DiMaggio's Pizzeria

- 3 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801

## Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers on Long Island, finding a truly great, authentic slice is a rite of passage. Look no further than DiMaggio's Pizzeria, a cherished institution located in the heart of Hicksville, NY. This local spot has been delighting customers for decades, creating a strong reputation that stretches across Nassau County and beyond. DiMaggio's isn't just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s a commitment to the time-honored tradition of New York-style Italian-American cuisine, with a focus on perfectly crafted pizza.

The establishment has been a staple in the Hicksville community for over 70 years, woven into the very fabric of the neighborhood’s history. It’s a place where families have grown up, and locals gather, creating a warm, familiar atmosphere that sets it apart from larger chains. The commitment to quality is evident in their use of fresh, flavorful ingredients and time-tested recipes. Customer reviews often highlight the difference in the pizza, describing it as thin, flavorful, and delightfully crunchy—a clear sign that the art of the perfect pie is alive and well here. In fact, a recent change in ownership has been met with enthusiasm, with patrons noting the pizza is "back to being amazing" and "even better" than it used to be, proving their dedication to upholding and improving their high standards.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Conveniently situated in a central Long Island location, DiMaggio's Pizzeria serves the greater Hicksville and surrounding Nassau County area. Its specific address is 3 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA. This prime spot in the Village Green is easily accessible for local residents and those traveling from nearby towns. The location makes it an ideal stop for a casual dine-in experience, a quick pickup on the commute home, or a centrally located spot for delivery.

Hicksville is a major hub, and the pizzeria's location is easily reachable by car with connections to major Long Island roadways. For those using public transit, the proximity to the Hicksville LIRR station makes it a feasible destination for New Yorkers relying on the train line. The restaurant offers comfortable seating for customers who wish to dine in, providing a classic, no-fuss environment to enjoy a meal. The accessibility, whether you're coming from down the street or making a special trip from another part of Long Island, is part of what makes DiMaggio's a go-to spot for authentic Italian food.

---

## Services Offered

DiMaggio's Pizzeria offers a comprehensive range of services designed to meet the needs of their New York clientele, from quick lunches to large-scale events. These services ensure that their popular menu items, from specialty pizzas to full Italian dinners, are available in a way that is most convenient for the customer.

• Dine-In Seating: The venue offers comfortable, casual seating for customers who prefer to enjoy their meal fresh out of the oven.
• Takeout / Pick-Up: Quick and efficient service for orders placed by phone or online, allowing customers to easily grab their food on the go.
• Local Delivery Service: The restaurant provides quick delivery service to the surrounding Hicksville and Long Island neighborhoods, allowing residents to enjoy their favorite pizza and Italian dishes at home.
• Extensive Menu Variety: Beyond their famous pizza, they offer a full menu including hot heroes (like Chicken Parm and Cheesesteak), classic Italian pasta dishes (such as Baked Ziti, Lasagna, and Chicken Parmigiana), appetizers, salads, and calzones. They also have specialty offerings like the Grandma Pie and a selection of specialty pizzas like Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lovers, and the classic Margherita.
• Catering: They act as "party-helper extraordinaires" by offering catering services for all types of events, providing large trays of their favorite pastas, main courses, and appetizers for family gatherings, office events, or celebrations.
• Specialty and Dietary Options: The menu frequently features options like a Gluten-Free Pizza crust, accommodating various dietary needs.

---

## Features / Highlights

What truly sets DiMaggio's Pizzeria apart is a combination of traditional excellence, local recognition, and a clear dedication to customer satisfaction. These highlights are what draw New Yorkers to this Long Island favorite again and again.

• The Signature Thin-Crust Pizza: The hallmark of DiMaggio's is their pizza, specifically praised for being thin, flavorful, and crunchy with "no flop," a characteristic highly valued by pizza aficionados. The commitment to this high-quality New York-style crust is what keeps customers loyal.
• Community Heritage and Local Legend: The pizzeria has deep ties to the Hicksville community and has been open for over seven decades. It is part of the local lore, famously being a favorite spot of Billy Joel's mother, Rosalind Nyman Joel, who would stop in for a slice.
• The "No Flop" Guarantee: Mentioned by discerning customers, the crust’s integrity—meaning the tip of a slice holds its shape—is a key sign of a well-made New York pie, and DiMaggio's delivers on this standard.
• Commitment to Freshness: The restaurant is known for its dedication to using fresh ingredients and preparing food daily, ensuring an authentic and delicious Italian experience.
• Friendly and Attentive Staff: Reviews consistently mention the staff's very friendly and welcoming demeanor, which enhances the overall dining and ordering experience.
• Exciting Specialty Pies: The menu includes unique and popular options like the Grandma Pizza (a thin-crust square pie) and a variety of specialty pizzas tailored to modern tastes, like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

---

## Contact Information

For current hours, placing a takeout order, delivery, or discussing catering options, DiMaggio's Pizzeria is easily reachable via phone and is located at the following address:

Address: 3 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA

Phone: (516) 796-0611

Mobile Phone: +1 516-796-0611

---

## What is Worth Choosing

For any New Yorker seeking an authentic and satisfying meal, DiMaggio's Pizzeria is a truly compelling choice. What makes it worth choosing is the successful combination of culinary excellence and local tradition. You should choose DiMaggio's because you are looking for a taste of classic Long Island pizza with an undeniable pedigree.

The overwhelming positive sentiment from long-time customers and new patrons alike speaks volumes. One customer, visiting from Florida, declared it the "Best pizza in Long Island," citing the food and service as "above all others in your region." This high praise is not limited to visitors; locals who had previously stopped coming returned after the new ownership and vouched for the pizza's quality, specifically mentioning the "thin, flavorful and crunchy" nature of the pies. This consistency and commitment to tradition—and willingness to listen to the community—is rare and valuable.

Beyond the pizza, the full Italian menu, from hearty Italian dishes like Lasagna and Chicken Parmigiana to generously portioned hot heroes, offers something for every craving. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick, perfect slice, picking up dinner for the family, or planning a large catered event, DiMaggio's provides a genuine taste of New York-Italian cuisine rooted in decades of local history and a continuous drive for quality. For Long Islanders, choosing DiMaggio's is choosing a local legacy that consistently delivers on the promise of great food and friendly service.

DiMaggio's Pizzeria

3 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA