Cutest Cookies

- 1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers searching for the ultimate personalized sweet treat, look no further than Cutest Cookies, a highly-regarded cookie shop and bakery located right on Staten Island. This women-owned business has built a loyal following over more than ten years by specializing in elaborately decorated cookie party favors for virtually every special occasion. From birthdays to religious milestones and everything in between, Cutest Cookies is dedicated to helping customers create a memorable and delicious focal point for their celebrations. What truly sets this local gem apart is its unwavering commitment to safety and quality: the bakery operates as a 100% nut-free facility, providing peace of mind for families managing nut allergies while still offering a high-quality product made with the best, freshest ingredients.

The core product is a buttery sugar cookie, freshly baked, hand-rolled, and hand-decorated by their team of cookie artists. They pride themselves on not stocking cookies; instead, every single order is baked and decorated just a few days before pick-up or shipping to ensure maximum freshness. This dedication results in treats that not only look fantastic but also taste "real yummy," as noted by the business itself. Their mission is simple yet effective: to provide top-tier products with equally excellent customer service, making the process of ordering custom treats seamless and enjoyable.

Cutest Cookies has firmly established itself as a staple in the New York bakery scene, particularly for those on Staten Island and beyond who require bespoke, high-quality, and allergy-conscious options for their events. Their commitment extends beyond the product, as they are a fully insured, licensed, and inspected bakery by the New York City Health Department, adding an extra layer of trust and professionalism.

Location and Accessibility

Cutest Cookies operates a storefront bakery at its main location, making in-person service and order pick-up convenient for the New York community. The bakery is situated at a well-known address in Staten Island, ensuring relative ease of access for both local residents and visitors traveling from other boroughs. Being located within New York City allows them to cater to the diverse and demanding events market of the metropolitan area.

The official address for this delightful cookie shop is:

1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

The bakery's standard hours of operation during the week are designed to accommodate order processing and pick-ups. They are open:

Monday - Friday: 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.

It is important for customers planning a visit or order pick-up to note that weekend hours may vary seasonally or by appointment, and it is always best practice to call the bakery directly to confirm weekend availability.

For service options, the bakery focuses on custom orders for events. They offer both convenient in-store pickup and in-store shopping during their operating hours, allowing customers to consult on designs and collect their sweet creations. It is important for clients to be aware that payment at the store is currently cash-only.

Services Offered

Cutest Cookies provides a focused range of services centered entirely on custom-decorated cookies and related treats for celebrations. Their offerings are designed to cover the full spectrum of personal and corporate events. They specialize in transforming their delicious butter sugar cookies into custom party favors tailored exactly to the theme and color scheme of the customer's event. Services include:

• Custom Decorated Cookie Party Favors: Hand-decorated cookies created to match any party theme, perfect for guests to take home.
• DIY Cookie Decorating Kits: Custom kits that include pre-baked cookies, icing, and decorations, allowing customers and their guests to enjoy a fun, interactive activity. One customer specifically praised these kits for being a great party favor that kids enjoy decorating and eating.
• Themed Cookie Collections: A vast selection of pre-designed cookies categorized by popular themes and occasions, simplifying the selection process for customers.
• Packaging and Presentation: All cookies are individually wrapped in clear cellophane bags and tied with a matching curling ribbon for a professional and elegant finish, ensuring they stay fresh for up to one month.
• Design Consultation: Customers can call or email the bakery to discuss design options and ensure their cookie favors perfectly match their party vision.
• Specialized Event Cookies: Extensive collections for holidays, seasons, and major life events, including Baby, Religious, Wedding, Birthday, Graduation, Sweet 16, and seasonal themes like Christmas, Easter, and Halloween.
• Gift Boxes and Tags: Offering various gift boxes and custom tags to complement the cookie favors.
• Order Pick-Up: Convenient in-store pick-up is available for all orders placed via phone or email.

Features / Highlights

The following key features highlight why Cutest Cookies has become a premier choice for custom treats in the New York area:

• 100% Nut-Free Facility: This is perhaps their most crucial feature, as no nuts of any kind are used in their facility, drastically minimizing the risk of cross-contamination and making them a safe choice for those with severe nut allergies.
• Women-Owned Business: Proudly identifying as a women-owned establishment, contributing to the diversity of small businesses in NYC.
• Highly Personalized Service: They work closely with customers to design cookies that precisely match the theme, colors, and specifics of any event, offering a truly custom party favor experience.
• Freshness Guarantee: The bakery does not keep any cookies in stock, ensuring that every order is freshly baked, hand-rolled, and decorated just days before it is picked up or shipped.
• Quality Ingredients: Cookies are sugar cookies made with real butter and use high-quality, basic ingredients with absolutely no preservatives.
• Custom Cookie Kits: A highly popular product for parties and events, providing both an activity and a take-home favor, praised by customers for being fun and "not too sweet."
• Commitment to Detail: Each cookie is a work of art, hand-decorated by a skilled cookie artist to achieve both beautiful aesthetics and a great taste.
• NYC Health Department Licensed: The bakery is fully licensed and inspected by the New York City Health Department, ensuring adherence to high standards of cleanliness and food safety.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about custom designs, or check on weekend hours, customers can easily reach Cutest Cookies using the following information:

• Address: 1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA
• Phone: (718) 966-2883 (also known as 718-966-CUTE)

Customers who wish to place an order for pick-up at the Hylan Blvd location are encouraged to call the bakery directly at the number listed above, as this is the preferred method for local orders to ensure all custom details are captured accurately.

What is worth choosing

For New York residents, choosing Cutest Cookies for your event favors is a decision based on quality, customization, and safety. The primary reason to choose this Staten Island establishment is the unique combination of exceptional decorative artistry and a 100% nut-free kitchen. This is a critical factor for many families and event planners in the city who cannot compromise on allergy safety.

Beyond safety, the customization options are unmatched. As one delighted customer shared, the appreciation for the artistic skill goes beyond just the cookies themselves, even extending to the decoration of an entire candy table, demonstrating the staff's commitment to making events special. Their cookies are consistently described as delicious—made with real butter and "not too sweet"—a perfect balance often sought in custom treats.

Furthermore, the DIY custom cookie kits are a highly praised offering, providing a unique and fun alternative to standard party favors. These kits are an ideal choice for children's parties, holiday gatherings, or team-building activities, giving guests a fun, memorable experience to take home. The personal touch from the woman-owned business, where staff are known for their "talent and kindness," transforms a simple transaction into a delightful customer experience.

In short, if you are planning an event in New York and need beautifully crafted, custom-designed sugar cookies that are absolutely delicious and guaranteed nut-free, Cutest Cookies offers a complete package of quality, safety, and artistic flair that is truly worth the trip to their Staten Island storefront.

Cutest Cookies

1300 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA