Jimmy's Famous Heros

- 1786 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235

When it comes to New York’s food scene, few things are as iconic as a perfectly constructed sandwich. In the heart of Brooklyn’s vibrant Sheepshead Bay neighborhood, a true culinary landmark stands: Jimmy's Famous Heros. This establishment is far more than just a typical sandwich shop; it has firmly cemented its reputation as a premier deli, celebrated by locals, college students, and tourists alike for its commitment to quality ingredients, substantial portions, and an authentic, old-school New York vibe. If you are searching for a sandwich that truly lives up to the name "hero," look no further than this historic spot.

Jimmy's Famous Heros operates as a versatile food destination. It is principally a classic sandwich shop and deli, specializing in a vast array of freshly prepared heroes and rolls. Beyond the incredible sandwiches, it also functions as a takeout restaurant, making it an ideal choice for a quick, high-quality bite during the busy workday or a substantial lunch on the go. Adding to its unique character, the establishment also has aspects of a fruit and vegetable store, suggesting an emphasis on fresh produce to complement their already stellar offerings. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual and historic, offering a welcoming, unpretentious backdrop that feels quintessentially Brooklyn. The team prides themselves on A+++ customer service, ensuring every visit is as pleasant as the sandwich is delicious.

The menu is a testament to the deli's dedication to selection and satisfaction, built around their renowned All-Day Sandwiches and Heros. Their selection ranges from classic cold cuts to signature Italian and hearty cooked options. For instance, the All-Day Sandwiches section features a wide variety of options, all priced at a consistent $18.00 (with some exceptions like Prosciutto and Soppressata at $20.00), demonstrating a clear focus on value for a substantial hero. Crowd favorites include the Mild Italian Sandwich, Hot Italian Sandwich, and the Chicken Cutlets Sandwich, often highlighted by patrons for their freshness and flavor. Customers rave about the quality, noting that all the "vegetables and breads and cold cuts are top of the line quality." It is this meticulous attention to ingredient quality that sets Jimmy's Famous Heros apart in a city saturated with delis.

The rolls section offers smaller, but equally satisfying options, with items like the Chicken Cutlet On A Roll and Hot Italian On A Roll available for $13.00, perfect for those desiring a quick, focused burst of flavor. Completing the meal, the deli offers a range of satisfying sides, including Grilled Chicken Salad, Homemade Cannoli for a sweet finish, and popular snacks like Seasoned French Fries and various Utz Classic Potato Chips. For beverages, the selection is expansive, featuring everything from classic sodas like Bottle Coca-Cola and Canada Dry Ginger Ale to a variety of Snapple flavors and Gatorade. This extensive menu ensures that whether you're craving a robust, fully-loaded hero, a fresh salad, or a simple roll, Jimmy’s Famous Heros has the perfect option.

The dining experience at Jimmy's is built on convenience and quality. It’s highly popular for lunch and is known to attract a diverse crowd, including university students and tourists exploring the neighborhood. The offerings cater to a wide audience, including those seeking comfort food, a quick bite, or even vegetarian options. Furthermore, the shop accommodates children with a dedicated kids' menu, making it an excellent stop for families exploring the Sheepshead Bay area.

One customer, for example, noted that their roast beef sandwich with provolone and garlic mayo was "packed and full of flavor," praising it as the "perfect pit stop on my way to enjoying it on the boardwalk." Another enthusiastically declared them to be the "BEST heroes in the universe! Hands down!" Such glowing endorsements highlight the consistent excellence and dedicated service provided by the team at Jimmy's. The dedication to making "Great sandwiches, made with care," as another reviewer mentioned, is the hallmark of this establishment.

For New Yorkers in search of an authentic and high-quality hero experience in Brooklyn, Jimmy's Famous Heros is a mandatory destination. The combination of a historic, casual atmosphere with top-tier, freshly prepared ingredients ensures an experience that is consistently satisfying.

Location and Accessibility

Jimmy's Famous Heros is conveniently located in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for local residents and visitors alike.

Address: 1786 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA

For those traveling by public transportation, the location is very transit-friendly. The closest subway stop is the Sheepshead Bay Station on the BMT Brighton Line, which is served by the B train (weekdays) and the Q train (all times). The shop is a short and convenient walk from the station. The B4, B44-SBS, and B49 bus lines also operate stops near Sheepshead Bay Road. For drivers, both street parking and a dedicated free parking lot are sometimes available, though street parking can be subject to city regulations (both free and paid options mentioned in various sources). A key accessibility feature is the Wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring a welcoming experience for all patrons.

Services Offered

• Takeout (Takeaway)
• Delivery (Including No-Contact Delivery)
• Lunch Dine-In Options
• Catering Services
• Accepts major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments
• Serves Coffee and select Beer & Wine (availability may vary)

Features / Highlights

• Historic and Casual Atmosphere: Provides an authentic, comfortable Brooklyn deli experience perfect for a quick, enjoyable lunch break.
• Extensive Hero Menu: Features a wide variety of signature heroes and sandwiches, including the hugely popular Mild Italian, Hot Italian, and Chicken Cutlets Sandwich.
• Top-Quality Ingredients: Noted by customers for using "top of the line quality" cold cuts, fresh vegetables, and breads.
• Accommodates Dietary Needs: Offers good Vegetarian options to ensure there’s something for everyone.
• Family-Friendly: Considered Good for kids and offers a Kids' menu.
• Convenient Hours: Open seven days a week from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM for pickup, with delivery typically running from 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM (always check for the latest hours).
• Proximity to Transit: Located just a short walk from the Sheepshead Bay subway station (B and Q trains).

Contact Information

Address: 1786 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA

Phone: (718) 648-8001

What is worth choosing

The true allure of Jimmy's Famous Heros lies in its commitment to the classic New York hero concept: a generously portioned, high-quality sandwich made with care. If you are making a first visit, the Chicken Cutlets Sandwich or either the Mild Italian Sandwich or Hot Italian Sandwich are highly recommended, as they consistently receive praise for being hearty, flavor-packed, and made with the freshest components. For a satisfying side, the Seasoned French Fries are a great choice. Patrons agree that the quality-to-price ratio is outstanding, making every selection a worthwhile investment in your lunchtime satisfaction. The fact that the ingredients are consistently described as "amazing fresh food" confirms that this deli focuses on delivering an authentic, high-value culinary experience that stands out in the Brooklyn dining landscape. Whether you are a local resident, a student, or a tourist, Jimmy's offers a genuine taste of what makes New York delis truly legendary.

Jimmy's Famous Heros

1786 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA