak, and Arroz con Tres Leches, we felt amazingly satisfied. The Nachos we felt could've had a little more chorizo but the chips themselves were very Crunchy.We also ordered one Jarrito, one Sangria, and Pineapple Agua Fresca which were all refreshing. We were curious about the Pineapple Fresca as it tasted like it was straight Pineapple juice. The price we also felt was a lot for what felt like a small but it was delicious and refreshing nonetheless. The Sangria on Wednesdays is half off which almost made us order two but we held off as we were all set.The architecture was beautiful and almost felt authentic, I loved the feel of the open kitchen concept as we saw the staff working, laughing, conversing, and it looked like they genuinely liked their jobs. Not one person was standing around even when we were the only 2 in the entire dining area. Which changed in a matter of 10 minutes the dining room filled with other customers. The customer quickly sat themselves and 1 needed an extra chair for their party of 5 which the employee quickly pulled from somewhere which was great as no other table or chairs were missing from other tables.On top of all that they also do Door Dash and to-go orders.We would recommend going here if you haven't already as this is our now go-to spot for all things Mexican. Thank you to the staff for your amazing service. 👏🏼
July 23 · Zaid Anaid
Not that they need another 5 star review to help get their business but here’s one anyway! This place is outstanding. Had their short rib arepa the other night and was truly taken aback by how flavorful and tender it was. My husband is a vegetarian and often times the selections for him feel more like an after thought but not here—his cauliflower tacos were creative, beautifully presented and tasty. The guacamole is done right with bright flavors and great chunks of avocado and the watermelon agua Fresca was so good we got another to go.
July 07 · Gina Sloman
Craft Taqueria is an absolute gem. You can truly feel the chef’s love and respect for Mexican cuisine in every bite.This is how you celebrate culture through food—elevating the flavors and traditions without losing their authenticity.As a second-generation Mexican-American family, finding a place like this means everything. The flavors are authentic, the ingredients are fresh, and the passion behind every dish shines through. The birria tacos are to die for—perfectly tender, flavorful, and comforting. And the steak torta? Hands down the best we’ve ever had, anywhere.We feel so lucky to have such an incredible Mexican inspired restaurant on this side of the bridge. It’s food made with heart, and you can taste it. Gracias, Craft Taqueria. 💛🌮
July 14 · Rosa Valencia
Unreal...By far my favorite taco place. They never miss here. Everything on the menu is so good and that's not sarcastic you really can not go wrong here. DO NOT SLEEP ON THE SPECIALS!!! I've been here quite a few times and have tried a lot of them but this arepa was insane I didn't want it to end. The prices are definitely on the higher side put the portions are generous and quality for that price point is a steal. Amazing thing going on in the kitchen here so do not hesitate to come here and definitely try as much as you can.
May 11 · Matthew Blewitt
The food is good. Staff is very nice. The empanada shell is so good. Everything is made in-house I believe. The birria Ramen is what I expected. We'll definitely be back to try the other stuff on the menu. By the way, if you ever stop by, don't forget to ge the lemongrass iced tea. It was very refreshing.
March 18 · Maruel Villegas