Library Café

- 274 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

For those in the New York metropolitan area looking for a dining destination that offers more than just excellent food and drinks, the Library Café in Farmingdale, Long Island, presents a truly unique chapter. More than a standard American restaurant, this establishment has cultivated a distinctive identity, skillfully blending an approachable menu with a sophisticated, casual, and historically resonant atmosphere. Housed in what was once the Farmingdale Public Library—and before that, a bank—the venue pays homage to its past with a charming literary theme that influences the decor, lending a 'Manhattan feel' to the heart of downtown Farmingdale.

The establishment is part of the esteemed Lessing's Hospitality Group, known for providing a high-quality experience. Library Café is renowned for its diverse offerings, making it a popular choice for everything from quick lunches and intimate dinners to lively happy hours and late-night gatherings. The focus remains on freshly prepared American fare complemented by an extensive "Library of Liquor," featuring signature cocktails named after celebrated authors and books, an impressive selection of beers, and a broad wine list.

The atmosphere is described by patrons as cozy, trendy, and historic, with high ceilings, beautiful wood trims, and subtle decorative elements that subtly nod to the venue’s literary history. It attracts a varied crowd, including college students, families, groups, and tourists, appealing to anyone seeking a friendly and engaging setting for dining and socializing on Long Island.

Location and Accessibility

Library Café is conveniently situated at 274 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735. This prime location places it right on Main Street and Conklin Street, making it a vibrant and central fixture in the Farmingdale community. For those traveling by car, the venue offers accessibility features designed to accommodate all guests, including:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating
• Parking options include free street parking as well as a paid parking lot nearby.

Its position in Farmingdale makes it easily reachable for residents across Long Island, offering a compelling alternative to Manhattan dining without sacrificing quality or style.

Services Offered

As a versatile American restaurant and bar, the Library Café offers an array of services to cater to various needs and occasions:

• Dining Options: Serving Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner.
• Service Options: Available for Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery, and Curbside pickup.
• Reservations: Accepts reservations, with Brunch and Dinner reservations recommended, especially during peak times.
• Private Dining/Events: Features a private dining room/loft for events, accommodating celebrations such as bridal showers, engagement parties, and corporate functions with personalized service and menus (cocktail party, buffet, brunch, plated options).
• Catering: Provides catering services, including take-out party trays.
• Late-Night Service: Offers late-night food and bar service, with the bar onsite being a major highlight.
• Family Amenities: Considered good for kids, offering high chairs, and a dedicated Kids' menu.
• Payment: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

Library Café's standout features contribute to its reputation as a must-visit spot on Long Island:

• Unique Historical Theme: Located in a former public library (and bank), the venue embraces a charming literary theme in its decor and in the names of its sophisticated cocktails (e.g., 'The Notebook,' 'Edith Wharton: Age of Innocence').
• Extensive Beverage Program: Known for its "Library of Liquor," featuring great cocktails made with fresh-squeezed juices, a great beer selection (including local craft beers like Lessing's Local Ale), a great wine list with over 20 wines by the glass, hard liquor, and happy hour drinks.
• Diverse Menu: The menu is extensive and approachable, categorized by playful names like 'Social Plates' and 'Big Plates,' featuring American classics, comfort food, and global influences. Menu staples include the Marinated Sliced Steak sandwich, the Cobb Salad, Killer Mac + Cheese, various burgers (like the 'All American' and 'Smokehouse'), and unique appetizers like Mini Reubens and Philly Cheesesteak Empanadas. Vegetarian options are available, such as the Buddha Bowl and Tuscan Burrata.
• Atmosphere and Entertainment: The atmosphere is sophisticated yet casual, cozy, and trendy. Highlights include a stunning two-story high wall behind the bar adorned with books, and the regular offering of Live Music and a venue to watch Sports.
• Service Quality: Highly praised by customers for its fast service, friendly, attentive staff, and knowledgeable bartenders/mixologists who provide excellent suggestions.
• Offerings: Includes Happy hour food, Small plates for quick bites, and a delicious Sweets menu featuring items like Sticky Toffee Pudding Cake and the Ultimate Peanut Butter Brownie Sundae.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries about private events, or to place an order, customers can use the following information:

• Address: 274 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735
• Phone: (516) 752-7678 or +1 516-752-7678

What is Worth Choosing

Library Café is worth choosing for New York-based patrons because it delivers a complete dining and social experience that successfully differentiates itself from the typical local restaurant. You are not just getting a meal; you are enjoying a "story." The unique theme, born from the building's history, creates a warm and rich environment—a sophisticated, historic, yet casual space that feels like a Manhattan spot transplanted to Long Island. The commitment to fresh, quality American fare is evident across the menu, from hearty burgers and comfort food like Killer Mac + Cheese to lighter options such as the Ahi Poke Tuna Bowl and various specialty salads. Furthermore, the outstanding beverage program, with its creative, author-themed cocktails and extensive beer and wine lists, guarantees a perfect pairing for any dish or mood.

Whether you're planning a casual lunch, a lively dinner with a group, need a perfect spot for brunch, or are simply looking for a quality late-night drink while catching the game or enjoying live music, the combination of excellent service, a diverse and affordable menu, and the distinctive literary atmosphere makes Library Café an unforgettable and highly recommended destination on Long Island.

Library Café

274 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA