Flatbush Bagel

- 557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

In the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, where every New Yorker knows the best day starts with a perfect bagel, Flatbush Bagel stands out as a beloved local establishment. Located right on Flatbush Avenue, this Asian-owned bagel shop has built a reputation for providing a truly classic New York experience, offering everything from freshly baked bagels and an astonishing variety of cream cheeses to hearty breakfast options and classic deli sandwiches. Whether you’re on your morning commute, seeking a satisfying weekend brunch, or simply craving an authentic taste of the city, Flatbush Bagel is a reliable, friendly, and essential stop in the Prospect Lefferts Gardens neighborhood.

The shop is more than just a quick stop; it’s a neighborhood anchor, committed to starting your day off right. With a menu that caters to every craving, from a simple buttered bagel to a complex combination sandwich, Flatbush Bagel ensures quality and speed, making it an ideal choice for the fast-paced lives of Brooklyn residents.

​

Location and Accessibility

Flatbush Bagel is conveniently situated at 557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA, placing it perfectly within the Prospect Lefferts Gardens area, close to Prospect Park. Its prime location on a major Brooklyn artery makes it highly accessible for both local residents and those traveling through the borough. The neighborhood buzzes with life, and the bagel shop is right in the middle of it all, inviting patrons in with the irresistible aroma of freshly baked goods and brewing coffee.

For those utilizing New York City’s extensive public transportation system, the shop is easily reachable by bus. The B41 bus route, which runs along Flatbush Avenue, offers stops very close to the location, making transit simple. While the nearest major subway station, Church Av, is approximately a six-minute walk away, providing access to the B, Q, and 2 subway lines, the abundance of bus service along Flatbush Avenue ensures a smooth trip. This accessibility makes it a practical choice for a quick visit before heading to work or school, or for grabbing a dozen bagels to bring home.

​

Services Offered

Flatbush Bagel is focused on delivering exceptional breakfast and quick-meal options with high convenience. The service options are designed to accommodate the varied schedules and preferences of New Yorkers.

• Delivery service for customers ordering from home or office.
• In-store pickup for quick, pre-ordered convenience.
• Takeout service for all menu items.
• Limited dine-in seating for those looking to enjoy their meal immediately (note: seating can be limited during busy hours).
• Accepts credit cards and debit cards for easy payment.
• Dedicated to providing a quick-visit experience for minimal wait time.

The core offerings revolve around breakfast, including a substantial coffee program to fuel the day. The shop is also officially identified as an Asian-owned business, adding to the rich tapestry of local entrepreneurship in Brooklyn.

​

Features / Highlights

What sets Flatbush Bagel apart is its commitment to variety and tradition, ensuring that every customer finds their perfect match, whether it's a classic New York bagel or a unique deli creation.

• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: Boasting one of the most comprehensive selections of spreads in the area, options range from classic Plain Cream Cheese and Scallion to specialty blends like Habanero Cream Cheese, Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese, Bacon Cheddar Cream Cheese, and Lox Cream Cheese. They even offer various Tofu cream cheese flavors, catering to diverse dietary preferences.
• Hearty All-Day Breakfast: The shop offers a wide array of breakfast options available all day, from simple Egg Sandwiches to more elaborate choices like the Meat, Egg & Cheese Sandwich, and various three-egg omelettes, including Greek, Western, and Lox & Onion. Pancakes are also available for a sweet start to the morning.
• Classic Deli and Specialty Sandwiches: Beyond breakfast, Flatbush Bagel provides a full deli experience. This includes deli salads by the pound (like Tuna Salad and Jalapeño Chicken Salad), fresh cold cuts by the pound (Pastrami, Roast Beef, Oven Gold Turkey), and a wide selection of combination sandwiches. Fan favorites include the famous Lox Sandwich, The Combo Sandwich (hot corned beef and pastrami), and the classic Reuben.
• Diverse Coffee and Beverage Menu: The shop understands the need for a caffeine fix. They offer traditional Hot Coffee and Iced Coffee, along with specialty options like Flavored Iced Coffee, Grady's Cold Brew, and Chameleon Cold Brew. The cold case is stocked with a variety of drinks, including fresh juices (Simply Juice, Natalie's Orchid Island Juice), Kombucha, and various waters.
• A Full Suite of Baked Goods: Complementing their bagels, the menu features a selection of fresh baked goods such as Muffins, Blueberry Danish, Cheese Danish, and various pound cakes (Lemon, Carrot, Red Velvet, Marble) and the decadent Chocolate Babka.

​

What is Worth Choosing: The Flatbush Bagel Experience

If you're in the neighborhood and looking for an authentic and satisfying quick meal, Flatbush Bagel is an excellent choice. The sheer variety on the menu means there is something for everyone, whether you are a devoted bagel purist or someone seeking a hearty lunch.

The most compelling reason to choose Flatbush Bagel is the extraordinary breadth of their menu, particularly the creative and numerous cream cheese options. This allows for unparalleled customization, a key selling point for any New York bagel connoisseur. Customers can experiment with a different flavor every day of the week and never run out of choices, from the savory Tofu Scallion to the sweet Apple Cinnamon.

Furthermore, the focus on quick, efficient service makes it ideal for the busy New Yorker. With options for delivery, takeout, and in-store pickup, getting your morning fuel or lunch fix is fast and convenient. While popular spots can experience peak hour congestion, as noted by a patron who wished for more seating, the staff's dedication to moving orders efficiently ensures that the wait is manageable.

For a reliable, flavor-packed, and authentically Brooklyn morning meal or lunch, Flatbush Bagel delivers a high-value, satisfying experience that keeps locals coming back day after day. It is a genuine neighborhood staple that truly embodies the spirit of a New York bagel shop.

​

Contact Information

Flatbush Bagel is ready to take your order and provide you with a fresh, delicious meal.

Address: 557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA

Phone: (718) 469-5700

Hours of Operation (General): The shop is open daily, typically from 6:00 AM to 3:00 PM, making it an excellent spot for breakfast and lunch. Note that online ordering and specific service times may vary slightly, such as pickup sometimes beginning at 6:30 AM.

Flatbush Bagel

557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA