Don's Sandwich Shop

- 606 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005

For decades, Don's Sandwich Shop has stood as a beloved local landmark on Main Street in Boonton, New Jersey, representing the quintessential "old-school" sandwich experience that North Jersey residents cherish. Far from a corporate chain, this establishment is celebrated as a true mom-and-pop gem, offering exceptional value, genuinely friendly service, and a lineup of classic deli sandwiches that have earned it a fiercely loyal following among locals.

Don's is more than just a place for a quick bite; it embodies the spirit of a cozy, neighborhood eatery where every order is prepared with care and attention to detail. The atmosphere is famously casual and comforting, offering a unique local flavor that you simply cannot find anywhere else. Patrons frequently highlight the exceptional quality of the ingredients, particularly the generous portions of fresh, succulent sliced meats, and the unique addition of their signature "Famous Dressing" that elevates every sub.

The core of the menu is built around extensive sandwich offerings, all prepared fresh on your choice of rye, white, wheat bread, a round roll, or a bagel. Importantly, the pricing structure is designed with value in mind: any sandwich prepared on one of the bread options is the same affordable price as a half of a sub. A special nod to value is the Mini Sub, available with any variety for a minimal price, perfect for a small appetite or for sampling different options.

Don's Sandwich Shop is perfectly situated at 606 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005, USA, right in the heart of Boonton's bustling and historic Main Street district. This central Morris County location makes it a convenient stop for workers, residents, and visitors exploring the area. The shop’s proximity to other local businesses and its deep roots in the community contribute to its reputation as a vital town fixture.

The location also offers practical considerations for customers, reflecting a commitment to accommodating all members of the community. Key accessibility features ensure a smooth and comfortable experience for everyone:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot (Free street parking is also available)
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

Furthermore, the availability of free street parking, a major amenity in busy downtown areas, adds to the shop's ease of access, making it a simple choice for a quick and satisfying lunch. The casual and cozy atmosphere is a major draw for local crowds and solo diners looking for quality comfort food.

Don's Sandwich Shop focuses on efficiency, speed, and quality, primarily serving those looking for a fast food experience without sacrificing homemade taste. Their service options are tailored to the needs of the busy New Jersey customer:

• Takeout: The primary service option, allowing customers to easily grab their freshly made order and enjoy it on the go. As a dedicated Takeout Restaurant and Fast Food Restaurant, efficiency is a core focus.
• Dine-in: A casual and cozy space is available for those who wish to sit down and enjoy their meal inside, offering a true neighborhood atmosphere.
• Catering: While primarily a lunch and takeout spot, the shop offers catering services, making it an excellent choice for feeding local business meetings, parties, or family gatherings with high-quality sandwiches and sides.
• Payment Options: The shop accepts modern payment methods for convenience, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

What distinguishes Don's Sandwich Shop from other delis in Northern New Jersey? It is a blend of iconic sandwiches, signature ingredients, and a truly unique community atmosphere:

• The Famous Dressing: A consistent highlight mentioned in customer feedback, this signature dressing is applied to all sub sandwiches and is a key ingredient that provides a distinct flavor profile, setting their subs apart from the competition.
• Iconic Belly Buster Sub: Simply listed as "Belly Buster" on the menu, this legendary sandwich is a massive, multi-meat creation often personalized by locals to include a variety of cold cuts, eggs, and breakfast meats, living up to its name and offering maximum value for a big appetite.
• Classic New Jersey Sloppy Joes: Don's specializes in the North Jersey-style Sloppy Joe, prepared authentically on three slices of rye bread with Russian Dressing and Cole Slaw, featuring meat combinations like Boiled Ham, Roast Beef and Swiss or Roast Beef, Turkey and Swiss.
• Old-School Club Sandwiches: Offering traditional three-slice club sandwiches with combinations like Roast Beef, Swiss and Bacon or Turkey, Pastrami, Bacon & Swiss, providing hearty and satisfying layered meals.
• Unique Atmosphere: Customers rave about the incredibly unique, small-town vibe—often described as a 'cozy small town Katz’s'—and the surprising combination of the sandwich shop with an adjacent professional drum store. This blend creates an unparalleled local experience.
• Extensive Sandwich Variety: The menu boasts over 30 different sub sandwich combinations, ranging from classic Roast Beef and Tuna to specialty options like Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Cheese and a full selection of hot subs, including Steak and Hot Roast Beef with Gravy.
• Side Dishes and Dessert: Complementing the main event are classic deli sides like Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, and Cole Slaw, along with Delicious Soups and Ice Cream and Cookies for dessert.
• Good for Kids: The shop is known to be good for children, providing a family-friendly environment and simple comfort food options.

To place an order for a classic sub or a legendary Belly Buster, or for catering inquiries in the Boonton, NJ area, use the following contact details:

Address: 606 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005, USA

Phone: (973) 263-3189

Mobile Phone: +1 973-263-3189

For New Jersey diners, choosing Don's Sandwich Shop is choosing authenticity, quality, and a commitment to the classic deli tradition, but with a unique, memorable local twist. What makes Don's truly worth choosing is the unparalleled blend of high-value portions and the distinct flavor profile created by their ingredients and preparation style. The fact that all sub sandwiches are meticulously prepared with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and their legendary Famous Dressing guarantees a consistently great taste that keeps locals coming back week after week.

Furthermore, Don's offers an escape from the generic fast-food experience. It is a place where the owners, Pat and Elizabeth, are known to greet customers with genuine kindness, making the service 'like butter,' as one customer described it. The dual identity as both a phenomenal sandwich shop and a professional drum store creates a quirky, first-class atmosphere that is unique to Boonton, NJ. Whether you are craving the enormous, satisfying Belly Buster, a perfectly constructed three-slice Sloppy Joe, or just a simple, quality Egg Salad and Bacon club sandwich, Don's Sandwich Shop stands out as an essential Morris County destination. It delivers on comfort food, speed, and exceptional local character, making it the perfect choice for lunch or catering.

Don's Sandwich Shop

606 Main St, Boonton, NJ 07005, USA